5400 vs 7200 in NAS

The Jackyl

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 16, 2008
Messages
214
Currently I'm working with a D-Link DNS-323. I use my NAS solely for video streaming to my PS3. I'm thinking 7200RPMs would be unnecessary for this kind of application, and more than that, I'm thinking higher temps, higher power consumption, shorter drive life.

Am I right here or am I totally off my rocker?
 
You're going to get significantly less performance with a pair of 5400 drives versus 7200 drives. If your NAS device is not keeping your drives cool, I would either modify it by adding a fan or purchase a different NAS device that doesn't have heat issues with 7200 drives.

Have you done any sort of benchmarking to see what the throughput of the device is across your network? I'm not familiar with that particular NAS, but many of them do not allow the full performance of the drive to pass through the onboard controller. If your NAS controller is shaving performance off your current 7200s, you could end up with performance worse than typical 5400 drives by using them instead. I'd suggest running a benchmark to better evaluate your current situation before changing it.

Jason
 
Last edited:
For your application, 5400 drives are fine. If you get some "green" type drives, the lower power and heat should serve well.

1080p streaming uses a *max* of about 8MB/s, which is going to be well within the envelope of any modern hard drive. With large videos, there's also a high chance that the reads will be very sequential so the performance shouldn't dip too much below the higher bounds of typical performance.

From this, you can compare the Caviar Black (7200RPM) versus the Caviar Green (approx 5400RPM) to get a basic difference in performance between the 2 speeds.
 
What kind of performance issues would I see? I currently have a 1TB 7200RPM drive.

Unfortunately in the past month I've had an issue with my DNS-323 locking up my PS3 when I attempt to play a video off of it using its own media server software, so I've been using PS3 Media Server from Google Code for streaming. Main drawbacks of this have been slower video seeking and a slightly lengthy load time when displaying files in folders off the NAS.
 
Also, I'm trying to figure out why between my DNS-323 NAS, DIR-655 router, and Sager NP9262 laptop am I only getting speeds of about 4-6MBps. But that's another thread in another forum.
 
For your application, 5400 drives are fine. If you get some "green" type drives, the lower power and heat should serve well.

1080p streaming uses a *max* of about 8MB/s, which is going to be well within the envelope of any modern hard drive. With large videos, there's also a high chance that the reads will be very sequential so the performance shouldn't dip too much below the higher bounds of typical performance.

From this, you can compare the Caviar Black (7200RPM) versus the Caviar Green (approx 5400RPM) to get a basic difference in performance between the 2 speeds.

Uncompressed 1080p MPEG2 video is a little over 19mb/s. The NAS controller overhead will be your worst enemy. Probably what is restricting you to 4-6mb/s now. Have you tried a direct connection from the NAS to the laptop? Probably need a crossover adapter or cable.

Jason
 
Uncompressed 1080p MPEG2 video is a little over 19mb/s. The NAS controller overhead will be your worst enemy. Probably what is restricting you to 4-6mb/s now. Have you tried a direct connection from the NAS to the laptop? Probably need a crossover adapter or cable.

Jason

You mean Compressed MPEG2 :) I have seen raw mpeg2 streams from comcast back when I used to pull video via the firewire port anywhere from about 7mbit to ~38mbit. Most hi-res movies are in mpeg4 on the computer tho, so they would be even lower bitrates. FWIW, uncompressed 1080p at 30fps would be ~2gbit/sec.

I'd say 5400 rpm disks are plenty fast enough. Are you getting 4-6mbytes/sec or 4-6mbits/s sec? If you are only getting 4-6mbits/sec then something is up, if you are getting 4-6mbytes a sec, that's not too bad for 100mbit ethernet.
 
You mean Compressed MPEG2 :) I have seen raw mpeg2 streams from comcast back when I used to pull video via the firewire port anywhere from about 7mbit to ~38mbit. Most hi-res movies are in mpeg4 on the computer tho, so they would be even lower bitrates. FWIW, uncompressed 1080p at 30fps would be ~2gbit/sec.

I'd say 5400 rpm disks are plenty fast enough. Are you getting 4-6mbytes/sec or 4-6mbits/s sec? If you are only getting 4-6mbits/sec then something is up, if you are getting 4-6mbytes a sec, that's not too bad for 100mbit ethernet.

righto :)

Jason
 
Uncompressed 1080p MPEG2 video is a little over 19mb/s. The NAS controller overhead will be your worst enemy. Probably what is restricting you to 4-6mb/s now. Have you tried a direct connection from the NAS to the laptop? Probably need a crossover adapter or cable.
Jason

I recently bought a crossover cable from monoprice.com. Unfortunately I didn't have any luck with it showing up with either my vista or mac osx laptops. Though, thinking about it now I probably forgot to switch the DNS setting on the DNS-323 to provide its own IP address. Though for me, I only use the cable if I want to transfer in excess of 100GB.

I updated my wireless and lan drivers (can't believe I had forgotten about that) on my laptop which now I'm getting 7-8MBps when moving files wirelessly from my laptop. Haven't checked ethernet speeds through the router, post updates. Prior to the update I was at least getting 12-16MBps.

The D-Link DIR-655 is a gigabit router, suppose to be capable up to 260Mbps over WAN.
 
Your cheap NAS isn't going to keep up with even the 5400rpm 'green' drives over the network. You'll be lucky to get 30MB/s out of it no matter what drives you use. BluRay 1x is 36mbps, or about 5MB/s max. Reencoded stuff you download is going to need even less bandwidth. If you're having trouble and you can maintain that performance I'd look elsewhere...

So go with the cheaper, cooler and less power hungry 5400rpms.
 
Is it really the NAS's fault? I don't have a gigabit switch/router so I don't know how fast they actually work, but do they really ever exceed speeds of 80MB/s (which is roughly what a WD Green drive would pull)?
 
Is it really the NAS's fault? I don't have a gigabit switch/router so I don't know how fast they actually work, but do they really ever exceed speeds of 80MB/s (which is roughly what a WD Green drive would pull)?

I don't really have experience with NAS and their overheads, but on my wired LAN, when I was in 100 Base-T mode, transfers were in the ~6-8MB/s range. When I upgraded the switch to gigabit, file transfers moved up to the ~70-80MB/s range with fast 7200RPM drives (e.g. Caviar Black).

If you have another computer, you could pull the HDs out of your NAS and see if the NAS is slowing down your hard drives.
 
Yeah, starting to wish I didn't get sell my cheap Acer desktop that I could have converted to a FreeNAS. But right now I just have two laptops.

The DNS-323 is suppose to have a gigabit RJ-45 port. But as keenan said it is on the low end of NAS drives.
 
Is it really the NAS's fault? I don't have a gigabit switch/router so I don't know how fast they actually work, but do they really ever exceed speeds of 80MB/s (which is roughly what a WD Green drive would pull)?

Yep, the hardware in it just isn't fast enough to push that much traffic. The cheapest way to get actually close to full GbE throughput is to build a cheap PC and use FreeNAS or OpenFiler. Performance on these standalone units ranges from suck to bad. The best ones available can do 50-60MB/s, and they cost more than a PC that can do 80-90MB/s with however many drives you decide to cram in.
 
Are there any reasons to go with FreeNAS or OpenFiler over WHS besides them being free?
 
I never really thought about it but transfer speeds can depend on how the disks are configured.

I assume everyone is talking about the standard mode?
 
Yeah, I've got the drives in standard mode. Thanks for the link. Good to see what I can be working towards.
 
Don't expect to stream 1080p...it's way beyond what you will get from even the fastest wireless routers. 720p even stutters occasionally and I am running a $400 wireless-n router.
 
Don't expect to stream 1080p...it's way beyond what you will get from even the fastest wireless routers. 720p even stutters occasionally and I am running a $400 wireless-n router.

BS... I have streamed 1080p content over N without issue...
 
Are there any reasons to go with FreeNAS or OpenFiler over WHS besides them being free?

I guess the biggest is probably the option to use parity RAID. And you don't have to maintain another Windows box, but that's only a plus for some :p
 
Back
Top