Build a Gaming PC for $1,900

KapsZ28

2[H]4U
Joined
May 29, 2009
Messages
2,114
The budget is very strict. It can't be more than $1,900 total. And it MUST use an Intel i7 CPU. The computer should be easy to expand on, and also overclock. Basically, the computer should be ready for the future and won't be completely obsolete 4 months from now. It must also use Windows Vista which is part of the price.

This is what I came up with.

Case: Antec Nine Hundred
Motherboard: Asus P6T Deluxe V2
CPU: Intel Core i7 920 with Noctua CPU Cooler
Memory: Corsair Dominator 6GB DDR3 1600 Triple Channel
Video Card: PNY GeForce GTX 295
Hard Drives: 2 WD Black 500GB RAID 0 and 1TB WD Black
Optical Drive: Plextor and Samsung DVD Burners
Power Supply: Tuniq 1000 watts
OS: Windows Vista Home Edition 64-bit

The premise of this gaming PC is to be as fast as possible for the money. Something that will achieve the highest frames per second when gaming, but also run everyday applications and programs such as Photoshop. Storage is also important. 1TB is fine, but more would be nice.

What would you build or change in the configuration I listed above to improve it?
 
Last edited:
No need for a 1tb black unless you need MAX speed for storage. I would consider maybe 12gb of ram with it, and maybe just a 285 for now and wait keep extra money to update to the next gen when they're out. I don't think the 295 is worth the premium. But if you need that power now (have a 30" screen or the like) then go with it.
 
The 1TB black was only like $95 plus it comes with a copy of Acronis True Image Home. I was looking at the 285, but it is still quite a bit behind the 295 until you add 2 or 3 285's, but then the price goes up.

As far as gaming, it will be used all the way up to 2560x2100 resolution.
 
With that budget, and the possibility of a 24 to 30 inch screen, why not go sli? I would think that would benefit him more than another 6 gigs of ram.
 
Please answer the questions in this thread so that we can help you better:
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1349433

Changes I would make:
- Drop the Antec 900 and go with the Coolermater RC-690 case. The Coolermaster RC-690 cools just as well as the Antec 900 while being more roomier. So the RC-690 case is a much better case for the money. You can clearly see how cramped the Antec 900 would be compared to the RC-690 here (the Antec 900 shares similar dimensions ot the Antec 900 Two):
http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1034082083&postcount=53
- Ditch the Dominator RAM. It's overpriced for what it offers. You would honestly not notice a difference in real world apps and games between that Dominator RAM and this well recommended G.Skill set:
$95 - G.Skill F3-12800CL9T-6GBNQ 3 x 2GB DDR3 1600 RAM
- For just $10 more, you can get much larger and slightly faster drives for RAID 0:
$75 - Western Digital WD6401AALS 640GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive
- PSU wise, ditch the Tuniq and go with these significantly better quality Corsair 850TX or Corsair 1000HX:
$135 - Corsair 850TX 850W PSU
$240 - Corsair 1000HX Modular PSU

Can't comment any further until you answer the questions from the link above.

EDIT: Oh and definitely get 12GB of RAM if the user is a heavy user of photoshop for a RAMDisk:
[RAM Disk]
In other words, as I said, the cost of the devices + the cost of populating them becomes absolutely ridiculous. Grab two Velociraptors and have fun... or even a handful of SSD drives and RAID 'em together. The overall price-to-performance ratio will blow these iRAM devices clear off the planet surface...

Sad, really, because I've been a proponent of actual RAMdisks for decades now. Hell, I used to boot my Amiga 500 off a RAMdisk, so I've seen pretty much every attempt at making such devices as the iRAM that have appeared, and they all suck, period. They just can't do the job adequately and keep the price-to-performance ratio anywhere near a reasonable level.

I built a RAID 0 box for a small image studio 2 weeks ago, a new startup here in Vegas that is making waves. They wanted a "demo" workstation to see what's possible for processing as they don't want to create a massive server-type situation in the office, but 3-4 workstations that are equal in performance and then just using simple file sharing as required. Very simple setup in terms of the network, but the workstation I built used 2 300GB Velociraptors (tried to sell 'em on SSD but the amount of data they're dealing with wouldn't be practical - again, a price-to-performance and ROI issue).

The hard part was getting them to spring for 16GB of RAM because of the cost, but a few weeks ago I saw that sale for 4 4GB sticks of RAM for about $450 and made a few phone calls and snagged a similar deal.

I set up Photoshop CS3 for 'em (their legit retail copy) on Vista Business x64. They started messing around with it, loading some rather large TIFF files in excess of 150MB a pop, several at a time, performing some basic scripted actions on 'em, blurs, filters, etc. Using the Velociraptors in RAID 0 meant very snappy and consistent performance, as well as having 16GB of RAM too. Also, it's a Q6600 based machine running rock solid at 3 GHz.

They were very pleased with the performance at that point, but I had a surprise for 'em. ;)

I asked if I could have 20 mins 'alone' with the workstation to "rewire it" as Tim Allen might say. That consisted of grabbing a trial version of SuperSpeed Software's RamDisk Plus 9 and installing it, doing the simple configuration, and then creating a 10GB RAMdisk and told Photoshop "Ok, you want a scratch disk? Here, try this on for size."

After I did some tests of my own using the same scripts they'd done earlier, boy... I tell ya. You haven't lived till you see 225MB TIFF files literally snap onscreen in the blink of an eye, multiple huge TIFFs with resolutions like 5000x5000 and even higher. That's what's possible with RAMdisks, because even Velociraptors in RAID 0 pumping out something like 280MB/s sustained pales to the close to 5GB a second in bandwidth of that RAMdisk.

I told 'em to come back in and rerun their test scripts.

Jaws hit the floor, folks. Well, not quite but figuratively speaking, at least.

They asked what I'd done, I told them I put the scratch disk in RAM where it should be if you have the RAM to make it happen, and they bought 4 licenses of RamDisk Plus 10 mins later, and I got a signed contract to construct 3 more workstations identical to that one top to bottom and also be their "geek" if any issues come up.

It was a very good week... ;)
 
Last edited:
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
The PC is going to be tested by PC World Magazine. They will be using WorldBench 6 for testing the components and the standard games they normally use.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
$1900 - I am tax exempt when buying parts and use distributors although NewEgg has very competitive prices.

3) Where do you live?
NJ

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Must use i7 CPU and X58 motherboard.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
Everything must be brand new.

6) Will you be overclocking?
Very much so. At minimum of 25%.

7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?
Can't say, but the test runs all to 2560x2100 resolution.

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Next week,

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
RAID, Crossfire or SLI

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
Must be purchased and will be Vista Home Premium.
 
You can compare what I am building against this. http://www.pcworld.com/reviews/product/44110/review/core_i7_sli_crossfirex_ddr3_gaming_system.html

They are using a single eVGA GTX 285 graphics card. The 295 will definitely outperform this. They used a single 1TB hard drive. Two 500GB drives in RAID 0 should run faster, should they not?

I picked that PSU because of pricing. The Corsair 1000 was a little over the buget. That could probably be offset if I ditched the 1TB hard drive and just used two 640GB's instead, but I liked the idea of additional storage and having Acronis True Image Home available.

I considered the G.Skill F3-12800CL9T-6GBNQ which is $70 cheaper, but has slower timings and I am not sure if it will overclock better than Corsair. I also liked this artical, http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/cpus/2008/11/06/overclocking-intel-core-i7-920/1, which showed how well the P6T Deluxe, i7 920, and Corsair memory worked together.
 
What about this?

Case: Antec Nine Hundred (Can't change)
Motherboard: Asus P6T Deluxe V2
CPU: Intel Core i7 920 with Noctua CPU Cooler
Memory: G.Skill 6GB DDR3 1600 Triple Channel
Video Card: PNY GeForce GTX 295
Hard Drives: 2 WD Black 640GB RAID 0
Optical Drive:Samsung DVD Burner
Power Supply: PC Power PPCS910 910 watts
OS: Windows Vista Home Edition 64-bit

That would come out to $1,800, which is what my original budget was.
 
Yes two WD Black 500GB HDDs in RAID 0 would perform a single 1TB drive. However two WD Black/Blue 640GB HDDs in RAID 0 will outperfom two WD Black 500GB HDDs in RAID 0. So the extra cost for the 640GB HDDs are worth it.

The lower timings do not matter at all. You would honestly not notice an iota of performance in real world apps and games. Sure the Domininator RAM will get you higher scores in synthetic benchmarks but it's been proven time and time again that there is very very little performance increase with lower timings with current systems. But you got me on the overclocking. I dunnot how well the G.Skill RAM will OC either. Still don't think the Dominators are worth it though.

EDIT: Oh didn't see your updated list. Your updated looks good to me except for the PSU: The Corsair 850TX is a much better buy than the PC P&C 910 since it is $50 less and only has 4A on the +12V less than the PC P&C 910W. IMO, that extra 4A on the +12V rail is not worth the extra $50 for the PC P&C.

How come you can't change the case?
 
I agree with Danny's suggestions.

If you're not running SLI/CF or some crazy HDD array, then there's most likely no need for any PSU above 650W.

Faster timings aren't worth a 79% price increase when performance doesn't improve much. You don't need anything faster than DDR3-1600, so no need to OC RAM, just buy that speed.

If you want fast I/O, get a couple OCZ Vertex SSDs and put them in RAID0.
 
How come you can't change the case?

Everything has already been ordered and not all of it can be refunded. Plus I would hate shipping back a heavy case from NJ to CA. I may also be stuck with the Corsair memory, but if I go with your suggested PSU, it will help offset the price a little bit.

This is probably what I will end up with.

Case: Antec Nine Hundred
Motherboard: Asus P6T Deluxe V2
CPU: Intel Core i7 920 with Noctua CPU Cooler
Memory: Corsair Dominator 6GB DDR3 1600 Triple Channel
Video Card: PNY GeForce GTX 295
Hard Drives: 2 WD Black 640GB RAID 0
Optical Drive:Samsung DVD Burner
Power Supply: Corsair 850TX
OS: Windows Vista Home Edition 64-bit
 
So, how'd you get PC World to review it?

/me wonders if they'll review one of "our" best bang for buck builds and compare it to a more expensive build, hehe. Though, they'd need to limit the res or something, lol, like the popular 1680x1050 or 1920x1200.
 
So, how'd you get PC World to review it?

/me wonders if they'll review one of "our" best bang for buck builds and compare it to a more expensive build, hehe. Though, they'd need to limit the res or something, lol, like the popular 1680x1050 or 1920x1200.

I think their main rule is that you must sell PCs nationally. So, as long as you are selling across the country, they will pretty much review it. They do ask questions about warranty, tech support, etc.

I am mainly doing it for advertising. I am more used to building desktop PCs, servers, HTPCs. I did some gaming systems, but it has been a couple of years and I haven't gotten into the i7s or new graphics cards yet. Last cards I was using were the 8800 GTS and 8800 GTX.
 
According to UPS, I should be receiving everything today. :D

I just hope nothing is DOA. Last time I bought an expensive EVGA mobo, the damn video slots didn't work.

Hopefully UPS will come soon so I can get it setup and run some benchmarks later today.
 
Had to wait all damn day for UPS to arrive. Finally got everything and assembled it. I think routing the cables probably took the longest. Next time I am spending extra on a modular PSU.

Here is a pic. http://www.ectechsupport.com/project/Black_Mamba.jpg

Yes, the name of the PC is Black Mamba.

Bios shows the CPU at 32C and mobo at 35C. I am about to setup the RAID and install the OS. If I actually continue to finish it tonight, I should have some benchmarks later.
 
Actually it is a Noctua fan. I've been trying to come up with a decent name for the system and so far that is all I got.

Black Mamba - Killer Insticts with Incredible Speed

They are the fastest snakes on the planet.
 
So I ran 3DMark Vantage at the default settings and got 21,398. Screenshot below.

http://www.ectechsupport.com/project/3DMark_Vantage.jpg

I am too used to 3DMark06, so I don't really have anything to compare Vantage too. Nothing has been overclocked yet.

I ran a performance test for the hard drives in RAID 0 and the sequential read was 203 mb/s and sequential write was 211 mb/s.

What temperature can the CPU handle? Intel says the thermal specification is 67.9C, but I keep reading that the CPU can go up to 80-90C. Right now I am burning in the system, so the CPU is running at 100% and it is about 62C. The motherboard is only 42C. I guess I won't ever have to worry about the mobo temperature.

I should have more tests later. I will probably try Windows 7 and XP as well. Although I don't feel like digging up a floppy drive just to keep the RAID setup for XP.
 
I overclocked just the video card and ran the fan at 65% and got 23317. I guess it is time to start overclocking the CPU.

3DMark_GPU_OC.jpg
 
Overclocked the CPU to 3.6GHz. Was running Prime95 and the CPU temp stayed around 78C. The mobo never seems to increase. Stays at 38C. I'll have to run some more benchmarks.
 
I don't think anyone is paying attention, but here is the final product.

Black_Mamba2.jpg


I am burning in with SiSoftware Sandra. So far so good. Knock on wood. I can probably overclock it more, but I'll keep it modest for now. An extra 1GHz is good.
 
we were paying attn, and we were also waiting for pics. :p

i have an opinion... that the noctua fans should never be used in cases with windows, lol.
 
Nice PC mark score. The PC's nice too, but the cables are a mess =P

I'm a bit too late, but I agree with what was stated earlier - the corsair dominator gives very little improvement over lower priced memory sticks. Corsair even has other memory that's around $60 less with the exact same statistics; I think the dominator is just easier to overclock, but you wouldn't notice much difference.

Can you get a Crysis benchmark on highest quality? Or any other new games. Would be appreciated. (I'm building a fairly similar system soon)

One more question, can you fit a fan in the little slot behind the hard drives? Or is the gtx card too big? It looks like it may be too big by the screenshot, but could you fit it in there w/o the cables?
 
Nice PC mark score. The PC's nice too, but the cables are a mess =P

I'm a bit too late, but I agree with what was stated earlier - the corsair dominator gives very little improvement over lower priced memory sticks. Corsair even has other memory that's around $60 less with the exact same statistics; I think the dominator is just easier to overclock, but you wouldn't notice much difference.

Can you get a Crysis benchmark on highest quality? Or any other new games. Would be appreciated. (I'm building a fairly similar system soon)

One more question, can you fit a fan in the little slot behind the hard drives? Or is the gtx card too big? It looks like it may be too big by the screenshot, but could you fit it in there w/o the cables?

The cables are messy because someone had me get the Corsair that isn't modular. :p There are way too many extra cables that I had squish behind the PSU.

I'll see if I can benchmark Crysis.

Extra fan? Ha, I can't even fit hard drives behind the video card. A case that is a bit longer and deeper would be nice. But the overall cooling is very good for just air.
 
The cables are messy because someone had me get the Corsair that isn't modular. :p There are way too many extra cables that I had squish behind the PSU.
...
Extra fan? Ha, I can't even fit hard drives behind the video card. A case that is a bit longer and deeper would be nice. But the overall cooling is very good for just air.

Nah, its just your case choice. :p You'd have better cable management and more room if you went with a different case, like the RC-690 -- but you already purchased the case before you asked, so oh wellz.
 
I'm getting both a modular power supply, and a 900-2 with the cable holes in the back, so that should help a fair bit with cable management.
 
He did the same thing here

http://www.ls1tech.com/forums/racers-lounge/1124638-build-gaming-pc-1-800-a.html

Ordered everything then asked questions...That's okay, it turned out pretty good it looks like other than the case choice/cable management ;)

That is because I never knew about this forum. :D I posted on two different sites and someone said this forum would be good to ask on. And they were right. Doesn't mean I can't change stuff. :p I may very well change the case.

And are you stalking me? ;)
 
Can you get a Crysis benchmark on highest quality? Or any other new games. Would be appreciated. (I'm building a fairly similar system soon)

I downloaded the demo. Set the resolution to 1600x1024, AA to 8x, and everything to very high. According to FRAPS, it was averaging about 30 FPS. But I didn't get too far into the game. I prefer demos that I can watch and don't have to play.
 
I'm getting both a modular power supply, and a 900-2 with the cable holes in the back, so that should help a fair bit with cable management.
Not really. The 900-2 is just as cramped as the Antec 900.

I posted on two different sites and someone said this forum would be good to ask on. And they were right.

Out of curiosity, what site referred you to this forum?

Oh and I was paying attention. Just didn't care for the synthetic benchmarks you posted.:D
 
That is because I never knew about this forum. :D I posted on two different sites and someone said this forum would be good to ask on. And they were right. Doesn't mean I can't change stuff. :p I may very well change the case.

And are you stalking me? ;)

lol Just happen to see this thread and was like deja vu?

:)
 
I ran 3DMark06 today and the scores were actually lower than 3DMark Vantage. I thought that was a bit odd. Other computers I have tested with Vista always scored higher with 06 verse Vantage. I'll probably try installing XP next and then Windows 7.

And I cleaned up the cables a bit, but there is only so much that can be done. A modular PSU would have definitely helped by eliminating 3 cables. But with 2 DVD drives, 1 card reader, 3 hard drives, and 4 fans, there are a lot of cables.

It is pretty quiet for being overclocked. I have all the Antec tricool fans on medium and so far the temps are good when running burn in programs. Even the video card is quiet unless you crank up the fan on it.
 
I tried XP 64 and Win7 64. 3DMark scores were all about the same, but the games seemed to play a bit smoother than when using Vista.

Also everything officially has Tuniq TX-2 thermal grease on it. I did the mobo and CPU before installing for the first time, so I don't know before and after results. Yesterday I took apart the video card and applied the TIM. The drop was probably about 4-5C. So far the only time I really see high temps is when my testing room gets up to 78 degrees and the humidity is probably about 45%. If I run the AC to get it down to around 72-73, the PC is much cooler, but I also blew the fuse because apparently the PC is on the same breaker as the AC.

Either way, it seems to be running good. I would love to try the 4870 X2 or even two 285's, but I have to ship it out by next friday. Hopefully by the time I get it back, I can get some other video cards to test out and maybe play around with water cooling and see what this CPU can really do.
 
Hm... I would have used MX-2, since its slightly better, but no worries, TX-2 still works good.

If you have a PC on the same circuit as a PC, it would be best to get a UPS or AVR unit for the PC. The power spikes/dips have been known to kill HDDs.
 
Back
Top