Delivering a Quality Windows 7 Upgrade Experience

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Windows 7 design team says that upgrading to the upcoming release candidate of Windows 7 is going to be a bit tricky and they are asking beta testers for their help. The first option allows you to upgrade the current beta build but this method is decidedly more complicated than the second option, reverting to Vista and then upgrading. Microsoft says they would prefer people use the second option because they are looking for potential headaches, hassles and hang-ups that could delay the final product. Hit the link to read the whole blog entry.

This is a little bit of a tricky post to write because we’re going to be asking everyone using our Windows 7 Beta to help us out, but doing so is going to take a little time and require a bit of a commitment to helping test the next milestone. This has been a remarkably valuable and beneficial testing cycle for Windows as we have had a tremendous amount of very rigorous testing and usage. We’ve had millions of people install and use the Beta since January and as we’ve talked about, the feedback and telemetry have been of tremendous value as we finalize the product. The effort of Beta testers has contributed immensely to our ability to deliver a high-quality product to hundreds of millions of customers.
 
So is Windows 7 only gonna offer the option to install as an upgrade over Vista and not XP or what? I know you're always better off with a clean install, and by the time it's out I'll probably be using Vista on most of my machines ('cept the netbook), just curious anyway.
 
You can install it fresh, however they are not supporting direct upgrades from previous beta versions of W7 without changing the installer files.
 
Well I was referring to the final finished copy of W7 after it's out and boxed, not necessarily the betas... (yes I know it's slightly OT to the thread, sry)
 
So is Windows 7 only gonna offer the option to install as an upgrade over Vista and not XP or what? I know you're always better off with a clean install, and by the time it's out I'll probably be using Vista on most of my machines ('cept the netbook), just curious anyway.

You can upgrade from windows XP to Windows 7. If that isn't in the beta now (not sure as I haven't tried it), they have already confirmed that there is an upgrade path from XP to 7. So you will be able to do so when it comes out.

If you can't do that right now then I would assume that would be in the first RC as they would want to test that also. Maybe they want to get Vista to 7 fully working first, then work out any bugs going from xp to 7.

Whats a quality Windows Upgrade?

Go get back under your bridge.
 
I find it funny in a way how they are almost begging people to actually TEST the OS they downloaded instead of using it as a free copy of windows. This is really the horrible part

Again, we know many people (including tens of thousands at Microsoft) are relying on the pre-release builds of Windows 7 for mission critical and daily work, making this step less than convenient

Who the hell uses a BETA OS in a mission critcal environment?

Any machine that you install a beta OS on should be able to be taken down at any moment and be wiped and reinstalled.

I guess that goes to say that it is a pretty stable OS if people feel that safe about using it like that. But that shouldn't be the case that people install it as a finalized product and never look back and be against do any actual testing.
 
Well, it's a testament to how well it's running, though it's essentially Vista w/a fresh coat of paint so that isn't a huge surprise. I'm glad they're worried about actually testing it though, nothin' funny about that, it's what they should be doing.
 
You can upgrade from windows XP to Windows 7. If that isn't in the beta now (not sure as I haven't tried it), they have already confirmed that there is an upgrade path from XP to 7. So you will be able to do so when it comes out.

If you can't do that right now then I would assume that would be in the first RC as they would want to test that also. Maybe they want to get Vista to 7 fully working first, then work out any bugs going from xp to 7.



Go get back under your bridge.



Actually, no you won't be able to upgrade from XP directly to Windows 7. You will need to do a clean install, there is going to be some sort of tool to help you backup your data, settings, etc though.

You will however be able to get "upgrade" pricing coming from Windows XP. But again, you will need to do a clean install.
 
Ehh... Just as well, whenever I end up installing it on the netbook I should do a clean install anyway. I was more concerned with that system than my desktops since on those I can just re-partition drives and handle image backups relatively easily while I migrate stuff, it's a little more annoying to do on the netbook.
 
So is Windows 7 only gonna offer the option to install as an upgrade over Vista and not XP or what? I know you're always better off with a clean install, and by the time it's out I'll probably be using Vista on most of my machines ('cept the netbook), just curious anyway.

Windows 7 and vista have alot it common, not so with XP so i wouldnt be suprised that if they did allow an XP upgrade it would ideally be a complete reinstall and somehow saves your files...
 
Well, it's a testament to how well it's running, though it's essentially Vista w/a fresh coat of paint so that isn't a huge surprise. I'm glad they're worried about actually testing it though, nothin' funny about that, it's what they should be doing.

Its a hell of a lot more than that.
 
I missed the Windows 7 beta. How is it for gaming?

My friend and I put Windows 7 on one of his rigs. We dual booted it with 7 and with Vista. The two games we tested actually got lower FPS in Windows 7 than in Vista, likely due to drivers being immature for those particular games.

The interesting part, is that regardless of the lower FPS both games played smoother and just felt "better" in Windows 7. Quite unexpected.
 
Its a hell of a lot more than that.

There are still people that make broad generalizations like that. Those same people said that Vista was just a sugarcoated XP, even though they changed a substantial amount under the hood, and reworked many of the core functions of Windows from the ground up. Regardless of Vista's bugs at release (which weren't any more extreme than when XP first came out) it opened the door to a much more fluid, enjoyable, and intuitive interface. Windows 7 brings in some additional features and stability that we wanted in Vista, but it's still more than just a fresh coat of paint. A fresh coat of paint would merely cover up bloat, whereas they're taking active steps to reduce bloat across the board. In most testing I've researched 7 boasts noticeably better boot times than Vista as well as better multi-core utilization. Several things do bear the analogy of a "fresh coat of paint" well, but these tweaks could come via service plan. While they did polish things up a bit that needed polishing, I think Windows 7 is a bit more than merely a fresh coat of paint.
 
If I can upgrade my current 64-bit Vista build to Windows 7, without spending hours upon hours reinstalling all my old apps and games... I'm sold quite frankly.
 
Heh, I find it funny how they are asking those who have access to a Vista product key to reformat and install Vista to upgrade to Windows 7 RC. I've got this scene in my mind...

Tailor: " I've made a new design for your clothes that I want you to try out."
Customer: "Cool!"
Tailor: "But there is a small problem, you can't go from the old design to the new one. It's a bit problematic. I need you to put on this iron maiden first and then put on the new clothes!"

:D
 
The last time I "upgraded" it was from 3.1 to 95. Does anyone actually do upgrades?

PS. I miss progman.exe... Damn kids with their start bars and close window buttons!
 
the very definition of the placebo effect right there....

I think it's because minimum frame rates were higher. The games we used were older anyways, and were well above 60fps average, so neither one was going to be jittery, it just seemed like there were less drops when using Windows 7. Of course it could just be because my friend's Vista install is jacked arriba or something...
 
Actually, no you won't be able to upgrade from XP directly to Windows 7. You will need to do a clean install, there is going to be some sort of tool to help you backup your data, settings, etc though.

You will however be able to get "upgrade" pricing coming from Windows XP. But again, you will need to do a clean install.

Damn, that you for that information. I guess I must have miss read that awhile ago when Microsoft said that were was an upgrade path from XP. This is the 3rd or so time then that I have incorrectly tried to correct somebody about the ability to install an upgrade from xp to 7 and keep all your stuff. So they just meant purchase wise. So it is the same as 2000 to Vista then. You can buy the upgrade license and "upgrade" from 2000 to Vista. However you have to do it as a clean install. That program you are talking about is the FIle and settings transfer wizard that was in XP that allowed you to copy your data and settings from 98 - XP into your new XP install, which in Vista was renamed Easy File Transfer. That is the same that you have to do for 2000 to Vista, 32-bit to 64-bit, or xp 64-bit to anything.

Microsoft does. It's called "eating your own dogfood."

There is a difference with Microsoft using it in house as much as possible for testing and the outside world using it as a finalized product and being fully unable to unstinall the OS or do any testing that might "break" their install thus causing major issues with their company.

Heh, I find it funny how they are asking those who have access to a Vista product key to reformat and install Vista to upgrade to Windows 7 RC. I've got this scene in my mind...

Tailor: " I've made a new design for your clothes that I want you to try out."
Customer: "Cool!"
Tailor: "But there is a small problem, you can't go from the old design to the new one. It's a bit problematic. I need you to put on this iron maiden first and then put on the new clothes!"

:D

They want people to TEST the upgrade. How else are they going to know for sure if it works correctly is nobody test it. That is suppose to be the point of being using the beta software. You are suppose to be testing it under any circumstance that a user might go through to see if you can break it.
 
I signed up for the beta test program and I have had good results with Windows 7. Will I be able to get the current build they are referring to?
 
I signed up for the beta test program and I have had good results with Windows 7. Will I be able to get the current build they are referring to?

Nope, only those in the private beta get the up to date releases. The rest of us that got it from the open beta will just have to wait for RC 1 to be released to get a newer version of the OS.
 
Damn, that you for that information. I guess I must have miss read that awhile ago when Microsoft said that were was an upgrade path from XP. This is the 3rd or so time then that I have incorrectly tried to correct somebody about the ability to install an upgrade from xp to 7 and keep all your stuff. So they just meant purchase wise. So it is the same as 2000 to Vista then. You can buy the upgrade license and "upgrade" from 2000 to Vista. However you have to do it as a clean install. That program you are talking about is the FIle and settings transfer wizard that was in XP that allowed you to copy your data and settings from 98 - XP into your new XP install, which in Vista was renamed Easy File Transfer. That is the same that you have to do for 2000 to Vista, 32-bit to 64-bit, or xp 64-bit to anything.



There is a difference with Microsoft using it in house as much as possible for testing and the outside world using it as a finalized product and being fully unable to unstinall the OS or do any testing that might "break" their install thus causing major issues with their company.



They want people to TEST the upgrade. How else are they going to know for sure if it works correctly is nobody test it. That is suppose to be the point of being using the beta software. You are suppose to be testing it under any circumstance that a user might go through to see if you can break it.

I guess I missed the part on TechNet that said their was a upgrade path from XP to Windows 7...

I would appreciate links to your facts.
 
I guess I missed the part on TechNet that said their was a upgrade path from XP to Windows 7...

I would appreciate links to your facts.

http://windows7news.com/2009/02/04/windows-xp-to-windows-7-upgrade-confirmed/

Although to make sure you understand my post correctly. My first post stated incorrectly that you could do an inplace upgrade from XP to windows 7. That is not true, I had seen many headlines that stated "Windows XP to Windows 7 upgrade confirmed" and quickly read a few over a few lines of them took them to mean upgrade as an in place upgrade. As pointed out though that is not true, you can use xp as the base for an upgrade licenses, but you can't do an inplace upgrade. If you have windows xp and want to upgrade to windows 7 then you will need to do a clean install just as you had to do if you tried to upgrade windows 2000 to Vista. So there is an upgrade path in that you can buy Windows 7 upgrade instead of the full edition, howeve there is not an in place upgrade path.
 
I have been running Win 7 Beta on my test (i7 OCed) rig for over a month. It is stable and just feels like a fairly finished product, smooth and quick. This is however a test rig as I am running Vista and even Xp on a notebook for all my mission critical stuff. When the RC-1 of iWin 7 comes out I will wipe the boot drive and reinstall. I have NEVER done an upgrade since Win 95.
Based on what I have experiences, as soon as the commercial version is available I will install Win 7 on all my business and personal units, one at a time of course. They will all be clean installs. Untill then I am enjoying seeing how far I can push my i7 rig and playing with WIn 7. SO far the experience has been a good one.
 
I run 3 Windows 7 machines now. 2 of them I did clean installs on (Each have had multiple 7 builds) and one of them I did a Vista -> 7 upgrade. The Vista -> 7 upgrade experience was HORRIBLE. The install itself took close to 2 hours. Afterwards, half of my apps no longer worked, the libraries feature didn't work and everything hung at least 2-3 times a day. After a week of troubleshooting I did a clean install (Which took less than 20 minutes) and set it up the same way. It's been rock solid.
 
Not suprised. After all it is a Beta and we all have known for years that a clean install works best. My last clean install took 12 minutes. I keep all my data on a seperate drive so really no biggie to do it. I even keep some of my non performance apps on the non boot drive. I moved the page file to the non boot drive (except for a tiny portion for a possiable dump file). All is well with Win 7 for me.
At this point Win 7 is my #1 fav. with Vista now at #2 and Xp #3.
 
I run 3 Windows 7 machines now. 2 of them I did clean installs on (Each have had multiple 7 builds) and one of them I did a Vista -> 7 upgrade. The Vista -> 7 upgrade experience was HORRIBLE. The install itself took close to 2 hours. Afterwards, half of my apps no longer worked, the libraries feature didn't work and everything hung at least 2-3 times a day. After a week of troubleshooting I did a clean install (Which took less than 20 minutes) and set it up the same way. It's been rock solid.

THAT is what they are trying to fix. Did you bother reporting any of that to Microsoft?
 
Not suprised. After all it is a Beta and we all have known for years that a clean install works best. My last clean install took 12 minutes. I keep all my data on a seperate drive so really no biggie to do it. I even keep some of my non performance apps on the non boot drive. I moved the page file to the non boot drive (except for a tiny portion for a possiable dump file). All is well with Win 7 for me.
At this point Win 7 is my #1 fav. with Vista now at #2 and Xp #3.

The point of beta testing isn't to try to get the best install though. It is to find as many ways as you can to break the OS. It doesn't do one bit of good if 98% of the people that downloaded the beta just install it in the most perfect condition that they can then don't try to break it. However that is what it sounds a lot of people are doing, and these are the same assholes that will bitch about some problem that the final version has and how it should have been tested better. With the number of people that downloaded the beta, if they actually did a little bit of testing and any reporting on bugs they found the final version would be damn near rock solid.
 
I have reported bugs, and changes I would like to see but what does that have to do with having to deal with a clean install, especially for a Beta? I agree that when Mr & Ms average user decide to upgrade to Win 7 the upgrade path should be easy and flawless but they are not the type who should be using a Beta anyway.

Whatever!
 
Does anyone know what's the upgrade path gonna look like from beta to retail version? Will you just have to do another clean install? Or will the beta even be usable 'till retail versions ship?
 
Next is RC-1 probibally with a clean install. The original Beta times out in August, the RC-1?? Who knows. I have a hunch that the retail will be out by October.
 
I have reported bugs, and changes I would like to see but what does that have to do with having to deal with a clean install, especially for a Beta? I agree that when Mr & Ms average user decide to upgrade to Win 7 the upgrade path should be easy and flawless but they are not the type who should be using a Beta anyway.

Whatever!

Who said they should be using a beta. However as I ponted out the point of the beta if for Microsoft to find all the bugs. This is how they do bug testing. They release beta versions to testers and the testers give them any bugs they find. Which then then fix, release a newer version which the beta testers then upgrade too and try to see if all the bugs are fixed... YOU the beta tester are suppose to be testing what could happen with the OS so that when joe blow gets the OS and installs it, it will work perfectly no matter how they install it. Same goes for what happens if you press ctrl + windows key + alt. Does nothing happen or does the computer automatically explode. People need to be testing upgrading from XP to windows 7 (even if it does do a clean install of the OS that still needs to be tested to make sure windows 7 knows it is suppose to use the OS as a base for an upgrade), people need to test upgrading from all versions of vista that they have. People need to test doing clean installs on blank harddrives, they need to test doing clean installs on harddrives that have stuff on them that needs to be wiped first.They need to try do installs on machines that should be under spec to make sure they get error messages telling them they machine is too slow or doesn't have enough memory or harddrive space.... If you aren't going to do any real testing then you shouldn't be using the beta any more than Mr & Mrs Average as you aren't any more of a help than they would be.

Yes, I've reported it all to Microsoft. Reports like mine are why they're pushing for more testing.

Yup, and people like you are the ones that understand what a beta test is actually suppose to be.
 
Back
Top