Blu-ray’s Fuzzy Future

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The NY Times takes a hard look at the year ahead for Blu-ray. The article touches on the pros and cons of the format but the overall tone seems to be “wait and see.”

“Satisfaction with DVD is very high, and sales figures for the DVD, though the market is contracting, are very strong,” said Chris Fawcett, vice president for the home audio and video division of Sony Electronics, which has lowered growth projections for Blu-ray to account for the downturn in consumer spending.
 
If true, that is great news for consumers. I would love to see some $10 blu-ray specials on the horizon.
 
Drop the price of Blu-Ray movies, problem solved.

DVD $10.00
Blu-Ray $15.00
 
An auction of an IDE BR drive (straight from a player I guess) went for $15 here a week ago and I hate myself for missing it. It had ONE bid.
 
waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . .

:p These supposed analysts have been saying that for kind of a long time now....you know my 2 year old nephew could spew that crap out all year too.

We need new analysts
 
waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . . waiting to see . . .

:p These supposed analysts have been saying that for kind of a long time now....you know my 2 year old nephew could spew that crap out all year too.

We don't need analysts

fixed :-P

I hope Blu-ray don't die to DVD. I mean, DVD's great and all, but I didn't buy a 1080p television to watch 480p movies!
 
Blu-Ray Sales up 400% in UK

http://www.pocket-lint.co.uk/news/n...home-entertainment-market-alive-kicking.phtml

"Target expands Blu-ray space for hardware, software. Move a response to customer demand"
http://www.videobusiness.com/index.asp?layout=article&articleid=CA6605722&desc=topstory

"Washington, D.C. (December 16, 2008) -- The studios' heavy promotion of the Blu-ray high-def disc is having an adverse impact on standard-def DVD sales this fourth quarter.

That's according to Wall Street analyst Richard Greenfield, as reported by Home Media Magazine.

Greenfield, who works for Pali Capital, notes that retailers have significantly lowered prices on Blu-ray players this holiday season and expanded shelf space to carry the new set-tops. Consequently, he forecasts that standard DVD revenue will fall six percent in 2008."
 
just saying, that you can choose what to report to skew the news you want to get across. Of course a lot of people ONLY get their blu-ray news from Steve on the H, which is always negative, yet claims he is only posting the news. Just that the positive news is always omitted.
 
Yeah right....then why is my local Best Buy out of every Blu-ray player they carry (with the exception of PS3s). I was just there this afternoon.

I know quite a few people who got blu-ray players for X-mas. I've also seen $10.00 Blu-rays at Walmart already. No one has the bandwith to enjoy streamed HD content and the PQ from the standard Netflix stream still is not up to par with sd-dvd. With all the recent talk of internet companies charging for actual bandwith usage I don't even see streaming as an option for a long time.
 
I think it just has something to do with how americans think.
We aren't bothered all that much by a retarded initial investment if it nets us long term quality. Blue-ray is higher quality you have to keep paying for with each movie.
For instance, how many of you would be interested in quad core cpus if they made all games cost 5-20 dollars extra?
 
I think it just has something to do with how americans think.
We aren't bothered all that much by a retarded initial investment if it nets us long term quality. Blue-ray is higher quality you have to keep paying for with each movie.
For instance, how many of you would be interested in quad core cpus if they made all games cost 5-20 dollars extra?

They did that for "next-gen" consoles basically.
 
Sorry, any article that features Rob Enderle as its primary source of information is flawed to begin with.

Rob part 1 : HD DVD is going to win.

Rob part 2 : HD DVD died , BD isn't going to sell, Digital Distribution is the future for HD Movies

Rob part 3 : BDs doing ok, but Digital Distribution is the future for HD Movies.

Seriously, Enderle, is a joke. He's extremely biased, and most of his predictions over the last year haven't only been a bit off, but completely and absolutely wrong.
 
Let's face it Blu-ray will continue to languish until they drop the prices on both the players and the movies and more people get Hi-DEF TV's. The average user doesn't crave the technology yet since not everyone has Hi-Def TV's the price point on these has also remained high thus a lot of people still don't have them. If the average consumer doesn't have a Hi-Def TV then they see no reason for Blu-ray. The issue goes down to the fact that the technological leeps with Blu-ray and Hi-Def are coming out at same time and people just don't have the money to do both. Both TV's and Blu-ray needs to be lowered in price for it to become more prevelant.
 
they way it should work.. if you watched the movie at the theater, the ticket stub should have a $8 discount or something on the blueray version
 
About 40 million US households now have at least one HDTV, which is roughly 34% of the US. Considering that number has doubled in a year, it says a lot. PriceGrabber recently surveyed 2,000 customers on their plans to move from standard TVs to HDTVs, and even with the piss-poor economy, 73% of those customers surveyed said they plan to upgrade to a HDTV within the year.

Personally, I gladly pay the additional $5 or so over the DVD price for the Blu-Ray Discs I purchase for the significant resolution increase, not to mention leaps in sound going from compressed DD/DTS signals on DVD to uncompressed HD audio with Blu-Ray Disc.

Prices have dropped significantly, and will continue to, not to continually mention that Blu-Ray Discs' prices on players and software are quite a bit lower than DVDs' were at the same age.
 
Are CD's dead? Not yet. The CD section at Hastings and Barnes & Nobel is as big as ever. On the other side, I've seen most of the music stores in the local malls go away. I still think of the CD first and the download second when I buy music, even the hard to find/foreign albums. I believe CDs will fade away eventually as will Blu-Ray, but not yet. I have great plans for a massive Blu-Ray library that will rival my DVDs.

I'm sure one day I'll have 5000 downloaded HD Movies in my pocket that will link to and play on any HDTV or projector. Or maybe we'll all have subscription services that let us watch anything anywhere anytime without having to buy individual titles.

The problem with all of this is it is the future. Not the now. People have gotten so used to the quick progression of technology, that they want to start digging the grave as the baby is born.
 
Regardless of the economic conditions there are some truths that hold fast.

1. TVs will get larger and cheaper.
2. More people will own larger HD TVs
3. More people will realize the benefit of BluRay over DVD because they will see it on their larger TVs.

It is a growth market. It will grow no matter what they do. If they want to speed up adoption though, they will lower disc prices.

Sony has taken it on the chin financially for BluRay long enough to get the format established. It is time for the studios to start getting behind it financially. They need to see the potential of reducing their profits significantly to increase demand if they want to see the format succeed. This means that I will be able to buy more movies :)
 
Of course a lot of people ONLY get their blu-ray news from Steve on the H, which is always negative, yet claims he is only posting the news. Just that the positive news is always omitted.

Because you KNOW what everyone else reads...

and you we know ONLY post bad news....


....well....except for this story, well...and this one ...and this one...or this one....or this one...or this one...or this one...or this one...or this one ...or the dozen nuetral Blu-ray hardware posts....

...and that is just last month.


I think what you meant to say was that some people ONLY see what they want to see. :rolleyes:
 
Hybrid BR and DVD on one disk - problem solved, at a decent price!

1 disk, 2 formats - consumer wins, they buy their DVD and if they get a BR player later they can play their same movies they already own in BR format
 
I know a lot of people that would jump on Blu-Ray if they could get $1 rentals from Redbox. Unfortunately, only a limited number of Redbox locations offer Blu-Ray. I know some of the ones in Jacksonville do, but they don't in my city, Atlanta.
 
I don't buy blu ray because i haven't bought a blu ray player yet because i still haven't decided on a tv. As soon as i get my tv, i will be getting my player. The quality looks sexy when i see it at stores.
 
Oh and stop this crap of releasing BR movies when they are nothing more then upconverted DVD's!!!
 
My HD tv plays HD content from my satellite, my TIVO, my computer, and my X-Box. None of those come in optical or any type of physical format. Why the hell should I buy a blu-ray player? I just went to the mall with an old friend who wanted to spend a $100 gift card. He got 4 blu-ray movies and had less than $10 left.

I've only seen two blu-ray movies that I actually want, Blade Runner (which, lucky me, my TIVO just snagged in HD) and The Dark Knight. One movie is not enough for me to buy a blu-ray player, especially when I don't even use my upconverting dvd player.
 
There is a classic saying, "There is no news, like bad news" and the media seems to be eating this whole anti Blu-ray thing up. They don't see the victory over HD DVD as a victory, but rather a grim prelude of Blu-ray's future; the falling prices for Blu-ray discs and players not as progress, but rather a desperate strategy or a failing format; and when it came to the holidays, instead of seeing the great sales Blu-ray discs and players had, they only see the over all dismal figures of the holiday shopping season as a whole.

Might I add that something similar is still being waged against Windows Vista.
 
Well, around me I can find 4 FutureShop and 2 BestBuy. Except for the PS3 and the Profile 1.1 Samsung player, everything else was out of stock. And they had tons of them for the Boxing day, you could get the Sony BDP-S350 for $219 with 3 movies, the Samsung was going for $199 with the same 3 movies.

Searching for something else, I did visit 2 FutureShop during the boxing day (bad idea!) and all I can say is that everybody seem to be leaving the place with one in hand. And they moved LOTS of HDTV out the doors during that day.

Both store had HUGE pile of Sony player, at the end of the say, they where gone.

All this only in the stores around me. I can only imagine everywhere else. So PLEASE, don't tell me Blu-Ray is dying. It's more alive now than it was....
 
My HD tv plays HD content from my satellite, my TIVO, my computer, and my X-Box. None of those come in optical or any type of physical format. Why the hell should I buy a blu-ray player? I just went to the mall with an old friend who wanted to spend a $100 gift card. He got 4 blu-ray movies and had less than $10 left.

I've only seen two blu-ray movies that I actually want, Blade Runner (which, lucky me, my TIVO just snagged in HD) and The Dark Knight. One movie is not enough for me to buy a blu-ray player, especially when I don't even use my upconverting dvd player.

Satellite / TIVO / Pay-Per-View HD content is rarely at 1080p. At most you get your stuff in 720p (and your box convert it to 1080p to match your TV...). And then, you have to count in the compression levels, witch are very high because they want to save on bandwidth to try and cramp more pseudo HD channels.

So in the end, the only media right now that offers true 1080p with a decent (low) compression level and HD Master Audio is.... Blu-Ray. It's the only way to enjoy movies (and now series) in HD.

First generation of Blu-Ray movies where crap, yes. But now, most movies, including old one, look stunning in HD. Blu-Ray transfer can't do miracle if the master source is crap, the result will be crap. But it's not the case most of the time (from what I've seen so far).
 
So PLEASE, don't tell me Blu-Ray is dying. It's more alive now than it was....

That doesn't mean it's not dying, or it will ever make money for Sony, or ever establish itself the way DVD players have. I mean it better be more alive then it ever has been, or it would already be dead...
 
Satellite / TIVO / Pay-Per-View HD content is rarely at 1080p. At most you get your stuff in 720p (and your box convert it to 1080p to match your TV...). And then, you have to count in the compression levels, witch are very high because they want to save on bandwidth to try and cramp more pseudo HD channels.

So in the end, the only media right now that offers true 1080p with a decent (low) compression level and HD Master Audio is.... Blu-Ray. It's the only way to enjoy movies (and now series) in HD.

Sounds fine on my 5.1 system and I'll never tell the difference on a 42" screen from where I sit.
 
Because you KNOW what everyone else reads...

and you we know ONLY post bad news....


....well....except for this story, well...and this one ...and this one...or this one....or this one...or this one...or this one...or this one...or this one ...or the dozen nuetral Blu-ray hardware posts....

...and that is just last month.

.



I think what you meant to say was that some people ONLY see what they want to see. :rolleyes:

Oh so one positive spun story? rest neutral or negative. Still lopsided.
 
I find it odd that folks who froth at the mouth over DRM on music think digital downloads are the future for HD video.

With IPSs putting caps in place, and worse compression or growing download sizes, to me the future of downloads even without the issues of DRM are looking sketchy.

There are tons of reasons why blu-ray uptake will be slow, but short of it dragging out long enough to make a flash memory format price competitive, I don't see it dying off without the total failure of multiple large companies.

A carbon tax on screens over a certain ize might be enough to do it too.
 
Sounds fine on my 5.1 system and I'll never tell the difference on a 42" screen from where I sit.

Well, for people with better equipment, it does make a difference. So again, Blu-Ray wins the current HD battle.

The ONLY thing "better" than a Blu-Ray disc right now is.... A free Blu-Ray rip found on some torrent. There goes your digital download. For a mere 25 to 50 Gb of download....

Everything else is just too much compressed or not even real 1080p.
 
So in the end, the only media right now that offers true 1080p with a decent (low) compression level and HD Master Audio is.... Blu-Ray.
Like I mentioned in another thread, I think the lossless audio stuff on Blu-ray is pretty silly. I doubt very highly my ears could discern the difference between good 'ol 1.5mbps DTS and lossless DTS-HD MA, even on my ~$800 headphone setup, and I have a pretty decent ear for lossy artifacts. User accounts of being able to tell a difference are meaningless unless the trials are blind or, preferably, double-blind, even if there's a supposed "night and day difference".

The lossless stuff is gravy, of course, but I have a hard time seeing that as a major advantage to what alternative formats could offer (regular DTS and lossy DTS-HD, AC3 or AC3+). People tend to be too leery about lossy audio compression these days when there's usually no real cause for any alarm.

Now, obviously, cable companies compressing the bejeesus out of their 720 streams (video, that is) is what gives Blu-ray the real advantage. For those lucky enough to have FO TV, that advantage is somewhat negated.

Oh so one positive spun story? rest neutral or negative. Still lopsided.
Pardon my Icelandic, but, really, who gives two shits?
 
digital distribution is not the future the second that it becomes it the interweb will collapse or be choked to death with drum roll please BANDWIDTH CAPS
 
lol like iam gonna trust the NYT for anything electronics related lol let alone news related
 
Back
Top