'Textual Harassment' No Laughing Matter

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to Law.com, "textual harassment" is no laughing matter. In other news, the recently invented term “textual harassment” IS pretty funny, so go ahead and laugh at that part.

Attorneys say that text messaging in the workplace is turning into a growing liability for employers, which are landing in court over inappropriate and offensive texts that are popping up on employees' cell phones.
 
It's funny but it as texting becomes more prevalent I totally expect to see there being more and more laws/regulations put on it. Verbal is one thing but texting is documented and businesses especially will probably be put on the spot of recording/monitoring everything down to stupid AIM/ICQ/Whatever texts.
 
Yet another example of people not understanding how the technology is going to come around to bite them in the ass.

Although in this case, I'm glad they are actually being that stupid.

sexual harrashment in any form is wrong. At least this way they are leaving some proof so that it isn't just a he said / she said case.
 
Can't we apply those common sense laws and society outrage tests to determine all of this over reactive bullshit is actually over reactive bullshit?

True sexual harassment is bad, of course, but what can pass as sexual harassment on technicality is absurd and completely out of line with what the law should be used for.
 
What isn't funny is that some women are using this as a lottery. For example:

"In April, text messages helped two female soccer players who accused their coach of sexual harassment secure a $450,000 settlement from Central Michigan University."

That is BS. I bet they don't even have life insurance that covers them that high. Yet, for having to deal w/ a few silly sex texts, they're entitled to $450k? :rolleyes: :mad:
 
What isn't funny is that some women are using this as a lottery. For example:

"In April, text messages helped two female soccer players who accused their coach of sexual harassment secure a $450,000 settlement from Central Michigan University."

That is BS. I bet they don't even have life insurance that covers them that high. Yet, for having to deal w/ a few silly sex texts, they're entitled to $450k? :rolleyes: :mad:

Actually I could see that value maybe being about right. You are looking at 2 girls not just one. So that only comes to about $225,000 per girl. On top of that their lawyer gets probably about 1/3 or so of that. So each might get about $150,000

Take into consideration that they might have had to change school thus maybe adding an extra semester or two to their college term. that is extra money they now have to payout for school. What if they were going to school on a schoolarship? I doubt they would keep playing soccer there after that if they didn't switch schools. So in that case they now have to pay for the schooling themselves from that point on. Or what if both were true, they had to switch schools and were at Central Michigan University on schoolarship? Maybe the new school wouldn't offer them a schoolarship. In which case not only are they now playing for school themself, but also now adding on an extra semester or two.

Take that and add in money to cover the "emontial stress" or whatever you want to call it from both the harrassment and the any changes to their college path that resulted from the suit, and $150,000 really doesn't seem that over the top.

Same would hold try for somebody that had to quit their job. They should be given enough to cover the loss of wages, any moving expense that they might have endured to get a new job. If the new job isn't comparable in pay and benefits to the old job, maybe even some money make up that difference. Then after that add on for them having went through the ordeal.

You can't really say every case should pay out X amount of money because every case is going to be different. Your boss telling you that you have a nice ass is different than your boss saying that if you want to keep your job that you need to start showing off more of your body. And both of those are different than your boss telling you that if you don't preform sexual favors for him and his friends that you might be replaced.
 
What isn't funny is that some women are using this as a lottery. For example:

"In April, text messages helped two female soccer players who accused their coach of sexual harassment secure a $450,000 settlement from Central Michigan University."

That is BS. I bet they don't even have life insurance that covers them that high. Yet, for having to deal w/ a few silly sex texts, they're entitled to $450k? :rolleyes: :mad:


Pretty much saying that you are defending the coaches actions makes me :rolleyes:.
 
And the fact that you don't know what actually happened makes me feel the same way.. unless you were the coach or one of the two girls, most likely you don't know everything that has gone on, nor can you judge the truth of someone's claims.
 
steve better start showing more leg, or we're going to have him removed from the front page news forum. :D:p
 
Actually I could see that value maybe being about right. You are looking at 2 girls not just one. So that only comes to about $225,000 per girl. On top of that their lawyer gets probably about 1/3 or so of that. So each might get about $150,000

Take into consideration that they might have had to change school thus maybe adding an extra semester or two to their college term. that is extra money they now have to payout for school. What if they were going to school on a schoolarship? I doubt they would keep playing soccer there after that if they didn't switch schools. So in that case they now have to pay for the schooling themselves from that point on. Or what if both were true, they had to switch schools and were at Central Michigan University on schoolarship? Maybe the new school wouldn't offer them a schoolarship. In which case not only are they now playing for school themself, but also now adding on an extra semester or two.

Take that and add in money to cover the "emontial stress" or whatever you want to call it from both the harrassment and the any changes to their college path that resulted from the suit, and $150,000 really doesn't seem that over the top.

Same would hold try for somebody that had to quit their job. They should be given enough to cover the loss of wages, any moving expense that they might have endured to get a new job. If the new job isn't comparable in pay and benefits to the old job, maybe even some money make up that difference. Then after that add on for them having went through the ordeal.

You can't really say every case should pay out X amount of money because every case is going to be different. Your boss telling you that you have a nice ass is different than your boss saying that if you want to keep your job that you need to start showing off more of your body. And both of those are different than your boss telling you that if you don't preform sexual favors for him and his friends that you might be replaced.
I appreciate the well-thought out reply (unlike justluv2play's retort). I see where you're coming from. But if the coach is fired (which he should've been after the case was substantiated), why would they need to transfer? More often than not from what I've read, the "emotional distress" is a bunch of baloney used by lawyers to milk out more $ for themselves and their clients. I bet the texting girl who fell in the manhole (a Front Page News story from several days ago) will get a boatload for "emotional distress" . :mad:

Pretty much saying that you are defending the coaches actions makes me :rolleyes:.
You're assumptions that I'm defending the coach's action makes me :rolleyes: even more.
 
I find it rather funny when you consider you can delete a text and block someone's number.. it's about like Facebook and Myspace, if you don't want someone talking to you, there are measures you can take to prevent it.
 
I find it rather funny when you consider you can delete a text and block someone's number.. it's about like Facebook and Myspace, if you don't want someone talking to you, there are measures you can take to prevent it.
I don't think you can selectively block certain ph. #s from a text message. I think it's an all or nothing deal w/ text (either block all or block none). I know in the past, I asked VZW about it and they said it wasn't possible. At the time, a "friend" was spamming me and running up my bill b/c I didn't have a text plan.

But you're right that the girls could've just ignored the text messages, not that I'd condone that guy's actions. (Just clarifying in case jusluv2play jumps to conclusions again.)
 
I'm not positive on that matter either (blocking individuals from texting you).. but in most cases (I understand exceptions like a boss or a coach) prevention is as simple as not giving out your phone number. While I don't condone what the coach did (if it indeed was true).. I find it hard to believe they couldn't just delete the messages as opposed to the hassle of a lawsuit.
 
it just sucks because since the beginning of time, sexual harrassment and stalking used to be much more rare. now we classifly a text that says "i want your ass" as sexual harassment (as long as she didnt want to hear that at that moment) and subsequently it makes most every guy that tries to get with a girl perverted. girls play hard to get by nature, but we cant say one single word to them after the first 'no' so thats that. and they wonder why so many guys are alone.
 
Hence my original comment where I think there was an ulterior motive involved with the lawsuit: to cash in. :(

You jump straight to the conclusion that the coach, while he may have been attempting to solicit something from the girls, that there is no way anything he did could have been malicious or prejudiced?

EVEN IF the girls simply ignored the text messages completely, you run into the problem of the coach acting in prejudice against the girls out of spite or revenge or even just out of being uncomfortable around them after the whole ordeal. This could be anything from benching the players during important games where scouts might be at (or any games for that matter) or by making their lives harder to get them to quit the team or even as simple as causing a rift between the girls and the coach that makes their sporting and academic experience impacted. This is simply NOT ACCEPTABLE in any sence of the word, and attempting to undermine what the law is there for is not going to allow any sort of "progression" against unfair lawsuits, it will only hurt the precedence set that helps to prevent this sort of thing from going on between teachers and students.

That is simply not an acceptable environment for students to be in and as such, the coach needs fired and the school needs to be fined to ensure things like this are never just swept under the rug, with no repercussions for the coach (or other figures of authority (I'M LOOKING AT YOU POLICE DEPARTMENTS))
 
it just sucks because since the beginning of time, sexual harrassment and stalking used to be much more rare. now we classifly a text that says "i want your ass" as sexual harassment (as long as she didnt want to hear that at that moment) and subsequently it makes most every guy that tries to get with a girl perverted. girls play hard to get by nature, but we cant say one single word to them after the first 'no' so thats that. and they wonder why so many guys are alone.
It's gotten so ridiculous that even looking at someone the "wrong" way can be construed as sexual harassment. Our company has even told us that. Furthermore, I know of one case (granted, as told by a coworker, so I didn't personally observe this) where a couple both working for our company met for in the hallway for lunch. They embraced and the husband tapped his wife's behind. Another woman who was walking by saw that and claimed she was sexually harassed by having to see that. The company wound up firing that guy. WTF?! :mad:

You jump straight to the conclusion that the coach, while he may have been attempting to solicit something from the girls, that there is no way anything he did could have been malicious or prejudiced?

EVEN IF the girls simply ignored the text messages completely, you run into the problem of the coach acting in prejudice against the girls out of spite or revenge or even just out of being uncomfortable around them after the whole ordeal. This could be anything from benching the players during important games where scouts might be at (or any games for that matter) or by making their lives harder to get them to quit the team or even as simple as causing a rift between the girls and the coach that makes their sporting and academic experience impacted. This is simply NOT ACCEPTABLE in any sence of the word, and attempting to undermine what the law is there for is not going to allow any sort of "progression" against unfair lawsuits, it will only hurt the precedence set that helps to prevent this sort of thing from going on between teachers and students.

That is simply not an acceptable environment for students to be in and as such, the coach needs fired and the school needs to be fined to ensure things like this are never just swept under the rug, with no repercussions for the coach (or other figures of authority (I'M LOOKING AT YOU POLICE DEPARTMENTS))
So making roughly half a million off the school makes it all good?

If the women genuinely feel they were sexually harassed and wronged, then they would've been satisfied to get an official apology from the school and see that coach get fired and barred for future employment from that school for life. But no, they needed $450k between the 2 of them to make it all good. :rolleyes:
 
It's gotten so ridiculous that even looking at someone the "wrong" way can be construed as sexual harassment. Our company has even told us that. Furthermore, I know of one case (granted, as told by a coworker, so I didn't personally observe this) where a couple both working for our company met for in the hallway for lunch. They embraced and the husband tapped his wife's behind. Another woman who was walking by saw that and claimed she was sexually harassed by having to see that. The company wound up firing that guy. WTF?! :mad:


So making roughly half a million off the school makes it all good?

If the women genuinely feel they were sexually harassed and wronged, then they would've been satisfied to get an official apology from the school and see that coach get fired and barred for future employment from that school for life. But no, they needed $450k between the 2 of them to make it all good. :rolleyes:

Like I said, its punitive. Your jealousy of other lucking monetarily out isn't enough of a reason to let everything slide.
 
Like I said, its punitive. Your jealousy of other lucking monetarily out isn't enough of a reason to let everything slide.
I'm not jealous. I'm just calling a duck when I see a duck. And these 2 women are quacking loud and clear.
 
I'm not jealous. I'm just calling a duck when I see a duck. And these 2 women are quacking loud and clear.

Like I said, you are jealous and indignant about it. What circumstances DO you deem permissible for a reward in this kind of case? Now that you've thought of some alternative scenarios, set your prejudice aside for a second and accept that these girls may have some valid claim as well.

And, even if they don't. tough shit, because sexual harassment in a school setting is not acceptable unless completely mutual between them. You don't know if these girls wanted anything the coach was doing to them, so you have no grounds to claim that they have no claim.

While it is unfortunate that the school lost some money, perhaps now they will try a little harder to prevent this sort of thing in the future.
 
Like I said, you are jealous and indignant about it. What circumstances DO you deem permissible for a reward in this kind of case? Now that you've thought of some alternative scenarios, set your prejudice aside for a second and accept that these girls may have some valid claim as well.

And, even if they don't. tough shit, because sexual harassment in a school setting is not acceptable unless completely mutual between them. You don't know if these girls wanted anything the coach was doing to them, so you have no grounds to claim that they have no claim.

While it is unfortunate that the school lost some money, perhaps now they will try a little harder to prevent this sort of thing in the future.
Congrats, it looks like you have "ESPN" since you know how jealous and indignant I am. :bow:

:rolleyes:

First, I never condoned the coach's actions. I just said if the women really did feel textually harassed, then they would've been satisfied to see him fired and the school offer an official apology.

If he raped them, yes, then I can see the "emotional distress" part of the settlement. Rape is a very serious offense. It's too bad that "textual harassment" is being judged like rape. :(
 
Funny thing how documentation works...Why are people so stupid?
 
Congrats, it looks like you have "ESPN" since you know how jealous and indignant I am. :bow:

:rolleyes:

First, I never condoned the coach's actions. I just said if the women really did feel textually harassed, then they would've been satisfied to see him fired and the school offer an official apology.

If he raped them, yes, then I can see the "emotional distress" part of the settlement. Rape is a very serious offense. It's too bad that "textual harassment" is being judged like rape. :(

In other words, any harassment that isn't at least rape doesn't deserve anything. How nice.
 
In other words, any harassment that isn't at least rape doesn't deserve anything. How nice.
Again, you're making up my words.

For "textual harassment", firing/apology would've sufficed.

And what do you mean "at least" rape? What kind of harassment is worse than rape? :confused:
 
Again, you're making up my words.

For "textual harassment", firing/apology would've sufficed.

And what do you mean "at least" rape? What kind of harassment is worse than rape? :confused:

So harassment (that just happens to also be caught in electronic form as well) don't deserve any chance to sue?

You are the one who used rape as a bar to set for what actually deserves more than an apology and a firing. Maybe you should leave your special peeves for another thread.
 
Let me get this straight.

Scumbag attorneys are advocating for "reasonable privacy", and want to leave Texting in a "private", unmonitored realm.

Then even more scumbag attorneys want to sue the company when unmonitored correspondance gets the company in trouble???



Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiigggggggggggggggggghhhhhhhht.
 
Let me get this straight.

Scumbag attorneys are advocating for "reasonable privacy", and want to leave Texting in a "private", unmonitored realm.

Then even more scumbag attorneys want to sue the company when unmonitored correspondance gets the company in trouble???



Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiigggggggggggggggggghhhhhhhht.

The EFF is not filled with scumbag attorneys.
 
Kristoff.. the problem here is that you don't know the circumstances and neither does he. While you question his knowledge of what took place and his judgment of what happened, the same can be done to you. He doesn't know if the girls just sued for no reason.. but you don't know if the coach actually did anything wrong.

I feel the main problem is how "harassment" is perceived. The definition for "harassment" is pretty much *so and so says that Joe Bloh said/ did this and it felt wrong*.. happens all the time where something with no substantial basing is construed as "harassment" by one party, when any casual observer of the situation would disagree. There needs to be a more structured definition of "harassment" and it has to be reasonable.
 
I feel the main problem is how "harassment" is perceived. The definition for "harassment" is pretty much *so and so says that Joe Bloh said/ did this and it felt wrong*.. happens all the time where something with no substantial basing is construed as "harassment" by one party, when any casual observer of the situation would disagree. There needs to be a more structured definition of "harassment" and it has to be reasonable.

That would make to much sense.
 
"Sexual harassment" = "I made up some BS so give me money"

I wish someone would sexually harass me.

I'm glad this is a text discussion medium, instead of a discussion spoken aloud. I don't think I could stand the windbags that like to call it sexual hair-ess-mint.
 
So harassment (that just happens to also be caught in electronic form as well) don't deserve any chance to sue?
Again, please tell me where I said this. My main argument is that text harassment != sex harassment.

You are the one who used rape as a bar to set for what actually deserves more than an apology and a firing. Maybe you should leave your special peeves for another thread.
I brought up rape b/c you'd think that's what these "textually harassed" women were a victim of based on the settlement. Hell, the guy didn't even grab a boob. Imagine if he did - then perhaps we'd stone him to death? Nah, maybe just settle it for $2 million - after all, a boob was violated. (Well, technically, say 2 boobs - 1 boob per student.) :eek:
 
I appreciate the well-thought out reply (unlike justluv2play's retort). I see where you're coming from. But if the coach is fired (which he should've been after the case was substantiated), why would they need to transfer? More often than not from what I've read, the "emotional distress" is a bunch of baloney used by lawyers to milk out more $ for themselves and their clients. I bet the texting girl who fell in the manhole (a Front Page News story from several days ago) will get a boatload for "emotional distress" . :mad:


You're assumptions that I'm defending the coach's action makes me :rolleyes: even more.

Just because the coach is fired doesn't mean that girls would get fair treatment after that. There could be fellow players / studens who are mad at them over getting the coach fired. There could be teachers that were friends with him who are mad at the girls. So even with the coach gone there could still be reason for the girls to need to switch schools.

When i was in highschool the band instructor sexually assulted a female student and tried to force himself on her. She had bruises on he arms and legs from the attack. This was enough for the instructor to get fired. This girl had to leave school though as nobody (student or teacherwise) believed her, they couldn't believe he would have tried to do that and was sure he paid somebody to hurt her in that way. Even with other girls coming forward saying he had made what they thought was inappropriate comments to them.

So you can't assume that just because somebody is fired the everyone would treat the victims as if nothing happened.

I find it rather funny when you consider you can delete a text and block someone's number.. it's about like Facebook and Myspace, if you don't want someone talking to you, there are measures you can take to prevent it.

that isn't going to do much. If the person is your boss, coworker or somebody that is suppose to have your number blocking them is going to be hard as then you couldn't get legit stuff from them. And blocking anyone else's number would just make them start doing it in person.

Kristoff.. the problem here is that you don't know the circumstances and neither does he. While you question his knowledge of what took place and his judgment of what happened, the same can be done to you. He doesn't know if the girls just sued for no reason.. but you don't know if the coach actually did anything wrong.

I feel the main problem is how "harassment" is perceived. The definition for "harassment" is pretty much *so and so says that Joe Bloh said/ did this and it felt wrong*.. happens all the time where something with no substantial basing is construed as "harassment" by one party, when any casual observer of the situation would disagree. There needs to be a more structured definition of "harassment" and it has to be reasonable.

True we do not know the exact circumstance of these case, but why automatically assume that the girls where in the wrong and that they are greedy bitches for filing a complaint? He got fired and somebody awared them money then they must have felt the circumstances were enough for them to have a case. Weither or not they got overpaid its hard to say. But in all honesty how is that any different that the person that slips on a wet spot in a store then sues for $500,000 pain and suffering. I could argue that pain and suffering is just as much bullshit as any other type of emotinal claim.

I will also agrue that beowolf comes off as sounding as no woman should be entitled to anything from a sexual harrassment claim. Sure, some might be frivolous, but that doesn't mean they all are.

You are correct in harrassment being precieved, But its hard to say what should and shouldn't offend somebody. One girl might like you saying "you have a nice mouth, however it looks like is missing my dick in it" although many other woman would probably slap you if you said that to them. Just because one might not have a problem with that statement, does that mean that should be fine with it? Then you also have to look at the person making the statements. Lets say a female works at an office and her boss is a handsome, well off male, he might be able to get away with making some flirty comments and askng her out for drinks. Now replace him with an older, overweight guy. They would probably not like him treating them in that manor. And unforunity with her saying no the the older fat guy, that would just give him more chances / reasons to keep asking her over and over and over again.

Every case is going to be different, so you really can't say that this is this and this only is harrassment.
 
Just because the coach is fired doesn't mean that girls would get fair treatment after that. There could be fellow players / studens who are mad at them over getting the coach fired. There could be teachers that were friends with him who are mad at the girls. So even with the coach gone there could still be reason for the girls to need to switch schools.

When i was in highschool the band instructor sexually assulted a female student and tried to force himself on her. She had bruises on he arms and legs from the attack. This was enough for the instructor to get fired. This girl had to leave school though as nobody (student or teacherwise) believed her, they couldn't believe he would have tried to do that and was sure he paid somebody to hurt her in that way. Even with other girls coming forward saying he had made what they thought was inappropriate comments to them.

So you can't assume that just because somebody is fired the everyone would treat the victims as if nothing happened.



that isn't going to do much. If the person is your boss, coworker or somebody that is suppose to have your number blocking them is going to be hard as then you couldn't get legit stuff from them. And blocking anyone else's number would just make them start doing it in person.
The boss/ coworker etc. etc. would be a different matter, I've already said this. However you don't know if the other person would actually start doing this in person if you blocked their number, and if they did then you'd have a solid case for harassment, not just text crap



True we do not know the exact circumstance of these case, but why automatically assume that the girls where in the wrong and that they are greedy bitches for filing a complaint?
Where did you read that I said the girls were being greedy bitches? I just said that we don't know both sides of the story and this could easily be a he-said she-said case that got misconstrued against the coach.

He got fired and somebody awared them money then they must have felt the circumstances were enough for them to have a case.
Maybe.. though I wouldn't be surprised if the American justice system failed to properly assess the situation[./B]

Weither or not they got overpaid its hard to say. But in all honesty how is that any different that the person that slips on a wet spot in a store then sues for $500,000 pain and suffering. I could argue that pain and suffering is just as much bullshit as any other type of emotinal claim.
You don't see me disagreeing about pain and suffering. I don't feel someone has a right to sue for half a million if they slip on a wet spot in a store.. shouldn't be allowed to sue for anything, they need to watch the hell out and take responsibility when they don't.

I will also agrue that beowolf comes off as sounding as no woman should be entitled to anything from a sexual harrassment claim. Sure, some might be frivolous, but that doesn't mean they all are.
His argument has little bearing on my attitude.. I believe many of the "harassment" cases to be frivolous, but I will not overstep any boundaries and say that all or even most cases are frivolous.

You are correct in harrassment being precieved, But its hard to say what should and shouldn't offend somebody. One girl might like you saying "you have a nice mouth, however it looks like is missing my dick in it" although many other woman would probably slap you if you said that to them. Just because one might not have a problem with that statement, does that mean that should be fine with it? Then you also have to look at the person making the statements. Lets say a female works at an office and her boss is a handsome, well off male, he might be able to get away with making some flirty comments and askng her out for drinks. Now replace him with an older, overweight guy. They would probably not like him treating them in that manor. And unforunity with her saying no the the older fat guy, that would just give him more chances / reasons to keep asking her over and over and over again.

Every case is going to be different, so you really can't say that this is this and this only is harrassment.


I also completely disagree with the last part.. it shouldn't matter what someone finds offensive as to what is considered "harassment". Harassment should be defined by the repeated or continued offending of an individual who has expressed their objections to your offensive actions or communications. If I tell a girl that "she'd look so much more sexy with my dick in her mouth" and she's disgusted, then she has every right to curse me out or slap me, however that shouldn't qualify for harassment. However if I were to tell the same girl the very same statement at a later time, it would then qualify for harassment.
 
I also completely disagree with the last part.. it shouldn't matter what someone finds offensive as to what is considered "harassment". Harassment should be defined by the repeated or continued offending of an individual who has expressed their objections to your offensive actions or communications. If I tell a girl that "she'd look so much more sexy with my dick in her mouth" and she's disgusted, then she has every right to curse me out or slap me, however that shouldn't qualify for harassment. However if I were to tell the same girl the very same statement at a later time, it would then qualify for harassment.

Come on, you have to be kidding? You wouldn't know thats a sexually harrassive statement in a work place or with a teacher to student capacity? You only think it should be classified as such if its repeated? Maybe I am missing your sarcasm and your just joking, I hope I am. But if I am not and your serious, then I pretty much think your absolutely clueless. Seek help
 
Back
Top