is SBS better than WHS?

theinv

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 17, 2008
Messages
216
If you don't need to backup whole pc, is the Smal Business Server (SBS) better than the WHS?
 
If i were not using WHS, i would be using 2008 not 2003. What are you doing? more info would help
 
um... sure if you need to run exchange, sql, and an AD domain... ??? they aren't even close to the same thing.
 
If i were not using WHS, i would be using 2008 not 2003. What are you doing? more info would help

I want a WHS like server for file backup and sharing, but I don't need to backup my pc. It needs to support storage pool like the WHS does, so I can add/remove drive easily.

The SBS 2008 is base on windows server 2008 technology, right? That's why I am considering it instead of WHS.
 
It's called Small Business Server because it's meant to facilitate small businesses. :)

It is a completely different class than WHS and does not contain any of the drive pooling that WHS uses.
 
It sounds like your server knowledge level is about equal to mine (barely nothing) and I have a WHS.

The WHS OS configures everything and relieves us novices from having to know the technical ins and outs.

The OS backup is just a small part of the WHS operation and I don't even use it.

I'm going to suggest that you look at the features you want/need for external storage and go from there.

For all I know a NAS would do you just fine.
 
It sounds like your server knowledge level is about equal to mine (barely nothing) and I have a WHS.

The WHS OS configures everything and relieves us novices from having to know the technical ins and outs.

The OS backup is just a small part of the WHS operation and I don't even use it.

I'm going to suggest that you look at the features you want/need for external storage and go from there.

For all I know a NAS would do you just fine.

I think you have no idea what SBS is.

The SBS is more advance than WHS. It has everything the WHS has except the ability to backup client PCs.

I am already using WHS and I know what WHS is about. I also never use the OS backup feature on WHS. That's exactly why I asked in the first post, whether SBS is a better option if you don't need to backup the client OS.
 
It's called Small Business Server because it's meant to facilitate small businesses. :)

It is a completely different class than WHS and does not contain any of the drive pooling that WHS uses.


The SBS does have storage pool. It's user interface is also very similar to WHS. You can read more about it from microsoft's website.

http://www.microsoft.com/sbs/en/us/overview.aspx

And here is one what one user said in the other forum by user "betalpha"

http://forum.wegotserved.com/index....008/page__s__dde1962d7c39c95f021859c15367c36f

WHS and SBS 2008

Posted By: betalpha
Posted 28 December 2008 - 01:50 PM

Well, I've been looking around for posts on Windows 2008 SBS since lately I've been messing with my home built workstation/server. Just like George, I have access to a lot of software with lable of Microsoft, and I'm particularly interested in Windows Server 2008 SBS. Revulotionary product, I have to say.

Basically, WS08SBS can do everyting WHS can. It can backup any part of the HDD, and you can host a shared folder for all the members, though not as easy for sharing media as in WHS. Moreover, after you bundle your domain name with the ISPs, you end up with a very robust server even able to host a website...


SBS 2008 screenshots:


SBS_ProtectData.jpg
 
Last edited:
I think you have no idea what SBS is.

I freely admitted that fact and also stated
The WHS OS configures everything and relieves us novices from having to know the technical ins and outs.

Since you've already found all your answers there's nothing more I can add.
 
The SBS does have storage pool.

Perhaps I'm missing something, but I don't see where SBS supports storage pool. I just logged into an SBS 2008 I recently put in and I don't see it anywhere nor does MS reference it. As stated already, SBS will also install Exchange and will require that it is a domain controller. With some finagling, it will be possible to share files and folders without requiring domain authentication. Otherwise, you will need to join your PC to that domain.

You said that you wanted to move to SBS 2008 because it's based on Server 2008. I think that's about the only thing that you would gain. 2008 does have some very noticeable improvements in networking. File transfers are much faster.

theinv said:
I am already using WHS and I know what WHS is about. I also never use the OS backup feature on WHS. That's exactly why I asked in the first post, whether SBS is a better option if you don't need to backup the client OS.

I think in your case, no, it is not a better option. You want something more advanced than WHS, which SBS 2008 is, but you also want the ease of use of WHS and the WHS storage pools. SBS DOES have "ease of use", but only when compared to a regular server OS. It's not "WHS easy". You will have the added complexity of dealing with an Active Directory domain, Exchange, workstation management, etc.

I'd stick with WHS if I were you. If you want to learn about SBS 2008 or the Server OSs, then by all means make the switch.

Myself, I'm actually in the process of moving FROM a Server 2008R2 Hyper-V host with an AD domain to a Mini-ITX WHS box. It's much simpler and easier to manage for myself. Saves on power too..

Riley
 
How is storage pool different from exdending drives in 2008? it can dublicate files but 2008 can do the same with server backup.
 
How is storage pool different from exdending drives in 2008? it can dublicate files but 2008 can do the same with server backup.

Because when you extend a disk it expands the partition across both disks.
Storage pool creates separate partitions and uses sybolic links to make it "appear" as a single storage device.

What this all means is if you extend drives and one drive dies, it takes the partition table with it and you will lose all of the data on that set of drives.
It essentially has the pitfalls of RAID0(not fault tolerant) without the performance gain.
 
Because when you extend a disk it expands the partition across both disks.
Storage pool creates separate partitions and uses sybolic links to make it "appear" as a single storage device.

What this all means is if you extend drives and one drive dies, it takes the partition table with it and you will lose all of the data on that set of drives.
It essentially has the pitfalls of RAID0(not fault tolerant) without the performance gain.

Ah yes. that is true. But you can make symbolic links with 2008 also you just have to make them manualy.
 
Ah yes. that is true. But you can make symbolic links with 2008 also you just have to make them manualy.

Well I mean if thats your logic then i guess win XP has storage pool too;)
 
Back
Top