Silverlight Catching Up to Flash...in Features

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
SAI has an article about Microsoft Silverlight and how it's catching up to Adobe Flash in regards to the feature set. Adoption is another thing altogether, though MS is definitely trying. Silverlight worked fantastically for me during the Summer Olympics last year and I look forward to seeing how it's improved when the Winter Olympics roll around.

Microsoft has been able to get companies like NBC to use Silverlight for one-time projects like the Olympics by funding them. (Likewise, Microsoft has a special relationship with Netflix; the DVD rental service's founder and CEO Reed Hastings sits on Microsoft's board.)
 
Silverlight is much better than Adobe Flash IMO. Performance with Silverlight is much better and I hardly notice any browser lag using it.
 
Exactly. Flash is plagued with memory leaks and it's soo bloated, I some times have to close my browser to get my computer to respond.
 
I don't see much holding Silverlight back. Much like everything from Adobe, Flash sucks. That is of course, except Photoshop. They really should be a 1-product company.
 
I don't see much holding Silverlight back. Much like everything from Adobe, Flash sucks. That is of course, except Photoshop. They really should be a 1-product company.

Definitely. Much better to do one thing awesomely than 20 things that are rubbish.
 
I liked Silverlight during the Olympics. It seemed to do a better job of buffering videos on my poor 1Mb connection than Flash.
 
If everyone would take the Opera approach to programming, we wouldn't have this issue. But Adobe since buying Macromedia has turned 2 cripple fight like products into all out retard slug fests.

Flash works, its "semi-bloated" on the client end.

Silverlight doesn't work in Opera that I have bothered to try and get going (ActiveX based plugins are fail on Opera).

Regardless, Adobe does make some good products, but the ones they got from Macromedia, hardly fall into that category as everyone else pretty well stated.

IMO, spin off those two products, have it drag Dreamweaver with it, and make a complete web services only type thing, and make them all more tight in code (remember the link Kyle had on front page about the guy commenting his thoughts on Adobe PSD inside his code :D )
 
What will eventually hold Silverlight back would be Adobe whiners and people pissing their pants because Microsoft dares to make a product!
 
First I didn't really like silverlight, but now it seems to be much better than flash, although I've always hated flash also. Therefore blocking all unnecessary things in my web browser, allowing stuff only when needed.
 
What will eventually hold Silverlight back would be Adobe whiners and people pissing their pants because Microsoft dares to make a product!

God forbid they allow MS to have a product that is better then the competition as well.

Silverlight is far better then Flash ever has been. It's faster and definitely more lightweight then the bloat that is Flash.
 
if only silverlight would catch on ... adobe has thumbed its nose at 64 bit IE for way too long! :(
 
I have no complaints whatsoever about Silverlight; I recently got a Netflix subscription and the streaming works flawlessly for me.I don't really have any other experience with it, at least that I'm aware of ;)
 
I hope Silverlight takes off. Microsoft has shown dedication to supporting it on all platforms, unlike Adobe who still can't even get a Linux client right, let alone 64-bit on any platform. Besides, however evil they are, Microsoft is still less evil than Adobe.
 
I love SL, I find it SOOO much easier to develop with also than flash for certain things.
 
Silverlight is far better then Flash ever has been. It's faster and definitely more lightweight then the bloat that is Flash.

I don't understand Silverlight being any better than flash. Video uses the same codec set and the same hardware acceleration, so there's no reason it would be more efficient that I can see. Smoothness is largely a question of buffering which is actually configurable in Flash.

As for bloat, I'm not sure where that's being seen. Silverlight relies on modules already loaded into the OS, so I'm not sure how you're judging bloat.

The real problem with this is the fact that one company controls the plugin, the browser, the operating system, the web server and the server OS, *and* the privacy standards organization. This creates serious dangers to consumers, to customers and the marketplace in general.
 
My friend is a web application developer, looking a his latest work with Silverlight, I was amazed. MS has done a very good job.
 
My friend is a web application developer, looking a his latest work with Silverlight, I was amazed. MS has done a very good job.

What is it about silverlight that makes for better results?
 
Back
Top