Best 500-650W PSU?

taylort232

n00b
Joined
Mar 14, 2008
Messages
44
I am looking for a $50-100 500-650W PSU to run my system. So far I have looked at the BFG LS-550 and the Rosewill RP550V2-D-SL. Any other suggestions?

C2D e6300 @ 3.15ghz
8800GT
2GB RAM
2x HDD
2x DVD
 
The LS-550 or even 450 would be a good choice for your system, since your power needs are fairly small. Other good choices are the Corsair VX450 or VX550 and the Antec Earthwatts series of PSUs..
 
I currently have an Antec Earthwatts 380W and it is starting to fail after ~2-3 years of use, so I'd like to have something that will last longer. How is the BFG GS series?
 
Do realize that the TR2 is also one of the cheapest Power Supplies at Newegg for a reason.Last I checked the TR2 supported less than 20A on the 12v rail, which is way too low compared to other 430W like the EA-430 or even 400W units like the 400CX.

The one you linked doesn't even show the maximum load on the individual rails. That in itself takes the PSU out of contention. The ones stated by Zero, Whisper and I are all good units made for long term stability for the OP's current rig and allows for expansion as needed.
 
Good power supply on the cheap. Same company that makes the Thermaltake 430 TR2 that has sold more units than any other on Newegg I believe.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817339012
hec PSUs are not quality units. Any >=500W unit for under $50 should be heavily scrutinized before you even consider purchasing it, and the lack of active PFC, 25C rating, poor efficiency rating of 75% or higher, and lack of a proper output chart should be obvious indicators that this is not a PSU you would want running your system.
 
dang JG, 49 bucks + free freight is such a awesome deal for a LS-450.
 
Awesome deal but I do have a question: I am looking at putting together a virtual server with vmware running 2 linux servers (opensuse 11.1 and fedora 10) in addition to windows server 2003/2008. No bells and whistes. It'll have an old HP DVD burner and the same config as in my signature (might subsitute the Q6600 for a Q8200).

Will this PSU suffice? The mobo manual indicates 500 or greater but since I am not looking at using this as a gaming rig or anything elaborate, I was just wondering.
 
Awesome deal but I do have a question: I am looking at putting together a virtual server with vmware running 2 linux servers (opensuse 11.1 and fedora 10) in addition to windows server 2003/2008. No bells and whistes. It'll have an old HP DVD burner and the same config as in my signature (might subsitute the Q6600 for a Q8200).

Will this PSU suffice? The mobo manual indicates 500 or greater but since I am not looking at using this as a gaming rig or anything elaborate, I was just wondering.

Depending on the number of HDDs you're going to have, you should be fine.

The recommendation is probably based on mid-range to low rated PSUs as well as having mid-range to high GPU.
 
Depending on the number of HDDs you're going to have, you should be fine.

The recommendation is probably based on mid-range to low rated PSUs as well as having mid-range to high GPU.

Any where from 2-4 Sata II drives. The windows box will be a file server, RRAS, DHCP, DC running Active Directory. The linux systems will be running a webserver with control panel and the other running a bulletin board system.

I dont really want to spend alot of money on a PSU but I also dont want to skimp on the PSU either.
 
Any where from 2-4 Sata II drives. The windows box will be a file server, RRAS, DHCP, DC running Active Directory. The linux systems will be running a webserver with control panel and the other running a bulletin board system.

I dont really want to spend alot of money on a PSU but I also dont want to skimp on the PSU either.

Well with the Q8200, there is going to be a slight drop in power usage. Not using a high end video card will also drop power usage as well. I only brought up HDDs because start up on those can draw about 2A off the 12V rail a piece. With 8-10 drives, spin up on all those at once could cause undue stress on the PSU. With 4 drives, you shouldn't have any problems. The LS series are really good PSUs from BFG.

Making a comparison to my system. I'm currently using an overclocked Q6600, a 4850, 2 HDDs, and 8GB or RAM. It's being handled by a 520W power supply just fine. I even have room to upgrade that 4850 to something like a 4890 or whatever ATi is going to offer with the RV870 (assuming it's under 10" since my case is short). The GPU alone on my machine could use upto 110W from some reports. Replacing that with a lower powered GPU (30-40W) would make a 450W like the LS-450 okay.
 
Sounds good. I am going to move my current nvidia 7300GS over to the new rig using the LS 450 and purchase a higher end GPU for my current system which is in my sig. Idealistically, I would like to have 3 or 4 500GB drives running one OS on each drive with windows sharing a partition on one of the fileserver drives. If I buy terabyte drives, then I will need fewer drives total in the system and just partition everything for each OS but I would like the HD intense appsto share partitions on drives with less hd intense apps. Anyhow, this PSU looks like it should do me well until I need to add more or bigger drives for either the webserver or the file server.

Thanks for the advice. FYI: I did see this same PSU on The Egg for 69.99 w/ $20 MIR but without Free Shipping. The only reason I am mentioning this is because some people were complaining of BFG taking sometime to process and ship this unit.
Here is the link: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817702014&Tpk=BFG LS-450

But if BFG is doing freeshipping AND they are not in california, I could save some cash on shipping, taxes and the overall price of the unit. Sounds sweet.
 
LS-550 is good but even a $40 Corsair 400CX would power that system just fine.
 
LS-550 is good but even a $40 Corsair 400CX would power that system just fine.

So would the LS-550 be a better deal with the 4 12volt rails even though its $10 more, has $20 MIR, doesnt come with free shipping and tax would be assed?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817702008&Tpk=LS-550

I did see a S&D refurbished LS-550 on BFG site but I tend to stay away from those. It was $50 as well.
http://www.bfgstore.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=BFGS550WGSPSU&CartID=1

Not that I am considering it, but I did look at it :p I've purchased S&D monitors before and never had a problem with them for years. I actually still have one and its like 7yrs old and still ticking.
 
Unless Newegg has a lot of backstock the BFG LS-550 has changed OEMs from Forepoint to Enhance and now has a single 42A/504W rail

The Refurb you linked to is the GS, not the LS...the GS is a completely different animal, and it not on par with the LS. $50 is about where a brand new full warranty GS should sell(newegg has them for $54), not a refurb 1 year warranty GS.

Buy.com has had the LS-550 for as low as $60 before, but they are out of stock now

Directron has them for $66 <-Link

If rebates don't bother you, and you would really like to have over 550W, then I say have at it.
 
Thanks for clarifying. I recently built a system and when purchasing a power supply, I was explicityly told to make sure I got a a dual rail system by someone. So I went out and purchased a Coolermaster as shown here: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817171023&nm_mc=TEMC-RMA-Approvel&cm_mmc=TEMC-RMA-Approvel-_-Content-_-text-_-N82E16817171023

It is deactivated and there were only 179+ reviews of this PSU so I am wondering if I should put that PSU in the new rig and buy another one for my current rig. Granted, nothing is wrong with the Coolermaster. I have had it since november/december 2008 and have no problems with it but I am wondering should I get somethign like the BFG 450/550 (more so the 550) for my current rig. What do you think?
 
Naw, the Realpower Pro 650W is of decent quality. You'll be fine. You lucked out too. I though you got the Extreme Power 650W, which is the baaaaaadd Coolermaster PSU.
 
Thanks for clarifying. I recently built a system and when purchasing a power supply, I was explicityly told to make sure I got a a dual rail system by someone. So I went out and purchased a Coolermaster as shown here: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817171023&nm_mc=TEMC-RMA-Approvel&cm_mmc=TEMC-RMA-Approvel-_-Content-_-text-_-N82E16817171023

It is deactivated and there were only 179+ reviews of this PSU so I am wondering if I should put that PSU in the new rig and buy another one for my current rig. Granted, nothing is wrong with the Coolermaster. I have had it since november/december 2008 and have no problems with it but I am wondering should I get somethign like the BFG 450/550 (more so the 550) for my current rig. What do you think?

the Coolermaster looks to be a good unit. i do believe it is an Enhance built unit (maybe someone else can confirm that). thats the same oem as the BFG LS-series. i think the CM would do well in your new rig and if you can get away with the cheaper LS-450 for your current rig i'd think that is a good plan.
 
the Coolermaster looks to be a good unit. i do believe it is an Enhance built unit (maybe someone else can confirm that). thats the same oem as the BFG LS-series. i think the CM would do well in your new rig and if you can get away with the cheaper LS-450 for your current rig i'd think that is a good plan.

The Real Power Pro Series 750W and below are Acbel.
 
Back
Top