X58 vs P55?

OPUS1

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Apr 25, 2003
Messages
1,766
as an old AMD lover
well
Goin Intel
varity da spice of life I guess
Is the only benefit of an MSI X58 board
over
an P55 GD80
SLI and 3 channel memory?
Doin 3d stuff and Daw...
I'm trying to decide what would be best
With an i7 Lynnfield
Thanks all
 
Last edited:
Wow, this post makes me feel sad inside.

If you can score a $200 i7 920 at Microcenter, that's probably the way to go. Otherwise, I'd say P55 with an i5 750.
 
P55 is going to provide you a great platform for gaming and all other applications. I feel though if you want a long term investment and want higher multicore support with the strongest support for dual graphics solutions take a look at our x58 line. You have support for i9 coming at the end of the year you have true x16 pci-e support for increased bandwidth and triple channel memory ( which although does not have a lot of real world impact still provides a higher memory count and more bandwidth than p55 ). In the end for me the performance is strong especially if you are willing to OC a little and get passed P55 turbo mode. Hope this helps. If you look at a board i would consider our Rampage II GENE unless you really need multiple PCI-E which if that is the case go with our P6TD. Please enjoy the rest of your day.
 
I'd second, if you go X58 the Rampage II Gene is an awesome board, I have one in an Antec P180 Mini and it is verrry nice with a ci7 920 oc'd.
 
Right now I think the strongest argument for going with the X58 platform is going to be for it's added PCI-Express lanes which are essential to multi-GPU solutions. Sure the memory bandwidth is nice and all but in the real world it doesn't do much for you. Beyond that the arguement for Gulftown is really probably moot. We also know that more than likely Gulftown will be available in some sort of Extreme Edition form originally and what we may see beyond that is largely unknown. Unless Intel introduces Gulftown parts in the $300-$400 price range I don't see very many enthusiasts running out to buy them. The fact is that unless they made significant changes to Gulftown over Nehalem the simple addition of cores is probably not going to do much for even the most hardcore gamer. That fact right there limits Gulftown's value as an upgrade option. A few people will buy them for bragging rights, or because they do something besdies gaming where the extra performance will come in handy.

Back on the subject of multi-GPU solutions, even P55 is good enough for them most of the time. A 16x8 or 8x8 lane configuration is going to be sufficient for everything you'd probably need. It is more than capable of handling dual Geforce GTX 295's or Crossfire 4870 X2's and no doubt single GPU 5870 cards will work fine in these boards as well, even in multi-card configurations. If you need CrossfireX or 3-Way SLI, then it's time to step up to X58. With that said, unless you are running a 30" LCD, multi-GPU configurations are probably a waste of money for most people anyway. So bear that in mind.
 
C
That's the Joy of [H] OCP!
Thanks
My biggest concern is being able to achieve a happy medium for:
Gaming
Digital Audio recording ( home Studio)
3D Rendering (Computer generated Visuals)
Not sure a Triple Graphics solution would help rendering
It looks as though the P55 platform with an i7 cpu
and of course a good Gpu card is the way to go (future proof)
No?
 
C
That's the Joy of [H] OCP!
Thanks
My biggest concern is being able to achieve a happy medium for:
Gaming
Digital Audio recording ( home Studio)
3D Rendering (Computer generated Visuals)
Not sure a Triple Graphics solution would help rendering
It looks as though the P55 platform with an i7 cpu
and of course a good Gpu card is the way to go (future proof)
No?

Gaming

Either platform will serve you well. Again the only time you need to go X58/LGA1366 is if you are going to go with a multi-GPU setup and that's really only needed for a 30" display. Even 1920x1200 on a 24 or 27" LCD isn't the damanding resolution it used to be.

Digital Audio recording ( home Studio)

All of the processors and platforms would serve you well in this regard. Also, you will probably need dedicated hardware for this as onboard audio is lackluster in the recording area. That's actually it's weakest area truthfully. Sound quality isn't usually exceptional, but it is decent for gaming and watching movies. A professional will want something else.

3D Rendering (Computer generated Visuals)

Rendering is all about processor power, memory capacity and bandwidth. You may want to lean toward LGA1366 for this. I know that many of the 3D programs have GPU acceleration capabilities these days. In that case multi-GPU setups may be worth while even though you may not have a 24"-30" LCD. However I don't know what GPUs are supported specifically. This may be for Quadro or FireGL cards only. (I haven't supported 3D applications in a couple of years now.)

Not sure a Triple Graphics solution would help rendering

As I said, they can. It may depend on a variety of factors as to whether or not this will be worth looking into.

It looks as though the P55 platform with an i7 cpu
and of course a good Gpu card is the way to go (future proof)


Actually P55 / LGA1156 is going to be less "futureproof" than X58 / LGA1366. LGA1366 gets Gulftown sometime next year. LGA1156 doesn't. 3D applications like 3D Studio Max and Maya can make use of these extra cores, so it may be worth while for you depending on how much you are willing to spend. Depending on your actual budget, you may even want to look at a dual Xeon solution given what you would be using the system for. The Xeon can play games too, but the main thing that might hurt your gaming performance at that point would probably be graphics card choice. Quadro and FireGL cards are great for 3D rendering applications but take a huge hit in gaming performance. Though you might be able to setup a dual boot setup with alternate drivers (softmod) for gaming and the other for application use.
 
Dan is absolutely correct. If the 1156 platform were available when I was building back in March, I could have saved myself a few $.
 
So if I have this right:
Fully understanding all the rest
ie: memory/GPU/ hard drives etc.
I would do better with a
i7-950 Bloomfield 3.06GHz 4 x 256KB L2 Cache 8MB L3 Cache LGA 1366 130W Quad-
Based MB
Then an
i7 870 Lynnfield 2.93GHz 8MB L3 Cache LGA 1156 95W Quad-MB?
Dang it all.....
Who said variety is the spice of life?
 
So if I have this right:
Fully understanding all the rest
ie: memory/GPU/ hard drives etc.
I would do better with a
i7-950 Bloomfield 3.06GHz 4 x 256KB L2 Cache 8MB L3 Cache LGA 1366 130W Quad-
Based MB
Then an
i7 870 Lynnfield 2.93GHz 8MB L3 Cache LGA 1156 95W Quad-MB?
Dang it all.....
Who said variety is the spice of life?

Well most people would tell you to go with a Core i7 920 and overclock it. The Core i7 950 is the same CPU but with a higher stock clock speed. The Core i7 920 can be had for as little as $199.99 if there is a Microcenter near you. If you don't wish to overclock or you are using this as a production machine. (Source of revenue.) Then you may want to consider the Core i7 950. Really though, triple channel memory support aside, it's really about the X58 vs. the P55 platform for your situation. I believe for your situation that the X58 LGA1366 platform may be the better one. Again this is dependent on budget concerns and usage. Your comments concerning how you intend to use it could certainly justify the purchase of the X58 and Core i7 900 series CPU, but again if you won't spend the money on the multi-GPU solution then it doesn't matter so much. All you'd get is the benefit of more memory bandwidth.
 
x58, I don't feel like the i5 platform has enough of the mystery about it let out...
If I were to go back to intel I would get i7 x58
 
x58, I don't feel like the i5 platform has enough of the mystery about it let out...
If I were to go back to intel I would get i7 x58

The mystery? What exactly is a mystery about it?
 
The mystery? What exactly is a mystery about it?

lifespan, atleast you know for the i7 there will be more coming for it i.e. 6 core cpus.
I mean it didn't really make much sense to create an entirely different socket.
and if it doesn't sell well, do you think they will continue the line?
 
This is a major quandary for me also (or will be in the new year)
For what I do-gaming, photoshop, browsing- hobby computing rather than work, I could probably do a really good upgrade of my system with a P55 and i5.
On the other hand I could save a bit longer and go X58 and i7.
I suspect I'll be wanting a new graphics card or cards later in the year.
I don't want to put money into p55 if it's going nowhere and I'll end up having to get an X58/i7 eventually anyway.
Could do with a roadmap. John:)
 
lifespan, atleast you know for the i7 there will be more coming for it i.e. 6 core cpus.
I mean it didn't really make much sense to create an entirely different socket.
and if it doesn't sell well, do you think they will continue the line?

I wouldn't worry about socket longevity. Whether it changes or not newer CPUs are going to need newer motherboards anyway. At best the CPU refresh will work but the CPU that comes after the refresh probably won't work in your board.
 
But the problem I'm having is
The P55 platform seems to be "cutting edge"
even if it's with an "newer older budget CPU"
Or
The X series boards are cutting edge
even if it's with an older faster CPU
or
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,

I am so sorry to subject all of you to my "Dos Dayz"
(flashBack)
Won't happen again
maybe...
It's lookin like the X platform with it's larger mem bandwith
beats the the P55
because
OK!
 
The X series will be (no doubt about it) supported into the future with 6cores.

The P series... (nobody knows?)
 
The X series will be (no doubt about it) supported into the future with 6cores.

The P series... (nobody knows?)

I understand that but...


The P55 platform seems to be "cutting edge"
even if it's with an "newer older budget CPU"
No North bridge etc.....
Or
The X series boards are cutting edge
even if it's with an older faster CPU
or
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,

I am so sorry to subject all of you to my "Dos Dayz"
(flashBack)
Won't happen again
maybe...
It's lookin like the X platform with it's larger mem bandwith
beats the the P55
because
OK!
 
I understand that but...


The P55 platform seems to be "cutting edge"
even if it's with an "newer older budget CPU"
No North bridge etc.....
Or
The X series boards are cutting edge
even if it's with an older faster CPU
or
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,
I am caught in an endless loop,I am caught in an endless loop,

I am so sorry to subject all of you to my "Dos Dayz"
(flashBack)
Won't happen again
maybe...
It's lookin like the X platform with it's larger mem bandwith
beats the the P55
because
OK!
Why does the P55 platform seem cutting-edge to you? It's inferior to the X58 platform in just about every way. And what's with all the crap in that post?
 
Looks like these two are going the way of X48 vs. P45. :D
 
Looks like these two are going the way of X48 vs. P45. :D
Not at all. P45 and X48 were both for the same socket and both had their advantages and disadvantages. In this case, the X58 platform is decidedly better than LGA1156.
 
Not at all. P45 and X48 were both for the same socket and both had their advantages and disadvantages. In this case, the X58 platform is decidedly better than LGA1156.
Right
So why put out the 1156?
Just so that I can go bozo?
 
If you're going bozo then you apparently haven't bothered to read any of the multitude of posts explaining the pros and cons of each platform to you. So instead of posting yet another "I'm confused"-type statement, I suggest you put on your reading glasses.
 
Not at all. P45 and X48 were both for the same socket and both had their advantages and disadvantages. In this case, the X58 platform is decidedly better than LGA1156.


I think it is too early to tell. Could be an over clocking monster just waiting for the right MB and owner. I'm waiting.
 
I think it is too early to tell. Could be an over clocking monster just waiting for the right MB and owner. I'm waiting.
How is it too early to tell? The LGA1156 platform was specifically designed to be inferior to LGA1366. There is no ambiguity in the issue. It's been shown that LGA1156 CPUs don't overclock any better than LGA1366 chips, and that they are either equal or inferior to them performance-wise depending on the situation. It doesn't get more clear-cut than that.
 
How is it too early to tell? The LGA1156 platform was specifically designed to be inferior to LGA1366. There is no ambiguity in the issue. It's been shown that LGA1156 CPUs don't overclock any better than LGA1366 chips, and that they are either equal or inferior to them performance-wise depending on the situation. It doesn't get more clear-cut than that.


I'll wait till I see some talented over clockers play with the P55 series mother boards. They are very new still. DFI has yet to bring a P55 MB to market. It's new.
 
How is it too early to tell? The LGA1156 platform was specifically designed to be inferior to LGA1366. There is no ambiguity in the issue. It's been shown that LGA1156 CPUs don't overclock any better than LGA1366 chips, and that they are either equal or inferior to them performance-wise depending on the situation. It doesn't get more clear-cut than that.

Now 0
Respect your elders
I was OCHP before you were born
Your quote:The LGA1156 platform was specifically designed to be inferior to LGA1366.
Brings my querry to the front
Why put out a "new Platform" if it doesn't show an advantage?
(yes I've read it all!)
Is it just to Fragment the PC market!?
Your Quote:
"It's inferior to the X58 platform in just about every way. And what's with all the crap in that post?"
So that's the reenforcement I have been looking for!
The crap in that post refers to a similar type of loop created back in the day before you wore diapers;):D
 
Why put out a "new Platform" if it doesn't show an advantage?
Because it's a cheaper mainstream platform and will sell better than the enthusiast LGA1366 platform. Intel's manufacturing costs are lower, their CPUs will sell for lower, and they'll make more profit. Your question is like asking why a car manufacturer brings out new budget models year after year when they already sell expensive supercars that have significantly better performance and reliability in every aspect.
Now 0
Respect your elders
I was OCHP before you were born
...
The crap in that post refers to a similar type of loop created back in the day before you wore diapers;):D
I somehow manage to avoid acting like a twelve-year-old when responding to people on the internet, so maybe I was born before you were. And I'm well aware of what an infinite loop is. So rather than insulting me, you should be a little more appreciative of the patience shown by the people here trying to help you by answering your query.
 
if you can afford it the x58 is the higher end platform and will give you more room to build a powerhouse
 
Because it's a cheaper mainstream platform and will sell better than the enthusiast LGA1366 platform. Intel's manufacturing costs are lower, their CPUs will sell for lower, and they'll make more profit. Your question is like asking why a car manufacturer brings out new budget models year after year when they already sell expensive supercars that have significantly better performance and reliability in every aspect.

I wholeheartedly agree with Zero82z on this. Couldn't have explained it any better than he did. The LGA1156/P55 platform fills a certain mainstream 'budget' niche in the market which is Intel's main concern. Simple as that. In terms of performance, X58 does outperform P55 but that does not mean that everyone should go the X58 route rather than P55. Each person has his/her own needs and requirements and should carefully weigh those prior to making a decision. As Zero has already mentioned, there have been numerous posts/articles/reviews explaining the differences between the two (i.e. more memory bandwidth on the X58 with triple channel). These should be read, analyzed, and taken into consideration as well in order to better understand which of the platforms provides you with the biggest advantage, fits into your budget, and fulfills your needs.
 
No malice was intended:(
Perhaps humour is a lost art
Or
I don't know what be funny:rolleyes:
ANy who
Thanks to all
especially BurntToast
I'm going to go X58
PS: 0
I appreciate you hard work at keeping the Forum well kempt....
But gee wiz
Did ya see the smiley face at the end of my Post?:D
I guess I'm not PC correct:confused::(
 
No malice was intended:(
Perhaps humour is a lost art
Or
I don't know what be funny:rolleyes:
ANy who
Thanks to all
especially BurntToast
I'm going to go X58
PS: 0
I appreciate you hard work at keeping the Forum well kempt....
But gee wiz
Did ya see the smiley face at the end of my Post?:D
I guess I'm not PC correct:confused::(

All is well, except your posts are a bit difficult to read/follow for some. ;)
 
Back
Top