i7 vs Q9550, hmmm, some help please?

NathanP2007

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Dec 17, 2007
Messages
1,697
So its not really a Versus persay. Currently i cant afford a Core i7 and new mobo, and im not even sure if i could i would, considering it seems like more and more new intel cpu's are coming out, and i think i have read that there arent a TON of i7/i5 boards out right now. I will probably be able to afford one by the time they change the stepping and voltage, aka when they come out with it re-done. (not sure the technical wording for what im trying to describe sorry.)

Anyways, so my gaming rig you see in my signature, that will be my standard computer once windows 7 comes out officially. The cpu is good, and im told its highly overclockable, and my mobo is a great overvclocking motherboard im told as well.
The best cpu you can get for my motherboard is the Q9650, but that is $350's and il pass. The next step down is the Q9550, which looks great and typically on [h]ere anyone with a great rig without core i7 has the Q9550. Im curious what your guys opinion is on it? If i got it, will it stand to time? Is it in the same ball park as the core i7?
Im planning on upgrading to it once the price drops more, iv noticed a popular store has it for $159.99 sometimes but you have to go to the store, and there isnt one in WA.

Lastly , if you know the answer to this it would be greatly appriciated: I notice the stepping on my Mobo website ( http://www.gigabyte.com.tw/Support/Motherboard/CPUSupport_Model.aspx?ProductID=3013#anchor_os ) that it takes for Q9550 is EO and C1, this guy http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1459388 talks about there being a new stepping or new batch or something. (Maybe thats why they arent on tiger direct anymore?restocking) and do you think if i bought one of those new batch ones, would it be compatible with my mobo? Do those companies update their compatibility list often enough for me to know if its compatible or not?
Thanks guys and girls.
 
Your motherboard can take ANY socket 775 processor. P45 is one of the newest chipset for 775.

I don't think you need a quad core these days for just GAMING, you're not going to notice a big difference with 99% of the games out there, if any at all. Yes, people are right, your cpu is very overclockable, try 3.8-4.0ghz or higher.

I would just use your system for now since it's still pretty dang fast, save up until you have enough for an i7 system + a faster videocard.

And this is [H]ardOCP, learn how to overclock already! :)
 
Your motherboard can take ANY socket 775 processor. P45 is one of the newest chipset for 775.

I don't think you need a quad core these days for just GAMING, you're not going to notice a big difference with 99% of the games out there, if any at all. Yes, people are right, your cpu is very overclockable, try 3.8-4.0ghz or higher.

I would just use your system for now since it's still pretty dang fast, save up until you have enough for an i7 system + a faster videocard.

And this is [H]ardOCP, learn how to overclock already! :)
I understand the quad core for gaming part, iv heard that a lot, though i have heard in the not to distant future, games will start being made to utilize quad core cpu's. I will say its not like i video edit or w/e, but it wont JUST be my gaming rig anymore, it will be my only rig for all desktop computing. Yeah, what your saying for just save up for a i7 system might be right, more opinions would be nice to hear though :) .
Lol id love to know how to over clock, but from "how to" websites it comes off as very complicated, it voids warranties, and im still scared of the risk of bricking something i paid money for. If you know a website that describes well how to overclock id love to read it. All i know is there a tons of multiplier this...voltage that (Vcore?) ...do you need to mess with other things or do you just fiddle with the cpu? etc theres to much that i DONT know, to start messing with bios.
 
Your best bet as someone who doesn't like to overclock would be to save up and get an i5 because of the turbo feature that basically overclocks for you when you're not using all 4 cores. The i5 itself is a bit cheaper than the i7 and the motherboards for socket 1156 tend to be cheaper as well. You'll have yourself a nice, modern quad core that should be future proof for a bit.
 
The newer E0 Q9550 batches are reported to run with less voltage than the first early E0 Q9550 batches.
Mine is one of the early E0 batches. It's a great CPU. If you are not an extreme over clocker the differences in batch voltages and actual performance probably doesn't reall matter. Performance wise they are all good.

However being that Micro Center sales E0 Q9550 for so much less money than anybody else and they have the newest E0 batches it makes for a strong argument that the performance of the Q9550 is a great value for socket 775 motherboards. Especially if you have a P45 chipset MB which has been reported to do very well with over clocking E0 Q9550 quad cores.

One good thing about Q9550 over i5 and i7 is that it has 95w TDP which is much lower than i7 cpus. This lower TDP means less power being used and most importantly to the enthusiast it means stability because of lower voltages and heat. When heat negatively effects the performance of electricity in the form of resistance the performance of the CPU is going to suffer.

If you don't have that much money and you have socket 775mb Intel Q9550 for $159.99 is a great upgrade.

If you have money and can afford to pay for all of the associated cost of running i5 or i7 rig then go i5 or i7.

Socket 775 seems to be coming to the end of it's life cycle and I don't know if intel plans on any new quad core 32nm cpus for it.

On the other hand i5 and i7 chipsets seem to have much more room to grow and ultimate longer life span as they are still fairly new in comparison to socket 775.

Value and cheap performance for limited time fram Q9550.

Right now it seems the newer intel sockets are still growing and in time there will be much improved chipset motherboards that offer more performance for newer Intel muti core cpus.

I'm happy with P45 chipset and Q9550.

I would like a newer mb and cpu but I'm not willing to pay the extra money for the performance gains which right now I just don't need.
 
Yeah tell me if you guys agree, it seems like the best thing to do is, save up for a long while cause im totally fine with my e5200, and if i can overclock it to 3.2ghz or something than it would be even better, but its good for gaming and overall speed, and 6 months from now or maybe even longer, i can pull out my board and cpu and maybe build a separate computer with those 2 pieces later on. But at that time, take my rig and buy a 1156 board and a i5 or i7 and have a i7 computer.
For now like i said, keep it at e5200, which is so far really nice, overclock it if i want more performance (and learn how), and down the line, buy a 1156 board and i5/i7.
 
Yeah tell me if you guys agree, it seems like the best thing to do is, save up for a long while cause im totally fine with my e5200, and if i can overclock it to 3.2ghz or something than it would be even better, but its good for gaming and overall speed, and 6 months from now or maybe even longer, i can pull out my board and cpu and maybe build a separate computer with those 2 pieces later on. But at that time, take my rig and buy a 1156 board and a i5 or i7 and have a i7 computer.
For now like i said, keep it at e5200, which is so far really nice, overclock it if i want more performance (and learn how), and down the line, buy a 1156 board and i5/i7.

I agree with sticking with the e5200 for now until you have enough for i5/i7. I myself was in a similar situation; had an althon x2 6000+, and also had an e5200 (my dads) and wanted to make the jump to i7 which I did, and dont regret one bit. Was about a week after i5/i7 p55 came out, decided id rather go with i7/x58 and got myself a 920. About overclocking, I cant stress how simple and easy it was with the e5200. I'm not a veteran overclocker by any means, but with the e5200 all I did was raise the fsb to 240 I believe (i think the multi was 12.5) to get it to 3ghz, I dont even think I increased any voltages or anything. It was almost as easy as getting the 920 to 3.5 ;)
 
Raoulvaz, is there anything else needed? Is stock air fine? What type of real world improvement will i see? (gaming, application speeds) Is there anything else you need to overclock/change voltage in unison with the cpu? Thanks
 
overclocking is too easy to be scared of it. Want to be completely safe? Then don't up your voltage any and increase your front side bus slightly. Then run 3dmark twice, once you're in windows, if it doesn't freeze you should be safe rinse repeat. If it does freeze just restart your computer and put it at the settings you had previously.

I can guarantee nothing bad will happen to your pc if you follow this formula, if you start upping the voltage thats when problems can occur but even that is safe if you do it modestly and follow what a known safe voltage for what the cpu is. As far as a warranty goes I've never seen a cpu go bad (except when I built my second pc and forgot to put the heatsink on all the way) and I have been repairing pc's for over 10 years now.

The q9550 is a great cpu and will actually beat the i7 920 in multiple gaming benchmarks(some not most) clocked at the same speed.
 
overclocking is too easy to be scared of it. Want to be completely safe? Then don't up your voltage any and increase your front side bus slightly. Then run 3dmark twice, once you're in windows, if it doesn't freeze you should be safe rinse repeat. If it does freeze just restart your computer and put it at the settings you had previously.

I can guarantee nothing bad will happen to your pc if you follow this formula, if you start upping the voltage thats when problems can occur but even that is safe if you do it modestly and follow what a known safe voltage for what the cpu is. As far as a warranty goes I've never seen a cpu go bad (except when I built my second pc and forgot to put the heatsink on all the way) and I have been repairing pc's for over 10 years now.

The q9550 is a great cpu and will actually beat the i7 920 in multiple gaming benchmarks(some not most) clocked at the same speed.

That sounds really good, and il do that once i get official Win 7 installed on my new rig, but like i asked before, im curious real world application. Will i see improved frame rate in games? Faster loading programs like Word/Internet?
 
That sounds really good, and il do that once i get official Win 7 installed on my new rig, but like i asked before, im curious real world application. Will i see improved frame rate in games? Faster loading programs like Word/Internet?

improved frame rate for sure, faster loading if you're running multiple applications
 
Your best bet as someone who doesn't like to overclock would be to save up and get an i5 because of the turbo feature that basically overclocks for you when you're not using all 4 cores. The i5 itself is a bit cheaper than the i7 and the motherboards for socket 1156 tend to be cheaper as well. You'll have yourself a nice, modern quad core that should be future proof for a bit.

Would HT make a difference in gaming performance?
 
You have fast enough ram as it is... just buy a nice air cooler and see how far you can push your CPU. It costs you $40 and you can probably get more out of your CPU than you think.

I think i've seen people get 3.7 to 4.0ghz out of your cpu. If you can get that and it's still slow, try upgrading to a GTX260 or HD4890 before you worry about a new CPU. I hear that for most current games clock speed is what's important. I could be wrong though... i don't know how much the 2mb cache hurts you.
 
I have gone from E5200 > E8400 > Q6600 > Q9550 and back to E5200. The main thing i do on my gaming rig is Game with casual encoding and nothing much more but of course its my media center, etc. Q9550 was a very good chip when i had it, did 4.0Ghz easily under my UD3P but it was a total waste since the E5200 did what i wanted and more.

E5200 are very good chips and still are fast and enough to meet the demands of current tech, Now that i have gone through 3 E5200's chips trying to find the golden one to keep overclocked, I wouldnt say that you will get 3.8Ghz+ out of them right off the bat. 2/3 of my E5200's clocked at a max 3.75Ghz with safe voltage. My current chip does 4.0Ghz with alot of tweaking and 1.45V and stable under any stress.

My suggestion would be to clock the E5200 mildly and save for i5.
 
There is a difference in alot of quad core games vs dual core games lately, don't believe otherwise. Those days of faster dual core are over imho.
 
There is a difference in alot of quad core games vs dual core games lately, don't believe otherwise. Those days of faster dual core are over imho.

Yes, just coming from a Core 2 Duo @3gig conroe to I7 I can 100% agree.

Borderlands, Supreme Commander(big time improvement I7), and to a less degree Fallout 3 all benefit from more than 2 cores.

Borderlands runs a Core 2 duo @3.0Ghz at 90% on both cores at 1900x1080. So I believe the CPU will be a bottleneck for many dual core users esp ones below maybe 2.8Ghz and worse for AMD X2 users.
 
Back
Top