Good RAID I card suggestion?

freakyhair

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 22, 2002
Messages
475
Hi all, I have the SIIG SC-SAER12-S2 PCI Express x1 SATA II Two-port Controller Card RAID 0/1 (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816150018), running two 250GB SATA cards in RAID1, and it pooped last night.

I looked on Newegg, and there are alot of different RAID cards. At this time, I really only want to run RAID1 (mirrored), and I might upgrade to 1TB drives soon. I need it to be PCI-E x1 as I have a SFF case, with limited slots.


I MIGHT eventually upgrade my PC in the next couple years to run a RAID 10 system, so 4 SATA ports would be nice, but I'd be willing to get a 2-port card now

Any suggestions? Thanks!
 
For RAID 0 or 1, software limitation and CPU overhead should be pretty much nonexistent and therefore a non-issue...hardware RAID cards are overkill for such functionality. Go with whatever you feel is best unless the card has some fucked up BIOS on it or whatever.

Oh yeah, and avoid NVRAID at all costs. ;)
 
For RAID 0 or 1, software limitation and CPU overhead should be pretty much nonexistent and therefore a non-issue...hardware RAID cards are overkill for such functionality. Go with whatever you feel is best unless the card has some fucked up BIOS on it or whatever.

Oh yeah, and avoid NVRAID at all costs. ;)

I guess I had not considered using SW RAID... I just always used HW RAID.

Can this be done using WinXP Pro only? or do you guys recommend other SW?

Thanks again!
 
I guess I had not considered using SW RAID... I just always used HW RAID.

Can this be done using WinXP Pro only? or do you guys recommend other SW?

Thanks again!

Well, from what I've heard and partially experienced, Windows Dynamic Disks are a pain in the ass. What I meant by "Software" RAID was really hardware-assisted software RAID, which comes in the form of add-on PCI/PCI-X/PCIe cards that do not have their own dedicated XOR processor for disk I/Os or onboard RAID controllers that essentially do the same thing.
 
BAD NEWS! The RR2300 does not allow you to use an existing HD to set-up a RAID1 setup. In other words, if I want to use this card, I need to do a fresh WinXP install. Not acceptable. This is what they told me...

"The RR2300 does not have this option - you cannot create RAID 1 arrays from existing data disks. Some of our older cards provide this option (such as the RR1640), but do not provide the OCE/ORLM function (the ability to expand or convert existing arrays)."

Also, my WD2500AAKS are not compatible (I should have ready that in their lists, but really, that is a crap answer I think. No other manufacturers have this issue.)


Anyone have experience with the Promise brand cards?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816102116
 
Anyone have experience with the Promise brand cards?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816102116

The Promise cards won't work either. Since you actually want to REUSE your array, you're gonna have to get a RAID card that uses the same RAID controller chip like your old dead card. Look at your dead card and see if you can find the name of the chip implanted/embedded somewhere.

Oh and that SIIG card you had WAS a software RAID card or "hardware-assisted software RAID" or fakeRAID card as Syntax Error mentioned
 
The Promise cards won't work either. Since you actually want to REUSE your array, you're gonna have to get a RAID card that uses the same RAID controller chip like your old dead card. Look at your dead card and see if you can find the name of the chip implanted/embedded somewhere.

Oh and that SIIG card you had WAS a software RAID card or "hardware-assisted software RAID" or fakeRAID card as Syntax Error mentioned

I'm not saying your totally wrong, but I have done the following before (I do this because I'm too lazy to find my floppy drive :)):
1. Install WinXP on a single drive just connected to the MB.
2. Set up Winxp, and install the RAID card
3. Use the RAID card's bios to clone the WinXP HD to a new identical HD (making the RAID1 setup)

How is this different than what I am trying to do? Currently, I'm using one of the HDs that was connected to the SIIG card, only connected directly to my MB.

Also, would that mean I need to get a new SIIG card? I was just scared off as this SIIG card did just die on me. Or is it just bad luck? Are SIIG cards usually OK? (I had an ATA133 SIIG controller that worked OK.)
 
I'm not saying your totally wrong, but I have done the following before (I do this because I'm too lazy to find my floppy drive :)):
1. Install WinXP on a single drive just connected to the MB.
2. Set up Winxp, and install the RAID card
3. Use the RAID card's bios to clone the WinXP HD to a new identical HD (making the RAID1 setup)

How is this different than what I am trying to do? Currently, I'm using one of the HDs that was connected to the SIIG card, only connected directly to my MB.

Also, would that mean I need to get a new SIIG card? I was just scared off as this SIIG card did just die on me. Or is it just bad luck? Are SIIG cards usually OK? (I had an ATA133 SIIG controller that worked OK.)

Wait now I'm confused. So you just want do all those steps again but with a different card? Not use your RAID1 array (meaning both drives same time) on a different card?
 
Wait now I'm confused. So you just want do all those steps again but with a different card? Not use your RAID1 array (meaning both drives same time) on a different card?

Well, I guess. Technically, my RAID was broken when I took the HD off the broken card's channel one, and just booted up off it from my MB (right?)

Right now, I have one primary HD (boot partition, and storage partition.) I have a second identical HD that I would like to use to create a RAID1 setup. I bought the RR2300 card to do this, but the only way to have the card recognize them is to initialize the HD's, which erase them (their tech support reaffirmed this.) Also, my HD's are incompatible with the RR2300. That is why I was looking at the Promise card. I wouldn't be totally against the SIIG card, just my last one died, and I don't like buying brands that die on me.

I'm not looking for speed, just some redundancy :) Am I being stupid/over-complicated about this???

Thanks!
 
A few months ago I got a rr3120 pci-e 1x. Thing works fine. Hosts up files bursting at 90 MB/s in raid 1 over the network (previously using es.2).

only thing that doesn't seem to work with all the highpoint cards I've had is the e-mail notification.

If that's important I'd go with a solution from adaptec.

btw: I think with highpoint you can shuffle drives between arrays even if it's a different controller (but same highpoint brand). If you are attempting to migrate member disks from a previous array of another vendor, that will not work.

fwiw I would just buy another card like you had, swap the card, boot, fine. unless you want to upgrade, which in your case sounds like a project.
 
Back
Top