U.S. Will Consider Single Rating System

Simple rating system "Intended for audences of ______years and above in maturity"
 
Simple rating system "Intended for audences of ______years and above in maturity"

Or just a number code which indicates exactly what elements are contained in that movie. I consider the gore in Saving Private Ryan to be far more shocking then say, the gore in District 9. Yet, both receive an R rating. If we knew they both contained gore and bad language, without any implications otherwise, I think that'd be a step up from the current system.
 
Simple rating system "Intended for audences of ______years and above in maturity"

Well that's a little subjective. Different parents have different opinions of what age their children should be to see certain types of content. I think ratings that actually describe the type of content found in the media are much more useful than simple age recommendations.
 
Nice, the personal attacks are out of the bag already.

It's a subjective rating system. What you want to expose your kids to and I want to expose my kids to are two completely different things. The R, pg-13, whatever rating, is arbitrary and is government suppression of free speech, technically speaking. I don't understand how you don't see this. Yes, it is a tool for parents and its always bandied around as such,
A rating system is something like this:

What is a mature audience? Is that an age group? Do some Disney movies offend your sensibilities if you're Hindu - should they still be rated G?

You looked one layer deep at the issue then wrote up a haughty reply, good job.

please go back to grade school and get an education as to what censorship is or better yet go to China......

rating a product is not censoring it.....I mean if you are really having difficulties with such a simple concept, you really need to get some common sense.
 
It's for your own good. We need a 200,000 dollar per year ratings czar that tells companies what content they can and cannot make. Hope and change!
 
Just imagine if they require all online games to be rated including mods.
 
please go back to grade school and get an education as to what censorship is or better yet go to China......

rating a product is not censoring it.....I mean if you are really having difficulties with such a simple concept, you really need to get some common sense.

How about you go back to middle school, join the debate team, and learn what a cogent argument is. What you're doing right now is called ad hominem. Grow up.
 
YEs, lets let big brother take care of our parenting. Let teh government tell us what is and isn't appropriate for our kids. *faceplam*
Parenting these days is what needs to improve.
 
YEs, lets let big brother take care of our parenting. Let teh government tell us what is and isn't appropriate for our kids. *faceplam*
Parenting these days is what needs to improve.

Oh yeah, because every parent out there has all the time in the world to pre-screen every single video, game, song, etc that's available before they allow their children to be exposed to it. I see nothing wrong with a simple rating system applied to all types of media that explains quick if there's sexual content, profanity, violence, etc present so we can just skim the back of the box when our kids come running up and saying "Ooh dad, can I have this game?!?!?"
 
I normally base my movies, music and games on ratings. If it aint "R" or Mature, I'm keeping my moolah.

Why stop with games, music, movies and television? I see this as really making my life way easier, I'll never have to think again. Thank you Uncle Sam.... thank you.
 
I normally base my movies, music and games on ratings. If it aint "R" or Mature, I'm keeping my moolah.

Why stop with games, music, movies and television? I see this as really making my life way easier, I'll never have to think again. Thank you Uncle Sam.... thank you.

That's a narrow way of selecting your movies. Lots of great movies are PG, especially most of the Pixar films.
 
I normally base my movies, music and games on ratings. If it aint "R" or Mature, I'm keeping my moolah.

Why stop with games, music, movies and television? I see this as really making my life way easier, I'll never have to think again. Thank you Uncle Sam.... thank you.

This has nothing to do with "having to think." It's about looking at something before you buy it and knowing what it contains so you don't have to spend hours of your life doing it yourself. There's a lot of people that don't want to watch sex scenes, listen to foul language, or expose their children to content they're not mature enough to view.

With your mentality, we should banish calculators; take down Do Not Enter, Stop, and One Way signs, and god forbid use our computers for anything more than games.
 
This has nothing to do with "having to think." It's about looking at something before you buy it and knowing what it contains so you don't have to spend hours of your life doing it yourself. There's a lot of people that don't want to watch sex scenes, listen to foul language, or expose their children to content they're not mature enough to view.

With your mentality, we should banish calculators; take down Do Not Enter, Stop, and One Way signs, and god forbid use our computers for anything more than games.

Did you mean to quote him, because it sounds like you were responding to me? And I shall respond! Look, I'm not saying some sort of indicator as to what a movies contents are is a bad idea. I'm saying the idea of an audience targeted rating system is rubbish and unnecessary given the diversity present in this country. Say what's in it, not who should watch it.
 
Did you mean to quote him, because it sounds like you were responding to me? And I shall respond! Look, I'm not saying some sort of indicator as to what a movies contents are is a bad idea. I'm saying the idea of an audience targeted rating system is rubbish and unnecessary given the diversity present in this country. Say what's in it, not who should watch it.

I wasn't responding to you at all. I was attacking his sarcastic tone about not having to think again because Uncle Sam is going to do it for him.
 
How about you go back to middle school, join the debate team, and learn what a cogent argument is. What you're doing right now is called ad hominem. Grow up.

There is nothing to debate here so just do us all a favor and quit making the human race look unedumacated.....


rating system != sensorship..................
 
Rating: "This product has swears in it."
Censorship: "We will stop the release of any product with swears in it."

Yeah, totally the same thing. :rolleyes:

No, what happens is you get stores that say, "we won't release anything that has <insert some type of rating>".

It's not exactly censorship, but one need look no further than Walmart's music policy or most stores policies on games to know that the rating systems do lead to self-censorship that largely didn't exist before those ratings existed.

With respect to music, Walmart is clearly the worst of lot, because they often sell albums that have been changed, but there's nothing on the album that indicates a change took place. I still remember a co-worker wondering why some Metallica album had a word beeped out on it. Asked him where he bought it....yup, it was Walmart...and he wouldn't have bought if he'd known.

Think about it: you can't buy an Adult game in most, if any store, because nobody will sell it. It's not like the original PC release of GTA: San Andreas (even if modded) was hard core porn, yet, for months, it was essentially pulled from the market, while Rockstar worked on removing graphics and code (and presumably performing a lot of regression testing).
 
No, what happens is you get stores that say, "we won't release anything that has <insert some type of rating>".

It's not exactly censorship, but one need look no further than Walmart's music policy or most stores policies on games to know that the rating systems do lead to self-censorship that largely didn't exist before those ratings existed.

With respect to music, Walmart is clearly the worst of lot, because they often sell albums that have been changed, but there's nothing on the album that indicates a change took place. I still remember a co-worker wondering why some Metallica album had a word beeped out on it. Asked him where he bought it....yup, it was Walmart...and he wouldn't have bought if he'd known.

Think about it: you can't buy an Adult game in most, if any store, because nobody will sell it. It's not like the original PC release of GTA: San Andreas (even if modded) was hard core porn, yet, for months, it was essentially pulled from the market, while Rockstar worked on removing graphics and code (and presumably performing a lot of regression testing).

it's not like there weren't places to buy uncensroed, or unedited copies. Walmart is an independent corporation that can set whatever sales policies they desire. They try to push the image of a family friendly store, and thus don't want things that would be considered vulgar.
 
No, what happens is you get stores that say, "we won't release anything that has <insert some type of rating>".

It's not exactly censorship, but one need look no further than Walmart's music policy or most stores policies on games to know that the rating systems do lead to self-censorship that largely didn't exist before those ratings existed.

With respect to music, Walmart is clearly the worst of lot, because they often sell albums that have been changed, but there's nothing on the album that indicates a change took place. I still remember a co-worker wondering why some Metallica album had a word beeped out on it. Asked him where he bought it....yup, it was Walmart...and he wouldn't have bought if he'd known.

Think about it: you can't buy an Adult game in most, if any store, because nobody will sell it. It's not like the original PC release of GTA: San Andreas (even if modded) was hard core porn, yet, for months, it was essentially pulled from the market, while Rockstar worked on removing graphics and code (and presumably performing a lot of regression testing).

In that case, you should complain to Wal-Mart because they are censoring the games, not the government/rating bodies.

Why must Americans always put the blame in the wrong place?
 
He was just providing one very good example of why ratings systems can be used as censorship. The rest of his post was well-said, too, it didn't just talk about Walmart.

There is nothing to debate here so just do us all a favor and quit making the human race look unedumacated.....


rating system != sensorship..................
AHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
 
He was just providing one very good example of why ratings systems can be used as censorship

once again a rating system != censorship. No matter how many times you say it, it still does not make it true.

Businesses have the RIGHT to pick and choose what they stock and sell. You as a consumer have the RIGHT to go to a business that that sells what you are looking for.

Just because Walmart chooses not to sell music or games above a certain rating, does not mean that product is censord. You can walk into any Gamestop, BB, Frys, Microcenter, etc and buy the stuff Walmart does not want to carry.......

Just because a company wants to use a rating system to determine what it sells does not equal censorship........ as another store down the street may decide to sell only items that are not rated E for everyone or will carry only popular titles. does the fact that company X only carries E for everyone or popular games mean that the rest are unavailable or censord?
 
once again a rating system != censorship. No matter how many times you say it, it still does not make it true.

Businesses have the RIGHT to pick and choose what they stock and sell. You as a consumer have the RIGHT to go to a business that that sells what you are looking for.

Just because Walmart chooses not to sell music or games above a certain rating, does not mean that product is censord. You can walk into any Gamestop, BB, Frys, Microcenter, etc and buy the stuff Walmart does not want to carry.......

Just because a company wants to use a rating system to determine what it sells does not equal censorship........ as another store down the street may decide to sell only items that are not rated E for everyone or will carry only popular titles. does the fact that company X only carries E for everyone or popular games mean that the rest are unavailable or censord?

The fact is, a rating system limits its audience. Many people don't even know or don't care enough to find out. Or only have access to a Walmart. Many people simply won't buy "mature" games, despite having no idea what actual content is in that game. Ratings=Government controlling audience. Not directly or egregiously, but it's still censorship.
 
Just ask content creators if it limits their audience. They know it's censorship because it definitely limits their audience. If you create an R movie based on a government workers ideal of offensive or grotesque, you get less sells. This leads to self-censorship.
 
Just ask content creators if it limits their audience. They know it's censorship because it definitely limits their audience. If you create an R movie based on a government workers ideal of offensive or grotesque, you get less sells. This leads to self-censorship.

That's a bad thing why?

You're equating people's desire to avoid something they find offensive to censorship. Censorship is "You can't sell this because [insert reason]" Not being able to sell something because there isn't an audience for it is just poor business planning.
 
That's a bad thing why?

You're equating people's desire to avoid something they find offensive to censorship. Censorship is "You can't sell this because [insert reason]" Not being able to sell something because there isn't an audience for it is just poor business planning.

That's not true. You're starting with the assumption there isn't an audience for it and that the audience would find it offensive based on the government subjective protocols for rating, which don't take into account how the material is presented and why. It limits the artist or companies ability to use material.
 
it's not like there weren't places to buy uncensroed, or unedited copies. Walmart is an independent corporation that can set whatever sales policies they desire. They try to push the image of a family friendly store, and thus don't want things that would be considered vulgar.

It depends where you live. In some places, Walmart is it. And up until everyone decided stealing music was OK, they were far and away the largest retailer of music.

Finally, as I said in the original post, CD's that are censored for Walmart have absolutely nothing on them to indicate they're censored.

And if they're worried about Family friendly, then why can you buy R rated movies. I'm sorry, but is there any Metallica CD that's as vulgar as virtually any Kevin Smith movie? Is there more violence than in Kill Bill?
 
In that case, you should complain to Wal-Mart because they are censoring the games, not the government/rating bodies.

Why must Americans always put the blame in the wrong place?

If the labels didn't exist, the censorship wouldn't either. Walmart censors based on a label, not on the content, which they've never heard, in most cases.
 
once again a rating system != censorship. No matter how many times you say it, it still does not make it true.

Businesses have the RIGHT to pick and choose what they stock and sell. You as a consumer have the RIGHT to go to a business that that sells what you are looking for.

Just because Walmart chooses not to sell music or games above a certain rating, does not mean that product is censord. You can walk into any Gamestop, BB, Frys, Microcenter, etc and buy the stuff Walmart does not want to carry.......

I can't say how Gamestop works, but BB doesn't carry A rated games. AFAIK, neither Microcenter, nor Frys carries them either.

I'm not against a rating system, if the vendors of the product wish to provide one. It should not be mandated by the government.
 
The fact is, a rating system limits its audience. Many people don't even know or don't care enough to find out. Or only have access to a Walmart. Many people simply won't buy "mature" games, despite having no idea what actual content is in that game. Ratings=Government controlling audience. Not directly or egregiously, but it's still censorship.

no it does not, a rating system allows people to decide if they want to buy the content or not. If you have a 7 year old kid that wants GTA and it is rated M for mature, you as the buyer would immediately know that the content is not approperiate for your 7 year old kid. If the game was not rated, and you bought it and found out that it was mature content, you have absolutely NO recourse since opened software can only be exhanged for lthe same title only. There is NO REFUND once you open it.

All a rating system does is allow people to not make the mistake of buying something they don't want based upon content. As I remember, the industry was putting out all sorts of inapproperiate for children content and they did not want to rate it until they were FORCED TO.
 
Back
Top