Modem Hacker Charged With ‘Aiding Computer Intrusion’

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I’m not taking a side in this argument or arguing the merits of the case, I am merely pointing out the fact that this guy shouldn’t be surprised the feds came knocking on his door. Hell, I’m actually amazed it took as long as it did.

An Oregon hardware hacker and author has been hit with federal criminal charges arising from his longstanding business of selling unlocked cable modems that can be used to steal extra speed from a broadband provider, or obtain free service.
 
Yeah, i bet his view was "its only illegal if you get caught"

Guess what. . . . . .he got caught lol
 
This guy is the very definition of amoral. He claims he is just like a gun dealer and it is not his problem what his customers do with his products. Sure there could be legitimate uses for use products but when 99% of his customers use his hacked products to break the law, you have to admit there is something wrong with his business model.
 
I'm sorry. But are we going to start charging gun shop owners for aiding criminal activity the next time someone in murdered with a guns sold from their shop?
 
My younger brother about 10+ years ago started selling pirated discs. movies, games, anything and everything and ... he got caught and since he had already served time in prison prior to that for selling drugs and being in possession of a firearm, he went back to prison.

I tried to tell him, his buddies that ... whatever money they made illegally was never going to be more than what he could make at a normal job earning a fair wage over a short period of 2 - 3 years. Maybe even less. Steady legit incomes always beat anything a small time crook can make.

What does this have to do with this guy and this story? Same difference, it's just not worth doing something illegal or borderline illegal to make a few extra dollars. The funny thing is, in the end, whatever speed his modem was set from the home office of isp, in the end would have provided him with more data than anything illegal he was doing. Kinda like the turtle and the hare story.

In the end, your really not getting over on the system.

Do some people REALLY beat the system, sure they do, but those guys are few and far between and their stories usually end up having a movie made about them.
 
i seem to remember there being a pretty lengthy discussion considering the morality of overclocking intel and amd processors when the celeron 350a came out... Just because modifying an athlon XP with a pencil is easier than modifying a motorola sufboard with a usb cable doesn't make the act of modification illegal.

to actual steal the cable modem service required sniffing the cable modem network from a working cable modem MAC; spoofing that person's MAC address when they weren't online, and downloading the configuration file from their modem to use when they weren't present, or you were willing to DoS attack them off the Node. NOTHING he sold or did allowed this, the only thing he gave, was the ability to unlock the administrative features of the cablemodem you purchased.

He could have created a firmware which automated many of the functions i described previously, but didn't specifically because it was illegal. He heavily moderated his forums, banned anyone immediately after posting anything remotely resembling any illegal content, and only sold/allowed those who guaranteed that they wouldn't be using the firmware or the information in the forums for illegal purposes.

in short, his firmware unlocked cable modems, just like your pencil trick unlocked amd processors.

Now there were definitely some unscrupulous vendors who sold overclocked systems with heatsinks GLUED to the processors and bios's modified to show a faster processor than was revealed after an official bios update. Are the people who posted the information about the pencil trick responsible for their actions?

Is the person who showed you how to unlock your cable modem responsible for the kid who used that information to DoS attack people off the internet?

Is the person who invented the taser responsible for those who misuse the taser?

personally, i see a clear difference between DerEngel who saw it as his job to moderate those forums day and night for illegal information, and those who make and distribute modified xbox firmware for *wink wink, nudge nuge* authorized backup copies ONLY... There are guide about how to create and burn backup copies of DRM protected games on the xbox hacking sites, DerEngel had no such similar information, to find out how to STEAL cable modem internet services requires a lot more searching via google, or piratebay type sites.

Unambiguition, i'm a Network engineer and PEN tester, i see it as my responsibility to know how these type off attacks work on specific networks; i've read DerEngel's book "hacking the cable modem", and i've read Bunnie's book "Hacking the Xbox: An Introduction to Reverse Engineering". Neither decribe the persuit of criminal activities in relation to defeat poorly thought out and designed computer systems...

This is a witch hunt, plain and simple. Perhaps if Ryan Harris was given the benefit of a tution to MIT, it would have proceeded like it did for Andrew Huang.

Andrew "Bunnie" Huang enable the complete defeat of all protected systems on your Xbox. And was given a tour of microsofts HPC labs and supercomputing centers around the world.

Ryan Harris enabled the ability to upload your own configuration files to your cable modem. And is facing federal prison.
 
I'm sorry. But are we going to start charging gun shop owners for aiding criminal activity the next time someone in murdered with a guns sold from their shop?

The way I see it, it's like a gun dealer selling illegal and hot guns to people without a license or doing a background check.
 
The difference is bunnie went to Microsoft, provided them with insider information and asked to be allowed to continue publicly hacking the console provided that he publish all of his findings and how to stop the hacks with revisions.
 
i seem to remember there being a pretty lengthy discussion considering the morality of overclocking intel and amd processors when the celeron 350a came out... Just because modifying an athlon XP with a pencil is easier than modifying a motorola sufboard with a usb cable doesn't make the act of modification illegal.

to actual steal the cable modem service required sniffing the cable modem network from a working cable modem MAC; spoofing that person's MAC address when they weren't online, and downloading the configuration file from their modem to use when they weren't present, or you were willing to DoS attack them off the Node. NOTHING he sold or did allowed this, the only thing he gave, was the ability to unlock the administrative features of the cablemodem you purchased.

He could have created a firmware which automated many of the functions i described previously, but didn't specifically because it was illegal. He heavily moderated his forums, banned anyone immediately after posting anything remotely resembling any illegal content, and only sold/allowed those who guaranteed that they wouldn't be using the firmware or the information in the forums for illegal purposes.

in short, his firmware unlocked cable modems, just like your pencil trick unlocked amd processors.

Now there were definitely some unscrupulous vendors who sold overclocked systems with heatsinks GLUED to the processors and bios's modified to show a faster processor than was revealed after an official bios update. Are the people who posted the information about the pencil trick responsible for their actions?

Is the person who showed you how to unlock your cable modem responsible for the kid who used that information to DoS attack people off the internet?

Is the person who invented the taser responsible for those who misuse the taser?

personally, i see a clear difference between DerEngel who saw it as his job to moderate those forums day and night for illegal information, and those who make and distribute modified xbox firmware for *wink wink, nudge nuge* authorized backup copies ONLY... There are guide about how to create and burn backup copies of DRM protected games on the xbox hacking sites, DerEngel had no such similar information, to find out how to STEAL cable modem internet services requires a lot more searching via google, or piratebay type sites.

Unambiguition, i'm a Network engineer and PEN tester, i see it as my responsibility to know how these type off attacks work on specific networks; i've read DerEngel's book "hacking the cable modem", and i've read Bunnie's book "Hacking the Xbox: An Introduction to Reverse Engineering". Neither decribe the persuit of criminal activities in relation to defeat poorly thought out and designed computer systems...

This is a witch hunt, plain and simple. Perhaps if Ryan Harris was given the benefit of a tution to MIT, it would have proceeded like it did for Andrew Huang.

Andrew "Bunnie" Huang enable the complete defeat of all protected systems on your Xbox. And was given a tour of microsofts HPC labs and supercomputing centers around the world.

Ryan Harris enabled the ability to upload your own configuration files to your cable modem. And is facing federal prison.

agree 100% unfortunately there are way too many tech illiterate people that think they have power over what they do not understand. Without people reverse engineering and tinkering we would not have things like the internet. What's next, are speed shops going to get shut down and raided when somebody using their services speeds or run from the police? Are small computer shops going to be shut down after they add a writable optical drive to a customers brand name computer?
 
The way I see it, it's like a gun dealer selling illegal and hot guns to people without a license or doing a background check.

writing your own firmware(and selling it) is illegal now? We better also arrest whoever was involved in writing Linux firmware for linksys routers.
 
The FBI is moving on his request for Arizona based MAC addressing, which indicates he uses his product for illegal means. You can thank the Patriot Act for their ability to act on such limited info as "threat of hacking" is now classified as a possible terrorist act meriting Federal intervention. Normally they would have to get a warrant for search & seizure first, which would be denied on the basis of one sentence, but because of the Patriot Act they can obtain more evidence to then ensure a warrant that will pass through a Judge.

Welcome to what signing away your right to Privacy has created. So, if you don't like this, then lobby your representatives on how you dislike the Patriot Act.

I’m sure there are nuances of this matter I am missing, such as how the FBI buying two units allows them to arrest him.
 
writing your own firmware(and selling it) is illegal now? We better also arrest whoever was involved in writing Linux firmware for linksys routers.

:rolleyes:

Way to take things out of context.

"selling unlocked cable modems that can be used to steal extra speed from a broadband provider, or obtain free service."

That was the purpose of his re-flashed cablemodem, just as it's not illegal to write a virus, but to write it and send it out into circulation is.
 
:rolleyes:

Way to take things out of context.

"selling unlocked cable modems that can be used to steal extra speed from a broadband provider, or obtain free service."

That was the purpose of his re-flashed cablemodem, just as it's not illegal to write a virus, but to write it and send it out into circulation is.

I can buy an optical drive that is capable of illegally copying software and media
I can by a router that will allow me to copy my computers mac address. I would not blame anybody who uses one to get a little extra speed out the isp that advertises XX megabits but only delivers in short bursts and intentionally throttles you down when you have a large download going. I don't see it as illlegal maybe a violation of TOS with the ISP but nothing more.
 
Writing a virus isn't illegial... Executing it's attack script is. So, what malicious code writers do is host the virus for others to willingly download, who then execute it on their machines and begin the infection process.
 
It's called "Cable" theft... What your ethical standards sees as ok, does not make it so.
 
It's called "Cable" theft... What your ethical standards sees as ok, does not make it so.

if you are paying for the line you are not stealing, I end up giving Comcast over $100 a month for service and rarely(never when I need it) see the advertised bandwidth I pay extra for. It's not stealing if you are just making sure you get what you are paying for.
 
if you are paying for the line you are not stealing, I end up giving Comcast over $100 a month for service and rarely(never when I need it) see the advertised bandwidth I pay extra for. It's not stealing if you are just making sure you get what you are paying for.

The problem is proving that is what your doing

Remember, quility until proven innocent
 
if you are paying for the line you are not stealing, I end up giving Comcast over $100 a month for service and rarely(never when I need it) see the advertised bandwidth I pay extra for. It's not stealing if you are just making sure you get what you are paying for.

Do you even read anything people say before you? The unlocked modem goes beyond what you paid for. You buy a 3mbps Comcast connection, that modem would get you 25mbps.

Go on, tell us how that's not stealing.
 
Then take legal action against them. Of course you don't have the income most likely to do so, so gather a group of people with proof... Or stop paying for their service because they are not providing high enough quality or meeting their promises. You don't tap your electricity to "loosen" how much your meter claims your drawing do you? And if you do and find that ok as well; morale issues indeed.
 
i seem to remember there being a pretty lengthy discussion considering the morality of overclocking intel and amd processors when the celeron 350a came out... Just because modifying an athlon XP with a pencil is easier than modifying a motorola sufboard with a usb cable doesn't make the act of modification illegal.

to actual steal the cable modem service required sniffing the cable modem network from a working cable modem MAC; spoofing that person's MAC address when they weren't online, and downloading the configuration file from their modem to use when they weren't present, or you were willing to DoS attack them off the Node. NOTHING he sold or did allowed this, the only thing he gave, was the ability to unlock the administrative features of the cablemodem you purchased.

He could have created a firmware which automated many of the functions i described previously, but didn't specifically because it was illegal. He heavily moderated his forums, banned anyone immediately after posting anything remotely resembling any illegal content, and only sold/allowed those who guaranteed that they wouldn't be using the firmware or the information in the forums for illegal purposes.

in short, his firmware unlocked cable modems, just like your pencil trick unlocked amd processors.

Now there were definitely some unscrupulous vendors who sold overclocked systems with heatsinks GLUED to the processors and bios's modified to show a faster processor than was revealed after an official bios update. Are the people who posted the information about the pencil trick responsible for their actions?

Is the person who showed you how to unlock your cable modem responsible for the kid who used that information to DoS attack people off the internet?

Is the person who invented the taser responsible for those who misuse the taser?

personally, i see a clear difference between DerEngel who saw it as his job to moderate those forums day and night for illegal information, and those who make and distribute modified xbox firmware for *wink wink, nudge nuge* authorized backup copies ONLY... There are guide about how to create and burn backup copies of DRM protected games on the xbox hacking sites, DerEngel had no such similar information, to find out how to STEAL cable modem internet services requires a lot more searching via google, or piratebay type sites.

Unambiguition, i'm a Network engineer and PEN tester, i see it as my responsibility to know how these type off attacks work on specific networks; i've read DerEngel's book "hacking the cable modem", and i've read Bunnie's book "Hacking the Xbox: An Introduction to Reverse Engineering". Neither decribe the persuit of criminal activities in relation to defeat poorly thought out and designed computer systems...

This is a witch hunt, plain and simple. Perhaps if Ryan Harris was given the benefit of a tution to MIT, it would have proceeded like it did for Andrew Huang.

Andrew "Bunnie" Huang enable the complete defeat of all protected systems on your Xbox. And was given a tour of microsofts HPC labs and supercomputing centers around the world.

Ryan Harris enabled the ability to upload your own configuration files to your cable modem. And is facing federal prison.

Quoted because it should be.
 
There is no evidence that DerEngel committed any cable theft... So what the heck are you talking about?

Read everyones posts and you'll realize I'm responding to the flow of conversation and not the main story at this point.

I was talking to OCgamer's 10:13 post.
 
i seem to remember there being a pretty lengthy discussion considering the morality of overclocking intel and amd processors when the celeron 350a came out... Just because modifying an athlon XP with a pencil is easier than modifying a motorola sufboard with a usb cable doesn't make the act of modification illegal.

to actual steal the cable modem service required sniffing the cable modem network from a working cable modem MAC; spoofing that person's MAC address when they weren't online, and downloading the configuration file from their modem to use when they weren't present, or you were willing to DoS attack them off the Node. NOTHING he sold or did allowed this, the only thing he gave, was the ability to unlock the administrative features of the cablemodem you purchased.

He could have created a firmware which automated many of the functions i described previously, but didn't specifically because it was illegal. He heavily moderated his forums, banned anyone immediately after posting anything remotely resembling any illegal content, and only sold/allowed those who guaranteed that they wouldn't be using the firmware or the information in the forums for illegal purposes.

in short, his firmware unlocked cable modems, just like your pencil trick unlocked amd processors.

Now there were definitely some unscrupulous vendors who sold overclocked systems with heatsinks GLUED to the processors and bios's modified to show a faster processor than was revealed after an official bios update. Are the people who posted the information about the pencil trick responsible for their actions?

Is the person who showed you how to unlock your cable modem responsible for the kid who used that information to DoS attack people off the internet?

Is the person who invented the taser responsible for those who misuse the taser?

personally, i see a clear difference between DerEngel who saw it as his job to moderate those forums day and night for illegal information, and those who make and distribute modified xbox firmware for *wink wink, nudge nuge* authorized backup copies ONLY... There are guide about how to create and burn backup copies of DRM protected games on the xbox hacking sites, DerEngel had no such similar information, to find out how to STEAL cable modem internet services requires a lot more searching via google, or piratebay type sites.

Unambiguition, i'm a Network engineer and PEN tester, i see it as my responsibility to know how these type off attacks work on specific networks; i've read DerEngel's book "hacking the cable modem", and i've read Bunnie's book "Hacking the Xbox: An Introduction to Reverse Engineering". Neither decribe the persuit of criminal activities in relation to defeat poorly thought out and designed computer systems...

This is a witch hunt, plain and simple. Perhaps if Ryan Harris was given the benefit of a tution to MIT, it would have proceeded like it did for Andrew Huang.

Andrew "Bunnie" Huang enable the complete defeat of all protected systems on your Xbox. And was given a tour of microsofts HPC labs and supercomputing centers around the world.

Ryan Harris enabled the ability to upload your own configuration files to your cable modem. And is facing federal prison.

Please take the time to post more often. This forum needs more of these posts.
 
Do you even read anything people say before you? The unlocked modem goes beyond what you paid for. You buy a 3mbps Comcast connection, that modem would get you 25mbps.

Go on, tell us how that's not stealing.

it all depends how you use it,(ie what configuration file you use) The internet is the same way, some people use it for illegally downloading music/software etc. Unless there is the device was created with no other purpose than to commit crimes, there is no reason the creator should be held liable for its use. If they are so worried about it go after the poeple that illegally use the product. If there is a guilty verdict in this case if will set a bad precedent for future gadget tinkerers and entrepreneurs. Apple might get the ammo they need to go after people will jail broken iPhones.
 
:rolleyes:

Way to take things out of context.

"selling unlocked cable modems that can be used to steal extra speed from a broadband provider, or obtain free service."

That was the purpose of his re-flashed cablemodem, just as it's not illegal to write a virus, but to write it and send it out into circulation is.


In that same vein, you can just as easily modify the MAC address of a linksys router to be whatever you want, and use that to spoof the other half of cable modem connection away from the original bonded computer (given that you DoS that computer while you're stealing its MAC/IP) if you're into networking, you can use all types of networking equipment to do all types of things that most people would find illegal in a court of law. JUST because a device can be used for a purpose that is illegal in nature doesn't make it illegal to posses, or use.

Ever car sold has the capacity to break the speed limit, i.e. the law, EVEN WITH the installed "governers " however removing those governers isn't illegal, and selling a car that has the capacity to break the law isn't illegal. selling a car that is heavily modified, and breaks the manufacture's warranty isn't illegal.

Neither is selling a modified linksys router, or an Overclocked computer. Given that you notify them before hand it has been modified. If i plan to use an overclocked computer and the additional computing resources to do something illegal, than I am at faunt, NOT the person who overclock the computer, and not the manufacturer of the high quality parts.
 
Do you even read anything people say before you? The unlocked modem goes beyond what you paid for. You buy a 3mbps Comcast connection, that modem would get you 25mbps.

Go on, tell us how that's not stealing.

not true. The modem would give you whatever speed you configured it for, and would allow you to see what your cable company configured your modem for. The don't always set it at the speed they sold it to you for, especially if there's network congestion, and more specifically if you violate their unadvertised per month bandwidth allotments. You violate that unspoken amount of traffic, and you will continue to pay for a 10mbs connection and x/month, however you will only be alloted 1mbs at the same price. They prey on the rationale that most will not notice if their speed suddenly drops from 10 to 3 or 5 to 1 if they need to solve a larger network issue, and MOST of the the time, they will not switch you back after the problem has been resolved.

I'm not attempting to justify anyone's motivation for modifying their config files, when my speed drops, i simply call tech support and ask them to fix it. I am however lucky enough to have a cableco who actually listens to their customers, some parts of the country are not so justly served.
 
Then take legal action against them. Of course you don't have the income most likely to do so, so gather a group of people with proof... Or stop paying for their service because they are not providing high enough quality or meeting their promises. You don't tap your electricity to "loosen" how much your meter claims your drawing do you? And if you do and find that ok as well; morale issues indeed.

when someone has a monopoly of the highspeed market in your area, your options are limited, some turn to this style of vigilante justice rather than a lawsuit they cannot afford.
 
Huh.........and I suppose you are going to claim that I can't do this with cable or satellite boxes either.:rolleyes:
 
He should of done is like everyone else does, teach other how to do it for free.
 
I think they are just drawing straws as to who is the least likely to put up a fight. Someone needs to go to jail for something or these over-paid federal task forces would go bye-bye.

I hope he wins in court. What he is doing is no more illegal that unlocking an extra core on an AMD X3 720. How the end user decides to use what is unlocked should be the issue.
 
Huh.........and I suppose you are going to claim that I can't do this with cable or satellite boxes either.:rolleyes:

i'm not sure where you're going with that. Those who participate in analog cable theft, were able to do so and get away with it by claiming their devices were for testing purposes only and never meant to be connected to a CableCo's system, without their notification.

They were very clear that if you used this on a CableCo's network without their permission you would almost certainly be in violation of state and/or federal law.

Big Dish Satellite was and is Free; the small dish version has now taken to "Free To Air"
A Satellite dish, grossly simplified, is a large antenna that receive signals from space. Anyone who wants to buy the antenna is allowed to receive the signals, THEY COULD NOT STOP YOU IF THEY WANTED TOO.

However, content providers DO want to charge, now, and have encrypted channels that they want to protect from the Free Air reception that Satellite Dish are inherently capable of.

Bypassing this content encryption without permission is illegal, a Free to Air box initially only has the capacity to receive unencrypted channels, including THOUSANDS of channels from around the world. HOWEVER, if you purchase a decryption card and a monthly service contract, use can also use your FTA box, to decrypt channels from DishNetwork or DirectTV, or any of the lesser known content providers with custom decryption cards for long distance learning, private corporate communication networks, etc.

If you obtain one of these decryption cards by, stealing it from bestbuy, or downloading a copy of bestbuy's card, and using that copy in your receiver, you are guilty of theft plain and simple.

In both cases, the user has to make a conscious decision to participate in criminal activity.

In the case of the cable modem, it is unlock, but being unlock is not inherently illegal; it's just granting options to portions of your modem that you paid for and the CableCo denied you when it upload it's configuration file. Your cable modem is far more powerful that you realize. You don't know this, because you're not allowed to see the hidden options; unless of course you're time warner, and the only thing you use to lock people out of those function is some poorly written javascript: "Time Warner Cable Exposes 65,000 Customer Routers to Remote Hacks" http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2009/10/time-warner-cable/

How do you know your network is secure, unless you're allowed to check it?
 
when someone has a monopoly of the highspeed market in your area, your options are limited, some turn to this style of vigilante justice rather than a lawsuit they cannot afford.

Vigilante Justice or Independent Theft?

You go to the store to get iodine salt. When you get there you find that there is six kinds of basic salt and one with iodine but the iodine cost ten times as much, do you steal the idonine salt because there are not enough options?
 
Vigilante Justice or Independent Theft?

You go to the store to get iodine salt. When you get there you find that there is six kinds of basic salt and one with iodine but the iodine cost ten times as much, do you steal the idonine salt because there are not enough options?

You go to the store to get iodine salt. When you get there you find there is only one kind of iodine salt, and although it says 10% iodine, it only has 1%. Your only option is to buy that Iodine salt, and consume 10x more salt to get the proper amount of Iodine.

A Vigilante outside the store says "pssh, comeere, i figured out a way to always get the amount of iodine they're advertising, you're paying for, and they're not providing."

Do you pay the Vigilante once, for a solution that works now, because without the Iodine you'll develop a goiter, or do you continue purchase the 1% iodized salt, and contact a lawyer about starting a class action lawsuit?
 
I'm wondering how can this people steal the internet of other I understand they need the mac address of someone that it's actually paying for the service, but don't they have to go to those peoples houses to get their MACs ?? what about if those peoples are online after u steal it and your are online too with the same MAC address don't the ISP knows there is a duplicate MAC in the network?? in that way it will be easy for the ISP to track you down, so I don't get how people dare to do this knowing if so simple to get in trouble.

and someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Toyota sold me a truck that can do 100+ mph. I plan to do 46 in a 45 on my lunch break. A federal task force should rip in to Toyota.
 
I'm wondering how can this people steal the internet of other I understand they need the mac address of someone that it's actually paying for the service, but don't they have to go to those peoples houses to get their MACs ?? what about if those peoples are online after u steal it and your are online too with the same MAC address don't the ISP knows there is a duplicate MAC in the network?? in that way it will be easy for the ISP to track you down, so I don't get how people dare to do this knowing if so simple to get in trouble.

and someone please correct me if I'm wrong.

(phone)ring *ring*

(comcast customer) "Hello"

(Internet theif) "Hi I'm Bob Johnson from Comcast, can I have you check something on your modem for me?"

(comcast customer) "what for"

(Internet theif) "We just want to make sure your service is working correctly and at it's full potential"

The rest is self explanatory.
 
I'm wondering how can this people steal the internet of other I understand they need the mac address of someone that it's actually paying for the service, but don't they have to go to those peoples houses to get their MACs ?? what about if those peoples are online after u steal it and your are online too with the same MAC address don't the ISP knows there is a duplicate MAC in the network?? in that way it will be easy for the ISP to track you down, so I don't get how people dare to do this knowing if so simple to get in trouble.

and someone please correct me if I'm wrong.

Depends on the network, some ISP's trasmit MAC's in the clear, they can be sniffed out
 
I’m sure there are nuances of this matter I am missing, such as how the FBI buying two units allows them to arrest him.

Easy answer, lets say the FBI agent was using the name of a well known terrorist figure, that would automatically give them cause.
 
Depends on the network, some ISP's trasmit MAC's in the clear, they can be sniffed out

so what about the people that are stealing the internet I have comcast and I will be mad if I know someone have my MAC and info to get free internet how are they gonna get those people?:mad:
 
Back
Top