Arrest Puts Focus on Protesters’ Texting

Professor-Chaos_South-Park.jpg
 
Also, keep in mind that some protesters have every intention of bringing about a police response. Quiet protests get ignored for the most part, ones where police have to take action get talked about much more.

Well, the problem with these guys is that it seems that was what their whole protest was... Just to rile up police and cause trouble.. I don't see how free speech even applies, because it doesn't even seem like they were saying anything.. Just looking at what they could do to cause trouble. I mean, if you're gonna go through all of that, at least have a point. I'm not sure whether I agree with their stance or not, since they didn't even seem to have one, other than causing a huge media shitstorm.. I'm all for free speech, but this kind of stuff is bound to actually do more harm than good in that respect.

All in all, though, I guess they really illustrated a point that extremism is bad, no matter which side of the fence you are on.. Now we have some wingnuts coming out on the far left... Just about as annoying as the ones on the right.

In the end, though, I think it's all par for the course when it comes to the G-20.. I thought it was going to be a hell of a lot worse... I'm just glad I didn't have to go through town when all of that was going on.. bleh!
 
We worry about "big brother" snooping in on our lives yet have absolutely no idea that it makes it so much easier when we publicly post for the world to see?
 
Replaying information accessible via public radio waves picked up by a frequency scanner is not assisting others to evade apprehension. He was laying the exact same information that was being broadcasted.

I hope he sues and donates the money back into the peace movement.
 
You do however need a permit to march I believe, which is what started the escalation.

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
:rolleyes:
 
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights states: "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference, and impart information and ideas through any media regardless of frontiers.

So this guy's human rights are being violated because he imparted information about police locations?

I find it kind of sad that the police do not read or even try to understand human rights/ the U.S. Constitution which has been upheld time and time again the supreme court.
 
police? try our politicians

The police only enforce the laws that our good 'ol elected officials make. Vote the pricks out
 
They way our system is set up, anyone who is even ABLE to be voted into office usually has hooks in them from some sort of power-that-be. It's really quite depressing.
 

If you have a real point to make, please do so. However its already been established that you need a permit for what they were doing. All the rolleyes in the world won't change that. I am not saying they are good laws or intelligent laws...but they are there.
 
Who do you want voted in then?

people who don't turn politics into a career is a good place to start. Make running for an office, while you still hold another, illegal (I'm looking at obama, hillary, palin, mccain and the rest of them). They have a duty to their constituents and by taking their focus off that job for a year and a half to campaign for another "job" is absolute bullshit. They have no problem collecting that check though :rolleyes:

If it were the private sector, they'd be fired on the spot.


Also make them LEGALLY accountable for their actions and policies. I bet you'd see a hell of a lot more caution before they decide to spend billions of our tax dollars on bullshit or forcing laws that WE don't want down our throats.

every single one of them, with a few notable exceptions, is out of touch with "real" people... it's disgusting. Either way, I'm done with republicans and democrats... and even worse, the party jumpers (arlen specter)
 
every single one of them, with a few notable exceptions, is out of touch with "real" people... it's disgusting. Either way, I'm done with republicans and democrats... and even worse, the party jumpers (arlen specter)

I agree with you on this. Corporations and lobbyists brainwash people into their corporate agendas. There's no reason for senators to be accepting millions from health products, insurance companies, oil companies, etc. Or that felony fraud and tax evasions are being waved for appointed congressmen. I feel we need a smaller government that is easier to do checks and balances on.

These latest mindless protestors are the sheep of Fox News, they'd rather cause a civil war and watch Obama fail instead of making the world a peaceful co-operation. I bet 35% of americans still believe Obama is a terrorist or muslim, I mean what kind of shit is that to tell your kids? So you have these protestors holding up hilter signs saying "Kill Him!" while legit protestors aren't getting their voices heard over the real issues facing americans.
 
I agree with you on this. Corporations and lobbyists brainwash people into their corporate agendas. There's no reason for senators to be accepting millions from health products, insurance companies, oil companies, etc. Or that felony fraud and tax evasions are being waved for appointed congressmen. I feel we need a smaller government that is easier to do checks and balances on.

These latest mindless protestors are the sheep of Fox News, they'd rather cause a civil war and watch Obama fail instead of making the world a peaceful co-operation. I bet 35% of americans still believe Obama is a terrorist or muslim, I mean what kind of shit is that to tell your kids? So you have these protestors holding up hilter signs saying "Kill Him!" while legit protestors aren't getting their voices heard over the real issues facing americans.


agreed. As a matter of fact, I was ecstatic when a local lawyer (libertarian) started doing tax day tea party's here to protest NY's dysfunctional government. Instead of MAKING due with what they have, they keep raping the people upstate to benefit those in NYC which is absolute bs.

When Fox turned it into "their" thing, it annoyed me. On one hand, it's great that they're getting the word out, but on the other it's putting other motives behind it other than fiscal responsibility and ending government waste :( All it's doing is giving the people who want larger government ammo against it. However, if they didn't cover it then nobody would of IMHO (or not seriously).

As for extremists, they're everywhere. I don't need to point out all the posters and crap blasting bush (and they have every right to have done so)... but it goes both ways. I'm sure the people who hated bush still loved our country and truly wanted was was best for everyone, just as the "white trash rednecks" (I'm sure) do. It's certainly gotten a bit out of hand though and the only ones to blame are the people who hold public office and run the media. They're the ones fueling it on both sides. It's pretty sad to read so many hateful posts about someone just because of their political ideology... a ribbing is one thing, but many times you can tell there is a lot of honesty behind it
 
There is no good answer to that question under the current two party system.

It doesn't get any better with more parties. Here we have two viable parties, the liberals and the conservatives. We also have the NPD, who supports either party as long as its in their best interest. Then there is the Bloc, who want to separate from Canada, and the Green party who's leader lost her seat in the last election.

In reality they are all the same.
 
We had our chance not so long ago to get somebody into office who actually stood on his own two feet. He may not have had the flashiest soundbytes and he may not have been the most handsome fella(yes, we tend to vote for the most charismatic/attractive candidate since the advent of televised campaigns)...but instead of giving his beliefs and thoughts actual consideration, he was turned into an internet laughingstock. Ron Paul folks.

Some of his ideas I did not and still don't agree with but he certainly has a vision, and a workable one. I have heard the man speak and to say the man is intelligent is an understatement.
 
Is it irony if an anarchist organizes communications? :D

The police aren't going to stop someone from leaving a protest.

Check out what the police did during the RNC. They made the mistake of nabbing a couple of local newsies.

I really hope there's more to the story because it didn't sound like the guy specifically knew that crimes were committed, expectations of douchebaggery from these 'protesters' notwithstanding. If that's the case it's another erosion of what we can and cannot do.

And then subpoenaing someone that wrote that TXTmob code...

I don't even see why having a police scanner should be illegal. Figure cops could get equipment by now to encrypt their messages. :rolleyes:

* picks up permit to wipe ass and heads to the bathroom with a roll of Contitutional toilet paper.
 
If using a police scanner is illegal, then I can understand that. However, revealing the whereabouts of police regardless of what is being done is not illegal. Period. Using twitter to reveal the location(s) of police is not illegal. Period. If it ends up that he gets charged with dissemination of information of police whereabouts and is convicted on that charge, that will be a serious problem right there. I would venture to guess a SCOTUS issue. I'll have to do a SCOTUS look up and see if there is precedent for this already or not.

Permits and protests are something different. City ordinances cannot prevent people from assemblage. That's a Constitutional right. However, a right to protest doesn't include the right to damage property or to disobey a lawful command from a position of authority. Not that I'm aware of anyway. Permits to protest are rarely, if ever to my knowledge, denied.
 
If using a police scanner is illegal, then I can understand that. However, revealing the whereabouts of police regardless of what is being done is not illegal. Period. Using twitter to reveal the location(s) of police is not illegal. Period. If it ends up that he gets charged with dissemination of information of police whereabouts and is convicted on that charge, that will be a serious problem right there. I would venture to guess a SCOTUS issue. I'll have to do a SCOTUS look up and see if there is precedent for this already or not.

Permits and protests are something different. City ordinances cannot prevent people from assemblage. That's a Constitutional right. However, a right to protest doesn't include the right to damage property or to disobey a lawful command from a position of authority. Not that I'm aware of anyway. Permits to protest are rarely, if ever to my knowledge, denied.

I agree 100%.
 
It doesn't get any better with more parties. Here we have two viable parties, the liberals and the conservatives. We also have the NPD, who supports either party as long as its in their best interest. Then there is the Bloc, who want to separate from Canada, and the Green party who's leader lost her seat in the last election.

In reality they are all the same.

First of all I would like to apologize for what may turn out to be a very messy post, but I have yet to figure out multiple quoting, and as such am just going to quote draax here and try to remember what everyone else said, and I totally just realized that I can see the rest of the thread below here. wow that is a shocker.

First off, the green party leader (Elizibeth May) never had a seat in the first place, green party has never had a seat. Secondly, although the Bloc is a separatist party that is not their only goal, they are a default option for the quebecois population who are not being properly represented by other federal parties and need someone to represent them. the Bloc is not only for separatists even if that is part of their final plan. Personally I think the system would work better with another conservative party (perhaps more like the reform party of old), of course I am biased in this in that I regard harpers government as unworkable/dysfunctional.

onto other stuff:

I definetely agree with dr.stevil when it comes to making politicians legally responsible in that it would mean more thought would be put into things, seeing as apparently harper is not even answerable to god for what he does as pm (sorry for the harper hate here but it applies). although I don't really like your use of the word "real", admittedly most politicians are more in touch with corporate lobbyists then their constituents, but I just don't like the title of "real people" even though I in truth don't think of corporate tools and the phenomenally rich as real people.

One thing that confuses and I am not sure about is the whole tea party thing, weren't they protesting against obama by not paying taxes or something? because that is what I heard but it doesn't make any sense to me, in that it would just be rebelling against a fair election, can someone appraise me of the true purpose?

to spinelli, who is this ron paul guy, cause I can't find an official platform anywhere and I have looked around ( all I can find is stuff about him in a blimp from xkcd :) ) (oh gods the smiley faced closed parentheses problem!). I will agree that people tend to vote for handsome people who are charismatic, but is there anything wrong with charismatic leaders? provided that they can do a good job (look at Pierre Trudeau he was the most charismatic canadian leader ever).

sorry for the long rambling post but I ramble a lot when thinking, and was also trying to figure out why my tv remote was only from about halfway down (fixed it with some ducktape). Also can someone please explain how you quote multiple people? I am guessing that you go and use the quote=name thing but how do you know the number that goes with the post?
 
to spinelli, who is this ron paul guy, cause I can't find an official platform anywhere and I have looked around ( all I can find is stuff about him in a blimp from xkcd :) ) (oh gods the smiley faced closed parentheses problem!). I will agree that people tend to vote for handsome people who are charismatic, but is there anything wrong with charismatic leaders? provided that they can do a good job (look at Pierre Trudeau he was the most charismatic canadian leader ever).

Ron Paul

..to answer your question, there is nothing wrong with charismatic leaders, provided they have other qualities that make them fit for the position. Sound bytes may rule the 'blogosphere' and crappy news programs but its no way to elect a leader. Unfortunately we do just that. We fall for the same old lies every time and blame the politicians instead of ourselves.
 
First off, the green party leader (Elizibeth May) never had a seat in the first place, green party has never had a seat. Secondly, although the Bloc is a separatist party that is not their only goal, they are a default option for the quebecois population who are not being properly represented by other federal parties and need someone to represent them. the Bloc is not only for separatists even if that is part of their final plan. Personally I think the system would work better with another conservative party (perhaps more like the reform party of old), of course I am biased in this in that I regard harpers government as unworkable/dysfunctional.
You are correct May never had a seat, however she did lose her bid to unseat MacKay, and is now trying to get a seat on the west coast. The green party has all of 6% of the national vote.
I don't consider a party, who wants to separate from the country, to be viable or a good choice for Canadians. Frankly, the population of Quebec needs to get over itself and realize they are not any more important than any other Canadian. Ever travel to Quebec? If you speak English they treat you like dirt. While I was at the Mount Tremblant ski resort every time I tried to order a cab, in English, I was promptly hung up on. Curious how, in Ontario, we have bilingual signs and customer service, yet as soon as I cross into Quebec, there are no English signs and very few are are willing to provide service in English. Heck of a double standard.
 
One thing that confuses and I am not sure about is the whole tea party thing, weren't they protesting against obama by not paying taxes or something? because that is what I heard but it doesn't make any sense to me, in that it would just be rebelling against a fair election, can someone appraise me of the true purpose?

no, not at all. It's just protesting wasteful spending on the state and federal levels (TARP and the stimulus bill not to mention bailing out the auto industry), people still pay their taxes though. Its more to serve as a warning to our politicians to do the right thing as they're all under very close watch... but they choose to mock people instead of listening to them and thats going to bite them in the ass come election time imo.

It's not limited to republicans, libertarians, democrats, green party or independants, contrary to what some would like you to believe, nor is it about race, amount of wealth, residency, etc. Anyone who gives a damn about the alarming rate at which we're spending money and/or those that have had enough of it are jumping on board. If nothing gets done about it, we're going to end up like the USSR :(. The corruption has to end and government has to learn how to live with what it has instead of bleeding us, who are already hurting, dry everytime they mismanage our cash. It's nice to finally see people getting together on something.
 
Well, I'm not sure about New York City, but up in Mass it's illegal to have a police scanner, that might be part of it. Also last I checked, helping someone evade arrest is also illegal. Accessory after the fact or some such?

Holy crap!? Illegal to have a police scanner? It's not only the right, but the responsibility of the citizens to monitor the police.

"Evade" or avoid arrest? Protesters were told to disperse, shouldn't they disperse? If I'm some place where there is a protest going on and people are told to disperse, then, shouldn't I try to avoid areas where people are getting arrested? Don't the police WANT less people to be at those areas??!?

Telling people where the arrests are occurring and directing them away from those areas is nothing more than a public service, helping the people and helping the police at the same time.

Everyone involved with the arrest and search of that man's property should be investigated and prosecuted, what they did was simply absurd and un-American.
 
so is gun ownership, but plenty of people don't mind stepping all over it.

the reality is that you DO need a permit to protest. Just like you need a permit to do anything in this overlegislated country... violation of the constitution or not

Absolutely right on - our government has gone nearly as mad as a rabid dog frothing at the mouth passing laws left and right without properly considering the consequences, either that, or they simply don't care.

I feel like I can't even say "my morals and family values" anymore, because I'm practically not allowed to have my own, they have to be dictated to me by law, by whatever passing fad at the moment has got the mob-minded masses riled up.

Such blatant disregard for the rights and responsibilities of the citizens and The Constitution has been a deepening and disturbing trend, and, Obama has NOT brought the "change" that he promised.
 
Its kind of like using a radar detector IMO. Unless he was helping a known criminal or harboring one, I think he is in the safe.
 
For more information about what was being broadcast, here's an interview with him from Democracy Now:

http://www.democracynow.org/2009/10/6/twitter_crackdown_nyc_activist_arrested_for

What he was doing is essentially what the state dept was applauding during the Iranian protests and asking Twitter to postpone their maintenance cycle to allow people from Iran to continue posting.

To clear up another misconception about Anarchism/Anarchists...
Anarchism as a whole is about mass organization to cause radical social/political/economic change.

It is a non-hierarchical form of political/economic thought, there are no "Leaders" because the idea is that everyone is equal.

hence the slogan: "No Gods, No Masters"

Anarchism is against COERCIVE control and AUTHORITY. It is also against state sponsored terrorism (i.e. US Foreign policy toward South America over the last 100 or so years) which is part of the anti-globalization stance because a majority of globalization is predatory capitalism, that props up oppressive governments to violently suppress the will of the people. (ex: Franco's Spain, Allende & Pinochet's Chile, Hussein's Iraq, insert any "friendly" oppressive regime that the has US funded).

Another Example using Guatemala, quoted from wikipedia:

In 1954, Arévalo's freely elected Guatemalan successor, Jacobo Arbenz, was overthrown in a coup orchestrated by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in the 1954 Guatemalan coup d'état. Colonel Carlos Castillo Armas was installed as president in 1954 and ruled until he was assassinated by a member of his personal guard in 1957. Substantial evidence points to the role of the American United Fruit Company as instrumental in this coup, as the land reforms of Jacobo Arbenz were threatening the company's interests in Guatemala and it had several direct ties to the White House and the CIA. (See United Fruit Company – History in Central America).

Anarchism is about decentralized direct democracy and mutual aid. Anarchism is also about community building and education.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchism
Not all anarchists are violent bomb throwing maniacs, that is maybe 1% of the movement as a whole. The rest are anti-war, anti-corporatism, & anti-state control.
 
You are correct May never had a seat, however she did lose her bid to unseat MacKay, and is now trying to get a seat on the west coast. The green party has all of 6% of the national vote.
I don't consider a party, who wants to separate from the country, to be viable or a good choice for Canadians. Frankly, the population of Quebec needs to get over itself and realize they are not any more important than any other Canadian. Ever travel to Quebec? If you speak English they treat you like dirt. While I was at the Mount Tremblant ski resort every time I tried to order a cab, in English, I was promptly hung up on. Curious how, in Ontario, we have bilingual signs and customer service, yet as soon as I cross into Quebec, there are no English signs and very few are are willing to provide service in English. Heck of a double standard.

yup, she couldn't even win even though the liberals didn't run a candidate, but then again running against the minister of national defence is a bit of a tall order, and she is almost guaranteed to win in saanich-gulf islands. (mackay is also supposed to be the hottest guy on parliament hill interesting tie in with the whole spinelli thing)

as I said before, although they were originally created with separation in mind they are more of a quebecker option now, looking out for their own type of thing. also isn't it only Ottawa that has bilingual signs? Do you know how much of a bitch it is to get service in french anywhere outside of Quebec? Although supposedly it is possible to get any service in Canada in french but that certainly isn't the case. Even though I don't agree with Quebec repeatedly using the notwithstanding clause to avoid bilingualism, other provinces use the notwithstanding clause as well for equally dirty things (can't think of any of them right now, but am fairly sure they are out there). To answer your question, yes I travel to quebec fairly frequently and have never had any problems, most likely because even though I am not that skilled in french, I know people who are, and try my hardest to be better when they aren't around. We are a supposedly bilingual country and if you don't like you can try to, aha, re-form the reform party (couldn't help it). As a test next time I try to phone a cab I am going to try speaking french and seeing if they respond :).

To spinelli:
Ron Paul has a very interesting platform but I personally can't see it, I just disagree with fundamental points, but supposedly democracy will win through, and the will of the people will be done. Either way what is to say the he would be any different then anyone else? Sure his platform is quite new in some points (I've never heard of someone running on the idea of bring back the gold standard), but his unerring belief in the free market is old hat. You say that people are always falling for the same old lies, I say that the lie that <b>this</b> person is truly different is the oldest of them all.
 
Ron Paul

..to answer your question, there is nothing wrong with charismatic leaders, provided they have other qualities that make them fit for the position. Sound bytes may rule the 'blogosphere' and crappy news programs but its no way to elect a leader. Unfortunately we do just that. We fall for the same old lies every time and blame the politicians instead of ourselves.

Meh. He has strong libertarian leanings, but I fail to see how eliminating a graduated income tax will do much of anything but hurt the poor/middle classes (who pay comparatively little taxes anyway). When you become rich in the American economy, you owe America for providing you with that opportunity in the first place. There's nothing wrong with that. He's against corporitization, but by ending government intrusion into the market, how in the crap is that going to keep corporations from becoming so powerful they rival the government itself? This country was not founded with the knowledge that megacorporations like Wal-Mart and Microsoft would have the financial muscle buy an army and march it through the Capital. An unregulated free market is one that is doomed to extreme cycles of boom and bust, along with extreme abuses of employees (like paying them with coupons for food at the company store, as they did back in the turn of the 20th century). It seems like he wants to revert back to America, version 1840's. While there are pro's and cons.... it just isn't going to happen.
 
To spinelli:
Ron Paul has a very interesting platform but I personally can't see it, I just disagree with fundamental points, but supposedly democracy will win through, and the will of the people will be done. Either way what is to say the he would be any different then anyone else? Sure his platform is quite new in some points (I've never heard of someone running on the idea of bring back the gold standard), but his unerring belief in the free market is old hat. You say that people are always falling for the same old lies, I say that the lie that <b>this</b> person is truly different is the oldest of them all.

I am not sold on his idea of bringing back the gold standard as am I not sold on a few other of his ideas. I never intended you or anyone else to view him as my ideal candidate in every respect. He does however have his own beliefs and stands up for them which is a refreshing change from politicians who are bought and sold like cattle and whose opinions change with the latest polls...usually they aren't even their own opinions, they are the opinions of teams of individuals crafted to appeal to as many people as possible and sound spiffy in a 3 second sound blurb or headline.

Sure, his belief in the free market system may seem old hat but in point of fact it isn't. Many (every?) politician in recent memory has given lip service to a free market economy while doing nothing to make it anything that resembles a free market. However I do not agree with an entirely free market myself. Ron Paul voted against Net Neutrality because he saw that as adding a level of legislation to the internet. I can see his reasoning but am not sold on it but its difficult for me to not to react emotionally on the subject instead of completely rationally. I get twitchy at the slightest prospect of anyone dicking around with the content I am provided and on the surface, a Net Neutrality type legislation would end my worries...but that may be a short sighted approach.

Ron Paul has no problem standing up for what he believes, even if he may sound like a nutter to the average Joe while doing so.

As to believing this guy would be different is a case of me believing in another one of the lies, maybe that's true. We'll never know, he won't be elected to anything beyond his current position or asked to be a VP for a serious contender and that's an absolute shame as far as I am concerned.

Anyway, it does not really matter one bit who we elect into office. Without a line item veto the presidency takes a fat one in the pooper from Congress. Without a President who has a pair of balls big enough to go on TV and say "Look America, I want to sign off on this bill called "Lets spend some fucking money on education" but the following Congressmen (dickwad, asshole, and cocksmoker) added in provisions completely unrelated to education spending and in fact what they tacked on is nothing more then pork meant to increase their cache with major contributors to their re-election campaigns. I hate to look like a douche for not signing off on the bill but until Congressman (dickwad, asshole, and cocksmoker) stop acting like their names imply, I simply can not."..without that at the very least or a line item veto at best, no real and meaningful change is possible.

Run-on sentences are awesome!!11!

Anyway, I have gone faaaaaaar off topic. We can take this to PM's if you wanna discuss it further /shrug
 
He's against corporitization, but by ending government intrusion into the market, how in the crap is that going to keep corporations from becoming so powerful they rival the government itself? This country was not founded with the knowledge that megacorporations like Wal-Mart and Microsoft would have the financial muscle buy an army and march it through the Capital.

Currently, big business is so deeply entrenched in out political system they already have what you really fear, they just didn't need to hire an actual army to do the dirty work. They hired armies of lawyers and lobbyists instead. Same result, less bloodshed.

Your post came in while I was typing my reply to another post, in that post I state I do not favor a 100% free market so I won't argue the points you made. They are valid concerns and I do not have a well enough informed opinion on what legislation is worth keeping and whats not. Thats too deep for me.
 
Currently, big business is so deeply entrenched in out political system they already have what you really fear, they just didn't need to hire an actual army to do the dirty work. They hired armies of lawyers and lobbyists instead. Same result, less bloodshed.

Your post came in while I was typing my reply to another post, in that post I state I do not favor a 100% free market so I won't argue the points you made. They are valid concerns and I do not have a well enough informed opinion on what legislation is worth keeping and whats not. Thats too deep for me.

Oh, I know. It's kind of scary. Especially because there was absolutely NO way for our Founding Fathers to have anticipated that. At least we pretend to have some semblance of antitrust legislation on the books though.
 
Amazing how different the "Tea party" protesters and the G20 protesters are treated. Sure, IMO, they are both protesting for idiotic reasons, but the tea party protesters get sponsored by the Republican party, actually have a TV station (Fox News) that tries to organize them, then tries to get them cheering just in time to record it (look online for the video of the fox producer trying her best to rile up the crowd for the cameras).

Think you have your history a bit mixed up here.

The Tea Party protest started with Congressman Ron Paul back while he was running for president in 2007 (google it if you like) ... Fox news and diehard republicans shunned him at the time. His support was mostly Constitutionalists, Libertarians, and libertarian conservatives (libertarian republicans). In fact, I am sure a good number of the G20 protesters are also Ron Paul / Tea Party protesters who are STILL shunned by Fox News.

It wasn't until Ron Paul's December 16th 2007 "Tea Party" protest/fund raiser made him over 6 million dollars in a single day that the republican party took notice and started to support these much more Republican Main Stream "Tea Party" protests.

So, in closing ... the Republican Party and most certainly Fox News had nothing to do with the "Tea Party" protests ... although they are most certainly trying to change the tone of them by advertising them in a far different light to a different type of crowd then the original ones.
 
The problem with the Republican party is that is has been hijacked by neocon religious wackos. I have comparatively few issues with Ron Paul, besides thinking his economic policy is... well.. different. At least democrats seem to want to fund the sciences and medicine again (or maybe just pay lip service to them).
 
I am not sold on his idea of bringing back the gold standard as am I not sold on a few other of his ideas. I never intended you or anyone else to view him as my ideal candidate in every respect. He does however have his own beliefs and stands up for them which is a refreshing change from politicians who are bought and sold like cattle and whose opinions change with the latest polls...usually they aren't even their own opinions, they are the opinions of teams of individuals crafted to appeal to as many people as possible and sound spiffy in a 3 second sound blurb or headline.

Sure, his belief in the free market system may seem old hat but in point of fact it isn't. Many (every?) politician in recent memory has given lip service to a free market economy while doing nothing to make it anything that resembles a free market. However I do not agree with an entirely free market myself. Ron Paul voted against Net Neutrality because he saw that as adding a level of legislation to the internet. I can see his reasoning but am not sold on it but its difficult for me to not to react emotionally on the subject instead of completely rationally. I get twitchy at the slightest prospect of anyone dicking around with the content I am provided and on the surface, a Net Neutrality type legislation would end my worries...but that may be a short sighted approach.

Ron Paul has no problem standing up for what he believes, even if he may sound like a nutter to the average Joe while doing so.

As to believing this guy would be different is a case of me believing in another one of the lies, maybe that's true. We'll never know, he won't be elected to anything beyond his current position or asked to be a VP for a serious contender and that's an absolute shame as far as I am concerned.

Anyway, it does not really matter one bit who we elect into office. Without a line item veto the presidency takes a fat one in the pooper from Congress. Without a President who has a pair of balls big enough to go on TV and say "Look America, I want to sign off on this bill called "Lets spend some fucking money on education" but the following Congressmen (dickwad, asshole, and cocksmoker) added in provisions completely unrelated to education spending and in fact what they tacked on is nothing more then pork meant to increase their cache with major contributors to their re-election campaigns. I hate to look like a douche for not signing off on the bill but until Congressman (dickwad, asshole, and cocksmoker) stop acting like their names imply, I simply can not."..without that at the very least or a line item veto at best, no real and meaningful change is possible.

Run-on sentences are awesome!!11!

Anyway, I have gone faaaaaaar off topic. We can take this to PM's if you wanna discuss it further /shrug

I understand what you are saying but democracy is not a perfect system (in my opinion), but it works well enough and one of the constraints is of course you have to appeal to the masses.

I agree that we have gone too far off topic but must unfortunately decline your invitation to continue this discussion because I really don't have the time, but thanks for offering
 
Meh. He has strong libertarian leanings, but I fail to see how eliminating a graduated income tax will do much of anything but hurt the poor/middle classes (who pay comparatively little taxes anyway). When you become rich in the American economy, you owe America for providing you with that opportunity in the first place. There's nothing wrong with that.

Uh no. No US citizen owes America anything. That is the most ridiculous statement I have seen written thus far. The people ARE the united states as that is how our founding fathers created it to be. "We the people" are the ones that grant the government the power to do what it does. The product of your time and skill is yours and no one else should have a claim to it. That is what makes the current tax system so evil. Even if tax was as little as 0.01% it would still instill the theory that the government now ownes you and allows you to keep other 99.99%. That is counter to the very ideas that the united states is based and the very president that allowed it under his watch wrote in his biography that it was the biggest mistake he ever made.

If anything is owed ... its the citizens owe it to themselves to keep the republic and civil liberties that great men and women died to create. Regardless of the source of which it is that is trying to limit them or take them away.

Usage fee's is the only way things should be taxed. Example ... people who buy automobile gasoline should have a tax on their gas to pay for road repair ... AND ONLY road repair. This is because if you are buying gasoline for your car you are obviously going to be driving on the road and thus the tax can be viewed as a usage fee.

Now lets take an example of the current system ... the government pays for clinics where abortions are done. Do you think its fair to take money from people who are greatly apose such a practice to pay for these procedures? Another one is that the government pays a lot of money to questionable countries ... since the only source of government money is through taxation of its people ... do you feel comfortable knowing that you indirectly through your government gave money to someone who has been known to cause mass murder in his/her country?

Another point I have to make is the idea that the middle class pays little tax ... you are very much mistaken. Tax is on a bell curve where the poor pay very little tax, the middle class pay the most, and the rich pay very little because they have the means to shelter their money.

Personally I feel that a flat tax should be implemented ... the IRS should be kept, but instead of auditing the people it should audit the spending of the people's money by its government and a yearly report should be given to the people. Once the people know how much is being spent where I suspect the government's spending will diminish in which case the flat tax can be lowered ... rinse and repeat until the government spending is under control ... and then re-evaluate if a tax is needed at all.
 
I couldn't agree more about a flat tax. It's the only fair way to do it. Taxing someone a higher PERCENTAGE is discrimination (rich or poor), plain and simple
 
Uh no. No US citizen owes America anything. That is the most ridiculous statement I have seen written thus far. The people ARE the united states as that is how our founding fathers created it to be. "We the people" are the ones that grant the government the power to do what it does. The product of your time and skill is yours and no one else should have a claim to it.

HAH. So I take it you're against the draft, then, too? And jury duty? You don't owe America anything, after all. :rolleyes:

I'm sorry, but I've lived in places with low taxes, and I've lived in places with high taxes. Guess which is higher educated, has nicer roads, has better infrastructure, and more jobs. The place with higher taxes. Now guess which is a complete shithole. I'm not saying higher taxes necessarily caused these things, but people are willing to pay more to live in a better place.

What government DOES with money is an entirely different issue (actually most government spending goes to the military, but you don't hear about that very much from the neocons). I agree that government spending is ridiculous, but to say that "render unto Caesar" is bunk is effing outrageous.

PS you honestly think the people still have power in this country? This country is run by interest groups and corporations.
 
Back
Top