Manhattan, Halo Style

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Imagine a 3D map of Manhattan all stretched out…Halo style. It looks pretty cool, I have no idea what it is for or why the guy did it this way but it’d be fun to play it as a map. ;)
 
Very cool idea, but I can't imagine a purpose other than being creative.

Being in architecture, I can tell you a lot of people have a hard time relating to technical drawings, including maps. It looks like the intent here is to give the user a p.o.v. shot integrated as part of the map. Just kind of a more intuitive version of the "you are here" dot, but giving them some visual reference more similar to what they might see actually standing there. In terms of interface design, it's a pretty neat idea, though looks like it could still use some 'polishing' up.
 
Being in architecture, I can tell you a lot of people have a hard time relating to technical drawings, including maps. It looks like the intent here is to give the user a p.o.v. shot integrated as part of the map. Just kind of a more intuitive version of the "you are here" dot, but giving them some visual reference more similar to what they might see actually standing there. In terms of interface design, it's a pretty neat idea, though looks like it could still use some 'polishing' up.

Fair enough, but I think what you're referring to could be done by simple providing the user with an aerial 3D image? I would guess, curving a 'flat' landscape this way, might only confuse someone.

Just my $0.02.
 
being the 1 person who hasn't played (or even seen) HALO (or its sequels), that reminds me of the book Ringworld..
 
looks to me the actual added benefit is that he was able to fit 3 times the amount of information on a single image.. lay that image flat in a 2d.. and you lose over 2/3's of the image/streets in view in the same frame size.. atleast thats what it looks like to me..
 
I agree - let's give credit to Niven's Ringworld. Halo simply ripped his idea off. Call that map a Niven Ring Map! Feck Halo! :p
 
Ringworld Engineers !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm still waiting for the television series to pop up.
 
Too bad you'd have to multiply that map billions of times before even coming close to the scale of the ring in Ringworld. I don't think my imagination will ever fully grasp how large it was.
 
60256_1152359707_large.jpg
 

Ringworld isn't covered, and this isn't nearly wide enough. Ringworld is a million miles wide, so there's no way to see both walls at once. Plus, the walls are a thousand miles tall with flup mountains covering them, so if you're standing at the bottom it doesn't look like a wall... and you can't see the other wall at all.

I might have read these books a couple of times, yeah.
 
well, this seems a bit more realistic :) The future of mankind after the sun explosasm's.
 
ringworlds needs to have segments that can seal off. one good explosion or puncture and everything flys out.

and yeah, Niven before Halo, but since most people nowadays only read Halo books, im not surprised thats the analogy used.
 
Larry Niven rocks.

I have read the Ringworld Books. They are fantastic.

I have also played Halo, and I have read 3 or 4 of the Halo books. The Halo books are really very good. I was surprised about how good the Halo books are. If you play Halo then you might enjoy the books.

But all credit should go to Larry Niven. The man is a G O D !

 
ringworlds needs to have segments that can seal off. one good explosion or puncture and everything flys out.

One "good" explosion would be more than enough to destroy the Earth, and there are countermeasures. Think about the Fist of God: a huge meteor hits the ringworld from underneath, and the Ringworld's huge speed (770 miles per second!) turns the impact into one strong enough to distort scrith into a mountain. Even that doesn't kill the Ringworld; the actual hole in the floor is stretched high enough to be out of the atmosphere, so the air doesn't all leak away. Also, the orbital defenses (I won't spoil it for those who haven't read the books) are more than capable of taking out meteorites that come in from other directions, invading armies, whatever. Anything Earth-sized or smaller shouldn't be a problem.

The Ringworld is friggin' huge, and made of a material that, in the author's words, has a strength nearly that of the strong nuclear force. Doing any significant damage to it is tough to accomplish.
 
Back
Top