Apple - Orange Distribution Deal Barred

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The French Competition Council has barred the exclusive deal between Apple and France Telecom's Orange mobile telephony unit. The iPhone can now be sold by other carriers in France.

The watchdog said the exclusive rights to iPhone held by France Telecom's Orange mobile telephony unit "by nature introduces a new factor of rigidity in a sector that already lacks competition." It said any operator can now sell the iPhone.
 
Excellent, I would like to see all "exclusive" phone deals be prohibited.
 
why shouldn't companies be able to do what they want?
dont like it, dont buy it.

ive somehow managed to survive without any apple products my whole life.
 
why shouldn't companies be able to do what they want?
Because the Free Market simply doesn't work. The events this years prove that companies doing what they want with no oversight leads to disaster.
 
Because the Free Market simply doesn't work. The events this years prove that companies doing what they want with no oversight leads to disaster.

it works just fine, most of the time. Sometimes it doesn't. Life does not come with airbags, Tovarisch.

Since when are people aren't allowed to fall on their faces? Companies need to learn from their mistakes same as everyone else, or they will never learn. People get all bent out shape because bad things happen when you make bad decisions. Your idea to solve the problem is to remove the ability to make decisions. Wow, great idea.

If you want a controlled economy, jump in your time machine and go back to Soviet Russia. Enjoy your bread lines.
 
Because the Free Market simply doesn't work. The events this years prove that companies doing what they want with no oversight leads to disaster.

The events this year simply prove that companies feel that they can fuck up all they want since hte govt will bail them out.

I personally think anyone at the top level of those companies should be stripped of all assets of any value, then imprisoned until they can repair the damages they have done....if that means they rot in jail...let them.

Irresponsibility is never acceptable...they are all adults, time to act like it. Especially so considering the insane wages they take claiming that the pay comes with the added responsibility...go figure.

The problem is that the government bailed them out....which just encourages this behavior.
 
Got to be kidding me.

If you want a phone but can't afford the iphone, buy a different phone.
 
I think it has to do with carrier exclusivity, not the price of the phone, my friend.:)

If the companies don't compete on prices, the phone prices will still be high. How is high prices going to help anything. You just have more choices of high priced items....
 
it works just fine, most of the time. Sometimes it doesn't. Life does not come with airbags, Tovarisch.

Since when are people aren't allowed to fall on their faces? Companies need to learn from their mistakes same as everyone else, or they will never learn. People get all bent out shape because bad things happen when you make bad decisions. Your idea to solve the problem is to remove the ability to make decisions. Wow, great idea.

If you want a controlled economy, jump in your time machine and go back to Soviet Russia. Enjoy your bread lines.

Die, capitalist pig!

Seriously, exclusive deals suck. They stifle competition. The XFX AIP deal with AMD will be good for all of us while making the players involved some real money.

I don't know how 'Mericans can stand how much it costs to switch phone service providers. Using your own words, cell phone companies have written service contracts that "remove the ability to make decisions" and government has allowed it.

Is this your free market?

As for your take on the current financial crisis... Jaysus. If only I could write off the 40% drop in my funds as a learning exercise for the financial industry.
 
Because the Free Market simply doesn't work. The events this years prove that companies doing what they want with no oversight leads to disaster.
That is somewhat oversimplified. For example, many of the housing problems are due to the government forcing the lenders to make loans to people with very poor credit histories, that they (the banks) would not otherwise lend to.

Of course, my statement is oversimplified too, but the point is too much regulation is bad too.

I believe too much regulation is far worse then too little.
 
Since when are people aren't allowed to fall on their faces? Companies need to learn from their mistakes same as everyone else, or they will never learn. People get all bent out shape because bad things happen when you make bad decisions. Your idea to solve the problem is to remove the ability to make decisions. Wow, great idea.
OK, you want a REALLY free market, then this is how it's done.

(1) All phones must be sold unlocked. Let companies compete on price of the phones like every other product out there. Why should phones be different?
(2) No exclusive agreements. Buy your phone anywhere from anyone.
(3) No Contracts. You don't have to have a contract to buy electricity do you?
(4) Let companies REALLY compete. On price of services and price of airtime.

I'll go for THAT free market.
 
If the companies don't compete on prices, the phone prices will still be high. How is high prices going to help anything. You just have more choices of high priced items....

how are the phone companies gonna compete on prices besides the price plans? the phone is going to be sold for a set price by apple regardless. and who knows how much of a cut apple takes from the price plans themselves. prolly more than enough to keep that mobile me service running...
 
That is somewhat oversimplified. For example, many of the housing problems are due to the government forcing the lenders to make loans to people with very poor credit histories, that they (the banks) would not otherwise lend to.
Government forcing lenders?? Are you joking?? No, what happened was that banks and other lenders got greedy, and wrote high risk loans to poor credit risks, hoping for big paybacks. Well now the banks are getting screwed and expect us to bail them out.
 
how are the phone companies gonna compete on prices besides the price plans? the phone is going to be sold for a set price by apple regardless. and who knows how much of a cut apple takes from the price plans themselves. prolly more than enough to keep that mobile me service running...

That's like saying the 280 GTX card is going to be sold by BFG at a set price anyway. It's called reselling and I shouldn't be forced to buy it at Tiger Direct.

Apple has always had its own (non-competitive) way of doing things, of course.
 
Wow. A government with Balls.

Well, kinda :)

lol I was expecting something like

Apple: We're making the iPhone exclusively available to Orange Communications.

French Government: No, that's monopoly! We'll ban iPhones unless it's available to all providers!

Apple: Uh no, we're making the iPhone exclusively available to Orange Communications.

French Government: We surrender! *waves white flag*
 
it works just fine, most of the time. Sometimes it doesn't. Life does not come with airbags, Tovarisch.

Since when are people aren't allowed to fall on their faces? Companies need to learn from their mistakes same as everyone else, or they will never learn. People get all bent out shape because bad things happen when you make bad decisions. Your idea to solve the problem is to remove the ability to make decisions. Wow, great idea.

If you want a controlled economy, jump in your time machine and go back to Soviet Russia. Enjoy your bread lines.

If we allowed companies to fall on their faces anytime they want, there'd be hell to pay. Look at the automotive industry. Steel mills are paying the price for their stupidity. My company's employees got thrown out of Severstal NA and US Steel Great Lakes and Gary Works (along with other contractors) because the Big Three canceled all orders for the time being. We're holding our breath and waiting to see what happens now.

Big businesses with too much control over the economy needs to be monitored and abusive bosses need to be held accountable. This isn't Utopia.

Apple needs to open their eyes and stop abusing their privilege to free enterprise by monopolizing their products.
 
Government forcing lenders?? Are you joking?? No, what happened was that banks and other lenders got greedy, and wrote high risk loans to poor credit risks, hoping for big paybacks. Well now the banks are getting screwed and expect us to bail them out.

Sorry, but the government did some pushing.

"Fannie Mae, the nation's biggest underwriter of home mortgages, has been under increasing pressure from the Clinton Administration to expand mortgage loans among low and moderate income people and felt pressure from stock holders to maintain its phenomenal growth in profits."

Link
 
Government forcing lenders?? Are you joking?? No, what happened was that banks and other lenders got greedy, and wrote high risk loans to poor credit risks, hoping for big paybacks. Well now the banks are getting screwed and expect us to bail them out.
yeah... you might want to look into the Community Reinvestment Act...
 
Sorry, but the government did some pushing.

"Fannie Mae, the nation's biggest underwriter of home mortgages, has been under increasing pressure from the Clinton Administration to expand mortgage loans among low and moderate income people and felt pressure from stock holders to maintain its phenomenal growth in profits."

Link
Exactly! This is the government intervention that destroys economies. I wish the would start to blanace the global free market by imposing the same tariffs on the countries who impose them on our exports. To be a completely free market all countries have to be open to the same degree.
As far as iPhone. I didnt want one in the first place, to me it was another trendy over priced Apple product.
 
Back
Top