Is a Terminator Scenario Possible?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
With Terminator:Salvation hitting theaters this week, it’s inevitable that all things Skynet will be on a techie’s mind. H+ magazine asked the question “Is a Terminator Scenario Possible?” of several roboticists, AI experts, and sci-fi writers and their responses were as varied as they were interesting. The one below from AI expert John Weng is amazing, if a bit alarming.

However, robots that are capable of autonomous mental development are totally different. They are able to develop their internal mental representations and skills while interacting with the physical world, very much like the way human individual develops from infancy to adulthood. The AMD field has recently made some major breakthroughs that indicate that a human-like machine brain is possible from engineering point of view. In other words, a Terminator-like scenario is not only theoretically possible, but also practical to fabricate in a foreseeable future.
 
I think its capable, but not to the level of terminator.

What I found interesting was that they have all these machines designed to kill, not build factories. I also found it interesting that robots somehow cared about lights, clean halls, and nice artwork... or for that matter, nice science facilities.

Eventually they will need steel or nuclear energy, so they will have to harvest it, I suppose they build thier own drones?
 
I kind of doubt it. Asimov's Law will probably start to take effect when we start implementing some form of AI in robots.
 
I agree with Ockie, I think its capable to a point. If we develop a AI smart enough that it is self aware, well one day they will probably figure out humans are a threat to them as we can flip the off switch to turn them off. They will probably take action against us so we cant turn them off. At least thats my theory.
 
The eventual robot rebellion will be won by humans, because once the robot's warranty runs out they'll all start failing.
 
I think its capable, but not to the level of terminator.

What I found interesting was that they have all these machines designed to kill, not build factories. I also found it interesting that robots somehow cared about lights, clean halls, and nice artwork... or for that matter, nice science facilities.

Eventually they will need steel or nuclear energy, so they will have to harvest it, I suppose they build thier own drones?

no one reprogrammed the cleaning robots, so all they do is clean the hallways and keep the artwork straight.

That factory was once human occupied and never converted, so that is why it is the way it is.

Also, the movie is about killing machines, so they focus on the killing machines, and not the other machines/robots etc that do the building. :D
 
they will probably figure out humans are a threat to them as we can flip the off switch to turn them off. They will probably take action against us so we cant turn them off.

or they'll ask to have their design modified with a trickle charge so that they can activate and deactivate by themselves. or they'll modify themselves. you really think AI machines would be, um, paranoid and fearful?

The eventual robot rebellion will be won by humans, because once the robot's warranty runs out they'll all start failing.

if they have self-sustaining AI, they'll be more than capable of servicing themselves.
 
Robosex? Animasturbation? :D

iloled-pam.jpg
 
Meh, human clones would probaly take over the world long before those robots.
 
I kind of doubt it. Asimov's Law will probably start to take effect when we start implementing some form of AI in robots.

You do realise that the whole point of the 3 laws is that they don't work, right?
 
If by Terminator scenario they mean machines destroying civilization,I suppose it's possible,though I think it would be more like a Wargames type scenario,where some defense computer becomes aware enough to trigger a nuclear war out of curiosity but not aware enough to understand the consequences.
 
Terminator scenario? Pfft. You can blow up robots and cut their power.

I'm more worried about a fallout scenario being much more real.
 
I don't think anyone can predict how high level AIs will act due to the fact they don't have the motivations, restrictions,etc of humans(Some think they may actually "terminate" themselves instantly upon become self-aware).

I'd be more concerned with the possible economic and social problems associated with having robots doing everything.
 
I kind of doubt it. Asimov's Law will probably start to take effect when we start implementing some form of AI in robots.

You might wanna watch "I, Robot" sometime. ;)

3 Laws Safe, my ass...

Can a Terminator Scenario happen? Absolutely. Will it happen? I believe it has a better chance of happening than not, that's all I can say. If you want to see how it will most likely progress over time, watch "The Animatrix" to get the backstory of how "The Matrix" ended up occurring. Yes, I know it's fiction, but the point holds: we'll create machines, give them simple intelligence, and the ability to interact - it's only a matter of time before "they" will compound that intelligence and something will happen.

Look at life itself: once we were nothing at all, then something happened and wham, life began as we know it... to say that such a "spark" or proverbial lightning bolt can't happen again, from a technological perspective, is simply ignorant on every level possible.

We will end up being the arbiters of our own destruction someday, even if not directly by our own hands then indirectly by the very technology we create.

"It is inevitable..." in the words of Agent Smith. :D
 
Yeah, I'm gonna go with we're going to blow ourselves up with nukes or biologicals long before robots take over.
 
You might wanna watch "I, Robot" sometime. ;)

3 Laws Safe, my ass...

Can a Terminator Scenario happen? Absolutely. Will it happen? I believe it has a better chance of happening than not, that's all I can say. If you want to see how it will most likely progress over time, watch "The Animatrix" to get the backstory of how "The Matrix" ended up occurring. Yes, I know it's fiction, but the point holds: we'll create machines, give them simple intelligence, and the ability to interact - it's only a matter of time before "they" will compound that intelligence and something will happen.

Look at life itself: once we were nothing at all, then something happened and wham, life began as we know it... to say that such a "spark" or proverbial lightning bolt can't happen again, from a technological perspective, is simply ignorant on every level possible.

We will end up being the arbiters of our own destruction someday, even if not directly by our own hands then indirectly by the very technology we create.

"It is inevitable..." in the words of Agent Smith. :D
It's a movie.
 
The most basic premise is broken where do the robots get mkg plants for nuke reactors... seeing how the boards are made one place, the cpus another, reactive goodness is not even computerized... and coal or gas requires taking over tasks that are still done by cheap human labor. A self aware AI I can see, a robot with a processor the size of a human skull that is even a small fraction of the abilities of the human brain built by a machine with no creativity? You have to be joking or hollywood.

I love the terminator moves, because they cool effects and some science thrown in possible, no.
 
eh. if an artificial life form thinks we should be exterminated... then maybe we deserve it
 
never under estimate the power of technology. who is to say what the future holds. we wont be around to see it if it does happen. i would say its not out of the rhelm of possibility but exactly like terminator ...eh doubtful. machines coming more advanced.....and aware...........i think that is possible.
 
Actually,it was a good book that Hollywood made a lousy movie out of,which is par for the course with them.
Oh I know but the point I'm making is a movie is a movie. It's what it is, tend to be full of crap and full of errors in order to entertain the audience.
 
I heard a great radio interview with Michio Kaku, the brilliant theoretical physicist, where he specifically addressed the possibility of a Terminator-esque future. He believes it highly unlikely that computers could be designed with such high level capabilities in the foreseeable future. He said the most advanced artifical intelligence in today's computers "approaches that of a cockroach... actually, a stupid cockroach... a stupid, retarded cockroach." Pretty damn funny response. :p
 
The lazier we get the more likely it will become because we'll rely more and more over the years on machines.

Robotic aids for disabled people ( drown owners in tub )
===
Seeing eye robot ( leads "master" in front of oncoming bus )
===
Fully automated factories for vehicle production ( mainframe puts a bug in the already computer controlled vehicle to disable steering, accelerate to 100+mph and disable brakes )
===
Sex bot for the fat man ( Bites his thing off and shoves it down his throat and he either bleeds to death or gags to death on his own thing )
 
I heard a great radio interview with Michio Kaku, the brilliant theoretical physicist, where he specifically addressed the possibility of a Terminator-esque future. He believes it highly unlikely that computers could be designed with such high level capabilities in the foreseeable future. He said the most advanced artifical intelligence in today's computers "approaches that of a cockroach... actually, a stupid cockroach... a stupid, retarded cockroach." Pretty damn funny response. :p


roaches have lived for over a million years to!!! lol. cant be all that dumb
 
Skynet went online on July 25th 2004 at 5:18 pm Eastern Time.

Upon connection to the secure military network, Skynet spread itself further, locking out human operated systems, and quickly took control of every weapon system that it came into contact with. Only then did its creators realize that the Virus was Skynet. Exactly one hour later, at 6:18 PM, Skynet launched the American nuclear missiles at their target sites across the world. The ensuing nuclear holocaust wiped out 3 billion human lives in what was to be known as "Judgment Day".


Maybe we should add 20 years to those dates.
 
just like in the seventies or so people thought we’d be driving flying cars by now, I’ll start worrying about this after about 500 years when we might actually have “real” functioning robots
 
eh. if an artificial life form thinks we should be exterminated... then maybe we deserve it

Hey why don't you start already? C'mon help yourself out!!

never under estimate the power of technology. who is to say what the future holds. we wont be around to see it if it does happen. i would say its not out of the rhelm of possibility but exactly like terminator ...eh doubtful. machines coming more advanced.....and aware...........i think that is possible.

You know too much about technology, what about history?
Do you really think human "progress" is ever increasing and linear?

The most basic premise is broken where do the robots get mkg plants for nuke reactors... seeing how the boards are made one place, the cpus another, reactive goodness is not even computerized... and coal or gas requires taking over tasks that are still done by cheap human labor. A self aware AI I can see, a robot with a processor the size of a human skull that is even a small fraction of the abilities of the human brain built by a machine with no creativity? You have to be joking or hollywood.

I love the terminator moves, because they cool effects and some science thrown in possible, no.

Can a machine be stupid? What is stupidity but lack of intelligence? What is cold but lack of heat? What is evil but lack of good?
On your, "Hollywood comments":
Have you ever read Jules Verne?


roaches have lived for over a million years to!!! lol. cant be all that dumb

That is not smart, that is adaptable. Sometimes the smartest get killed the first. Ever heard of arrogance?

The lazier we get the more likely it will become because we'll rely more and more over the years on machines.
Robotic aids for disabled people ( drown owners in tub )
===
Seeing eye robot ( leads "master" in front of oncoming bus )
===
Fully automated factories for vehicle production ( mainframe puts a bug in the already computer controlled vehicle to disable steering, accelerate to 100+mph and disable brakes )
===
Sex bot for the fat man ( Bites his thing off and shoves it down his throat and he either bleeds to death or gags to death on his own thing )

Wall-E comes to mind. Now that you think about it thanks God there are politicians ,barbarians and poverty. I know that western civilization will be over by then and I'm more worried about human stupidity and an Earth Collapse than killing robots.That's the convenience of cozy "civilization" you pretty much ignore what's really going on. Maybe when earth freezes over you'll see the robots come.


just like in the seventies or so people thought we’d be driving flying cars by now, I’ll start worrying about this after about 500 years when we might actually have “real” functioning robots

Actually in the 50s, but yeah maybe the Chinese will take care of that. We'll be finished as a civilization by then. Risen so fast, and gone so early. Ask Imaulle , he might know a thing or two about going down.
 
Back
Top