Microsoft's Project Natal In Action

I wonder if it would have been more beneficial to launch this with their next console.

Nintendo did a very smart thing with the Wii and its controller. The device was actually an optional peripheral designed for the Gamecube, not the Wii. Instead of launching it that way, they designed the next console around the motion controller concept.

Can you imagine what a colossal flop that sort of addon for the Gamecube would have been? It would have been considered an optional toy, and that's it. Nintendo took the other road and basically created a license to print money.

Launching it with a new console did two things. It obviously helped to build up hype that the Wii was an entirely new concept in console control and design, but most importantly it forced all developers to conform to this new interface and design their games around it. Most add-on type products like the Eye-Toy, etc, can be fun distractions but they don't sell enough to get a decent number of games behind them. Every game on the Wii has to at least take the motion and IR sensors into account before going to more conventional control schemes with the Classic controller.

Anyway, I'm interested to see how this shakes out. I'm honestly surprised to see Microsoft launch something like this so late in the game, assuming that they're going to squeeze another two or three years out of the 360 before rolling out their next console.
 
Anyway, I'm interested to see how this shakes out. I'm honestly surprised to see Microsoft launch something like this so late in the game, assuming that they're going to squeeze another two or three years out of the 360 before rolling out their next console.
Why wouldn't it be directly usable by the next-gen system?
 
Why wouldn't it be directly usable by the next-gen system?

The point of my post is that the technology would be more widely accepted by audiences and developers if it was a standard part of a new console. I'm more interested in seeing it as included with whatever the next XBox is. That would be the same successful strategy Nintendo used, and it would be pretty mindblowing technology for everyone to have out of the box.
 
Why wouldn't it be directly usable by the next-gen system?

Microsoft has already said there is not going to be another Xbox for at least a couple years (I want to say 2012...).

I think a new revision of hardware would actually be able to improve on this a bit too...
 
If I want to move I go outside...I am all for tech, but this will never be for me.
 
The point of my post is that the technology would be more widely accepted by audiences and developers if it was a standard part of a new console. I'm more interested in seeing it as included with whatever the next XBox is. That would be the same successful strategy Nintendo used, and it would be pretty mindblowing technology for everyone to have out of the box.
This allows developers to experiment with it and get used to programming for it a few years in advance.
 
..Just like how all the Xbox games were "directly usable" on the 360? :rolleyes: :p

This is a hardware feature. It's like saying they wouldn't use wireless controllers next gen, or that sony wouldn't use blu ray.
 
I actually liked Sony's wand more. I know pedos are going hog wild about being able to play games with the their very own virtual boy. But the wand looked like more fun to me, Harry Potter game anyone or Star Wars light saber dual?
 
I actually liked Sony's wand more. I know pedos are going hog wild about being able to play games with the their very own virtual boy. But the wand looked like more fun to me, Harry Potter game anyone or Star Wars light saber dual?

Yeah. While Natal's body detection tech and voice recognition are very cool, the Sony prototype actually demonstrated greater precision and utility than anything Nintendo or Microsoft has shown.

A combination of Natal and Sony's tech would be pretty awesome. :)
 
Waiting on Japan to make a rape simulation game using this technology.
 
+1 for Sony wand >> Natal.

I don't know how anybody can see this. I mean it's a knockoff of the Wiimote, but a more accurate design (Something Nintendo should've designed from the start, to be sure).

Natal is something brand new and freaking awesome. Obviously Microsoft isn't just wanting this to do games, but rather make it friendly for the whole family from everthing from movies to video chatting... With no battery-driven stick needed to work it.
 
While I admit the concept is cool and it would be great for certain games...but...


I play video games to relax and DO nothing. I am by no means out of shape or fat. But it would be a huge inconvenience if I had to flail around like a bumbling idiot to 'relax'.

ya i agree, lazy on couch = win

also i dont want a console with a camera pointed at me, that freaks me out
 
HAHA yeah right, it takes loads of engineering effort to get basic head tracking on the PC working smoothly, much less context sensitive full body capture in a way thats smooth and responsive.

Add to that, most people just flail about with the Wii controller to get the desired results rather than doing anything accurately, I think this is just something for MS to monopolise on the what made the Wii popular, only it looks like it will completely fail.

Another vote for I'll believe it when I play it.
 
I believe this will be huge, it will have lot more applications than gaming.
 
meh, when I can feel the guy punching/kicking/shooting me back that is when I will get something like this, or I guess I could just go to Chicago or something.
 
Add to that, most people just flail about with the Wii controller to get the desired results rather than doing anything accurately, I think this is just something for MS to monopolise on the what made the Wii popular, only it looks like it will completely fail.

Another vote for I'll believe it when I play it.

I could sit on the couch and just flick my wrist around with the Wii.... So I'm basically cheating the system.

With Natal I can't do that ;)

It also seems NOBODY reads the comments about how well it performs. Go read Gizmodo, they have a good writeup. They said they've never been as impressed with a demo as this before, and it performs as advertised.
 
Back
Top