Arrest Puts Focus on Protesters’ Texting

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you are using Twitter to help protestors avoid being arrested, you should probably make sure the cops aren’t monitoring you. Oviously this guy had warning signs...Congratulations! You have 44 FBI agents following you on Twitter! :D

Elliot Madison, 41, a social worker who has described himself as an anarchist, had been arrested in Pittsburgh on Sept. 24 and charged with hindering apprehension or prosecution, criminal use of a communication facility and possession of instruments of crime. The Pennsylvania State Police said he was found in a hotel room with computers and police scanners while using the social-networking site Twitter to spread information about police movements. He has denied wrongdoing.
 
Amazing how different the "Tea party" protesters and the G20 protesters are treated. Sure, IMO, they are both protesting for idiotic reasons, but the tea party protesters get sponsored by the Republican party, actually have a TV station (Fox News) that tries to organize them, then tries to get them cheering just in time to record it (look online for the video of the fox producer trying her best to rile up the crowd for the cameras).

They are there because a TV station told them to be there, they protest whatever the TV station told them to (which is always the opposite of whatever Obama's stance on something is - Republicans were for net neutrality under Clinton, and now they're against it under Obama?), and then the TV station uses the footage they caused to demonstrate why their original demand for the protest was valid. Talk about circular logic. They get praised as just 'ordinary, hard working, good americans.'

Meanwhile, the G20 protesters have no idea what they want to protest. They complain about globalization (why? They're not sure, they just think it's evil somehow.), capitalism, and just all kinds of things. They aren't sponsored by the Republican party of course, so they get orders to disperse. They get tear gas, they get cops rounding them up to arrest them, even people that tell them things from home get arrested.

I don't think anybody can argue the cops are unbiased or fair when you contrast the enormous differences in the way the two groups are treated. The guy with a "Obama Bin Laden" poster is just a good american, but the guy with the spiky hair needs to be tear gassed and arrested for being in a crowd? It doesn't say they did anything other than 'disobey an order to disperse.'
 
Not sure what all that has to do with being busted because you used Twitter to help protesters avoid arrest but....let's try to keep this on topic.

:)
 
Violation of first and forth all at the same time. Looks like the judge isn't looking favorably on the arrest. Good thing too.
 
Tea party protesters were protesting in a normal and non-violent way in predetermined locations of assembly. G20 protesters were advocating and initiating destruction of public and private property at random places for no apparent reason other than for the sake of 'protest'. There's a difference between protest and vandalism.
 
Tea party protesters were protesting in a normal and non-violent way in predetermined locations of assembly. G20 protesters were advocating and initiating destruction of public and private property at random places for no apparent reason other than for the sake of 'protest'. There's a difference between protest and vandalism.


Agreed :) if you agree or not with WHY they're protesting is irrelavent. Act like children and you'll get treated like such. Showing the officers respect will get you much much further than being a d-bag to them
 
Not sure what all that has to do with being busted because you used Twitter to help protesters avoid arrest but....let's try to keep this on topic.

:)

I'm just saying - if it's illegal to organize, or assist protesters (like what this guy was arrested for), shouldn't a lot of people at Fox News be getting their computers and everything else in their home seized right now?
 
Tea party protesters were protesting in a normal and non-violent way in predetermined locations of assembly. G20 protesters were advocating and initiating destruction of public and private property at random places for no apparent reason other than for the sake of 'protest'. There's a difference between protest and vandalism.

Here's what I got from the article on why he was arrested:
"On Thursday, F.B.I. agents descended on a house in Jackson Heights, Queens, and spent 16 hours searching it. The most likely reason for the raid: a man who lived there had helped coordinate communications among protesters at the Group of 20 summit in Pittsburgh."

Here's what I got from the article on why the protesters were being arrested:
"A criminal complaint in Pennsylvania accuses him of “directing others, specifically protesters of the G-20 summit, in order to avoid apprehension after a lawful order to disperse.”"

The protesters get an order to disperse (it doesn't say they were being arrested for vandalism, just a simple order to go away), so this guy tells them to go somewhere else, at which point they and him are now criminals?
 
I'm just saying - if it's illegal to organize, or assist protesters (like what this guy was arrested for), shouldn't a lot of people at Fox News be getting their computers and everything else in their home seized right now?

there's a difference between organizing and willingly helping someone break the law fyi

The police were breaking up the crowd... the dummy then used social networks to help people get around it. There is NOTHING illegal about organizing and/or protesting as long as you're civil and following the laws
 
You are intentionally overlooking the fact that the "Tea Party" gatherings had permits while the G20 protesters did not. Once they hit the streets and began marching it became an unlawful assembly and they refused to disperse. Some refused with violence. Shops were damaged and rocks and other objects were thrown at police. There was none of that going on at any of the Tea Party horseshit I believe. I realize you may have gotten all your information from one online blurb, so I suggest you find a few more.

If you wish to compare the two protests, that is fine, but do not be intentionally blind to facts which have a negative impact on what you are trying to say just because you want to make a point....or whatever it is you think you are doing.

Also, keep in mind that some protesters have every intention of bringing about a police response. Quiet protests get ignored for the most part, ones where police have to take action get talked about much more.

As to the story about the guy with the scanner who got arrested...I am not sure how I feel about it yet. On the surface I find it disturbing but I have not looked into the story enough to have an intelligent opinion.
 
Forgot to quote the post I was responding to, it was this one...

Amazing how different the "Tea party" protesters and the G20 protesters are treated. Sure, IMO, they are both protesting for idiotic reasons, but the tea party protesters get sponsored by the Republican party, actually have a TV station (Fox News) that tries to organize them, then tries to get them cheering just in time to record it (look online for the video of the fox producer trying her best to rile up the crowd for the cameras).

They are there because a TV station told them to be there, they protest whatever the TV station told them to (which is always the opposite of whatever Obama's stance on something is - Republicans were for net neutrality under Clinton, and now they're against it under Obama?), and then the TV station uses the footage they caused to demonstrate why their original demand for the protest was valid. Talk about circular logic. They get praised as just 'ordinary, hard working, good americans.'

Meanwhile, the G20 protesters have no idea what they want to protest. They complain about globalization (why? They're not sure, they just think it's evil somehow.), capitalism, and just all kinds of things. They aren't sponsored by the Republican party of course, so they get orders to disperse. They get tear gas, they get cops rounding them up to arrest them, even people that tell them things from home get arrested.

I don't think anybody can argue the cops are unbiased or fair when you contrast the enormous differences in the way the two groups are treated. The guy with a "Obama Bin Laden" poster is just a good american, but the guy with the spiky hair needs to be tear gassed and arrested for being in a crowd? It doesn't say they did anything other than 'disobey an order to disperse.'
 
Well, I'm not sure about New York City, but up in Mass it's illegal to have a police scanner, that might be part of it. Also last I checked, helping someone evade arrest is also illegal. Accessory after the fact or some such?
 
I think a lot of it must have to do with the content of the messages he was sending on twitter. I don't think it is illegal to say "police are going here", "police are responding to a #345 there". etc...

But if he's saying something like "Police are responding to your shots fired at XXX get away before they arrive..." That makes him an accomplice after the fact.

We don't know what he was saying exactly. It might have been more contextually relevant than we realize. It could have been a terrorist organizing a suicide bombing for all we know. It's probably just an idiot on a police scanner with twitter, but I'm just saying, we don't know all the facts.
 
You are intentionally overlooking the fact that the "Tea Party" gatherings had permits while the G20 protesters did not. Once they hit the streets and began marching it became an unlawful assembly and they refused to disperse. Some refused with violence. Shops were damaged and rocks and other objects were thrown at police. There was none of that going on at any of the Tea Party horseshit I believe. I realize you may have gotten all your information from one online blurb, so I suggest you find a few more.

If you wish to compare the two protests, that is fine, but do not be intentionally blind to facts which have a negative impact on what you are trying to say just because you want to make a point....or whatever it is you think you are doing.

Also, keep in mind that some protesters have every intention of bringing about a police response. Quiet protests get ignored for the most part, ones where police have to take action get talked about much more.

As to the story about the guy with the scanner who got arrested...I am not sure how I feel about it yet. On the surface I find it disturbing but I have not looked into the story enough to have an intelligent opinion.

You do not need a permit to protest in public. Period. It's in the Constitution, and it's a right. You are right, though, that police disperse crowds when they perceive (a very slippery subject!) that damage to property or human life may occur as a result of the gathering.

As far as this guy is concerned.... this is very, very concerning. Since when is it a crime to transmit and disperse public information?
 
As far as this guy is concerned.... this is very, very concerning. Since when is it a crime to transmit and disperse public information?

Its a crime if police are responding to some indecent and the perpetrators are following the guy on twitter. It's just contextually relevant.
 
If you wish to compare the two protests, that is fine, but do not be intentionally blind to facts which have a negative impact on what you are trying to say just because you want to make a point....or whatever it is you think you are doing.

I just think this guy really should not have been arrested, and his place searched for 'assisting' protesters. The police tell the crowd to leave, this guy tells the crowd to leave, now this guy's a criminal? I didn't see anything like that happening to the tea party protesters. It seems really unfair how different the two protesters are treated.

Take a guess who scares me more:
The fringe members of the G20 protests with bricks complaining about capitalism, or the fringe members of the tea party protests with semiautomatic weapons and "Arrest Obama! He's a communist!" t-shirts.

Yet, I see the guy who might have helped the G20 protesters (by telling them to leave right after the police just told them to leave) get arrested in this article, while nobody was arrested for helping organize the other protests.
 
You do not need a permit to protest in public. Period. It's in the Constitution, and it's a right. You are right, though, that police disperse crowds when they perceive (a very slippery subject!) that damage to property or human life may occur as a result of the gathering.

As far as this guy is concerned.... this is very, very concerning. Since when is it a crime to transmit and disperse public information?

You do however need a permit to march I believe, which is what started the escalation.
 
Its a crime if police are responding to some indecent and the perpetrators are following the guy on twitter. It's just contextually relevant.

People dispersing after an order to disperse is not a crime. Helping them avoid the police is not a crime. My impression is that the police wanted to arrest people for "not dispersing," but couldn't, because they we're dispersing using the information given to them by Madison....

Madison was broadcasting where the police were, and what they were doing. By charging this man with a crime, it sets a precedent that anyone who conveys information about the whereabouts and activities of police is potentially a criminal. I personally do not find that comforting.
 
I think a lot of it must have to do with the content of the messages he was sending on twitter. I don't think it is illegal to say "police are going here", "police are responding to a #345 there". etc...

But if he's saying something like "Police are responding to your shots fired at XXX get away before they arrive..." That makes him an accomplice after the fact.

We don't know what he was saying exactly. It might have been more contextually relevant than we realize. It could have been a terrorist organizing a suicide bombing for all we know. It's probably just an idiot on a police scanner with twitter, but I'm just saying, we don't know all the facts.

Well, the article gives an example of the types of messages being sent:

Many of those messages tracked police movements. One read: “SWAT teams rolling down 5th Ave.” Another read: “Report received that police are ‘nabbing’ anyone that looks like a protester / Black Bloc. Stay alert watch your friends!”

^ Seems pretty innocent to me...
 
I just think this guy really should not have been arrested, and his place searched for 'assisting' protesters. The police tell the crowd to leave, this guy tells the crowd to leave, now this guy's a criminal? I didn't see anything like that happening to the tea party protesters. It seems really unfair how different the two protesters are treated.

Take a guess who scares me more:
The fringe members of the G20 protests with bricks complaining about capitalism, or the fringe members of the tea party protests with semiautomatic weapons and "Arrest Obama! He's a communist!" t-shirts.

Yet, I see the guy who might have helped the G20 protesters (by telling them to leave right after the police just told them to leave) get arrested in this article, while nobody was arrested for helping organize the other protests.

Dear lord, are you intentionally being daft?

Unless something is left out of the orginal article, I also agree that madison should not have been arrested ad think this is setting the grounds for a potentially troubling precedence.
 
You do not need a permit to protest in public. Period. It's in the Constitution, and it's a right.

so is gun ownership, but plenty of people don't mind stepping all over it.

the reality is that you DO need a permit to protest. Just like you need a permit to do anything in this overlegislated country... violation of the constitution or not
 
I just think this guy really should not have been arrested, and his place searched for 'assisting' protesters. The police tell the crowd to leave, this guy tells the crowd to leave, now this guy's a criminal? I didn't see anything like that happening to the tea party protesters. It seems really unfair how different the two protesters are treated.

Take a guess who scares me more:
The fringe members of the G20 protests with bricks complaining about capitalism, or the fringe members of the tea party protests with semiautomatic weapons and "Arrest Obama! He's a communist!" t-shirts.

Yet, I see the guy who might have helped the G20 protesters (by telling them to leave right after the police just told them to leave) get arrested in this article, while nobody was arrested for helping organize the other protests.

The man in this case who was arrested was not arrested for telling the protesters to simply leave as you put it. He was arrested for helping the protesters escape arrest. Again, I have not looked into the details much but a quick read would lead me to compare it to a situation where somebody is on the run from the law for whatever reason and you call him up and say "don't go to Joe's house, the cops are there"..guess what, you broke the law. This is not the same as a news show/radio broadcast saying what the police are doing or where they are. However they have to prove his messages had the intention of helping others avoid arrest and without seeing all the messages and some kind of timeline, I can't really say one way or the other.

Also you keep ignoring several key facts. There is a difference between a protest and a march. There was no action taken by the police until the lawful protest became an unlawful march. You keep trying to compare apples and oranges with the Tea Party junk yet you fail because you are not comprehending much that disagrees with you.
 
My impression is that the police wanted to arrest people for "not dispersing," but couldn't, because they we're dispersing using the information given to them by Madison....

That doesn't make sense really. Police usually don't want to do mass arrests it's a huge headache for the jail staff and pre-trial staff and most people get OR'd and right back out on the street. It takes a cop several hours to arrest people and with lots of cops trying to make arrests, that leaves less of them helping out on the street.

I clearly have no idea what that guy was saying on twitter but with the knowledge I do have, it doesn't seem like he committed any crime. All I'm saying is that what he said in his messages and how they were received by the recipients is the determining factor in whether or not he was engaged in criminal activity. Simply echoing what's being said, over radio waves, is not a crime as far as I'm aware.
 
so is gun ownership, but plenty of people don't mind stepping all over it.

the reality is that you DO need a permit to protest. Just like you need a permit to do anything in this overlegislated country... violation of the constitution or not

Seriously. The problem is that both the Republicans and the Democrats, conservatives and liberals, LOVE to stomp all over the Constitution, albeit on different amendments :p

One thing that really irks me about so-called Republicans is that they herald themselves as the proponents of "small government," yet usually (this may be a gross oversimplification) seem to side with police in cases like this. I just think that this country needs a healthy dose of level-headed libertarianism (although some libertarians are friggin wacko, bordering on anarchists).

Back on topic. I think we've well-established that this guy should not have been arrested because it sets a very dangerous precedent.
 
That doesn't make sense really. Police usually don't want to do mass arrests it's a huge headache for the jail staff and pre-trial staff and most people get OR'd and right back out on the street. It takes a cop several hours to arrest people and with lots of cops trying to make arrests, that leaves less of them helping out on the street.

I clearly have no idea what that guy was saying on twitter but with the knowledge I do have, it doesn't seem like he committed any crime. All I'm saying is that what he said in his messages and how they were received by the recipients is the determining factor in whether or not he was engaged in criminal activity. Simply echoing what's being said, over radio waves, is not a crime as far as I'm aware.

See my post with the quote from the article. The article gives examples of the types of messages being relayed. In no way are the messages the article gives anything but completely legal.
 
See my post with the quote from the article. The article gives examples of the types of messages being relayed. In no way are the messages the article gives anything but completely legal.

I agree that the messages quoted in the article don't seem illegal. I do think it's unlikely that any incriminating messages would be revealed to the press, this guy was charged with a crime and a warrant was issued by a judge, so I'm making an educated guess that there's some message that wasn't harmless.
 
Seriously. The problem is that both the Republicans and the Democrats, conservatives and liberals, LOVE to stomp all over the Constitution, albeit on different amendments :p

One thing that really irks me about so-called Republicans is that they herald themselves as the proponents of "small government," yet usually (this may be a gross oversimplification) seem to side with police in cases like this. I just think that this country needs a healthy dose of level-headed libertarianism (although some libertarians are friggin wacko, bordering on anarchists).

Back on topic. I think we've well-established that this guy should not have been arrested because it sets a very dangerous precedent.

couldn't agree with you more. I'm still on the fence about if he should of been arrested or not yet as I don't have all the facts. In all honesty it sounds like he made the cops job harder than it had to be and they're getting even with him/making an example out of him. If that's the case, I don't agree with it but he should of used better judgement... especially if police scanners are illegal in his area. ESPECIALLY on a public social network.
 
The man in this case who was arrested was not arrested for telling the protesters to simply leave as you put it. He was arrested for helping the protesters escape arrest. Again, I have not looked into the details much but a quick read would lead me to compare it to a situation where somebody is on the run from the law for whatever reason and you call him up and say "don't go to Joe's house, the cops are there"..guess what, you broke the law. This is not the same as a news show/radio broadcast saying what the police are doing or where they are. However they have to prove his messages had the intention of helping others avoid arrest and without seeing all the messages and some kind of timeline, I can't really say one way or the other.

Also you keep ignoring several key facts. There is a difference between a protest and a march. There was no action taken by the police until the lawful protest became an unlawful march. You keep trying to compare apples and oranges with the Tea Party junk yet you fail because you are not comprehending much that disagrees with you.

The people weren't 'on the run from the law after committing a crime' though. The police told them to disperse, then they left the area (this guy having told them to leave as well), and then you have the police claiming that was a criminal action. There is no underlying crime here other than being part of a crowd, so your 'on the run from the law' comment doesn't really relate. The fact they left the area is actually proof they complied with the order to leave the area.

You accuse me of ignoring key facts, but it seems you are ignoring some too (just see the previous paragraph). Look on Youtube at the actual recordings - you have a bunch of people standing around, yelling things I don't necessarily agree with, but then the police shout "This is an order to disperse. Anybody in this area for any reason will be subject to arrest. Leave the area immediately or you may be injured by nonlethal weapons." followed by them shooting tear gas into the crowd. Even the article states he was helping people protest, not helping people march.
 
I agree that the messages quoted in the article don't seem illegal. I do think it's unlikely that any incriminating messages would be revealed to the press, this guy was charged with a crime and a warrant was issued by a judge, so I'm making an educated guess that there's some message that wasn't harmless.

Yeah, we'll just have to wait and see. But compare this to someone yelling from the top of a building "The police are here on (e.g.) 5th and Main!"

I don't think whether that person is charged with a crime depends on the mission the police are attempting to accomplish. For example, if the police are looking for an accident victim, and the person is announcing where the police are, that person clearly hasn't committed a crime. If the police are looking for people who fail to disperse after a given order, and the person is announcing where the police are (so as not to get arrested for failure to comply with said dispersal order), there still can be no crime committed.

I agree, though, that this could be a sticky situation. However, it appears to me like this man's radical political beliefs factored in on his arrest, and I do not agree with that.
 
The people weren't 'on the run from the law after committing a crime' though. The police told them to disperse, then they left the area (this guy having told them to leave as well), and then you have the police claiming that was a criminal action. There is no underlying crime here other than being part of a crowd, so your 'on the run from the law' comment doesn't really relate. The fact they left the area is actually proof they complied with the order to leave the area.

You accuse me of ignoring key facts, but it seems you are ignoring some too (just see the previous paragraph). Look on Youtube at the actual recordings - you have a bunch of people standing around, yelling things I don't necessarily agree with, but then the police shout "This is an order to disperse. Anybody in this area for any reason will be subject to arrest. Leave the area immediately or you may be injured by nonlethal weapons." followed by them shooting tear gas into the crowd. Even the article states he was helping people protest, not helping people march.

Except that objects were thrown at police and property was damaged, some may call that a crime....and you still refuse to acknowledge the march as unlawful. Some of the protesters have acknowledged it, so can you.
"Up to now there was so much fear - people were told that it would be dangerous and violent at the march on Thursday but it wasn't as bad as people thought it would be," said Peter Shell, president of the Thomas Merton Centre, which advocates change through peaceful struggle.

"This march will be much better. We have a permit. We confront the policies of the G20, not the police. We're a different kind of protest," said Shell.

Here is a link you may want to read before you continue to claim how peaceful everything was. Here are a few pictures as well.

As far as violent police clashes go, this was pretty tame but pretending everyone walked away whistling "We are the World' is willful ignorance.

I will reiterate something I said earlier, without all the messages that were sent and an accurate timeline, I cant say one way or the other if what he was doing was right or wrong.
 
Like I keep saying, simply announcing the activities and whereabouts of the police to anyone who will listen should not be crime, even if it aids people who have committed crimes. In order to maintain a free society, we need to tolerate a bit of injustice. That's just how it has to be. /soapbox
 
The people weren't 'on the run from the law after committing a crime' though. The police told them to disperse, then they left the area (this guy having told them to leave as well), and then you have the police claiming that was a criminal action. There is no underlying crime here other than being part of a crowd, so your 'on the run from the law' comment doesn't really relate. The fact they left the area is actually proof they complied with the order to leave the area.

He was helping them continue an illegal and violent protest by advising them on how to avoid the police. If they were trying to disperse they could have just walked away. The police aren't going to stop someone from leaving a protest.
 
Of course there's no proof either way, but there are a lot of rumors floating about that the police use undercover men to incite violence from within the crowd (throwing rocks, encouraging others to do so, vandalizing, etc..), to justify the official police retaliation.

This sort of thing has happened before, and is currently under investigation in London in relation to protests for the G20 meetup there: http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/may/10/g20-policing-agent-provacateurs
 
He was helping them continue an illegal and violent protest by advising them on how to avoid the police. If they were trying to disperse they could have just walked away. The police aren't going to stop someone from leaving a protest.

Yes, they do. I witness firsthand a woman get a baton to the back of the head as she was peacefully leaving a "riot" in my hometown. I was not taking part in any illegal activities, nor was I part of any group, and got pepper sprayed over a block away from where police responded to. Police get into a mode of operation that is best approximated by "guilty guilty guilty, shoot first ask questions never" when in a crowd-dispersal situation. Simply being in the area means that you are liable to be arrested. I'm all for dispersing crowds when they get out of control, but police do tend to get a bit out of hand in doling out the "justice."
 
The man in this case who was arrested was not arrested for telling the protesters to simply leave as you put it. He was arrested for helping the protesters escape arrest. Again, I have not looked into the details much but a quick read would lead me to compare it to a situation where somebody is on the run from the law for whatever reason and you call him up and say "don't go to Joe's house, the cops are there"..guess what, you broke the law. This is not the same as a news show/radio broadcast saying what the police are doing or where they are. However they have to prove his messages had the intention of helping others avoid arrest and without seeing all the messages and some kind of timeline, I can't really say one way or the other.

I'd like to point out that the second the police issue a "disperse" order, everyone in the area is potentially breaking the law and could be construed as a criminal. By aiding people in their dispersal, he WAS assisting "criminals" escaping from the police, which is how the police see it (at least that's my understanding of the situation). The problem is that simply by broadcasting the whereabouts and activities of the police, he became a criminal. That is just wrong.
 
Oh noes! He had a picture of *GASP* Lenin. Maybe. Why is that even IN the article? To get the conservatards riled up. Way to pander.

The G7/20 protesters (called g-tards from here on out) tend to be clueless too. As much as I think the teabaggers are a bunch of clueless 'tards as well, the g-tards are no better, the difference is the Teabaggaers don't flip over cars and smash storefront windows.

When the g-tards showed up in Seattle for their riot it was pathetic. They were protesting ...um... something. They were all the usual jobless graft consuming profesional activist type. Or clueless students. Fighting The Man.

I don't have much sympathy for these guys or their enablers. Can we get some type of left vs. right tard thunderdome going? Just let 'em all wipe each other out and the center can just go about being rational and pragmatic? Problem is the left probably doesn't have enough guns, so we'd have to give 'em some. But still, I think the idea has merit.
 
The people were upset cause they could not get PERMITS to PROTEST.... So much for first ammendment when the big boys are in town.... Didn't know the constitution said you had to have a permit.. Bunch of crooks running the show and got us brain washed
 
Back
Top