Bing Provides ‘Overall Superior Experience’ to Google, Study

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
The Catalyst Group conducted a small case study and found that Microsoft’s Bing search engine beat Google in design and search results. However, user loyalty will be a huge obstacle for MS to overcome as respondents said that they would still use Google over Bing due to familiarity and use of other Google products.

“Bing generates interest, but it's hard to take me away from Google because I’m so comfortable with it," the subjects who chose Google told Catalyst researchers. “The differences are very small [between the two search engines]. They’re too small for me to switch to Bing.”
 
Also, I have icons and add-ons for Google Maps, Google Earth, and Google Preview, as well as my Google Toolbar built right into Firefox. Why do I want to change to lose functionality?
 
Plus, being on 56k (with no option for high speed where I live) Bing is SLOOOWWW.
 
Plus, being on 56k (with no option for high speed where I live) Bing is SLOOOWWW.

:rolleyes:

Google would be SLOOOOWWWW on that connection as well.

The only major difference of loading times is that Bing's homepage has a nice looking background on it, whereas Google's is pretty simple.

Compared to any other website on the Web though, Bing is still pretty freaking simple.
 
Also, I have icons and add-ons for Google Maps, Google Earth, and Google Preview, as well as my Google Toolbar built right into Firefox. Why do I want to change to lose functionality?

I'm sure Microsoft would release something if interest picks up.

Right now you've just got Windows Live and MSN toolbar. IMO that's hurting them, too many brand names. Combine Windows Live and MSN together and just stick everything under BING, much more success.

MSN.com needs to auto-route to BING.com too.
 
:rolleyes:

Google would be SLOOOOWWWW on that connection as well.

The only major difference of loading times is that Bing's homepage has a nice looking background on it, whereas Google's is pretty simple.

Compared to any other website on the Web though, Bing is still pretty freaking simple.

Bing loads pictures and diffeerent elements where as google loads a dialog box and no background. I imagine on 56k the difference could be pretty damn big.
 
I remember when Yahoo was "the biggest and best too".

Then they decided to use this technology from a small startup called Google, it would help make Yahoo searches more accurate.

Lets just say, that didn't quite work according to plan for Yahoo ;)
 
It sucks when a company has the finances to do everything better than everyone else aka Microsoft This is why laws were implemented to prevent monoplizing and i'm sure the hammer will be brought down on MS eventually. Fair or not I do not know but it just goes to show when a company just decides to rest on thier laurels and stagnates for a bit someone can and will come along and 1up them.
 
I've been trying out bing since it went live, and I generally think it's as good as google. Sometimes Google gives a list of site, but most of the time they're identical. For media, I find that bing is easier to use, and their travel interface (copied or not) is excellent.

I still use pricegrabber for shopping, most of the time, but if you get right down to it, it makes sense to use bing, because they pay you to shop through them.
 
Bing loads pictures and diffeerent elements where as google loads a dialog box and no background. I imagine on 56k the difference could be pretty damn big.

Wait... searching for images results in big pages???

News to me.
 
Just search for "H" and see which one does not suck. :)
 
Wait... searching for images results in big pages???

News to me.

What? How about you actually look at the sites before saying anything else stupid? Google has a plain background with nothing going on Bing has images to load as well as javascript.

It may be simple compared to other sites but compared to google its not even close. You cant really get simpler than google.
 
ok test run #1 tried to search for 17-40mm canon lens. Only gave me shopping results. all not what I was looking for. oh well, back to google better luck next time bing.
 
i like how i can just enter regular everday needs like "47oz in pounds" and google just does it, no searching for conversions needed. bing does some conversions, but they have a long way to go in that area.
 
OMG yea! It was SO like *totally* haaaaaaaaaaard to like install the Bing search thingy in my Firefox. :rolleyes: Been using it great since launch, I still use Google sometimes too as it's hardcore keyword driven engine works well in some instances. Why can't you simply use both? Geez! Damn kids these days and their single search engine mentality. When I was kid we had 10 different search engines and you had to search each one by hand in a separate browser window while walking 10 miles uphill in the snow!

The Bing search thingy:
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/10434
 
What? How about you actually look at the sites before saying anything else stupid? Google has a plain background with nothing going on Bing has images to load as well as javascript.

It may be simple compared to other sites but compared to google its not even close. You cant really get simpler than google.
Bing has a shitload more functionality than Google, too...

I guess it's a personal preference, but it's not extra bloat for the heck of it, either.

ok test run #1 tried to search for 17-40mm canon lens. Only gave me shopping results. all not what I was looking for. oh well, back to google better luck next time bing.
Yea, Bing does that like ALL THE TIME for me.
Wait a minute, it doesn't:
3667405148_db6a7a4b36.jpg


i like how i can just enter regular everday needs like "47oz in pounds" and google just does it, no searching for conversions needed. bing does some conversions, but they have a long way to go in that area.
Yea... Bing can't do stuff like that.
Wait a minute, it can:
3666599321_6afa97c2e3.jpg



Seriously, people. I understand if you like Google for personal preference, but some fanboyish blindness is just ridiculous.
 
Bing has a shitload more functionality than Google, too...

Dont recall saying it didnt.

I guess it's a personal preference, but it's not extra bloat for the heck of it, either.

According to you a couple posts ago that "bloat" didnt exist and it was sooo simple, make your mind up already. Personal preference and functionality have absolutely nothing to do with what you where arguing, someone said its slower than google on 56k and you argued against it.

Seriously, people. I understand if you like Google for personal preference, but some fanboyish blindness is just ridiculous.

Same can be said to you :rolleyes: You dont have to blindly jump in head first and argue every little damn thing that is even remotely negative about bing.
 
Seriously, people. I understand if you like Google for personal preference, but some fanboyish blindness is just ridiculous.

chill... chill......... i said googles is better, i didnt say bing cant do any conversions. there has been a few times already where i had google convert things bing didnt.
 
OMG yea! It was SO like *totally* haaaaaaaaaaard to like install the Bing search thingy in my Firefox. :rolleyes: Been using it great since launch, I still use Google sometimes too as it's hardcore keyword driven engine works well in some instances. Why can't you simply use both? Geez! Damn kids these days and their single search engine mentality. When I was kid we had 10 different search engines and you had to search each one by hand in a separate browser window while walking 10 miles uphill in the snow!

no, when we were kids we had 10 and we used spider search engines to scan all 10 at once with every result on a single page:D
 
I'm sure Microsoft would release something if interest picks up.

Right now you've just got Windows Live and MSN toolbar. IMO that's hurting them, too many brand names. Combine Windows Live and MSN together and just stick everything under BING, much more success.

MSN.com needs to auto-route to BING.com too.

I think you will see a lot of rebranding in the coming months. They have already moved a lot of the MSN services under live and now a lot of the live services under Bing.

Overall I think once they get there it will be good. MS has always had a tough time keeping things separate yet together...it is a fine balance and not easy to do in a HUGE company like MS with tons of different divisions (remember they are run separately in many cases).
 
google wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

craigslist wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

stop making shit pretty. it wastes bandwidth and taxes cpu a little more
 
Bing is a fine search engine. It's set as my default search engine now and it's finding useful hits I'd say about 90%+ of the time. Just a swag on my part but for general searching it's easily on par with Google.

But guess what; if I don't find a useful hit on Bing, I just do a Google, Yahoo, or other search. Why would anyone limit themselves to one search engine? That's dumb.

At any rate, I want Bing to do well because it raises the bar for everyone and makes Google do new and better things. It’s called competition and that's usually a good thing for most people.
 
I know it's a joke, but I think your search is irrelevant. I would never search for this website by entering H, and only H or just "hard."

However, I might search for Hard computer, hard tech, hard overclock, hard review and so on, and none of those turn up on bing (hard tech, as well has hard computer don't work on either).

IMO, it really looks like MS is either not looking at this site or Google turns up these hits, because it's got a decade of user input.

No doubt, however, Google is sometimes better, but I do like Bing's interface and I think it's a dramatic improvement over live search, which I thought was awful (so bad that I'd search for solutions to Windows problems and still got better results on Google, which was fucking pathetic).

I like Google, but for now I talk to Chandler before Google.


Just did a search on the terms "hard overclock". These are the first two hits

http://www.hardoverclock.com/
http://www.hardforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2
 
google wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

craigslist wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

stop making shit pretty. it wastes bandwidth and taxes cpu a little more

Yes, and bing has become very simplified compared to the other versions of live/MSN search plus it is much simpler than other search engines like Yahoo IMO.

It actually loads very quickly, search results are quick as are page loads.
 
I really like Bing. It's got some very nice features. I enjoy the image search, and the video is neat being that you can play video via rollover.
 
Same can be said to you :rolleyes: You dont have to blindly jump in head first and argue every little damn thing that is even remotely negative about bing.
There's nothing wrong with him weeding out BS post and proving people wrong who are obviously trolling against bing.
I know it's a joke, but I think your search is irrelevant. I would never search for this website by entering H, and only H or just "hard."
I agree with you here. Google just handles miss spellings differently than bing does. Typing in 'Hard' is a miss spelling for this site.
 
Your on the spanish version, search in spanish and it works fine :rolleyes:

47 oz en libra

Uhm, no. I'm using the Portuguese version since I'm Portuguese and that's what it says in the screenshot. Please learn to read before calling someone dumb, ok?

Like I said, it works but not for me.
 
According to you a couple posts ago that "bloat" didnt exist and it was sooo simple, make your mind up already.
How about disclosing all information first?
I was just assuming you meant their web results, as that's what most everyone uses.

Same can be said to you :rolleyes: You dont have to blindly jump in head first and argue every little damn thing that is even remotely negative about bing.
Sorry, but you make a bullshit claim that isn't true, I have every right to refute that.

google wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

craigslist wins because it keeps it simple stupid.

stop making shit pretty. it wastes bandwidth and taxes cpu a little more
If everything followed your belief system, we'd still be using DOS.

Must be an American thing
Looks like it. But to be fair, how your originally stated it (in English), works perfectly fine...
 
There's nothing wrong with him weeding out BS post and proving people wrong who are obviously trolling against bing.
I agree with you here. Google just handles miss spellings differently than bing does. Typing in 'Hard' is a miss spelling for this site.

Techie is very sensitive to any MS criticism. I, more of then that not, defend MS, but Techie has jumped on me and others for minor quibbles and in one case he jumped down my throat because I dared to mention that one of those Laptop hunter commercials was filmed in a Fry's (as if that was some how a slight against MS).
 
Techie is very sensitive to any MS criticism. I, more of then that not, defend MS, but Techie has jumped on me and others for minor quibbles and in one case he jumped down my throat because I dared to mention that one of those Laptop hunter commercials was filmed in a Fry's (as if that was some how a slight against MS).

some people just need more pussy... it might not be their fault it could be their womans..... ahem....
 
while bing and google fight for search engine market share, ultimately, google will prevail due to end user familiarity and usage, unless bing does something outstanding to set themselves apart.

They're losing a key demographic as time goes on.
 
How about disclosing all information first?
I was just assuming you meant their web results, as that's what most everyone uses.

I didnt make the claim to begin with but either way. Didnt say it was just the main page either.

Sorry, but you make a bullshit claim that isn't true, I have every right to refute that.

It is true and your wrong plain and simple but because you think im dogging on your precious you are blindly jumping to its defense.
 
Uhm, no. I'm using the Portuguese version since I'm Portuguese and that's what it says in the screenshot. Please learn to read before calling someone dumb, ok?

Like I said, it works but not for me.

Sorry, I didnt call you dumb, I was just saying you should try it in your native language.

Spanish is also similar to portuguese, so my bad for not reading the line under the search box......
 
Back
Top