PCP&C reliability issues: fact or fiction?

Status
Not open for further replies.

fsh42na

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Messages
1,472
I know that I shouldn't believe the reviews at the Egg, but there does seem to be a disturbing trend regarding DOA's being reported on the popular; forever on sale Quad 750. What are your recent experiences with these power supplies? I trust the feedback/ experiences of [H] members infinitely more than the Eggers.

Thanks
 
Don't know bout the new stuff
But their customer service is dang good!
Had the smoke come outta my 4 yr 11 month old 510
filled out the RMA stuff
even E'd a very nice person at PCP&C
She got back fast
Had new smoke put in
and it's workng fine
The whole turn around time was about 3 weeks!
 
I'm using the Silencer 750 in my WHS - no drama. Also 3 Silencer 370s in various lighter computers. An old Silencer 510 and Silencer 470 are also still chugging along w/o issues, and I have no idea how old they are. Most likely 4+ years.

PCP&C offers some well built stuff that lasts.
 
Going strong for about a year so far,no issues.Check sig.
 
I bought a Quad 750 Red Edition from NCIX and the PSu was overheating and the fan was not starting to spin. The Computer shut down by itself under heavy use.

Started a RMA and managed to find out the fan header was not connected I saw the wire loose inside. I managed to puld it on the header without opening the PSU with tweezers run great now so I cancelled the RMA.
 
Thanks for the replies people:D Thus far the "DOA" reports appear to be overblown. I think I'm gonna go shopping at ZZF before they sell out:cool:
 
I usually don't trust Newegg reviews, but a DOA psu is different, not much "expertise" needed to plug in a psu to see if it works, I noticed the same trend months ago and from googling it seemed like most people commenting (not just from Newegg) were guessing that OCZ's QC standards may not have been as stringent as PCP&C's, I don't know if that has changed recently, but months ago (4 or 5?) it seemed that 2 or 3 out of every 5 Newegg reviews on that psu (750w) were DOAs (especially the red model)...
 
I just had my 2nd Corsair PSU go bad on me. I had a Silencer 750 in a prev build for over a year before I sold it and no issues. Not saying Corsair is bad, but there's bad PSU's with every manufacture.
 
I've had my Silencer 750 for about 1 1/2 years, with no problems at all. Extremely stable.
 
How's the noise level when one of these gets up to load? I'm getting read to order but that one difference (vs the Corsairs) is holding me back.
 
Well I can't hear mine ever. Of course I have 6 fans 7 hard drives a GTX 295 and a 8800GTX plus I play with headphones on so...

But I never heard it spin up on loads.

When I first got it I saw that the fan was not spinning but I tought it would spin up on temp raise... I was wrong and the fan was not connected hehe. But ever since I connected it I didn't notice any difference in noise, the rest of my rig does more noise I guess.
 
Well I can't hear mine ever. Of course I have 6 fans 7 hard drives a GTX 295 and a 8800GTX plus I play with headphones on so...

But I never heard it spin up on loads.

When I first got it I saw that the fan was not spinning but I tought it would spin up on temp raise... I was wrong and the fan was not connected hehe. But ever since I connected it I didn't notice any difference in noise, the rest of my rig does more noise I guess.
Well, your PC isn't a particularly big load for a 750W PSU, so you're not stressing it enough to get the fan to spin up. If you were running something more hefty like an overclocked i7 with two or three-card SLI/Crossfire, you'd probably get some more action out of the fan.
 
Well, for me that's gonna be a big problem. My primary gaming pc is in the bedroom. My wife typically goes to sleep first so if she can't sleep cuz of the noise, well......................:eek:

Well, it depends how much load you'll be putting on the PSU. Depending on your system specs, even under full load your PC may not draw enough power to make the PSU fan spin up.
 
Well, it depends how much load you'll be putting on the PSU. Depending on your system specs, even under full load your PC may not draw enough power to make the PSU fan spin up.

In my case, it's gonna be the following:

Core I7 920 moderately overclocked
6gb triple channel DDR3
Asus 6T dlx or EVGA X58
EVGA GTX 275
2 DVD burners
4-5 hard drives
assorted case fans
Coolermaster ATX 840 case
 
In my case, it's gonna be the following:

Core I7 920 moderately overclocked
6gb triple channel DDR3
Asus 6T dlx or EVGA X58
EVGA GTX 275
2 DVD burners
4-5 hard drives
assorted case fans
Coolermaster ATX 840 case
That shouldn't be too bad for the Silencer, especially when it's idle.
 
That shouldn't be too bad for the Silencer, especially when it's idle.

Problem is I won't be idling it much while she's asleep:eek:
I'll probably just go with a Corsair TX 850w that I had my eye on all along. It's just that when these deals go past me, I can't help but try to grab them if I can:eek:

Thanks
 
just want to add to the whole discussion: first pcpc i bought was a 510 turbo, i called them to order, when the lady couldnt' answere my questions she transfered me to an engineer who went over it with me and custom tailored my psu for me, they are fucking awesome, i've only used them for every computer i've built since (over 20) and not 1 i've had to rma
 
just got a 750 silencer from ZZF, packaging looked skimpy but the psu works fine and dandy, the 12v ripple is practically non-existent on load.. i love it. havent yet heard the fan, but look at my rig.. i bought this thing for growing into :) sooooooooooo...fiction!
 
just got a 750 silencer from ZZF, packaging looked skimpy but the psu works fine and dandy, the 12v ripple is practically non-existent on load.. i love it. havent yet heard the fan, but look at my rig.. i bought this thing for growing into :) sooooooooooo...fiction!

What type of oscilloscope are you testing with?
 
I just built a PC with the PC P&C 750. Been running for 2 weeks now with absolutely no problems whatsoever. I can't hear the PSU fan at all (if it makes noise, it's drowned out by my CPU and case fans).

Fiction!
 
My 750 silencer was DOA in january, great customer support though. A few days later when my roomate got his it was DOA as well. 2 DOA's to the same house in the same week? I will be sticking with corsair or another descent brand. The RMA process negated the cheap price because I had to pay shipping to get it back to them. O well I know DOAs happen, but 2 to the same house within a few days in not coincidence...
 
I've been using them for about 8 years now with no problems. I currently have a 750 Silencer that works flawlessly and I've recommended them to about 3 or 4 other guys doing builds and they love it. I called their tech support one time and was transferred to an engineer who answered my questions and asked if I needed any special connectors. I didn't but I won't buy another brand of power supply unless things like this change.
 
I know that I shouldn't believe the reviews at the Egg, but there does seem to be a disturbing trend regarding DOA's being reported on the popular; forever on sale Quad 750. What are your recent experiences with these power supplies? I trust the feedback/ experiences of [H] members infinitely more than the Eggers.

Thanks

My friend/room mate is using either a Quad 750 or silencer 750 for the last 8 months without any issue what so ever. I would say to go for it.
 
i have been using one for over a year now and no problems and i can't hear it over the system.

 
i have two silencer 750 units and 510 unit in different rigs and have never had a problem with any of them. all 3 function flawlessly. my oldest 750 silencer is of the original color of bronze. that should tell you how old it is. the 510 is older yet and has never given me any issues. based on my experience, i highly recommend PCP&C units to any all of my clients. not all go for it but most do. the ones who don't want modular. i'm replacing my oldest silencer with a corsair hx850 this week solely because i want a modular. the silencer will be going into my daughter's rig.
 
Over a year now with the red 750 and no problems, it is fairly quite as well, hard to tell though because of the fans in my case, ran with the current rig in the sig for a while with crossfire 4850s, not too demanding on a 750 but getting there. In my mind a hollywood, based on a true story movie(ie fiction with a hint of truth)
 
Hey guys, since the PC Power techs aren't signed up here, I want to let you what was going on with DOA's back in January or so. There was a small percentage of the 750w units in one batch that tested fine when they were assembled, but had a problem. Apparently there was one specific component (can't remember which) that had a less than perfect solder job. So, when the units were tossed around during shipping it would break loose, causing a DOA. It was a random thing, and most the units sold were just fine. The quality department jumped on it and inspected the remaining units we had in stock. The problem was fixed, and they want to aplogize to anyone that went through the inconvenience.

I used to live close to PC Power and spent some time there before the OCZ purchase and visited recently as well. They are still in the same building, and have the same workers, engineering and management staff, just like "the old days". They added a new support tech and automated some of their paperwork and that's about it. Honestly, not much has changed there at all, including their quality and testing procedures. They still develop new products the same way and truly care about the PC Power brand and the quality of the units that they sell.
 
there was one specific component (can't remember which) that had a less than perfect solder job. So, when the units were tossed around during shipping it would break loose, causing a DOA. It was a random thing, and most the units sold were just fine. The quality department jumped on it and inspected the remaining units we had in stock.

i suspected as much. thanks for the explanation. when you're mass-producing electronic components, something is bound to go wrong SOMETIME.. i honestly cant believe the fuss thats been made regarding this issue though tbh..
 
i suspected as much. thanks for the explanation. when you're mass-producing electronic components, something is bound to go wrong SOMETIME.. i honestly cant believe the fuss thats been made regarding this issue though tbh..
We understand the concern and just wanted to be up front about it since the subject came up. And yes, things do happen and being on top of the problem is key to keep things from getting out of hand.
 
Silencer 610 in my home machine going strong for 3 years. I've wanted a PC Power and Cooling PSU for years and always had Thermaltake before that. No complaints.
 
ok no you're right zero, voltage fluctuation != ripple. foot = in mouth. my point is that such miniscule voltage variation measured yes even in software, under stressful conditions, is indicative of a solid rail. im not saying its DEVOID of variation, thats impossible. im saying its very controlled variation.
 
my point is that such miniscule voltage variation measured yes even in software, under stressful conditions, is indicative of a solid rail.
Wrong again. Power coming from the PSU runs through a lot of circuitry before it hits the Winbond chip that records the voltages, and even ignoring the (considerable) inaccuracy of the chip itself, there will certainly be major differences between the power stability measured at that point and the power that is being supplied directly from the PSU.
im not saying its DEVOID of variation, thats impossible. im saying its very controlled variation.
If the variation was truly controlled, then it wouldn't exist. There is absolutely no reason to purposefully introduce controlled voltage fluctuations into a PSU's power output.
 
Power coming from the PSU runs through a lot of circuitry before it hits the Winbond chip that records the voltages, and even ignoring the (considerable) inaccuracy of the chip itself, there will certainly be major differences between the power stability measured at that point and the power that is being supplied directly from the PSU.

i know. im not ignoring that fact. you're acting like i am.

If the variation was truly controlled, then it wouldn't exist. There is absolutely no reason to purposefully introduce controlled voltage fluctuations into a PSU's power output.

thats not even what i said. you're just purposely misconstruing my meaning to twist my words. jesus, i said i was wrong with my earlier statement about ripple, im not wrong in saying that you can extrapolate an APPROXIMATION of a rails stability by monitoring voltages through a multimeter and software. jesus christ, is it pick on hollywood day or something?
 
Last edited:
i know. im not ignoring that fact. you're acting like i am.
You are ignoring that fact, because if you weren't, you'd consider the fact that many of the fluctuations in the voltages are filtered out by the board's power regulation circuitry, so even if a program like OCCT reports stellar voltage regulation, the voltages may actually be fluctuating wildly.
thats not even what i said. you're just purposely misconstruing my meaning to twist my words.
No, I replied to what you said. If you meant something different, then you should have used a different choice of words.
im not wrong in saying that you can extrapolate an APPROXIMATION of a rails stability by monitoring voltages through a multimeter and software.
Yes, you are wrong in saying that you can approximate the stability of a rail through software monitoring. And while it is true that you can determine the quality of a rail's voltage regulation with a multimeter, that is not what you said before. You clearly specified that you were talking about software voltage readings and not readings from a multimeter.
jesus christ, is it pick on hollywood day or something?
No, it's "correct the inaccurate statements of misinformed posters" day.
 
Yes, you are wrong in saying that you can approximate the stability of a rail through software monitoring. And while it is true that you can determine the quality of a rail's voltage regulation with a multimeter, that is not what you said before. You clearly specified that you were talking about software voltage readings and not readings from a multimeter.

in my now-edited-out post, and even in a post of YOUR OWN that quoted mine and got deleted, i mentioned measuring voltage variation with a multimeter as well as through software. you're saying things that arent true and attributing them to me (somehow) after i made one obvious mistake.

oh, and no board i know of "reports stellar voltage regulation" when the PSU itself is "actually fluctuating wildly". in sane-world where rational people live and things make sense, the fluctuations of a decent PSU measured by any halfway decent mobo, sensor, and software are APPROXIMATELY corollary and are slightly tempered versions of the actual variation. granted, with shit hardware, the case could be very different; this isnt the case here.

you arent "correcting" anything anymore, you're just going wayyyyyy out of your way to try to pick at what im saying. lay off.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top