Craigslist's 'Erotic Services' Shutdown Could Backfire?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
PC World seems to think that Craigslist shutting down its “Erotic Services” section could backfire. While the article trots out the age old “regulating the internet is bad” argument, and points out that websites aren’t responsible for 3rd party content, Craigslist was getting far more notoriety for hookers than classified ads. I think a voluntary shutdown was a smart move, what’s your opinion?

While Craigslist's move may have a come as a result of its own internal decision, the company's willingness to cave under pressure still sends a troubling message about the power of states' legal threats. The conclusion of this battle, in more ways than one, is anything but a happy ending.
 
I mentioned Craigslist the other day and a family friend (not very computer literate) actually said “isn’t that where everyone is getting hookers?”

I said “No”

She said “Oh, I thought it was that website where everyone was getting the hookers and then some guy started killing them”

Ummmm….well, yeah...but...
 
gotta love the bad image craigslist has, its a great website and i usually find great deals on there in my local area. Just because one person was using it to get his jolly's off and kill people. Now everything things the hole website is just for hookers and sex. Its not a swingers site.....
 
I mentioned Craigslist the other day and a family friend (not very computer literate) actually said “isn’t that where everyone is getting hookers?”

I said “No”

She said “Oh, I thought it was that website where everyone was getting the hookers and then some guy started killing them”

Ummmm….well, yeah...but...

Sounds like part of the plot from Dexter season 1 ;)
 
The way I see it, with the Erotic Service section you could at least find where hookers are soliciting their services and do something about them. With that section gone, it'll be harder for authorities to keep track of them. Not to mention you hurt legitimate businesses that uses that section.
 
The way I see it, with the Erotic Service section you could at least find where hookers are soliciting their services and do something about them. With that section gone, it'll be harder for authorities to keep track of them. Not to mention you hurt legitimate businesses that uses that section.

Heh, that is an excellent point.

Sounds like part of the plot from Dexter season 1 ;)

LOL!
 
now cops have to do harder more illegal ways to catch people...

craigslist is the best sting operation ever.

in many states you cannot solicitate even if you are a police officer. so craigslist gives them a different option.
 
The way I see it, with the Erotic Service section you could at least find where hookers are soliciting their services and do something about them. With that section gone, it'll be harder for authorities to keep track of them. Not to mention you hurt legitimate businesses that uses that section.

One could argue that with all of the hooker spam gone, those legitimate businesses will now have more effective advertisement, since they're not buried to the second, third page instantly.

I don't really care personally. I think it's stupid Craigslist is taking the blame for it. They remove ads when they're flagged and brought to their attention, nothing else should be required. Of course, prostitution should be legal anyways. But that's a whole 'nother debate ;)
 
Heh, this is a lose lose for everyone.

Now we'll get trasy adds inside the other threads.
 
Law enforcement/government was just waiting for an incident like this to use as an excuse to close down the erotic sites. They had already been complaining about the ads before this happened. The fact is CraigsList is well know for buying and selling. I have sold cars, computers, appliances etc throughout the years even bought a Beagle.

The point is that with any of these ads there is the risk that you might get involved with a psycho killer, robber or scammer. When someone comes over to your house to look at something you are selling there is this risk involved or when you go to their house to buy something there is the same risk.
 
What sucks is you won't be able to play what the fuck bingo in the adult classifieds anymore. I found a gem of one that was an amputee that wanted someone to fuck the hole at the end of her leg stump.
 
What sucks is you won't be able to play what the fuck bingo in the adult classifieds anymore. I found a gem of one that was an amputee that wanted someone to fuck the hole at the end of her leg stump.

I didn't even think of that!

The true crime here isn't the fact that it's being shut down, it's all of the gems Best of Craigslist will be missing now.
 
While I think it was a smart move on Craigslist part... It's all conditioning us for larger and larger things folks.

I'm sure Craigslist will be a small fry compared to what will have happened in 3 more years.
 
Wow,

I missed that you could get Hooker on Craigs list! Am now I'm too late.
:(
 
I think Craigslist pussed out. It people want to bone hookers or whatever, what business is it of anyone else, especially the government? Hell its better than those nasty chicks hanging out on street corners. Bottom line is, people are going to do it anyway, as they've done for a few thousand years, so why is anyone harassing craigslist about it? My guess would be they have some kind of psychological control issues, as the erotic section does not effect anyones lives but the ones who use it.
 
Craigslist has an hooker services?! Wow. Didn't know that. I guess all the other stuff overruled that for me.

I think I clicked on it to see what it was about before... Not too interested in herpes, though, so nothing really appealed to me. So, being the married nerd I am, I went back shopping for computer and networking equipment to drool over. Sad when I'd prefer a nice Cisco router over a hooker and blow. Damn.
 
Nice to see this first thing on hitting the forum page:

2u6lfsh.jpg
 
Its a hot button issue and is going to draw a lot of attention to the site, not necessarily positive, nor negative. Just look at the other thread dealing with this issue or the impact of moral politicians and religious leaders. This is just bringing the net neutrality to the forefront on another subject beside piracy.
 
Craigslist has an hooker services?! Wow. Didn't know that. I guess all the other stuff overruled that for me.
Not hooker services per se, but yeah. I never really ventured over that way, though I do think it's kind of unfortunate I won't be able to now, if I had the inclination.

I guess might have to use Google or something if I want to find myself a whore in the future. An extra couple of steps. Bummer.
 
Thats just one site. Most of the dating sites have hookers on them.

Its just that on craigs list it was blatantly obvious.
 
My concern is whether or not it made it easier to bust the REAL fucking subhuman scumbags of the earth - pedophiles!

Now it's going to be a bitch to find ANYONE doing something they shouldn't be for law enforcement.
 
You're right, when they started charging $5 to post and the number of postings on CL erotic services dropped 95% I noticed a greater then 95% increase in the number of hoe's I saw working the streets in Oakland!

Could this be an evil plot to further depress housing prices in large population centers? :p
 
It's funny if you track the infinite wisdom of law enforcement through the years. If you go back to the roots of the drug war, they took a small, manageable problem and drove it underground to spark a massive (violent) epidemic. Every single time they try to villanize something, it just comes back stronger.

While Craiglist did provide ease of access, it also provided a traceable link if something bad happened. Let's assume the CL killer didn't use CL. How would they have tracked him then? How would they have even linked the victims together? I mean, they found the guy in a week or so. If they hadn't had all of those leads, it would have taken them months or more (assuming they would have found him).

It'll be interesting to see how this problem resurges... I'm wondering if this is more of an issue simply because it drew a huge spotlight on law enforcement agencies competance and their tactics.
 
It's funny if you track the infinite wisdom of law enforcement through the years. If you go back to the roots of the drug war, they took a small, manageable problem and drove it underground to spark a massive (violent) epidemic. Every single time they try to villanize something, it just comes back stronger.

Thats because people have an inherent need to be left the fuck alone and not be told what to do. I know everytime someone tells me something I can't do, I make it a point to do it, even if its something I would have not cared to do otherwise.

Prohibition worked out great didn't it?
 
Thats because people have an inherent need to be left the fuck alone and not be told what to do. I know everytime someone tells me something I can't do, I make it a point to do it, even if its something I would have not cared to do otherwise.

Prohibition worked out great didn't it?

that has been my message for ages.

legalize it all and it works out.

why in the hell is prostitution illegal anyway? It's been around since the dawn of time.... if you REALLY want to get technical about it, that's really what marriage and dating boil down to anyway..."buy me shit/take care of me and i'll stay around and fuck you"

prohibition is a great example, we have been getting drunk since some dude came out of his cave and found fetid fruit juice... then suddenly its illegal.

the govt needs to back out of shit like this.
 
What sucks is you won't be able to play what the fuck bingo in the adult classifieds anymore. I found a gem of one that was an amputee that wanted someone to fuck the hole at the end of her leg stump.

wow, just wow.
 
legalize it all and it works out.

I think I get your meaning but the way you worded it is a little worrisome. To tell them to legalize it would be conceding that they have the right to make it illegal in the first place, which I refuse. If myself and another person decide to make a transaction of any sort that does not involve or bother another person in any way, a third person (government or otherwise) has no right to interfere or to decide whether it is "legal" or not. It makes no logical sense to interfere. The only reasoning is their serious control issues. Freedom is not subject to the wants or morals of anyone.
 
I think I get your meaning but the way you worded it is a little worrisome. To tell them to legalize it would be conceding that they have the right to make it illegal in the first place, which I refuse. If myself and another person decide to make a transaction of any sort that does not involve or bother another person in any way, a third person (government or otherwise) has no right to interfere or to decide whether it is "legal" or not. It makes no logical sense to interfere. The only reasoning is their serious control issues. Freedom is not subject to the wants or morals of anyone.

you are right, you just worded the long way what i meant in the short statement.
 
Thats because people have an inherent need to be left the fuck alone and not be told what to do. I know everytime someone tells me something I can't do, I make it a point to do it, even if its something I would have not cared to do otherwise.

Prohibition worked out great didn't it?

Yeah... lol

There was a great piece on the drug war on the History channel. It documented how heroin went from a legal pharmaceutical (ironically used to treat morphine addiction and coughing) to throwing casual users into jail for 5-20 years. The interesting thing was that when it was legal, they said there were only about 100,000 addicts. When the mob took over operations, it completely blew up.

Now, I'm not defending heroin...it's just that instead of dealing with problems directly, legislators and law enforcement tend to think that if they hide the problem, it's gone. Just like out here in Chicago when they dismantled the projects, the murder rate actually went up to pass NY's. The theory is that dimantling the problem from a central location was like taking a large cancerous cell, splitting it up and attaching it to large healthy cells in hopes that the healthy cells will win out. They just made the problem worse.

The thing is that legislators don't offer any alternatives or rehabilitation. They think they're right and people should listen. You can't correct a conditioned behavior if you don't know how.
 
Back
Top