$2300 i7 Gaming Build

RAD

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 12, 2009
Messages
489
Thanks for all of the feedback and education, build complete! (Link to the build log)

Hi everyone. Thank you very much for taking the time to visit my thread. I have heard great things about the HardForum community and I have spent many, many hours surfing your forums. At the end of April I will be pulling the trigger on ordering the following components and building my first computer from scratch. I would love any advice you could give. I am comfortable at the current price point of around $2300 after shipping/tax.

Here are my answers to the standard question array:
1) What will you be doing with this PC? This build is for gaming.
2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included? $2300 after shipping/tax. Thanks to hardforum tinkering the actual price is going to come in around $2000 with better components than my original selection.
3) Where do you live? Northern California
4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? Please be very specific. Everything, including the monitor, sound system and keyboard/mouse.
5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? I am not reusing any parts.
6) Will you be overclocking? I will be overclocking, some.
7) What size monitor do you have or plan to have? A 22" LCD.
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC? At the end of April
9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? I don't need RAID, I do need firewire. I am probably not going to run SLI.
10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? Windows 7 RC.

Some further notes: I really want this computer (with a few upgrades as time goes on) to last me for about 5 years. I do want to overclock it but I don't want to significantly decrease the lifespan of my components below that 5 year window. Some of the parts I have currently selected I know are rather extravagant. I have been informed I could shave about $30 by buying a TRUE instead of the Coolermaster v8, but if the performance is going to be roughly the same I currently am leaning towards the v8 just on style. Some of my other decisions run along the same lines. If performance is roughly equal I am willing to lean towards personal preferred style for slightly more money. I do not download movies, music, or other media so 300 gb of hard drive space is plenty for my purposes.

The following is my component list from Newegg:
Entire List

Here is the list by component for those that don't want to link through to another site:
Case: CM 690 Case with window. Changed from Antec Twelve Hundred - Purchased for $99.98 (case plus window)
Extra fans to fill the case: 2x Scythe SY1225SL12M 120mm "Slipstream" Case Fan Changed from APEVIA CF12SL-UBL 120mm - Purchased for $13.98
1xSilenx 80mm fan - for behind mobo - Purchased for $9.99
Motherboard: GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD4P LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard - Changed from UD5 - Purchased for $259.99
Hard Drive: Western Digital VelociRaptor WD3000HLFS 300GB 10000 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - Purchased $229.99
CPU: Intel Core i7 920 Nehalem 2.66GHz LGA 1366 130W Quad-Core Processor Model BX80601920 - Purchased $279.99
CPU Cooler: COOLER MASTER V8 RR-UV8-XBU1-GP 120mm Rifle CPU Cooler - Purchased for $69.99
CPU Thermal Paste: Arctic Silver 5 Thermal Compound - Purchased $8.99
GPU: EVGA 01G-P3-1285-AR GeForce GTX 285 SC Edition - Changed from XFX GX260NADBF GeForce GTX 260 Black Edition Core 216 896MB - Purchased $354.99
RAM: G.SKILL 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600. Changed from OCZ Platinum 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 - Purchased for $89.99
PSU: CORSAIR CMPSU-750TX 750W - Purchased for $119.99
CD/DVD Reader/Burner: LG Black 22X - Purchased for $24.99
OS: Windows 7 64 bit RC - Free until next year. Changed from Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium SP1 64
Speakers: Logitech X-540 70 watts 5.1 Speaker -Purchased $78.99
Keyboard: Saitek PK02 Eclipse II Changed from RAZER Lycosa - Purchased $44.99
Mouse: Logitech G5 7 Buttons 1 x Wheel USB Laser 2000 dpi Mouse Changed from RAZER DeathAdder - Purchased $44.99
Monitor: 22": LG Flatron L227WTG-PF, 1680x1050 (16:10) - I have decided on this monitor, after reading the anandtech lcd thread - Purchased from Newegg as Best Buy no longer carries. $229.99, zero dead pixels. 7 days later the price dropped to $219 still with free shipping and after I contacted newegg they refunded the $10. Can't beat newegg customer service.

Final price breakdown:
Components: $1,951.82
Tax: $161.84
Shipping: $64.93
Electronic Recycling Fee: $16.00
Total: $2194.89

Office Desk off of Craigslist: $30.00
Office Chair from Target: $161.46

Grand Total: $2386.05
 
Last edited:
Damn, numbers get better and better. 5 years is hella far down the line - 22nm is 2012, add 2 more years to that and... atom-sized CPUs?

1. 1700rpm fans are not quiet
2. No comment on style....
3. Purchase date of April; ATI will have their 4890 out by then that's to compete with the GTX285.
4. You can settle on the cheaper UD3R http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128375 since it doesn't look like you're taking any advantage of the UD5, namely 3xSLI
5. SLI at a "later" date is a bad idea. SLI within a couple/few months is still okay, but beyond that (and if you're reaching into 6+ months) is.. stewpit.
6. You need to decide on monitor size/resolution - 22" is 1680*1050, 24" is 1920*1200.
 
I'd drop the Windows Vista because Windows 7 will be out in less than a year and there's no point in getting Vista at this point (unless you don't plan to upgrade to W7 and plan on staying with Vista).

I'd also recommend getting some good-quality medium speed Yate Loons for the half the price of those LED fans.
 
Thank you all very much for the feedback so far! I really appreciate your help.

I will change my plans as far as using the SLI path as a path to upgrade. Thank you for pointing that error in my concept out. I will also keep an eye out for reviews on the ATI competitor as April comes around to see if it will turn out to be the better option over the gtx285. For the motherboard I will look into downgrading but I would like to keep it as a version with 6 ram slots (this looks to be the ud4p, I have made the change to the build). I am betting I will be throwing 3 more sticks in at some point.

In regards to Windows Vista vs Windows 7: I have read a lot of stuff saying how great Windows 7 is and I would love to have my system just start out on Windows 7. Here is my concern: My understanding is that the windows 7 beta is going to end in August, and if they don't release the OS until October or later I will be without an OS for several months.

I am really on the fence between the 22" monitors and 24" monitors. I appreciate the continued feedback and pros/cons of the different resolution sizes, input lags, refresh rates, image clarities, etc.
 
After doing a lot of reading through various forums, I finally found the anandtech lcd thread. I am thinking I will probably go with the 22": LG Flatron L227WTG-PF, 1680x1050 (16:10). Newegg link here.
 
With a 1680*1050 your choice of video card becomes more flexible, where a GTX285 wouldn't be recommended by most of us - the GTX260 is it for that resolution, or 4850 for a more limited budget.
 
With a 1680*1050 your choice of video card becomes more flexible, where a GTX285 wouldn't be recommended by most of us - the GTX260 is it for that resolution, or 4850 for a more limited budget.

Thank you for the information lowteckh. So far the computer is actually coming in under budget, so I am not too concerned with being economical on this component. May I ask the details of why the gtx260 is better for this build? I am certainly all for saving $100 if I am going to see no improvement at all on the gtx 285!

Is their performance identical on a 22" monitor, or is the change in performance just negligible?

Thanks again!
-RAD

Also, on a side note, down the road when I start buying components, is this where I should post pictures of the building process?
 
Main reason why the GTX260 is recommended on a 22" monitor is that you would not notice a difference between a GTX280/GTX285 and a GTX260 at that low of a resolution. Sure the FPS on the GTX280 will be higher on the GTX260 but you would honestly not notice it. Unless you're getting a 24" monitor or bigger with a res of 1920x1200, then the GTX280 or GTX285 will be recommended.

And yes start posting pics of the build process. Always fun to see in progress pics :)
 
First off, this is your computer so what I offer are just ideas.

Hard drive: You can ditch the 300GB 10K for
Western Digital VelociRaptor WD1500HLFS 150GB 10000 RPM
and
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3250410AS 250GB 7200 RPM
Basically, after rebates, you get 100GB more for $15.

CPU cooler: I hear great things about Scythe
Scythe SCMG-2000 120mm Sleeve CPU Cooler

Keyboard: I love mine and it offers good lighting for nighttime with adjustable light intensity
Saitek Eclipse PZ30AU Black USB Wired Standard Keyboard

So in all you're also saving about $60. Yeah that's not much but could go towards another game since that's the main purpose of the build ;)
 
Parker said:
Keyboard: I love mine and it offers good lighting for nighttime with adjustable light intensity
Saitek Eclipse PZ30AU Black USB Wired Standard Keyboard

This. I have one, its awesome.
 
I went to BestBuy and played with a logitech g5 mouse yesterday and found it to be very comfortable, so I switched the build to one of those. I also switched to the saitek keyboard based on your recommendations and its amazing affordability.

Here are my remaining questions/concerns:
1) If I go from the start with Windows 7 rather than Windows Vista, I may have a period of several months without a valid OS when the Windows 7 beta ends.
2) Downgrading from the gtx285 to the gtx260. I did so on hardforum recommendations but I am really questioning myself on this one. It seems that a graphics card is such an important component that it might be a mistake for me to cheap out on it. My reasoning is that I have eye towards having this computer last me a long time and the 260 may end up obsolete/inadequate faster than the 285.

Thanks for your feedback so far,
RAD
 
1) You can try Vista for 30-90 days after win.7 beta ends. ;) Hopefully win.7 is released within that time frame, lol.

2) Keep in mind that GPUs are the fastest depreciating component in a gaming PC. I've found it much more cost effective to spend less and upgrade more often than to spend more and upgrade less often, especially since GPUs get refreshed every 6-8mo.
 
2) Downgrading from the gtx285 to the gtx260. I did so on hardforum recommendations but I am really questioning myself on this one. It seems that a graphics card is such an important component that it might be a mistake for me to cheap out on it. My reasoning is that I have eye towards having this computer last me a long time and the 260 may end up obsolete/inadequate faster than the 285.
RAD

Here's my way of looking at it. I wouldn't worry about the 260 becoming obsolete sooner than the 285. They're both in the same GTX 200 series. Looking down the road 5 years, there will be many more series that have come out by then. If one of your options was a 9800 series and the other being a GTX 200 series then yeah, the 9800 will be obsolete sooner. But technically I would assume that by then both 260 & 285 will be "obsolete" at roughly the same time. So this brings you back to the comments/advice in this thread on what to choose. For the size monitor that you'll purchase the 260 would be the best option (cost/performance per application). For your resolution, a 285 will only net you a couple more fps which to the naked eye will probably amount to the same visual performance. For $145 cheaper I'd go with GTX200 ftw. :cool:
P.S. If you're not happy with the choice down the road, you can always sale it and probably make up the difference in cost for an upgrade.
 
5. SLI at a "later" date is a bad idea. SLI within a couple/few months is still okay, but beyond that (and if you're reaching into 6+ months) is.. stewpit..

I am going to second this..

Either get SLI now or I suggest getting a slight better card like a 285. If you don't get SLI now, you'll never get SLI. By the time you are even ready to do it, there will be something better and a second card won't be worth your money. My other thing on video cards is get the best one you can afford. Down the road a game at 1680x1050 is not going to be the same as a game today at 1680x1050 (or whatever res you use) so sure a 260 (as some say) is more than enough but it won't always be that way. Don't skimp now unless you plan to upgrade the video card sooner.
 
Well, this doesn't really apply to this build, but I thought I would mention it for fun anyway. I finishing cannibalizing the last of the components from my very dead old desktop for pieces to put into my wife's little HP a706n. I installed my old graphics card (Albatron GeForce 7600gs) into her desktop. The fan is making horrible noises (my research indicated that the stock fans on these graphics cards breakdown fast). I bought this fan to replace it. (ZEROtherm GX700 Ceramic VGA Cooler)

I figure this is a very low stakes / low expense chance to put something together. If I break the card no big deal, I'm out 20 bucks. If it works then it is a (very) little confidence booster on the road to building my computer. I will post a pic or two of my gunked up old fan and the new one when the fan comes.
 
Heh. Ran into one problem, not that it is a big deal. The new fan requires a 3 pin power connector. There is only a 2 pin connector on the graphics card and there isn't an open 3 pin power connector on the motherboard. So on that computer I have the option of having the graphics card fan plugged in, or the exhaust fan in the back of the computer plugged in. Oops.
 
Or you can just get one of those molex to 3Pin Fan power connectors.
 
Beautiful. I didn't even know such a thing existed. Thank you very much. I am running hwmonitor on that computer to keep an eye on the temps until I can go buy one of those. I love you guys.
 
I hate to be the voice of dissent, specially to people more knowledgeable than me but... If you have the money I personally would spring for something a bit higher than a GTX 260. I have a very similar setup (not i7 of course but that wont make a huge difference in games specially at 1680x1050) and I would say a GTX 280 or higher would make a difference, a GTX 260 is not enough. I can run old games at max but newer games start giving me trouble, Far Cry 2 lags pretty badly as soon as I enable 8x AA, Grand Theft Auto 4 (patched to fix memory leaks) plays pretty choppy at 1680x1050 with most settings at medium, specially when it rains or when near water, heck I can't even max out Silkroad!(Crappy free chinese MMORPG)

The price difference between the GTX 260 you selected and a GTX 285 is only $65. If I had to do my build all over again I'd spend the extra $65 for some future headroom and peace of mind :)
 
..and this is my opinion..

Since 1900x1080 is the high def future I would recommend the 24" and gtx285 :)

Trust me.. how often do you buy a monitor? Might as well do it properly..

Think about it this way.. the native resolution of high def video is 1900x1080 which happens to be the native resolution of a 24" monitor.. in which case you would want a gtx285..

I was 95% set on a 22" and gtx260 core 216 card for like 3 weeks but I read around and ended up going over my budget and bought a good 24" dell monitor and a xfx gtx285 black edition and I tell ya.. although the next 2 weeks were tight on the money side of things I am absolutely 100% pleased I went over budget and bought 24".

If you can't afford top range 24", buy a top range 22".. Some 1 once said to me,
"If you are going to do something, do it right".

The size of the monitor isn't all important as it depends on how close you sit to it I think.. the point is.. which ever 1 you get, get the high end value monitor in that particular bracket. eg a top range 22" is better than a shit 30" with lag and motion blur aye? :)

Let me put it this way.. If you bought a 24" and gtx285 you would not wake up tomorrow and go 'man 24" gaming in 1900x1080 res is crap!' would ya? Best to go a bit over budget and get something that will blow you away, rather than save 200 bucks and be like.. 'hmmm.. dunno if that was a good idea.. its not as good as I thought'.

If you cheap out now you will regret it. You can cheap out on somethings but a monitor, speakers and graph card I think are all important ;)

wow that was long.. ;) hope you didn't fall aslee..:eek:zzzzzzzzz
 
Oi and a verbatim v1 gaming mouse and razer lycosa keyboard is just damn cool ;)
 
Fun with junky old components: I took the fan that was making horrible, horrible noises off and put a $20 heatsink from newegg on instead. It was a fun little project, with only one real hitch; the motherboard not having an extra power connector for the fan. Easily solved with a $2 adapter. Thank you for letting me know that part was out there and easily obtainable.

On a side note: I changed my graphics card back to the gtx 285, because it is just so damn cool. I am ok with the extra $100 for it.

Picture 1: The old fan.
oldfan.jpg

Picture 2: Back of the old fan.
oldfan2.jpg

Picture 3 Card with the old fan off of it:
cardwithoutfan.jpg

Picture 4: Card with new fan attached.
cardwithnewfan.jpg

Picture 5: Card in its new home, an itty bitty HP case.
casea.jpg
 
Hi everyone,
I am now at roughly the 2 week mark from ordering my computer. I wanted to reheat this thread and see if I could get a bit more feedback from you all. I think I have settled on getting the geforce 285, even though a 22" monitor may not take full advantage of it.

I have a few outstanding concerns that I was hoping to get all of your feedback on:
1) Antec 902 vs Antec 1200: The more I think about it, the less in love with the idea of a case quite as monstrously large as the Antec 1200. I am not running a server bank and will probably only ever have one to three hard drives in there, so the extra bays provided by the 1200 are a non factor.
However, I don't want to downsize to the 902 if it means that the optional side fan will not fit with a TRUE or V8 or if the interior fan will not fit with a gtx 285.

2) TRUE vs Coolermaster v8: Since I first started planning this build Thermalright has launched a TRUE that includes a high quality fan w/mount and the 1366 bracket at the same price point as the v8. I understand that the TRUE performs better than the v8 IF you put in the time to lap it perfectly, but what about unlapped? I probably am not going to lap my heatsink and I am concerned about the production quality of the TRUE, I have read a lot of reviews stating they really need the lapping as the stock surface is machined relatively poorly. So what wins in a fight between the unlapped TRUE and v8 at the same price point?

3) BenQ G2400WD vs LG L227WTG: I use a 24" monitor at work, and frankly I don't like it. However, this may be a problem with me being at work and not a problem with the monitor size. The BenQ has gotten some great reviews both here on hardforum and elsewhere and I am very tempted by it, even though it is about $150 more than than the LG. However, I am not going to be using the monitor as a hub (not routing my 360, TV, etc through it) so the downside of the LG not having HDMI input isn't too critical for me. I lean one way, then I lean the other. It is a very tough decision. I know I will like the LG, I have used one before and I loved it. It is such an amazingly fast monitor that it almost reminds me of a CRT. I don't know that I will like the BenQ, but it brings a lot to the table; good response times and input lag benchmarks, 1:1 mapping up to 1600x1200, 1920x1080 resolution support, etc.

Thank you all again for all of your invaluable feedback!
 
Last edited:
1) TBH, I personally don't like either case. Construction qualilty and cooling capability does not justify the price IMO. Anyway, The Antec 1200 is only $20 and should be guaranteed to fit the TRUE or V8. That piece of mind is worth the extra $20 IMO.

2) Even unlapped I think the TRUE still outperforms the CM v8, if barely.

3) Monitors are not my area of expertise. You'll get more knowledable answers in the display subforum
 
1) Coolermaster CM690 my friend. Beautiful solid lines, plenty of room for GTX285 and V8 cpu cooler. Great airflow. Cheap as. For the price and even more, in my opinion can't be beaten. Check this out:

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1234744

I built my i7 rig in one.. Say no more ;)


2) Was in the same boat as you. I went the V8, Looks wicked, Cools very cool, No maintenance/ No lapping, easy install, easy cool, easy as. Problem solved

3) Don't fret about having a 22" and a GTX285 man.. think of it as future proofing (a little) :) In 6 months time when the new stress testing game (see oblivion, then see replacement Crysis) comes out your GTX285 will struggle on a 24" but not so much on a 22".. I can't predict the future but I can predict that games will get more graphically intensive and I can tell you that any card runs more fps on a 22" than a 24".. give it time.
Dunno about the brands you want but I'm sure sum1 will come up with something. Go with what you know but then again don't be afraid to change if the benefits are there :)

Hope this helps bro

:Luca
 
Wow, the CM 690 is a really nice case. Gotta love that price point too. I also love that it has a grill on the bottom set up for the PSU so you don't have to drill your own hole or mount the PSU upside down.

Here are my concerns with it:
1) You have to pay $25 extra to get the window, which I do want. If I am going to put this much money and work into a system I want to be able to show it off without opening it up. However, even with the extra $25 it still blows the Antec 1200 out of the water price-wise.

2) You have to buy 4 extra fans to fill out the case. HOWEVER, even with 4 extra very nice fans I think it still beats the 1200 on price by about $50.

3) No air filters on the intakes to keep some of the dust/etc out of it. On the upside, you don't have to take out the air filters and wash them.

4) Raw cooling power: Is it able to support a reasonable overclock to the 920, let's say something conservative like to 3.6?

5) No built in fan control dials as comes with the 1200.

Here is my other question (on RAM):
Hardforum really likes this G.Skill ram kit. Am I going to see any performance degradation if I go with that kit rather than the OCZ ram kit I have selected?

Both are priced within 5 bucks of each other right now so price isn't the concern. The difference as I understand it is that the OCZ kit runs at higher voltages but at lower CAS latency than the G.Skill kit. But I don't really know what that means as far as choosing one over the other in real world performance.
 
Last edited:
The voltage on the G.Skill RAM kit is lower than the OCZ kit, and that's important if you plan on overclocking. CAS latency matter little towards overall performance compared to raw speed -- tweaking it will only net you, at most, a few FPS in some games.

You don't need to purchase expensive fans for the CM 690. Pick up some Yate Loons from Jab-Tech or some other store that sells them for $4-$6 per fan. For case fans, you don't need the "best of the best" -- save those fans as replacement fans for a CPU cooler.

Search the forum for the number of satisfied Core i7 overclockers with the CM 690 case. The numbers might surprise you. ;)
 
1) I guess you missed out when the RC-690 was $20 after MIR. Don't worry, me too. :(
2) 4 x $4 = $16, As tiraides mentioned, Yate Loons FTW!
3) you can buy filters if you wish, they're not really needed -- your parts will still get dusty in the Antec case.
4) Why wouldn't it be?!? :confused:
5) Degradation? only if you overvolt it too much -- then again, same goes for the OCZ RAM. :p
6) tiraides covered this... and eveyrything else, but I didn't see his reply until now, lol.
 
Last edited:
Search the forum for the number of satisfied Core i7 overclockers with the CM 690 case. The numbers might surprise you. ;)

I am sorry, my search skills must be weak. I have tried a variety of search terms around i7, overclock, and cm 690 and haven't come up with much specifically discussing overclocking the i7 chip with this case. I am assuming your statement means that this case is a good choice, but I just want to make extra sure I have your meaning correct.
 
yes, its a good choice. what makes you think it has less cooling ability than the antec? :confused:
 
yes, its a good choice. what makes you think it has less cooling ability than the antec? :confused:

That is a great question. I guess I just bought into some hype from some friends and reading about the Antec being one of the "best of the best". I like that Cooler Master 690 case though, it really has a stylish look to it and a great price point (It is too bad that I missed some of those super awesome deals on it). I have switched the build to this case.

I also switched the ram to the G.Skill ram, based on the advice regarding the voltages being better and CAS timings not being that critical.
 
Before you jump on that deal, ensure that all of the software and drivers that you'll be using are compatible with Windows 7 and/or a 64-bit OS. You're not going to find a better "deal" on a Windows-based OS (outside of college or the MSDN), but sooner or later, you'll have to obtain a new, commercial OS.
 
I made mistake of getting 4 nexus real silent fans.. For 1, with the cm690 you only really need 3 fans and for 2 the coolermaster fans that came with teh case are pretty much just as quiet as the nexus fans.. barely notice the difference and paid out my ass for them (nexus fans).. waste..

Cm690 will handle your OC easy man. There plenty of room inside the case.

Antec a great case too but I could never trade my cm690 for 1.

:Luca
 
Before you jump on that deal, ensure that all of the software and drivers that you'll be using are compatible with Windows 7 and/or a 64-bit OS. You're not going to find a better "deal" on a Windows-based OS (outside of college or the MSDN), but sooner or later, you'll have to obtain a new, commercial OS.

Well, this rig is pretty much going to be for fun, so I don't expect to use much in the way of legacy software with it. I am going to go with a 64 bit os regardless, which means I am going to have to deal with that driver support no matter what. I am happy to pay for windows 7 when I have to but I was certainly less enthusiastic about having to buy vista 64 now when 7 is right around the corner in any case.

In regards to fans it looks like I am only going to be buying about $20 extra worth of fans even going through Newegg. Since the windowed side panel only has room for 1 fan and it comes with it that means all I need are 2 more 120 mm fans for the case and the one 80x80x15 fan for exhaust on the mobo (I just hate to leave empty spaces even when they aren't necessary -grin-).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top