Google Street View Does Not Invade Personal Privacy

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A UK privacy watchdog says that Google’s Street View does not invade personal privacy. Bonus: The article contains one of the best Google Street View snapshots I’ve seen all week (hint: boobies).

Google's Street View provoked a storm of controversy during its launch last month. The free service, available on the Google Maps website, allows anyone in the world to type in an address and view a 360 degree picture of the street.
 
Safe for work (and nothing special). Just a chick looking away from the camera with a low cut top.

No invasion of privacy with Streetview. If it's in public, it ain't private.
 
Great set of tits but I bet her teeth are atrocious.
 
Exactly. If you can see it from the street, it isn't being kept very private, now is it? :rolleyes:

I don't agree for a number of reasons.

My driveway and its contents is on public display for anyone with a PC, otherwise you would have to actually drive past my home to "scope things out"

Google has gone over the line with street view on private homes.
 
I don't agree for a number of reasons.

My driveway and its contents is on public display for anyone with a PC, otherwise you would have to actually drive past my home to "scope things out"

Google has gone over the line with street view on private homes.

its not like they have a driver drive by your house every hour on the hour and broadcast it to the public threw the internet, THINGS CHANGE OVER 1 YEARS TIME. you make it seem as if a robber is going to use the info to get into your house just by knowing a single photo. the photos dont even get a time or actual date.
 
I don't agree for a number of reasons.

My driveway and its contents is on public display for anyone with a PC, otherwise you would have to actually drive past my home to "scope things out"

Unless you have a tall fence around your house that you can't see through. or tall shrubs, then what you can see from the street is not really "private". What difference does it make if they have to drive past your house or if they can see it online? It's equally plausible to do either one. Do you really think someone is going to see your house from across the country, and drive hundreds of miles to steal things? Considering that the Google Street View pictures were taken at some random time over the last couple years, who's to say that the pictures are even an accurate representation of what is still there?

Honestly, I think driving or walking past a house is far more "invasive" of privacy than looking at a Google Street View, and there's really nothing to stop people from doing that. In fact, people do it inadvertently every day. :p
 
Do you really think someone is going to see your house from across the country, and drive hundreds of miles to steal things?

Who said anything about theft? I purchased a home for privacy, not to have Google broadcast the contents of my yard and driveway to everyone on the planet.
 
I find it amusing that there is folks on this board that flip out about the thought of "data mining" but it is perfectly a-ok for a company to photograph you private abode and make those pictures available to anyone with a computer.
 
Who said anything about theft? I purchased a home for privacy, not to have Google broadcast the contents of my yard and driveway to everyone on the planet.

So, let me get this straight.

You keep objects in your yard and driveway that you don't want other people to see?

Where is there any semblance of logic in that reasoning? Why should anyone think that anything on their lawn or driveway, in plain view of the public, is private? What are you going to do, go outside with a gun and if someone looks at your yard, threaten them?

You bought a house to have privacy, not the yard and driveway. If you don't want people to see inside your house, shut the drapes. Otherwise, shut up about privacy if you aren't going to take measures to ensure that you have it.
 
I find it amusing that there is folks on this board that flip out about the thought of "data mining" but it is perfectly a-ok for a company to photograph you private abode and make those pictures available to anyone with a computer.

Your "abode" is not private if it sits in view of a public street. In addition, Google Street View is not updated in real time, or even anything approaching real time. The data showing my house is months old, for example.

There is little or no harm that can come from someone being able to view the outside of your home as it appeared several weeks or months ago. A person from the Internet has to already know your address to even know where to look, and when they do, the odds of them seeing anything useful are minimal. They cannot see if a window is unlocked, or if you do not lock your back door at night. They cannot see you fapping it in your shower.

Can you give any practical examples of how your home as it appeared weeks or months ago being pictured on street view causes a real issue? I mean beyond any objection just on principle, of course.
 
Your "abode" is not private if it sits in view of a public street.

While this is true, does this give them the right?

In addition, Google Street View is not updated in real time, or even anything approaching real time. The data showing my house is months old, for example.

Why do people keep harping on this? Does this somehow make it right?

I mean beyond any objection just on principle, of course.

I'll be the first to admit I'm big on priciple.

Perhaps its an issue of reasonable expectations- I'm perfectly fine with people driving by, but then again if I saw someone out in the driveway taking pictures of my home you can bet either they would get a visit from me requesting THEIR home information or at least the plate copied down and reported to the police.

In this area it would definitely fall under suspicious activity, I'd report it if my neighbors house as well.

Photographers need releases from people before their images can be used, why should the property I paid for be any different?

No address is needed for streetview either, all you have to do is click an area and move down the street one house at a time.
 
While this is true, does this give them the right?
I think anybody has a right to view anything over the Internet that they could view legally with their own two eyes. Why we would we put MORE restrictions on a LESS personal view of your property?

Why do people keep harping on this? Does this somehow make it right?
Right or wrong is a personal view, but what is a fact is that it makes it almost useless for any nefarious espionage-like purpose.


I'll be the first to admit I'm big on priciple.

Me too, but in this case I don't feel my privacy is being encroached on. I just don't see what harm could come. No one has ever explained to me what that harm could be.

Perhaps its an issue of reasonable expectations- I'm perfectly fine with people driving by, but then again if I saw someone out in the driveway taking pictures of my home you can bet either they would get a visit from me requesting THEIR home information or at least the plate copied down and reported to the police.

In this area it would definitely fall under suspicious activity, I'd report it if my neighbors house as well.
If someone is specifically targeting YOUR house then yeah, there's an issue. That activity is an indication of some ill intent. Someone taking some low quality pictures of every house indiscriminately is not intending to commit any crime. The person viewing those pictures, if they intended to use it for some crime, could actually get more information from just driving by your house, one time, which you said was okay with you.



Photographers need releases from people before their images can be used, why should the property I paid for be any different?
It would be an undue burden to require people to seek the rights to have someones home or property in their photograph. You'd be unable to take a picture anywhere because someones property would always be in frame, and if you did, you could never post it publicly.


No address is needed for streetview either, all you have to do is click an area and move down the street one house at a time.

I'm aware of how street view works, what I was suggesting there is that someone who does not know where you live cannot determine where you live using street view. They'd have to know which house was yours already, and if they know that, they know enough to just drive by if they want. If they cant drive by, then they probably can't do much to harm you.
 
I think anybody has a right to view anything over the Internet that they could view legally with their own two eyes.

How about phone number? Personal Information? Credit data? DMV records?

Why we would we put MORE restrictions on a LESS personal view of your property?

What part of private property is hard to understand? Public property I don't have a problem with.

Me too, but in this case I don't feel my privacy is being encroached on.

We disagree then, politely enough.

If someone is specifically targeting YOUR house then yeah, there's an issue. That activity is an indication of some ill intent. Someone taking some low quality pictures of every house indiscriminately is not intending to commit any crime.

You have no problem with a very profitable corporation with questionable motives (EULA for Chrome for one example) taking pictures of a large number of private homes?

Those camera vehicles don't work for free, at some point there is money in it for Google.

It would be an undue burden to require people to seek the rights to have someones home or property in their photograph.

Again, we disagree. You dismiss my right as an property owner for Googles convenience.

My point of few is tha a company that operates for profit has taken a picture of my property and made it available to anyone with an internet connection without so much as a "by your leave"

Personal pictures with my home in the background? I don't have a problem with (not that there is anywhere to take pictures with my house in the background, which is another story) Posted by a corporation in a searchable database?

Yes I do have a problem with that and so should you.
 
I disagree. It's just not that big of a deal. A picture of your house on the Internet is not an invasion of your privacy.
 
To all those that think the outside of you home is private, go stand there buck naked and see just how long your privacy lasts. Use logic people.
 
How about phone number? Personal Information? Credit data? DMV records?

I said anything they could view legally with their own two eyes. So phone number, yes if it's listed. The other stuff is not available to everyone. You missed my point entirely.

What part of private property is hard to understand? Public property I don't have a problem with.

What the outside of your property looks like is not private, at least not from a legal standpoint. In fact, if you have junk in your yard and people don't like they way it looks, the city can make you remove it. So there is definitely a pre-established public interest in how the outside of your property looks.

You have no problem with a very profitable corporation with questionable motives (EULA for Chrome for one example) taking pictures of a large number of private homes?

Those camera vehicles don't work for free, at some point there is money in it for Google.

Are you implying that they are somehow selling information on your home? They make the pictures available for free on the Internet. The max they could do is put an advertisement on the page, and that doesn't affect you in the least. We can talk about the evil corporations and their filthy profits and their secret motives, but that's just speculation. There is no proof of anything wrong going on there.

Again, we disagree. You dismiss my right as an property owner for Googles convenience.

Not just Google. Anyone who takes a picture that has someone elses property in it. If I make the picture with your home in it freely available, or if Google does it, it is all the same.

My point of few is tha a company that operates for profit has taken a picture of my property and made it available to anyone with an internet connection without so much as a "by your leave"
Why does it bug you so much that Google is a company that makes money? That seems to indicate your issue isn't with privacy at all, but with companies.

Personal pictures with my home in the background? I don't have a problem with (not that there is anywhere to take pictures with my house in the background, which is another story) Posted by a corporation in a searchable database?

Yes I do have a problem with that and so should you.

It doesn't matter to me who posts it. The benefit to someone trying to locate a home or business that they are going to, and the various other uses for StreetView vastly outweigh any concerns I have about it.
 
I disagree. It's just not that big of a deal. A picture of your house on the Internet is not an invasion of your privacy.

Oh?

A local newpaper published a picture of a local house with a 1969 GTX parked in the driveway, the owner is still being deluged with phonecalls and people knocking on his door. All the locals know better than to bother the guy, its been there for 20 years.

Park a hemi Cuda in your driveway and see how much peace and quiet you get, not much and I bet the car will be gone within a week.
 
I said anything they could view legally with their own two eyes. So phone number, yes if it's listed. The other stuff is not available to everyone. You missed my point entirely.

You missed mine- At what point do you stop? Where is the line?

What the outside of your property looks like is not private, at least not from a legal standpoint. In fact, if you have junk in your yard and people don't like they way it looks, the city can make you remove it. So there is definitely a pre-established public interest in how the outside of your property looks.

Which is an issue with you and the locals and what locals are willing to accept, arguing about peoples yards in this town won't get you far. Owners rights have a bit more weight then what the local busybodies think.

Are you implying that they are somehow selling information on your home?

How do you know they are not? They are a for profit company.

Google collects a lot of data, one could safely assume some of it is sold to other companies as would be an industry practice.

They make the pictures available for free on the Internet.

Again, you waive away what I think or any rights because it is currently free.

The max they could do is put an advertisement on the page, and that doesn't affect you in the least.

See post above about selling of data.

Not just Google. Anyone who takes a picture that has someone elses property in it. If I make the picture with your home in it freely available, or if Google does it, it is all the same.

No it isn't- Do you offer that photo in a searchable database with my address tagged to it?

Why does it bug you so much that Google is a company that makes money?

Not in the least, I object to my home being used without permission and being plastered on google maps. Personally I think that companies should charge for what the market will take, you can always walk away if the price is too high.

It doesn't matter to me who posts it.

We disagree on this point.

The benefit to someone trying to locate a home or business that they are going to, and the various other uses for StreetView vastly outweigh any concerns I have about it.

Rolls eyes.

You give people directions, thats what we did in the old days before mapquest or google.
 
Arguing with gdonovan is pointless. He doesn't like streetview and doesn't think it should be around. Most people don't care as they're not showing anything you can't see by walking down the street. Fact is, they don't seem to be breaking any laws here so deal with it.
 
Arguing with gdonovan is pointless. He doesn't like streetview and doesn't think it should be around.

Sorry I don't indulge in groupthink.

I never stated I thought streetview should be around, I object to private property being displayed by a company without owners permission.

I have made the point several times now, I need a macro for my keyboard.
 
Damn lack of edit button.

"I never stated I thought streetview should NOT be around"
 
Back
Top