WHS Power Consumption e5200 vs. e6600 w/speedstep

BurntToast

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 14, 2003
Messages
3,678
Which one makes for the most efficnet WHS processor. The e5200 or e6600? My main concern would be the 24/7 power usage.

I went from considering a Atom 330 and under clocked 5050e to where I'm at now since I happen to have a e6600 available.

Both the e5200 and e6600 are rated at 65TDM and support speedstep. If paired on the G33/Q35 chipset, they should both idle at about the same. Right?

I'm looking for the low TDM of an Atom yet the performance of a desktop CPU. With a lower power bill as my main priority, which one better fits the bill?

If anyone has any better suggestions please let them be known (mobo/cpu).
 
Well using this article as a guide, since the E5200 is based on the same Wolfdale core as the E8xxx series tested in the above review, the idle and load wattage should be the same.

Do note that I think those numbers are off BUT the ratio should be about the same. Meaning that at idle and full load, the E5200 will still take less power than the E6600.
 
Which one makes for the most efficnet WHS processor. The e5200 or e6600? [snip]

Both the e5200 and e6600 are rated at 65TDM and support speedstep. If paired on the G33/Q35 chipset, they should both idle at about the same. Right?
Well, both are 45nm, both use the same building blocks, so at least idle power draw should be about the same.

I say should because there are more factors to take into account.

1) Intel is known to voltage-bin the higher FSB parts (as well as Xeon parts), meaning sometimes a higher FSB on the CPU can mean lower standard operating voltages, which in turn means less power draw. Just look at the QX9770 vs. QX9650, the QX9770 tends to have lower operating voltages, despite both being about the same speed. And please disregard what I just said if you plan on undervolting, since that adds a completely new variable to the mix.

2) Some chipsets draw more power with higher FSB parts and/or with higher-speed memory being used. That might shift power draw by 1~2W at most, but just to be sure, please check the Intel datasheet on the chipset you intend to use.

3) Extra CPU cache MIGHT affect power draw, but since all post-Netburst Intel CPUs (C2D/C2Q/i3/i5/i7/i9) can shut down parts of the cache lines when not in use, that's probably only relevant for load situations.

That being said, the upcoming Celeron E3xxx series (in sale now on the Asian market, AFAIK) seem to be ultra low power chips, with the E3200 drawing less than 20W at load before undervolting (here).

Hope this helps.

Cheers.

Miguel
 
Huh? The E5200 is a Wolfdale (45nm) but the E6600 is a Conroe so isn't it 65nm?
Thanks for bringing that up.

I was actually considering the Pentium Dual Core E5200 and the Pentium Dual Core E6600, both Wolfdale parts with possibly very similar idle power consumption.

If , however, the E6600 the thread starter is referring to is a Conroe E6600 CPU, then the choice is much easier, the E5200 should have better power consumption on the whole spectrum (idle and load).

Cheers.

Miguel
 
When is the E3200 due to arrive? Articles have been hinting that this will be an OEM release only to larger system builders.

Is there anything close in terms of performance/power consumption, with under clocking/under volting?
 
When is the E3200 due to arrive?
It's on sale now on Asian markets, according to the latest news. So it should hit other markets within a month or so.

Let's not forget it's early September now, and IT shopping right now sucks big time (high demand from the "Back to School" specials, low supply on the factory side - most factories reduce output during July/August), you can't find anything, and when you do is like 25% higher than it should be...

Articles have been hinting that this will be an OEM release only to larger system builders.
Yes, I've read that, too. Hopefully this is not one of those "HP only" models, like that elusive 35W Athlon X2. If it's a "tray only" model, it should pose no problem, since at least in Portugal it's rather easy to find OEM/Tray CPUs for sale, the only differences being half or 1/3 the warranty period (one year instead of two or three) and no heatsink. You only get the little clear plastic case protecting the CPU, period. Not a problem, since most stores also stock HUGE amounts of stock heatsinks which they are almost too eager to part with (most of the time for free, or under €5), plus the CPU is usually somewhat cheaper.

However, do keep in mind that the reports on the CPU being available on Asian markets show pictures of RETAIL boxes, not OEM chips... That seems a good omen, no?

Is there anything close in terms of performance/power consumption, with under clocking/under volting?
Depending on the CPU you end up with (expected sample variance, and stuff), you can probably match power consumption with just about any E5000/E7000/E8000 series (plus the new Pentium Dual Core E6000 series). I've yet to find a Conroe or Wolfdale-based CPU that doesn't undervolt by a big margin. And if you can get your hands on a motherboard that can handle negative voltage offsets (that is, it will supply the CPU/RAM/FSB/etc. with a fixed amount less voltage than the one the component asks for, or below the voltage set on the appropriate BIOS field, my guess is most of them should be able to hit about 0.8~1V at least idling.

I've yet to find a nice G31/G33/Q35/Q43/G43 motherboard with such voltage options, though. The only time I've heard of that feature was on a Gigabyte mobo, and it blew me away :). If you know about any, at a decent price tag, please let me know, OK?

Cheers.

Miguel
 
Back
Top