Ban Caller-ID Spoofing?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
That blind kid that got himself sent to prison for “swatting” has renewed the debate over caller-ID spoofing. My question is this…what is a legitimate use for caller-ID spoofing? Can anyone think of a legit use?

Two years ago I wrote a post scoffing at members of Congress who were pushing legislation to outlaw caller-ID spoofing. I was wrong; they were right. People who abuse caller-ID need to know they're breaking the law.
 
My question is this…what is a legitimate use for caller-ID spoofing? Can anyone think of a legit use?

Not wanting to give out your personal information? Seems legit enough to me :eek:
 
Witness programs and Battered wives are the two that I'm told about. Thing is that they have other ways that they can do this other than spoof. Vonage anyone?
 
Up here in Canada on Telus I get spam ALL THE FUCKING TIME on my work phone (but not my personal Bell call). 1/4 of them outright state they are promoting to Telus users, the rest spoof numbers and are USA based companies promoting some stupid shit about me winning a boat or some crap. They hang up as soon as I ask for a manager. Even if they "remove" me from their list it takes 30 days for this to happen.

I at this time cannot think of a legitimate use for spoofing other than say for legal enforcement, but I always figured they were allowed to do that anyways...
 
Not wanting to give out your personal information? Seems legit enough to me :eek:

Caller ID blocking is not the same as spoofing. Spoofing makes you look like someone else, instead of just anonymous. It is a lesser form of identity theft.
 
My question is this…what is a legitimate use for caller-ID spoofing? Can anyone think of a legit use?
I've used it before to get clients to pick up the phone when they owe me money. I call that a legitimate use.
 
I've used it before to get clients to pick up the phone when they owe me money. I call that a legitimate use.

I don't pick up unless i know who's on the other side. If I don't recognize the #, I don't pickup. even if i do, I usually wait until the answering machine does first and I know the voice.
 
All the spoofers use really stupid numbers anyways its easy to see they are fake and just click them off.
I also wont answer an.

They have my number. They may speak to me when i have theirs.
 
Legitimate use?
How about a business that has mutiple phone lines, and wants all outbound calls to "appear" to come from the main number? Otherwise the outbound calls would have random ID numbers and the customers wouldn't know who is calling!

I have dual T-1 lines (46 lines) comming into the office phone system. there are 8 phone numbers and block of 100 DID numbers forwarded the the numbers assigned to the T-1 line. Customers need to see the official published main number, not the number assigned by the phone company to the T-1 line when someone in the office make a call.
 
I have dual T-1 lines (46 lines) comming into the office phone system. there are 8 phone numbers and block of 100 DID numbers forwarded the the numbers assigned to the T-1 line. Customers need to see the official published main number, not the number assigned by the phone company to the T-1 line when someone in the office make a call.

That is Caller ID masking, some carriers support it, some dont. Its legit for business telco accounts
 
Legitimate use?
How about a business that has multiple phone lines, and wants all outbound calls to "appear" to come from the main number? Otherwise the outbound calls would have random ID numbers and the customers wouldn't know who is calling!

I have dual T-1 lines (46 lines) coming into the office phone system. there are 8 phone numbers and block of 100 DID numbers forwarded the the numbers assigned to the T-1 line. Customers need to see the official published main number, not the number assigned by the phone company to the T-1 line when someone in the office make a call.

Spoofing is when the caller changes the outbound ID to one different than that configured by the telco. What you described above is how your lines should be as part of your telco service.

It's painfully obvious that the industry isn't capable of creating and enforcing these policies internally, it will be up to the FCC to give the telcos a set of uniform rules on what is and is not acceptable when it comes to caller ID. Of course that wouldn't be necessary if the telcos had their act together.
 
I don't pick up unless i know who's on the other side. If I don't recognize the #, I don't pickup. even if i do, I usually wait until the answering machine does first and I know the voice.

i think the failure of the callerID system (spoofing, anonymous calls, private calls, telemarketers) has forced most of us to treat their phones this way.
 
Yes, I can think of several legitimate uses of spoofing. My desk phone has its own individual DID but I have it masked with a corporate number so as to not unnecessarily give out my number when doing test calls (I work in the NOC for a VoIP Company). The vast majority of our corporate users - especially in our call center - have a similar practice. Of course, the number we use to do this is actually a legitimate number, and calling that number back will in some way connect you back to this company, although maybe not the exact department that the call originated from.

Technically speaking, there are plenty of our support technicians that could set up any or all users on our softswitch with a masked number. They are under strict orders to never do so unless it is requested by the customer, and said number is one that both we and the customer "own".

Part of the problem is that it's so incredibly easy to set up something that is spoofed, for every legitimate use, there is another fraudulent or shady use. But you don't have to be all-powerful to set such a thing up, so it's not as simple as the telecom industry merely not having its shit together. As far as I know, barring fraudulent use, it's completely legal for me to mask my number to something completely different - like maybe some other persons cell number. I, of course, adhere to the rule of not modifying it if it's not actually our number (either my company, or that of a customer). But if some rogue tech chooses to disobey this guideline - Should my whole company, or the whole industry be punished? Is it our fault?

Unfortunately it is not as simple as "the industry" enforcing any given policy - There are far too many individuals capable of disregarding policy, and even individuals who operate outside the bounds of the industry - And those are the ones who are probably more likely to disregard said policy.

TL;DR
Yes there are legit uses, but there should be some definite guidelines surrounding what is and is not acceptable when it comes to how, why, and what you spoof.
 
It seems that most people do not understand what caller-ID spoofing is.

*67 is a legitimate form of caller ID blocking. The person you are calling cannot see your number / name. This is NOT caller-ID spoofing.

Caller-ID spoofing is when you deliberately manipulate the number displayed on your outgoing caller ID to look like someone else's number.

Not wanting to give out your number, battered women and witness protection have no need to change their caller-ID to the number for Dominoes Pizza or the LAPD, FBI, IRS (and so on). Caller-ID spoofing is technically fraud.



(Legitimate numbers assigned to companies (offices / hotels) so that all outbound calls say "Marriot Hotel" and display the main phone number has nothing to do with caller-ID spoofing.)
 
Nope. Ban Away!

I would love to be able to track down all the "You are paying too much interest on your credit cards" jackels out there, and report their asses to the FTC for DNC violations.

Companies are getting brave when it comes to the do-not-call list. It's like they don't think anyone will report them.

We should be. It's the only way the system will work. Hit them in the pocket with the fines. From what I can tell, the FTC is quite happy to enforce and fine for this law, but they can't if no one reports them.

"Sorry, I will remove you from the list" does not cut it for me any more.
 
It seems that most people do not understand what caller-ID spoofing is.

*67 is a legitimate form of caller ID blocking. The person you are calling cannot see your number / name. This is NOT caller-ID spoofing.

Caller-ID spoofing is when you deliberately manipulate the number displayed on your outgoing caller ID to look like someone else's number.

Not wanting to give out your number, battered women and witness protection have no need to change their caller-ID to the number for Dominoes Pizza or the LAPD, FBI, IRS (and so on). Caller-ID spoofing is technically fraud.



(Legitimate numbers assigned to companies (offices / hotels) so that all outbound calls say "Marriot Hotel" and display the main phone number has nothing to do with caller-ID spoofing.)
you do understand you can spoof absolutely any 10 digit number right? if you spoof a number that is not used by anyone, how is it any different from using a call block? in fact call blocking is less secure. have you heard of caller id block unmasking? i use it. the only way people can remain anonymous to me is to actually spoof their number. and as i said, if you spoof your number to one that is not in service, where is the fraudulent activity occurring?
 
Not wanting to give out your personal information? Seems legit enough to me :eek:

Umm... so you will be anonymous to the reciever, you will strike up a conversation without mentioning names or numbers.


Really?


Usually when you call the person that person knows you, unless if you are trying to sell something, spam, or do something else that the receiver does not want.
 
i invite you to call me steve, with a *67 legitimate use call block at my personal number of 443-839-8339. then you will see the benefits of caller id spoofing versus caller id blocking. My name is John by the way.
 
Legitimate use?
How about a business that has mutiple phone lines, and wants all outbound calls to "appear" to come from the main number? Otherwise the outbound calls would have random ID numbers and the customers wouldn't know who is calling!

I have dual T-1 lines (46 lines) comming into the office phone system. there are 8 phone numbers and block of 100 DID numbers forwarded the the numbers assigned to the T-1 line. Customers need to see the official published main number, not the number assigned by the phone company to the T-1 line when someone in the office make a call.

Exactly. I used to install Avaya PBX's and we had to "spoof" caller-ID to reflect the main line's number on virtually every install.
 
Spoofing is when the caller changes the outbound ID to one different than that configured by the telco. What you described above is how your lines should be as part of your telco service.

Should be... but isn't. Multiple T1's or analog lines will have their own individual numbers, as would separate DID's, but as a company you may only want to broadcast your main line. The phone company does not orchestrate this. The "spoof" is programmed into the PBX. For example, on an IP Office, you would set up your dial 9 short code to "9 = #S3055551212 where "303-555-1212" is the number that will be sent back as caller ID information to the person being called. What ISN'T set up on the PBX and what IS dependant on your phone company is what text is displayed when "305-555-1212" is sent back from the PBX. But once the phone company sees the digits being sent back for caller ID info, a basic cross-reference is done and the number is matched up with the appropriate text on record with the phone company.
 
My question is this…what is a legitimate use for caller-ID spoofing? Can anyone think of a legit use?

We support for several call centers at work, both inbound and outbound. For several of the outbound setups, they're doing customer satisfaction surveys and whatnot for company X. In this case we spoof their outgoing number to be that of (depending upon which campaign):
- The primary switchboard of company X
- The customer support hotline of company X run by callcenter B (which we don't support).

Additionally for our service desk operations, we have several white-label support contracts. We are based in Germany, but we're spoofing several UK numbers, inbound there is a genuine UK number thats routed to us.
 
What I meant but forgot to say was: In germany this has to be specifically enabled by the telephony provider, otherwise they overwrite whatever is sent out with the correct number. The same goes for caller ID blocking.

These features are generally then only available for corporate customers.
 
I don't answer any calls if they don't have a name and number, which included telemarketer and "private name private number"(which includes the mother in-law) , i pay for caller ID dammit., im entitled to know whos calling me before i pick up


lately it been 00000000000 calling my cell, bastards, they know its illegal to call a mobile # for any type of telemarketing so they hide it, so annoying.
 
Umm... so you will be anonymous to the reciever, you will strike up a conversation without mentioning names or numbers.


Really?


Usually when you call the person that person knows you, unless if you are trying to sell something, spam, or do something else that the receiver does not want.

ROFL, that was funny. I just dropped in on this page, seen that, and started laughing my ass off.
 
We use caller ID spoofing at my work.

It forwards extensions as the number dialed to certain cell phones.

i.e. if someone on my helpdesk calls my cell phone, our system spoofs the number to be the extension of the person that called (eg. 388), so that I can tell who is calling me.

Rather useful, as I can tell if it's the CEO or a helpdesk goon, when I'm meeting with clients, and decide to take the call or not.

FWIW, we only spoof to a limited set of numbers (management cell phones).
 
lately it been 00000000000 calling my cell, bastards, they know its illegal to call a mobile # for any type of telemarketing so they hide it, so annoying.

I've had that once. Isn't it Skype-out or something that gives zeros for caller ID?
 
I actually program PBX units, and there is a use for it.

I have a customer that wanted to forward calls to his cell, well simple forwarding doesn't send the orginal callers caller id with the call. So we use a code for the PBX to "spoof" the caller is to transmit the callers caller id, instead of the one of the PBX.
 
as some seem to like to argue over legitimate use of changing the caller ID, its fine if its coming back to you or to the companly

what the main topic was talking about is illegal use of it Not legal use,
e.g. telemarketing fake number or get an Friend in trouble by using there caller ID, or showing an Shop caller ID to place blame somewhere els

caller ID spoofing should not be alowed (like Germany) only for companys and even then it has to be to an legal number and should be get an masive fine and have there lines cut off for 1 week, second time jail time and company close

any calls from International or other Fraud places should be blocked unless you Opt in to recive Internationale calls or at least get an warning before thay connect you, as the phone companys can block them as there system knows where it has come from
 
That blind kid that got himself sent to prison for “swatting” has renewed the debate over caller-ID spoofing. My question is this…what is a legitimate use for caller-ID spoofing? Can anyone think of a legit use?

That's pretty easy:

You have a customer service or tech support call center. These people may call customers back to help with some issue. You may not want customers to call back the line that that person is on (in some cases, they may be incapable of receiving direct calls), so you show a central line (often an 800 number).
 
as some seem to like to argue over legitimate use of changing the caller ID, its fine if its coming back to you or to the companly

what the main topic was talking about is illegal use of it Not legal use,
e.g. telemarketing fake number or get an Friend in trouble by using there caller ID, or showing an Shop caller ID to place blame somewhere els

caller ID spoofing should not be alowed (like Germany) only for companys and even then it has to be to an legal number and should be get an masive fine and have there lines cut off for 1 week, second time jail time and company close

any calls from International or other Fraud places should be blocked unless you Opt in to recive Internationale calls or at least get an warning before thay connect you, as the phone companys can block them as there system knows where it has come from

Well the main topic did have a question at the end. Can anyone think of a legal use? That's why there are a wide variety of statements
 
About a year ago my frien jailbreaked his IPhone and had a program that did caller id spoofing, I called my friends Cell Phone using his own cell phone number, I mean if your cell phone rang and you saw your own cell phone number calling yourself wouldnt that seem wierd. So my friend Jon answered the phone and he says, " Hello who is this?" and i replied, trying to disguise my voice with a horrible tone " Jon this Jon from the future, im calling you warn you about your girlfriend she is gonna try to kill you!" he just kept saying over and over again who is this!. Well i hung up because i was laughing so hard and he called me on his landline about 10 minutes later and told me the story, I told him maybe it was true and that i believed his story. We called him a couple of more times before we showed him what we did and he wasnt very amused lol!
 
Back
Top