US Response to Cyber Attacks: Nothing ‘Off the Table’

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
US Air Force General Kevin Chilton told Stars & Stripes that the US military’s response to a cyber-attack would not necessarily be limited to cyberspace. He said that the Law of Armed Conflict “will still apply to this domain.”

"I don’t think you take anything off the table when you provide options to the president to decide," he said. "You don’t take any response options off the table from an attack on the United States of America. Why would we constrain ourselves on how we would respond?"
 
So if someone takes down the military's website with a DDOS attack, they get bombed?
 
So if someone takes down the military's website with a DDOS attack, they get bombed?

Hell yeah. I think that if anyone is waging any form of war they deserve to pay the consequences of their actions. If they are trying to destroy our defense networks through the internet we by all means have the right to destroy their physical networks in order to disrupt their attempts to destroy ours remotely.
 
So if someone takes down the military's website with a DDOS attack, they get bombed?

I doubt if he's talking about just a web site, but he is doing his job. If an outside enemy attacks a country either through physical or cyber attacks then that country has the right to defend itself including the use of physical attack. Pretty simple concept actually.
 
His job is to present all available military options to the administration, and be prepared to implement them. What the administration actually chooses to do is another matter. Don't waste your time reading more into it than is there.
 
His job is to present all available military options to the administration, and be prepared to implement them. What the administration actually chooses to do is another matter. Don't waste your time reading more into it than is there.

Yup. The whole "we keep all options on the table" is a canned response. The idea is that in general the less they know about the possible consequences of their actions the less likely they are to attack us in the first place.

We have a similar policy with nuclear weapons. We say all options are always on the table (as in we're willing to use nukes even if the enemy doesn't) to keep them on their toes. While unlikely, they don't have 100% certainty that we wont play dirty.
 
So if someone takes down the military's website with a DDOS attack, they get bombed?

Um, yes? We rely on digital information. Shutting down a military data system could be much more crippling than shutting down a base via physical means. For one - the enemy gets to do it remotely, in a safe place. That's incentive enough for an enemy to consider the cyber realm.
 
For some reason, each time I see this thread title today I immediately think of John Travolta's character Gabriel explaining to Hugh Jackman's character Stanley the who-what-when-where-why of his existence:

Swordfish dialogue said:
Stanley: War? Who are we at war with?
Gabriel: Anyone who impinges on America's freedom. Terrorist states, Stanley. Someone must bring their war to them. They bomb a church, we bomb ten. They hijack a plane, we take out an airport. They execute American tourists, we tactically nuke an entire city. Our job is to make terrorism so horrific that it becomes unthinkable to attack Americans.

Or words to that effect... funny how it seems to be so applicable to this so-called response announcement.
 
Don't be afraid of the country that has a couple nukes and MIGHT use them. Be afraid of the country that has thousands, and HAS used them.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Don't be afraid of the country that has a couple nukes and MIGHT use them. Be afraid of the country that has thousands, and HAS used them.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

The country that has nukes and has restrained from using them since worries me not a whit.

The one that has them and stones women in the streets for showing an anke does.
 
imagine a real cyber atack on the us army mainframe from all of the hackers in the world america would be defenseless
 
imagine a real cyber atack on the us army mainframe from all of the hackers in the world america would be defenseless

Critical systems and tactical databases are not plugged into the internet...there is a physical separation of "critical" and "unsecured" computers. If you think mission critical control computers are attached to the internet then Ive got some land in Brooklyn I'd like to sell you...any joker attacking the US defense department by computer is incapable of stopping a physical retaliation...like the General said...ALL options remain on the table.
 
They could just disconnect the rest of the world from the intrawebnetubez to snuff an attack. :cool:

Yes, has used, and should have used nuclear weapons to destroy Kandahar Afganistan on Sept 11th... all the major players were in one place at the same time. Boom. :eek::p:D
 
Took 4-5 days to shoot 3 pirates in a row boat, I don't have much faith in the Generals statement or his commander and chief.

I prefer to live in a country were our military thinks a bit before they go and kill people in that kind of a situation. The use of deadly force isn't something I want to seen chosen on a whim.
 
Milhouse: "Well Bart, we've learned that war is not the answer"

Bart: "Except to all of America's problems"
 
I prefer to live in a country were our military thinks a bit before they go and kill people in that kind of a situation. The use of deadly force isn't something I want to seen chosen on a whim.

You need to look up the history of pirates and how they were delt with in the past.
 
If the US does not want its computers attacked the solution is simple:

Make sure that none of the computers are physically attached to the public internet.

If you can spend over a trillion dollars a year on plutonium, titanium and other exotic metal based hardware... You'd figure the top level stuff can easily be put on a seperate line or even a single dedicated satellite.

Even the the 1960's the US had the "red line" which was an untappable telephone line that only the president and top generals could use.
 
You need to look up the history of pirates and how they were delt with in the past.

Thing is - the internet would definitely be considered "international waters or airspace" if there was a way to classify it militarily.

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNe.../Russia_planes_090227/20090227?hub=TopStories

Now this is more interesting from a pure military perspective. Hidden and hushed up to most americans, the Russians did fly either a TU-95 or TU-160 bomber (the largest bomber in the Russian airfleet) violating Canadian airspace just 24 hours before Obamas first visit to Canada.

If you think the great media wall of China is bad - the US is completely in the dark about international relations.
 
If you think the great media wall of China is bad - the US is completely in the dark about international relations.

Don't speak for me, I was well aware of the Russian bomber paying a visit. My interests range far beyond anything discussed on this forum.

The media is too busy talking about Micheles arms or the White House dog or Obama going out for the burger.

In short they are providing cover for their "man" while things are going to hell.

Pirates were hanged more or less on site in the past, they choose to operate outside of the laws of nations and were treated as such.
 
Thing is - the internet would definitely be considered "international waters or airspace" if there was a way to classify it militarily.
I don't think so. The internet resides on servers, cables, and other infrastructure that are owned by businesses and governments. I believe the owners of said infrastructure have every right to police their virtual borders. Virtual borders are extensions of physical borders.

Even if the internet were to be considered as "international water/airspace," the same rules would apply. If a ship is attacked in international waters, usually the owner of said ship will do anything in their power to protect the ship, cargo, and above all the crew.
 
If you give power of control to the physical line owners - than anyone who is a larger ISP has jurisdiction over the data that goes across it yes?

If the US military uses these commercial/public lines for whatever reason, then its pretty well up to them to make sure its protected along its way with some sort of unbreakable encryption - otherwise its pretty well in the public domain.

Sure, the US is allowed to protect their data by all means possible software wise - they cant physically invade a country though. If China said that a US hacker got some of their plans stolen off the internet - does that mean that China can send a million tanks to land on the shore.

More often - things like this are exaggerated as an excuse to use physical invasion "Weapons of mass destruction anyone?"
 
spoken like a true armchair general.

Perhaps you should read the timeline of the event and the rules of engagment that were laid out.

A statement from the White House indicated it was "unfortunate" the pirates were killed.

W.T.F.
 
Took 4-5 days to shoot 3 pirates in a row boat, I don't have much faith in the Generals statement or his commander and chief.

First thing I thought of when I read your statement was this picture.

navy2u.jpg
 
Perhaps you should read the timeline of the event and the rules of engagment that were laid out.

A statement from the White House indicated it was "unfortunate" the pirates were killed.

W.T.F.
I was just messin with ya, i just neglected to insert the right emoticon :p (we're all armchair generals here !)

But In regards to your original statement i quoted: i sorta know where you're coming from, and agree to an extent.
 
Um, yes? We rely on digital information. Shutting down a military data system could be much more crippling than shutting down a base via physical means. For one - the enemy gets to do it remotely, in a safe place. That's incentive enough for an enemy to consider the cyber realm.
"They fight us over here so they dont have to fight us over there" -W. bush kinda:eek:
 
Hell yeah. I think that if anyone is waging any form of war they deserve to pay the consequences of their actions. If they are trying to destroy our defense networks through the internet we by all means have the right to destroy their physical networks in order to disrupt their attempts to destroy ours remotely.


Hell Yeah!! +1
 
Interesting idea... but some thoughts on this.

If we decide to implement this rule this means that China could provoke an military response for invading our digital borders with an attack. As they have done many cyber attacks against our netspace.

And in the case of bot nets... are we going to charge into the old folks homes that happen to have 6 compromised computers that were attacking or routing attacks for a 3rd party in Russia or china operating illegally?

Will we start seeing actual investigation of cyber attacks to determine the source and not just shore up vs losses.

If that is the case then I am all for it! But I don't think that that is going to be the case.
 
Since most of these high profile Chinese hackers are very open about what they do, why not have some CIA branch that deals with them..and I mean DEALS with them.. find out who they are, they end up found dead in a dumpster.
 
Since most of these high profile Chinese hackers are very open about what they do, why not have some CIA branch that deals with them..and I mean DEALS with them.. find out who they are, they end up found dead in a dumpster.

Oh yeah, and China and Russia for that fact would react favorably to CIA agents operating in their countries, killing their citizens. Not that I'm against your idea, just not gonna work. If things keep going we are going to see strongly nationalistic stances on the internet, blocking foreign connections and strong federal laws regarding the internet which in all reality is the only solution to these problems (but something I'm against).
 
I can see China going down for Cyper ware fare LOL
Hackers
Copycats
Gold Farmers
etc etc
 
Don't be afraid of the country that has a couple nukes and MIGHT use them. Be afraid of the country that has thousands, and HAS used them.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

and those nukes we used are the only reason you and I are not typing in german right now. those 'awful' devices are why you still have as much freedom as you do
 
and those nukes we used are the only reason you and I are not typing in german right now. those 'awful' devices are why you still have as much freedom as you do

Um... fuck. My brain hurts from this much fail.

We didn't nuke Germany.

We nuked Japan AFTER Germany surrendered.
 
Let give Germany all the nukes xD lets see what they will do with it LOL
 
Germany doesn't have any balls anymore.

*before someone takes this the wrong way, I'm German and sick of their social bureaucracy*
 
Back
Top