Bing Takes Share from Google, Yahoo

Try this Techie: Hit File, then Save As, then change file type to Webpage, Complete. Measure the folder contents of the webpage you saved to your drive.
 
The thing is, even on dial-up, 0.02 MB is nothing. That's 20KB. Nothing.

I know what the next retort would be (as I've heard it before) "I don't want to load 20KB on every page when Google only loads 8KB".

Guess what? When it comes to search results, you're actually loading more data with Google than Bing:

Thus, the only thing "Bigger" in size is your home page. And with the increase in search-from-browser searches, even that's becoming a non-issue.

The next argument I'd hear? "Well, Bing's image search is so glitzy, it'll lose that." Wrong again. For some reason IE doesn't grab the page size so my screens are from FireFox here, but here's Google versus Bing image search:

Bing actually improves that over time as since you don't have to load each page again, all it does is load the new images. You don't have to reload all the HTML, CSS again and again and again like with Google.

So what if the front page is 12KB more? That's a ridiculous amount to be concerned about even on dial up much less a desktop where most people do their work. Plus, even with more "Glitter" than Google, Bing still loads less than Google does.

You clearly have much more experience arguing the fanboy position than I do.

In any case, you can reread my posts and see that I was referring to my own personal tastes and that the bloat I was referring to was Bing.com. I'm not trying to convince you I'm right, I was sharing my personal opinion, just as you are sharing yours. You can see very plainly that I post my own experiences and detail what I see as superfluous.

You seem convinced that Bing is better, and that's great. They haven't convinced me yet, but I'll keep looking in, and perhaps you should take your "open-mind" advice and do the same.
 
You seem convinced that Bing is better, and that's great. They haven't convinced me yet, but I'll keep looking in, and perhaps you should take your "open-mind" advice and do the same.

Used to use Google full time until their results got crappy and filled with search portal spam.
Switched to Yahoo, results were OK, but with less spam.
Tried Live for a short while, it sucked.
Went back to Yahoo.
Bing came out, better than all 3.

I've got an open mind about the search results, and as market share is slowly showing, and as many here have pointed out: There's lots of people that just use Google and don't give it a second thought. When they actually try Bing out they end up liking it. Many here have switched to using it as their primary engine.

When I'm looking for mundane stuff, I'll sometimes search in two or three engines... Sometimes another engine does provide better results.
 
Could be. No idea... When it says "Page Size" though I'd assume it's everything.

I just noticed this comment, the actual delivered size is much different, I've copied the charles logs for a homepage load and a search on each.

I'm on a slow connection right now, so that's why the response rates are terrible. These results are so far from scientific it's not even funny, but this does seem to follow what I've experienced.

The data is all below, but here's what it says:

Google.com homepage: 12.44KB, 735ms
Bing.com homepage: 114.24KB, 5.3s
Google.com search: 11.23KB 422ms
Bing.com search: 25.02KB, 3.9s

Google Homepage:

Code:
1	http://google.com/	google.com	301	text/html	259 B	219 B	250ms
2	http://www.google.com/	www.google.com	200	text/html	203 B	2.84 KB	203ms
3	http://www.google.com/intl/en_ALL/images/logo.gif	www.google.com	200	image/gif	251 B	8.36 KB	78ms
4	http://clients1.google.com/generate_204	clients1.google.com	204	text/html	125 B		93ms
5	http://www.google.com/csi?	www.google.com	204	text/html	215 B		110ms
	Total				1.03 KB	11.41 KB	734ms
	Grand Total					12.44 KB	
	Duration						735ms

Bing Homepage:

Code:
1	http://bing.com/	bing.com	301		318 B		78ms
2	http://www.bing.com/	www.bing.com	200	text/html	1.36 KB	11.18 KB	469ms
3	http://www.bing.com/fd/s/a/k.png	www.bing.com	200	image/png	262 B	4.67 KB	125ms
4	http://www.bing.com/s/wlflag.ico	www.bing.com	200	image/x-icon	264 B	1.12 KB	218ms
5	http://www.bing.com/fd/ls/l?IG=63842271cb5d4c318025efea0da1f92e&CID=0F5CA13A449544ACBA3C8E2D18E06F87&PM=Y&Type=Event.CPT&DATA={'pp':{'S':'L','PC':81,'BC':81,'BS':85,'H':89,'C1':-1,'C2':-1,'CT':260,'IL':0}}	www.bing.com	204		367 B		172ms
6	http://www.bing.com/fd/sa/5_05_0_385874/AutoSug0.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	3.26 KB	93ms
7	http://www.bing.com/fd/hpk2/Lebanon_EN-US399634007.jpg	www.bing.com	200	image/jpeg	373 B	67.58 KB	641ms
8	http://c.bing.com/c.gif?DI=0	c.bing.com	302		382 B		172ms
9	http://www.bing.com/fd/sa/5_05_0_385874/Shared.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	1.05 KB	188ms
10	http://c.atdmt.com/c.gif?DI=0&RedC=c.bing.com&MXFR=0F5CA13A449544ACBA3C8E2D18E06F87	c.atdmt.com	302		260 B		156ms
11	http://www.bing.com/fd/sa/5_05_0_385874/log/log3_c.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	323 B	687 B	109ms
12	http://www.bing.com/fd/hpk2/Lebanon_EN-US399634007s.jpg	www.bing.com	200	image/jpeg	372 B	8.27 KB	3.3s
13	http://www.bing.com/fd/sa/5_05_0_385874/fadeInImage2_c.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	1014 B	2.1s
14	http://c.bing.com/c.gif?DI=0&MUID=1f3d7ada4fc34e85b84511d4e68ad924	c.bing.com	200	image/gif	579 B	42 B	62ms
15	http://www.bing.com/fd/ls/GLinkPing.aspx?CM=TMF&IG=63842271cb5d4c318025efea0da1f92e&CID=0F5CA13A449544ACBA3C8E2D18E06F87	www.bing.com	200	image/gif	532 B	42 B	234ms
16	http://www.bing.com/sa/5_05_0_385874/Homepage2Hotspots_c.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	1.46 KB	94ms
17	http://a4.bing.com/fd/ls/ls.gif?IG=63842271cb5d4c318025efea0da1f92e&CID=0F5CA13A449544ACBA3C8E2D18E06F87&PM=Y&TYPE=Event.ClientInst&DATA=%5B%7B%22T%22:%22CI.Init%22,%22FID%22:%22CI%22,%22Name%22:%22Base%22,%22TS%22:1250825058547%7D,%7B%22W%22%3A1920%2C%22H%22%3A957%2C%22T%22:%22CI.Dims%22,%22FID%22:%22HP%22,%22Name%22:%22br%22,%22TS%22:1250825058547%7D,%7B%22Data%22%3A-1%2C%22T%22:%22CI.Test%22,%22FID%22:%22HP%22,%22Name%22:%22IsLive%22,%22TS%22:1250825058547%7D,%7B%22Time%22%3A653%2C%22T%22:%22CI.Load%22,%22FID%22:%22HP%22,%22Name%22:%22bg%22,%22TS%22:1250825059200%7D%5D	a4.bing.com	204		367 B		329ms
18	http://www.bing.com/fd/s/a/j1.png	www.bing.com	200	image/png	261 B	2.54 KB	94ms
19	http://www.bing.com/sa/5_05_0_385874/HomepageWithSL.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	3.89 KB	203ms
	Total				7.49 KB	106.75 KB	8.8s
	Grand Total					114.24 KB	
	Duration						5.3s

Google Search:

Code:
1	http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=test+search&btnG=Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi=	www.google.com	200	text/html	258 B	8.94 KB	281ms
2	http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&safe=off&q=test+search&um=1&ie=UTF-8&imgefp=kn9CRM-I2TMJ&imgurl=media.kidk.com/images/090730_microsoft_bing.jpg	news.google.com	200	image/jpeg	217 B	1.70 KB	109ms
3	http://clients1.google.com/generate_204	clients1.google.com	204	text/html	125 B		78ms
	Total				600 B	10.64 KB	468ms
	Grand Total					11.23 KB	
	Duration						422ms

Bing Search:

Code:
1	http://www.bing.com/search?q=test+search&go=&form=QBLH&qs=n	www.bing.com	200	text/html	362 B	10.51 KB	1.2s
2	http://www.bing.com/fd/ls/GLinkPing.aspx?IG=63842271cb5d4c318025efea0da1f92e&CID=0F5CA13A449544ACBA3C8E2D18E06F87&PM=Y&ID=homepage,21	www.bing.com	200	image/gif	444 B	42 B	375ms
3	http://www.bing.com/fd/s/a/j.png	www.bing.com	200	image/png	261 B	3.91 KB	234ms
4	http://www.bing.com/fd/ls/l?IG=08619aab6f7b442c95d9ef2c393fce6f&Type=Event.CPT&DATA={'pp':{'S':'L','PC':11,'BC':765,'BS':784,'H':802,'C1':-1,'C2':-1,'CT':823,'IL':0}}	www.bing.com	204		242 B		2.6s
5	http://www.bing.com/sa/5_05_0_385874/CapPreAndPopAndAjax2.js	www.bing.com	200	application/x-javascript	324 B	3.89 KB	141ms
6	http://www.bing.com/s/hov_target3.png	www.bing.com	200	image/png	260 B	313 B	109ms
7	http://www.bing.com/fd/sa/5_05_0_385874/brand3_c.css	www.bing.com	200	text/css	308 B	3.20 KB	125ms
8	http://www.bing.com/sa/5_05_0_385874/serp2_c.css	www.bing.com	200	text/css	307 B	735 B	110ms
	Total				2.45 KB	22.57 KB	4.9s
	Grand Total					25.02 KB	
	Duration						3.9s
 
I just noticed this comment, the actual delivered size is much different, I've copied the charles logs for a homepage load and a search on each.

I'm on a slow connection right now, so that's why the response rates are terrible. These results are so far from scientific it's not even funny, but this does seem to follow what I've experienced.

The data is all below, but here's what it says:

(snip)

Bing's slightly slower than Google because of the "Did you know?" image and it's results that load on every front page. It changes daily, so it doesn't really get cached.

It's a shame you can't disable it in Bing's preference, but then again it's not THAT much of a bandwidth hog.
 
Google.com homepage: 12.44KB, 735ms
Bing.com homepage: 114.24KB, 5.3s
Google.com search: 11.23KB 422ms
Bing.com search: 25.02KB, 3.9s
Good research, I stand corrected.

Still, is 114KB that much? Is 25KB that much?
Your response times will also vary depending on location, of course.

When I'm on a desktop, load times when you're dealing with 114KB are so minor I don't worry about it. When I'm on my phone, everything defaults to the mobile version, so I really don't understand the huge concern over page load times...


It's a shame you can't disable it in Bing's preference, but then again it's not THAT much of a bandwidth hog.
You'd have to rely on cookies or something for that... A passive webpage is my favorite kind. Setting cookies sucks.
 
You'd have to rely on cookies or something for that... A passive webpage is my favorite kind. Setting cookies sucks.

Yeah but I'll just leave it alone. Some of the daily images are very interesting. Today's an image of a volcano in Hawaii. Very fascinating stuff.
 
Yeah but I'll just leave it alone. Some of the daily images are very interesting. Today's an image of a volcano in Hawaii. Very fascinating stuff.

I still prefer Yahoo :)

If it weren't for the news snippets on Yahoo's front page I'd really have no idea what's going on.
 
Bing's slightly slower than Google because of the "Did you know?" image and it's results that load on every front page. It changes daily, so it doesn't really get cached.

It's a shame you can't disable it in Bing's preference, but then again it's not THAT much of a bandwidth hog.

Yeah, I cleared my cache before each load anyways; the image does take a while in transit for slow connections, but it's the response times on search that have me worried.

I do appreciate the novelty of that image, those images are damn cool. Though really I don't end up using a homepage, my (local, no load) chrome launch tab is how I start my browser experience, so the expedience of a search or a google.com hit is truly more important to me.

Google has a bit better infrastructure than Microsoft since they're more deeply entrenched in the search game. But what that means is that Microsoft will have an easier time improving their response times, while Google is going to be fighting wars for that extra millisecond, so the next year or so will be interesting.
 
Back
Top