US Govt Possibly Released 70 Million Veterans Data

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
The US government may have accidentally released personal information of 70 million veterans when the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) improperly disposed of a hard drive containing that data. NARA’s IT manager called it “the single largest release of personally identifiable information by the government ever.” Oops.

The hard drive helped power eVetRecs, the system veterans use to request copies of their health records and discharge papers. When the drive failed in November of last year, the agency returned the drive to GMRI, the contractor that sold it to them, for repair. GMRI determined it couldn’t be fixed, and ultimately passed it to another firm to be recycled.
 
As a veteran, after reading that article I feel that there is essentially zero risk.

First of all, the drive in question was part of a 6 drive array, so it only has 1/6th (or possible 1/5th, if that includes a hotspare) of the data.

Second, the drive is simply unaccounted for. The chance that the drive could have accidentally made it into the hands of someone with criminal intent, without being altered and in a functional state (it was a failed drive after all), and then that person being able to extra ANY usable data from 1/6th of the array, is essentially nil.

While this shouldn't happen, its not like it was a laptop with millions of records on it disappearing.

I've dealt a great deal with this exact type of situation. I know both Dell and HP (among others) have an option that you can get that doesn't require you to return the drives for replacement. Pretty much all government agencies should be selecting this option.
 
Just reiterating the statement I put on Wired:

First, with how easy it is to run a harddrive through a degausser, this is ridiculous. The two things I really want to know are:

1. What jerkoff made this decision: “Let’s not take the 30 seconds to stick this through a degausser, even though it isn’t likely anyone will recover data off of this drive comprised entirely of sensitive information of those who protect our country.”
2. What jerkoff made this decision: “Let’s sign a contract where harddrives cost $2000.”

They should release their names, and then they should release their asses to the dogs.


Yes, it is extremely unlikely and, effectively, there ALMOST no chance of someone recovering the data. However, that is no excuse when the possibility could have easily been "no chance" instead of "almost no chance."
 
Not when the US gov't buys them. When we buy them they can cost $435.00 a piece
 
Yeah, but that never could happen to all of our private medical records if our lord and savior Obimbo's government-run health care system becomes the law of the land... right?
 
Yeah, but that never could happen to all of our private medical records if our lord and savior Obimbo's government-run health care system becomes the law of the land... right?

No sir, you gotta have HOPE!! This is change we can believe in and change can't happen without YOU!

(this message brought to you by the Obama Really is the Messiah Foundation. Fantasyland chapter.)
 
No sir, you gotta have HOPE!! This is change we can believe in and change can't happen without YOU!

(this message brought to you by the Obama Really is the Messiah Foundation. Fantasyland chapter.)

Yes comrade...

(this message brought to you from the forum's resident communist)
 
half of the people in government are idiots.
You're so wrong. They're not smart enough to be idiots.

The U.S. government is the clearest example of the "Peter Principle" in practice.
 
Ok, yeah bad security choices and it should change, but the chance of pulling data off that drive are really low.

"As part of a six disk RAID 5 set-up, the drive likely contained about 18 percent of the database..."

So this guy doesn't know if it has a hot spare or not, but is assuming not. Either way, the article and his quotes make it sound like its 18 percent of the names and data. Anyone that knows how raid 5 works can tell the deception in that. Sure technically that's right, but it is not like the first 18 percent of the book. For those that don't know Raid 5, a quick dirty comparison would be to convert the book into binary then take every 5th 1 or 0. That is whats on the drive. That is way harder to put back together then having every 5th character. You might find periods and things like that in character. You won't get crap from 1110010010011100000101000011000 when you know your missing 4 digits between every one of those.

If you know what your doing, you might be able to tell what kind of data was on it, some things like a file structure, formatting, how much data was there, stripe size, etc. I wouldn't have much hope of actually recovering the data off it though. This isn't a drive from a top secret research project where even letting the bad guys have a guess of how much data was on the array could be a security issue. As long as they can't recover names and associated data, its no security breach.

I'm not really worried that some person might know that someone that may have the letter h, l, or r in their name might have the number 1, 5, or 7 somewhere in a possibly related number of some kind. That is completely useless and you could guess that without ever seeing any data. That's about as exact of real data your likely to pull from the drive. That is unless they lied or were wrong about the raid 5 and array size...
 
Yeah, but that never could happen to all of our private medical records if our lord and savior Obimbo's government-run health care system becomes the law of the land... right?

Yeah, I read the secret bill Obama will be slipping in place of any of the bills that get drafted in Congress.. It's going to totally outlaw all private insurance, and create an evil single payer system. :rolleyes:
 
What I have a problem with is this part:
He adds that more drives failed after the November incident, and that he performed a forensic scan on them to prove that they were full of sensitive data.

“I said you can’t turn them back in. The data is Privacy Act — it’s against the law,” Bellomy told Wired.com. “We have no clue how many drives have been sent back over the past seven years since this system was in place. I am a government employee and I’m a veteran, and just this year had both my credit cards replaced because they were compromised.”


Then again my credit is trashed from the first three incidents that I just have to shrug and plan on another five years of having to monitor my credit and deal with screwy items showing up every now and then.

Personally I'd like a new SSN every time they decided to make mine publicly available, or the Credit card companies to use something else for tracking so SSN can go back to a government only function.
 
“I happen to be a proponent of a single payer universal health care program. I see no reason why the United States of America, the wealthiest country in the history of the world, spending 14 percent of its Gross National Product on health care cannot provide basic health insurance to everybody. And that’s what Jim is talking about when he says everybody in, nobody out. A single payer health care plan, a universal health care plan. And that’s what I’d like to see. But as all of you know, we may not get there immediately. Because first we have to take back the White House, we have to take back the Senate, and we have to take back the House.” Barack 2003. That is the full exact quote. He did not say, Just Kidding at the end either Uriel.
 
Yeah, I read the secret bill Obama will be slipping in place of any of the bills that get drafted in Congress.. It's going to totally outlaw all private insurance, and create an evil single payer system. :rolleyes:
You just keep right on chanting: "Barack Hussein Obama... mmm, mmm, mmm!"
 
What I have a problem with is this part:
He adds that more drives failed after the November incident, and that he performed a forensic scan on them to prove that they were full of sensitive data.

“I said you can’t turn them back in. The data is Privacy Act — it’s against the law,” Bellomy told Wired.com. “We have no clue how many drives have been sent back over the past seven years since this system was in place. I am a government employee and I’m a veteran, and just this year had both my credit cards replaced because they were compromised.”


Then again my credit is trashed from the first three incidents that I just have to shrug and plan on another five years of having to monitor my credit and deal with screwy items showing up every now and then.

Personally I'd like a new SSN every time they decided to make mine publicly available, or the Credit card companies to use something else for tracking so SSN can go back to a government only function.

The SSN should never ever be used as an identifier. That was never it's intent.
 
Back
Top