Worst Cities For Jobs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you have recently lost your job and are considering relocating to find work, you really should read this first, it could save you a lot of heartache and hassle.

First let's deal with the perennial losers, the sad sacks of the American economy. Mostly cities in the nation's industrial heartland, these places have ranked toward the bottom of our list for much of the past five years. Eleven of the bottom 16 regions on our list are in two states, Ohio and Michigan. In fact, the Wolverine State alone accounts for bottom four cities: Jackson, Michigan, Detroit, Saginaw and Flint.
 
I'm thinking the reason behind Michigan and Ohio being low on the list is because of the auto and auto parts industry layoffs. There's just much more people looking for work, throwing the whole re-employed/still-unemployed scale off.
 
Interesting.

Michigan dominated the Worst cities for jobs (no surprise there) and Texas dominated Best cities for jobs.


Never been to Texas, but is it really all that?

Thinking about leaving O-hi-O in the next couple years and have considered Texas on a couple occasions.
 
I say we just drop Michigan as a state and give the land to Canada. Then the unemployeement rate will go down. Sorry Ockie and the rest of you up there.
 
I say we just drop Michigan as a state and give the land to Canada. Then the unemployeement rate will go down. Sorry Ockie and the rest of you up there.

Canada already has a province dedicated to over-payed auto workers. They don't want Michigan.
 
Ah, poor Michigan. Would the last one to leave, please turn out the lights? It'll make a comeback once water starts trading at $40/barrel.
 
I have been contemplating leaving Florida for a while now for either Texas or California. Texas is closer and doing much better so this seems like a good time to head to the [H]'s [H]ome state :cool:
 
I say we just drop Michigan as a state and give the land to Canada. Then the unemployeement rate will go down. Sorry Ockie and the rest of you up there.

HAHAHA, I'm cool with that. I want to move as it is already. If I had a buyer for my house tomorrow without losing tens of thousands, I'd sell and move.



At least we can brag and say that we are the first in a lot of areas, crime, unemployment, depression, obesity, car theft, etc. When I see lists like these, I just assume Detroit will be on the top. :D
 
I have been contemplating leaving Florida for a while now for either Texas or California. Texas is closer and doing much better so this seems like a good time to head to the [H]'s [H]ome state :cool:

My friend just moved to Texas only a couple months ago for a job opportunity, and now he's going to have to move back to Washington due to lack of work. Doesn't sound like a particularly great situation anywhere right about now. :(
 
My friend just moved to Texas only a couple months ago for a job opportunity, and now he's going to have to move back to Washington due to lack of work. Doesn't sound like a particularly great situation anywhere right about now. :(

The grass in always greener on the other side isn't it?
 
The grass in always greener on the other side isn't it?

qft. I have the hardest time getting this across to my wife sometimes. Simply moving to another city won't necessarily just magically make everything better.

Anyway, that said, we've had our eye on Austin for quite a while. We might make the move early next year, but who knows. Were initially planning on it for the beginning of this year, but w/ the "z0mg3c0nomies!!!" I was hesitant to voluntarily leave my current job.
 
HAHAHA, I'm cool with that. I want to move as it is already. If I had a buyer for my house tomorrow without losing tens of thousands, I'd sell and move.



At least we can brag and say that we are the first in a lot of areas, crime, unemployment, depression, obesity, car theft, etc. When I see lists like these, I just assume Detroit will be on the top. :D

Like ockie i too live in Michigan. It is a very ruff time right now, i saw a list of companies closing or doing major lay offs in my area and it was very long. I am with ockie on that if i could sell my house today i would be gone.
 
As a Michigander...yep, it sucks.

On a side note, the Forbes slideshow was annoying me, so I mapped the Worst Big Cities list in case that helps anyone out. Anybody want to do the Medium/Small cities, or the Best Cities?
 
How the hell did San Diego not make the list?
 
I too live in Michigan, and I also have plans to bail when the time is right.
 
Michigander here too. 12.6% unemployed :(
Quite a few close friends are out of work.
For a long time our local economy was cars, cars and cars...
 
My friend just moved to Texas only a couple months ago for a job opportunity, and now he's going to have to move back to Washington due to lack of work. Doesn't sound like a particularly great situation anywhere right about now. :(

Sad, but accurate assessment.

I can confirm this as well, as I'm a native Texan, and left in 2004 due to the bottom falling out in the Metroplex. I hated like hell to have to leave....but when you can't even find work at a damned 7-11 (or any other convenience store) or the like, things are B A D.

That's why I'm in this craphole called St Louis...at least there was *some* work to be found.

I miss my mesquite trees, and the wonderful countryside (ahhhhhhh the hill-country!!), the fishing (no damned salt water for light-years around here...), not to mention God's Gift to Texas -the hospitality- and (not so) common decency!!

But...things are what they are. You have to be able to eat and have a roof!
 
I love people who say just get rid of Michigan. Nice fighting spirit you all have there.

Having been in Michigan since age 5, I prefer to stay here. I say for all those that can't take a downturn that you should get out of Michigan and that will help fix the unemployment problem right there.

I wish there weren't so many losers here in Michigan that make their $$ working in Detroit and yet drive cars made elsewhere. What are you thinking? The "best" car is the one that puts money on your table, and food on your plate, and a roof over your head. That is how I think. Not "oh, that one has inferior interior plastics yada yada yada."

The funny thing is that I see people here from all over the world that have left their country to find work. And what to 99% of them do? Buy cars from some other place, effectively ensuring their own unemployment. Think about it.

I go out of my way to buy products made in the USA by USA based companies. That goes a long way.

People came to Michigan because there were jobs available that paid good money so you could raise a family on. You know, what you all are looking for. Now the whole country is mad at the US car companies for what...paying their employees too much and giving people who committed 30 years of their lives to the factories so they could get a retirement. This IS the American way, but so many people now do not have this so they feel like others who have EARNED this do not deserve it. People feel like the US car companies should go bankrupt. A fine lot you all are. I hope for those that do not think like I do good luck in moving to where ever the jobs currently are. Make sure you tell your boss you don't want a pension/retirement plan and that you want to make the same $$ as your counterpart in the third world country. Seems fair to me.

Oh, and as the autos shut down, the people who get laid off will naturally move to your home state and compete with you all for whatever jobs remain.

It is in the best interest of the entire country that we support a US resource and see to it that it remains alive, just like foreign governments are doing with their own struggling auto industries.

Good luck to you all.
 
Wow, we (Michigan) have two of the top 10! I was expecting more! WOW Cali is not too far behind!!!
 
Here's the problem with the "buy American":

the US auto complex isn't making things that the (general) consumer wants.

They have to cut too many corners to meet a price point that will convince the consumer that they're getting value for their dollar.

Outside of the light truck market, there's not much to like from Detroit in the vein of the "under $30k" segment. At least that's what the consumer has voted, with their dollars. Ford has the Focus which they've finally sorted out it would seem. That's the only one that comes to mind, tho. Mustang/Camaro/Challenger are too niche to sell in large volume. GM tried to fight Mazda with the Solstice/Sky, but it was too little, too late, and again too niche to be called bread and butter for any of these large companies.

If the US auto complex was *serious* about "making cars" instead of "printing money for it's current and former employees" about 10 years ago, they wouldn't be in this situation.

The suits were too spineless to tell the UAW to get bent when renegotiating contracts. The UAW was only looking out for themselves, and thus started killing the golden goose. If both sides had been a bit better at looking out for the bottom line of the company that kept them both in a paycheck, the US auto complex wouldn't be in freefall, and in turn, Detroit would be a place to actually go to work, not leave to find work.

On top of all of that, what has the Michigan state legislature done to attract other industries? Good tax codes that make it attractive to open business and employ people there? It wouldn't appear that has happened either, as Ford decided to open their biggest plant in Brazil, not in Detroit.

In the end, it's people that are the problem, and ultimately, the solution. Not the government.
 
Here's the problem with the "buy American":

the US auto complex isn't making things that the (general) consumer wants.

They have to cut too many corners to meet a price point that will convince the consumer that they're getting value for their dollar.

Outside of the light truck market, there's not much to like from Detroit in the vein of the "under $30k" segment. At least that's what the consumer has voted, with their dollars. Ford has the Focus which they've finally sorted out it would seem. That's the only one that comes to mind, tho. Mustang/Camaro/Challenger are too niche to sell in large volume. GM tried to fight Mazda with the Solstice/Sky, but it was too little, too late, and again too niche to be called bread and butter for any of these large companies.

If the US auto complex was *serious* about "making cars" instead of "printing money for it's current and former employees" about 10 years ago, they wouldn't be in this situation.

The suits were too spineless to tell the UAW to get bent when renegotiating contracts. The UAW was only looking out for themselves, and thus started killing the golden goose. If both sides had been a bit better at looking out for the bottom line of the company that kept them both in a paycheck, the US auto complex wouldn't be in freefall, and in turn, Detroit would be a place to actually go to work, not leave to find work.

On top of all of that, what has the Michigan state legislature done to attract other industries? Good tax codes that make it attractive to open business and employ people there? It wouldn't appear that has happened either, as Ford decided to open their biggest plant in Brazil, not in Detroit.

In the end, it's people that are the problem, and ultimately, the solution. Not the government.


Very well said. Hit the nail on the head.
 
Having grown up in Michigan and now living in Chicago, I cannot wait for the opportunity to move back, preferably the Traverse area
 
I love people who say just get rid of Michigan. Nice fighting spirit you all have there.

Having been in Michigan since age 5, I prefer to stay here. I say for all those that can't take a downturn that you should get out of Michigan and that will help fix the unemployment problem right there.

I was born in Michigan, moved to Southern California when I was 8, and I have to say that it was one of the better decisions my parents made. :D

And jellisii nailed it with his post.
 
For the small town list I wish they would not put Grand Haven with Holland. Grand Haven (where I live) is a touristy type small town with lots of money they is doing good. It is tiny though and the city proper is about 2 miles across if that and maybe one building is over 4 stories and maybe a few dozen are over 2 stories. They have little in the way of industry in the town. Holland on the other hand is like 30 times bigger and has a lot of industry in it (and is where I work). Holland is doing pretty bad. Grand Haven property values are not doing bad, but Holland is just horrible. Houses that were appraised for $100,000 are selling for $40,000. It is bad.
 
Man Ca. is in the crapper not surprised though. I was a little surprised that 5 citys on the worst list were in Ca. Great move to raise taxes here again lol. Bet that will move us ahead of Michigan in a hurry.
 
Another Michgander here.
I hope at least 3 million people leave, the southern part of the state dominates our politics.
When people think of Michigan they think of Detroit, well this is a very large beautiful state, Detroit gives it a bad name...

Go to Northern Michigan sometime, Detroit may as well be a million miles away.
 
First time I have seen Toledo, Oh ranked number one in something. Of course, it's for being the worst. I'm sure our mayor will demand a recount or something
 
California has 4 of the top 10.

Well California is the most populous state in the union. So I'd say that's lower than Michigan.

They got 36 million in California whereas Michigan has 10 million. Michigan would be higher than California if you factored in the capita.
 
Here's the problem with the "buy American":

the US auto complex isn't making things that the (general) consumer wants.

They have to cut too many corners to meet a price point that will convince the consumer that they're getting value for their dollar.

Outside of the light truck market, there's not much to like from Detroit in the vein of the "under $30k" segment. At least that's what the consumer has voted, with their dollars. Ford has the Focus which they've finally sorted out it would seem. That's the only one that comes to mind, tho. Mustang/Camaro/Challenger are too niche to sell in large volume. GM tried to fight Mazda with the Solstice/Sky, but it was too little, too late, and again too niche to be called bread and butter for any of these large companies.

If the US auto complex was *serious* about "making cars" instead of "printing money for it's current and former employees" about 10 years ago, they wouldn't be in this situation.

The suits were too spineless to tell the UAW to get bent when renegotiating contracts. The UAW was only looking out for themselves, and thus started killing the golden goose. If both sides had been a bit better at looking out for the bottom line of the company that kept them both in a paycheck, the US auto complex wouldn't be in freefall, and in turn, Detroit would be a place to actually go to work, not leave to find work.

On top of all of that, what has the Michigan state legislature done to attract other industries? Good tax codes that make it attractive to open business and employ people there? It wouldn't appear that has happened either, as Ford decided to open their biggest plant in Brazil, not in Detroit.

In the end, it's people that are the problem, and ultimately, the solution. Not the government.

Very well said. Hit the nail on the head.

I 3rd that. I really like what you said about the UAW. They're pricks and I hate them, but I also hate unions in general. What I really can't wait for is the day the automakers don't have unions. All they did was add to the problem and pushed for undeserved wages. Pay $100,000 to stand and bolt together a car? It's a job that has to be done right, but really...100k? get lost. Better yet, just get the fuck out.

To add...I've been saying almost exactly this for a quite a while. Americans are stuck on this 'Buy American' bullshit, it's BULLSHIT. Hardly anything is 'made in America', and just because it may be assembled in America doesn't mean you're buying true American. There isn't a true American product anymore.

But basically everything you said is exactly why I'll never buy an 'American' car again. In addition, the cars cost more than others, perform less, break down more, and overall, in my opinion, just can't really compete anymore with the others. I mean, those reasons, plus the fact that the Big 3 let happen what has happened to them. That's right, they LET this happen to them, and it was only a matter of time before shit hit the fan, and because of the economic situation, that time has come. As Yoda would put it, "Hitting fan, shit has".

I drive a Pontiac but I'll never buy another again. I don't mean I won't buy a new one because they're closing, I mean a Pontiac in general, from anyone, because I don't want to. Why would I buy a car from a brand that is closing? Why would I buy a car from a brand, owned by an automaker with multiple failing brands? Why would I buy a car from an automaker who, in my opinion, has done a lot of failing in recent years? I wouldn't. I won't. Depending on what my income is in the future, I'm going to buy a VW, Honda, BMW, Mercedes, or Porsche.

<Rant off>
 
Oh but to be back on topic, I live in Cleveland, OH. There has been so many job losses, especially recently, here that I can get to work in the morning with ease on the highway. Back in just December, there was fairly heavy traffic and even jams depending on the time. But anymore....there isn't. There have been so many job cuts that there aren't even traffic jams (where I am at, at least). Michigan is pretty rough too. My aunt just lost her job a week ago. She was an assistant/secretary. I don't know if she was laid off or fired, they couldn't give her a straight answer, or a reason.
 
I like all the "OUT OF A JOB YET? KEEP BUYING FOREIGN!" stickers on the cars around Detroit that the UAW passed out to them. I should get a bumper sticker for the back of my Evo that says "OUT OF A JOB YET? KEEP WORKING UNION!". But then, I'm sure it would get sledgehammered and torched to the ground.
laugh.gif
 
Did any of you check out the Best Cities List? Looks like a good part of them are southern cities, with 7 out of the top 10 being Texas cities and even Louisiana has 2 cities in the top 20. But, like others have said, it's all relative; the economy down here pretty much sucks too right now. The oil drilling industry (which I work in) is having severe doldrums right now and there have been thousands laid off in it in the last 6 months or so.:(

And you people from up north that are thinking of moving south for a job, listen up. Be prepared to suffer tremendously from the heat/humidity if you move along the southern coastal plains. You really don't know what heat is until you work in south LA or along the TX coast in the July-September time frame.:eek:
 
I like all the "OUT OF A JOB YET? KEEP BUYING FOREIGN!" stickers on the cars around Detroit that the UAW passed out to them. I should get a bumper sticker for the back of my Evo that says "OUT OF A JOB YET? KEEP WORKING UNION!". But then, I'm sure it would get sledgehammered and torched to the ground.
laugh.gif
It's so stupid and retarded with that "KEEP BUYING FOREIGN!" sticker. Honda and Toyota makes a good number of their cars here in the US using American products to assemble their cars and do you see them having financial problems at all? Fuck no. Instead we're shelling out billions of dollars to the Big 3 that still haven't changed their concept or told the UAW to take a fucking hike.

When I graduate from school, my car I'm going to be buying is most likely going to be Toyota. My experience with them has been nothing but good. Fuck the Big 3 and they still haven't been able to make a car that is efficient and affordable. Sure they're coming out with cars like that but it's a little bit too late for me to change my mind.
 
I have been contemplating leaving Florida for a while now for either Texas or California. Texas is closer and doing much better so this seems like a good time to head to the [H]'s [H]ome state :cool:



Interesting.

Michigan dominated the Worst cities for jobs (no surprise there) and Texas dominated Best cities for jobs.


Never been to Texas, but is it really all that?

Thinking about leaving O-hi-O in the next couple years and have considered Texas on a couple occasions.

qft. I have the hardest time getting this across to my wife sometimes. Simply moving to another city won't necessarily just magically make everything better.

Anyway, that said, we've had our eye on Austin for quite a while. We might make the move early next year, but who knows. Were initially planning on it for the beginning of this year, but w/ the "z0mg3c0nomies!!!" I was hesitant to voluntarily leave my current job.

To all the people contemplating Texas, I say do it! Times are still hard for some people here, but in general, our city (Austin) and Texas in general has not been doing nearly as bad as other states and cities. Texas is great for outdoor activities, sunny weather a lot, it does get hot in the summer, but thats just a great exscuse to go to lake Travis, or float the river in San Marcos, go swimming, or have a BBQ. Austin, San Marcos, and San Antonio are great, Houston and Dallas as well, but those cities are obviously a lot bigger. Houston traffic sucks! Austins is not the best either, actually I think ratio wise its one of the worst.


Also, one great thing to remember is that Austin has a Fry's Electronics :)
 
Back
Top