New Build: Up in smoke

StarsFan4Life

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
472
F!

I recently purchased and built the following PC:

* Cooler Master Elite 330
* Gigabyte GA-MA78GM-S2H 780G motherboard
* AMD Phenom II Quad 940 Black Editon - Stock cooling
* 8GB G-Skill PC2-6400
* XFX Radeon 4870 1GB
* Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB SATA II
* Western Digital Caviar Black 640GB SATAII
* Onboard LAN/HD Audio
* Antec Earthwatts 650wt psu
* Logitech DiNovo Keyboard
* Logitech MX Revolution Mouse
* 2 X Yate Loon 120mm silent case fans
* 2 X Dell 23" S2309 W @ 1900 x 1080
* Microsoft Windows 7 64-bit and all updates
* DirectX 10 installed


I purchased it all on 6/20/2009 from Newegg.com.


Lastnight, I was enjoying a game of Day of Defeat Source....like I do almost daily. All of the sudden, my screens went black and I noticed a pungent "electronic melting" smell and looked to see my PSU was sparking and smoking.

I pulled the power plug....but it was too late.

So far...it seems to have taken the PSU and the motherboard...as I tried a spare Coolermaster PSU I had laying around. It would not boot up at all.

Is it possible it could have taken the CPU, RAM and video card long with it? None of these components have that smell coming from them.

Needless to say, I got on chat with Newegg...and they would do absolutely NOTHING about it...because I was 9 days outside of the 30 warranty they offer. I couldn't be more pissed than I am right now. This PSU was highly recommended by a lot here at [H] so I took it over a BFG....which seems to be a costly mistake.

I already submitted an RMA form with Antec and Gigabyte.....but if the problem was with the PSU in the first place....should they reimburse me for all parts it destroyed (given that I still need to test the ram, video card, cpu and hard drives)?

What the hell do I do here besides an RMA?
 
It could happen with any brand. I have seen BFG, Thermaltake, Antec, Corsair, Coolermaster, Coolmax, etc kill computers, It just happens.
 
Is it possible it could have taken the CPU, RAM and video card long with it? None of these components have that smell coming from them.
.............
I already submitted an RMA form with Antec and Gigabyte.....but if the problem was with the PSU in the first place....should they reimburse me for all parts it destroyed (given that I still need to test the ram, video card, cpu and hard drives)?

What the hell do I do here besides an RMA?

There's a possiblity that the PSU could have taken out those other parts but it's a pretty low possibility due to the Earthwatt's quality. Yeah I know how that sounds after yours just died but just luck of the draw man.

AFAIK, the only company that actually reimburses you for the hardware destroyed by their own PSU was Corsair. However that was a very special situation IIRC.

If you can, test your parts in another PC. Rule out which ones are dead and which are alive.
 
i would call antec. see if they can help you out. never know it would not hurt. i see you have an arma with them ok. i hope they can do something for you
 
Yup, this is true. Every manufacturer will have a bad batch eventually. A Q6600 Quad build I put together for a friend with a Corsair 650TX PSU, the PSU went up in smoke. He bought a Antec EA650 to replace that Corsair PSU.

It could happen with any brand. I have seen BFG, Thermaltake, Antec, Corsair, Coolermaster, Coolmax, etc kill computers, It just happens.
 
Yup, this is true. Every manufacturer will have a bad batch eventually. A Q6600 Quad build I put together for a friend with a Corsair 650TX PSU, the PSU went up in smoke. He bought a Antec EA650 to replace that Corsair PSU.

I am just worried that since it took out my motherboard, chances are it took out other components too.
 
I'm not surprised if it may have taken other components to. The scary part is the CPU. if the cpu is damaged and you try to find out if it still works in another mobo, the damaged cpu may damage the mobo also. I had that happen to me before. I had an AMD Duron chip and had a guy at a pc store check it out for me. I ended up damaging his mobo. Good thing he did not make me pay for it. :p
 
I'm not surprised if it may have taken other components to. The scary part is the CPU. if the cpu is damaged and you try to find out if it still works in another mobo, the damaged cpu may damage the mobo also. I had that happen to me before. I had an AMD Duron chip and had a guy at a pc store check it out for me. I ended up damaging his mobo. Good thing he did not make me pay for it. :p

Is there an easy way for me to tell if it got to the CPU without putting it in another machine?
 
I don't think you can. When you physically inspect the cpu, it may not look damage from the outside but, yet still be damaged. You can pull out the cpu and see if any of the pins are burnt then it would be obvious that it is damaged. It wouldn't hurt to look. My AMD Duron chip did not look damaged from the outside.
 
Ram tested....all passed just fine. Found the problem on the motherboard, it is for sure shot.

I will post a pic later on.
 
Let us know if Gigabyte replaces it for you. They may give you a hard time. If they do, I'd seriously look into getting reimbursed by Antec or APC, lol.
 
Yes, no problem. But, I thought your Antec 650 crapped out? Unless you plan on picking up another one?
 
If you are going to pickup something at Frys, get the BFG LS-550 for $64.90 Then, RMA and have your Antec EA650 psu repaired. Just use that PSU as a backup when they mail it back to you.
 
This got me thinking...can you burn-in a PSU without connecting it to a mobo? I don't just mean turn it on, but actually stress test it for like a week before putting it in a system.
 
[LYL]Homer;1034421762 said:
This got me thinking...can you burn-in a PSU without connecting it to a mobo? I don't just mean turn it on, but actually stress test it for like a week before putting it in a system.
Depends. If you have the kind of PSU testing setup that HardOCP and JohnnyGURU.com has, you can easily stress test a PSU without attaching it to any real computer hardware per se. You would also get pretty accurate readings.

But for a home solution: If you have a ton of old drives that you don't need/care for, you could just attach those to the PSU as a semi-decent stress. But you would need a lot of drives (roughly 10 or so) for good load. CPUs and video cards are the biggest energy consumers in a PC so for a decent load/stress test you would need those. Still wouldn't be as accurate as an the PSU equipment that [H] and J.G. have .
 
I am going to Fry's tomorrow to buy a new Gigabyte GIGABYTE GA-MA790X-UD4P to replace the one I am RMA'ing (I will sell it off). Is this the way to go?

Also, when I get my PSU back, is it enough power to power my system efficently?
 
Let us know if Gigabyte replaces it for you. They may give you a hard time. If they do, I'd seriously look into getting reimbursed by Antec or APC, lol.

What exactly would APC do? There was no power surge.
 
650watt Earthwatts is more than enough to power your current set up.

I using a 380watt with 4 SATA hard drives, 1 SATA DVD R/RW, 5 case fans, 7750 kuma OC and 9600 GT (4870 ain't get here yet to test if it will work).
 
650watt Earthwatts is more than enough to power your current set up.

I using a 380watt with 4 SATA hard drives, 1 SATA DVD R/RW, 5 case fans, 7750 kuma OC and 9600 GT (4870 ain't get here yet to test if it will work).

The reason I ask is Antec said otherwise:

Comment: Hi,

Based on your configuration...the PSU you have is overloaded to the max. I would recommend a 750Watt and higher amperage 12V rail.

I am sorry that you are not having a good day or time...

please go ahead and RMA the PSU...


This was an email direct from Antec RMA department.
 
Hi,
Based on your last email, you are full of shit....
please go ahead and pull your head out of your ass after you are done paying for my burned up rig...



There... I wrote up a response for you.
 
Huh, that's bullshit coming from Antec then. According to the Corsair PSU Finder, the Corsair 450VX with its 33A on the +12V rail is enough for that setup. Considering that the EA650 has 45A on the +12V rail, it's hard to believe that it's insufficient power.
 
Yes, the Antec EA650 has the 8 pin connector. That is the EPS 12V connector. The Antec EA650 would not be overloaded with your setup.
 
What exactly would APC do? There was no power surge.

Not sure. How does APC determine if their product was at fault?

@OP: Is the UPS still working?

The reason I ask is Antec said otherwise:

Comment: Hi,

Based on your configuration...the PSU you have is overloaded to the max. I would recommend a 750Watt and higher amperage 12V rail.

I am sorry that you are not having a good day or time...

please go ahead and RMA the PSU...


This was an email direct from Antec RMA department.

I'd like to see their math on that, please.
 
Just as a reference, my last build exploded 2 weeks after I built it with a 750 watt silverstone psu. I RMA'd my PSU, mobo, and proc. I didn't know for sure what it fried so I just sent everything I couldn't test back. Once I got all new ones back, I found out my video card was fried too.
 
Back
Top