Apple Recommends Antivirus Software For Macs

okay found it!


http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/os-x-applications-games/132225-apple-says-get-antivirus.html

from one poster..

Quote:
OS X, and any computer operating system, is susceptible the viruses - that is a fact, and a long-standing one at that. The difference between OS X and Windows is that it is not prone to viruses because there are built-in safeguards that make it very difficult to write a successful virus unless there is an unpatched hole. This is precisely why there has never been an "in-the-wild" virus for OS X.

Although Apple may now officially recommend an anti-virus product, they're simply useless as they have nothing to scan for (aside from Windows viruses). I'll also go a step forward and say that provided you are cognizant of any requests for your administrator password, you'll likely never have an issue with any kind of malware.



Thoughts?

Complete nonsense. Apple OS X has much less built in security than Vista. The reason Mac OS's don't get infected a lot is because they are not as prolific as Windows is. These days trojans and other malware are written to make money. It makes more fiscal sense to make viruses for Windows than for OS X, but if OS X ever gets more than 25% market share, then malware for OS X will be a common thing.
 
Nice. Bigotry doesn't even get a person a slap on the wrist, but swearing, which everyone else does (including you) earns them a ban.

Staying on topic, Apple shot themselves hard in the foot with their ads. They have a crapload of backpedaling to do.

Was more the context the swearing was in.
 
I'm not sure I understand that. I mean, if you overheard a conversation where one person says "I have eight PCs on my table", and the other person says "I don't", you would assume that the second person has no PCs at all? All you could garner from that conversation is that the second person doesn't have eight PCs on his table.

Now, I think the commercial was worded very carefully to make viewers think that, maybe, Macs don't get viruses (a little shady, which isn't at all atypical for Mac ads), but the commercial doesn't make that claim.

this reminds me of a 5 year old waving his hand 5 inches from your face, screaming "I'M NOT TOUCHING YOU, I'M NOT TOUCHING YOU!"
 
Obviously you don't.

PC: "...last year there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs."
Mac: "PCs. Not Macs".

You interpret this to mean "there are no viruses for Mac OS", do you? That's...well, that's a pretty impressive leap.

The implication was clear. You can't get a virus with a mac.

That has been the Apple mantra for years.

One of these must be true:

1. You recently became aware that Apple makes computers
2. You don't believe what you just said, but you like trolling.

I've seen these arguments long enough that I remember when Mac fanboys swore that Macs couldn't get viruses, because the software was so good and the reason there were attacks on Windows was because it was poorly written.

They argued that it had nothing to do with marketshare. Then when viruses and attacks were proven possible, it became that they're just theoretical attacks, that are too hard to execute, unlike Windows. Again, the attacks on windows were because it was easy, not because of marketshare.

Did I mention all the apple users who always said they never needed to run AV software (sometimes that was given as a reason they switched to the Mac).

When the mac was the first OS that was compromised this year at a hacking convention, it was because the hacker wanted a Mac (or some such nonsense), not because it was the easiest one to hack.

When attacks on a mac are via software that's sold with the mac, but not part of the core OS, it's not a Mac flaw, but when it's a part of Windows, it's just a part of that rotting mess from M$.

The bottom line is we've been saying for the better part of this decade that the only thing protecting Apple (and the other OS's) is marketshare, while fan boys have been claiming that was just FUD.
 
I don't care why Azhar was banned. What's BS was that phide got away with it. But whatever. I'm sure Azhar will appreciate you guys' lack of support.


2 weeks for posting off topic. See how this can work?

Who's next to paint a target on themselves?
 
The implication was clear. You can't get a virus with a mac.

That has been the Apple mantra for years.

One of these must be true:

1. You recently became aware that Apple makes computers
2. You don't believe what you just said, but you like trolling.

I've seen these arguments long enough that I remember when Mac fanboys swore that Macs couldn't get viruses, because the software was so good and the reason there were attacks on Windows was because it was poorly written.

They argued that it had nothing to do with marketshare. Then when viruses and attacks were proven possible, it became that they're just theoretical attacks, that are too hard to execute, unlike Windows. Again, the attacks on windows were because it was easy, not because of marketshare.

Did I mention all the apple users who always said they never needed to run AV software (sometimes that was given as a reason they switched to the Mac).

When the mac was the first OS that was compromised this year at a hacking convention, it was because the hacker wanted a Mac (or some such nonsense), not because it was the easiest one to hack.

When attacks on a mac are via software that's sold with the mac, but not part of the core OS, it's not a Mac flaw, but when it's a part of Windows, it's just a part of that rotting mess from M$.

The bottom line is we've been saying for the better part of this decade that the only thing protecting Apple (and the other OS's) is marketshare, while fan boys have been claiming that was just FUD.

Exactly, i got fed up of hearing exactly the same crap. Its like mac users think theyre the chosen few sent to enlighten the world to how computing should be. In other words all style with barely anything upgradable by the end user. And seriously WTF is it with Jobs obsession with things being thin? OK crt to lcd, very noticable difference and saves some space, but when he gets on that soapbox of his year in and out and wants the audience to start whacking off to the fact (and they do..always) that somethings .00025 of an inch thinner than the previous model thats where i start headbutting walls.

Best example of that would be the macbook air, strip just about everything out of it and focus on the fact its thinner, wow where do i sign up for this cripppled pos?
 
Can you tell me how Apple suggesting anti-virus protocols is proof that implying Macs get "few, if any viruses" is a lie? Historically the crux of this argument for the PC side was that Macs just didn't have the market share that PCs did and that's why there were very few (and at one point in time, absolutely zero) Mac viruses. But Apple's market share has been steadily (albeit slowly) increasing for years now, and I don't see a ton of reports on terrible viruses. Which is also surprising, because a large amount of viruses are spread from your computer-illiterate grandmother opening a .vbs file she got as an attachment in her e-mail; PC elitists have long maintained as an integral part of their arguments the idea that people who buy Macs are just too stupid to learn how to use a "real" PC.


It's a numbers game. Unless a single piece of code will run on both a PC and a Mac, why would any serious crime ware group choose the Mac?

If the Mac has 10% of the world's users (I suspect it's much less than that outside the U.S. market), and an attack has a 10% chance to succeed on the pc and a 50% chance of success on OS X, they'd have almost 100% of more successes on the Windows system.

Now if they were successful against 100% of the macs, then it'd make sense to attack OS X.

If Apple is lucky, someday they'll get attacked as much as Windows.

Granted, I have not been following the reports of Mac vs. PC viruses extremely closely, being as it is that I don't particularly care. I just feel compelled to post in these threads wherein 15-20 PC "fans" (nice word deliberately used) catch on to a tiny, potentially negative thing about Apples, or Macs, and use it to gloat about the PC's superiority and talk about how much they hate the snobby "elitists" who buy Apple's products. Hypocrisy hurts my bones, and you guys aren't even doing a remotely decent job of it.[/QUOTE]
 
http://gizmodo.com/5100996/false-alarm-apple-mac-os-x-anti+virus-recommendation-is-old

Not that I am an apple fanboi (posting from a vista64 computer) but this was just an update to an old tech note. Apple has been recommending, and in some cases selling, AV software for years. Since long before their switch into UNIX land. I even seem to remember them selling AV at one point as being kind to your PC using buddies by not passing on the windows viruses you get in the mail...
 
I was just browsing one of the computer sites I go to at work, cannot post here while at work for reason only known to our IT dept, I saw this posted:

Hi I'm a MAC and I'm a PC!!

MAC: Uhhhh PC
PC: What is it MAC
MAC: Well I've got this rash and it hurts when I pee.
PC: Oh thats a virus MAC, not to worry, I'm sure your anti-virus will get rid of it
MAC: My what?
PC: Don't you use protection MAC?
MAC: ???? Protection thats for PC's, I'm a MAC we don't get viruses!!!!
PC: Well you have one, and well your probably going to die from it.
MAC: BUT......
PC: Yep you whored yourself around around without being safe and now look at you.
MAC: ........
PC: OH PC's are stuffy, Vista has annoying popups, BLA BLA BLA..... I hope you suffer!
MAC: Can't you help me PC!!! I'll be better I swear!
PC: Well I guess I could ask my DAD Bill gates, If he could pay for a doctor visit.
MAC: REALLY! Wow that's swell PC!! I love you PC.
PC: I love you to MAC.

The End

And this:

Next commercial:

Mac (Muffled): Hello, I'm a Mac
PC: Hello, I'm a PC.
PC: Hey Mac, I see you're all better now, but...
Mac (muffled): But what? I feel great!
PC: But why are you wearing 2 large body condoms?
Mac: Oh, this is Apple's new iDoubleBag program to fight off nasty viruses, because you never can be too safe, you know.
PC: Uh, I thought Macs didn't get viruses.
Mac: Well, it turns out that viruses just didn't know we were out there. Now that Leapord has sold so many copies, I'm feeling a little exposed.
PC: Honestly, you look pretty ridiculous.
Mac: Yeah, well, it is a bit stuffy in here, and I do feel a bit sluggish.
PC: I think that's because you're running out of air.
Mac: Yeah....well.....(Thud)
PC: Uh, Mac?

Fini

I was laughing my ass off when I read this, just wanted to forward someone else's work.
 
gizmodo are so biased and in love with apple. I wouldn't be surprised if those gizmodo wankers dug around on the net anywhere to find any reference about using AV software on a mac in the last year or two. Then, turn around and write some idiotic blog post about how it's nothing new OMG LOVE UR MAC WE DO!!! I LOVE TURTLENECKS!

I stopped going to that low-quality drivel-fest long ago over their idiotic love for mac and neglect for other awesome companies.

But I will have fun with this, my sister is a mac zealot, and so is my brother. The thing about the macs is that they're locked down. I'd imagine them being a lot harder to fix than a windows box. OSX doesn't seem to have that many power tools outside the terminal.
 
I don't care why Azhar was banned. What's BS was that phide got away with it.
I'm not going to spend too much time on this, but I want to clarify that my apology was sincere and I feel badly that he was banned due to my insensitivity. So, enough about that.

this reminds me of a 5 year old waving his hand 5 inches from your face, screaming "I'M NOT TOUCHING YOU, I'M NOT TOUCHING YOU!"
You mean it reminds you of someone who made an reasonably intelligent argument? :)

The point I intended to make there was that Apple didn't explicitly say that Macs can't get viruses, and that's a factually accurate statement. It's obvious they worded the commercial very carefully, but Apple's never (to my knowledge) said that Mac OS is immune to viruses, despite what the handfuls of users seem to believe here. Take that for whatever it's worth.

So, yeah, you can call me the annoying little pedantic brat of a kid holding his finger half an inch from your arm and saying "I'm not touching you!", but that doesn't mean I'm wrong ;)

One of these must be true:
1. You recently became aware that Apple makes computers
2. You don't believe what you just said, but you like trolling.
I bought my first Mac in 2001, I believe, so the former certainly isn't true. As for "liking to troll", do you feel I'm trolling because I'm going against the popular anti-Mac sentiment here rather than blindly for it, or for some other reason? What have I done differently than anyone else in this thread aside from swimming against the tide?

(Those are actual questions I'm posing for your response -- I'm legitimately curious)

I've seen these arguments long enough that I remember when Mac fanboys swore that Macs couldn't get viruses...They argued that it had nothing to do with marketshare.
I've just never known a Mac user who's said anything like that. I think there's a fairly small population of Mac users who have such an unreasonable devotion to Apple that they readily convince themselves that certain realities about Apple products don't exist, but to view some of the posts in this thread, you might be inclined to believe that all Mac users are like this, and that couldn't be further from the truth. That's my main issue here.
 
Anti-virus software was a part of Apple's .Mac package for years, almost up until it got repackaged as MobileMe. There has been antivirus software on the Mac since OS X came out, sold in Apple stores no less. How is any of this news?

Now, getting malware on OS X is tougher than getting it on XP for the same reason it is in Linux or Vista: users have to temporarily elevate themselves to root or admin instead of being logged on as that by default. That basic difference in user privileges is why Apple has been able to claim superiority in security over Windows for years (security in XP was a disaster that cost the company billions). This doesn't mean that malware is impossible on the platform, and its why taking additional steps for personal security is something that they recommend and have actually been recommending or actually bundling for a very long time now, despite the fact that malware issues on the OS X platform is much much smaller than it is on Windows. Then again, no platform has the malware issues that Windows does. Apache is way more prevalent than IIS and as far as I know it still isn't nearly as big a target.
 
From those two statements, I assume that the number of known virii on the Mac OS =/= 114,000. So the Mac OS could have *more* than PC.
 
The above reply was to this post


Obviously you don't.

PC: "...last year there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs."
Mac: "PCs. Not Macs".

You interpret this to mean "there are no viruses for Mac OS", do you? That's...well, that's a pretty impressive leap.
 
Mac users looking for an antivirus program might want to check out ClamXav at:
http://www.clamxav.com/

It's free, open source and based on the popular ClamAV.

It is not a on access scanner. It doesn't scan files as you open them. The included ClamXav Sentry component can however be configured to watch folders and sub folders.

It supports on demand scanning (right click -> more -> Scan...). The right click context menu is configured manually during installation.

It also supports scheduled scans and automatic updates.
 
I bought my first Mac in 2001, I believe, so the former certainly isn't true. As for "liking to troll", do you feel I'm trolling because I'm going against the popular anti-Mac sentiment here rather than blindly for it, or for some other reason? What have I done differently than anyone else in this thread aside from swimming against the tide?

Because you're arguing that Apple hasn't effectively said they were invulnerable to Viruses. They may have had some help page that recommended using AV software, but all of their marketing has made it clear that if you buy a Mac, your computer can't get sick.

Yes, I can parse it out and say that legally APple is in the clear, but the message to the masses wasn't, "We have a tiny marketshare, so nobody will attack OS X." The message was, "Our OS is bulletproof unlike that POS os from Redmond."

Those commercials were funny (not so much the more recent I'm a mac commercials), but Apple doesn't get to market things one way for 5 years and then expect everyone who's been saying the entire time that it's all about Marketshare to shut up and pretend like 5 years of apple FUD never happened.

I've just never known a Mac user who's said anything like that. I think there's a fairly small population of Mac users who have such an unreasonable devotion to Apple that they readily convince themselves that certain realities about Apple products don't exist, but to view some of the posts in this thread, you might be inclined to believe that all Mac users are like this, and that couldn't be further from the truth. That's my main issue here.

Well if you mean known personally, then same here....but that's because I've only known 2 Mac users in my life, and none of them were likely to post on mac boards, much less on tech news sites.
 
You mean it reminds you of someone who made an reasonably intelligent argument? :)

The point I intended to make there was that Apple didn't explicitly say that Macs can't get viruses, and that's a factually accurate statement. It's obvious they worded the commercial very carefully, but Apple's never (to my knowledge) said that Mac OS is immune to viruses, despite what the handfuls of users seem to believe here. Take that for whatever it's worth.

So, yeah, you can call me the annoying little pedantic brat of a kid holding his finger half an inch from your arm and saying "I'm not touching you!", but that doesn't mean I'm wrong ;)

you're right, it just makes you an ass.
 
I know at least two people currently who are "Mac converts" from PC's, and ask me almost every time when I'm getting a Mac and getting rid of my slow, beat up, crappy PC. Everything's just easier on it, it just works better, blah blah blah... Yes they both basically feed me Mac marketing lines of why a Mac is better. One of my wife's old boyfriends also was a big Mac fan... I never met him, but she has told me that he would argue Mac over PC whenever he got the chance just because he was such a firm believer in it :rolleyes:

So, this is @ phide, just because you haven't met these rabid Mac worshippers, they are not figments of peoples imaginations. Yes, they are not EVERY Mac user (thank God). And don't worry, I agree that people on EITHER side can take the whole "I'm a Mac", well "I'm a PC", thing WAY too far, who really cares what type of computer someone else uses? But for as much as someone may defend their PC from a Mac user, you can bet your ass that there is a Mac fan just waiting to spew Mac propaganda :p
 
Well if you mean known personally, then same here....but that's because I've only known 2 Mac users in my life, and none of them were likely to post on mac boards, much less on tech news sites.

as i mentioned before when someone said mac users arent like that, just go visit www.mac-forums.com!
 
Anti-virus software was a part of Apple's .Mac package for years, almost up until it got repackaged as MobileMe. There has been antivirus software on the Mac since OS X came out, sold in Apple stores no less. How is any of this news?

Now, getting malware on OS X is tougher than getting it on XP for the same reason it is in Linux or Vista: users have to temporarily elevate themselves to root or admin instead of being logged on as that by default. That basic difference in user privileges is why Apple has been able to claim superiority in security over Windows for years (security in XP was a disaster that cost the company billions). This doesn't mean that malware is impossible on the platform, and its why taking additional steps for personal security is something that they recommend and have actually been recommending or actually bundling for a very long time now, despite the fact that malware issues on the OS X platform is much much smaller than it is on Windows. Then again, no platform has the malware issues that Windows does. Apache is way more prevalent than IIS and as far as I know it still isn't nearly as big a target.

I could be wrong Serpico, but I believe that web pages running on Apache web servers are defaced at roughly the same rate as IIS, so I'm not really sure you can claim better security for one vs the other. I'd think that database attacks are vectors that are attempted that can be exploited on all web servers.

There are also attacks that don't require any user interaction, and those are not limited to windows. It was less than a month ago that such a vulnerability was discovered in the most recent Ubuntu release (I'm unsure if the issue was fixed or not).

Finally, I think that most attacks on windows occur on systems that aren't fully patched (which is why I now check friends computers to make sure they auto install patches, because I got tired of visiting and seeing 6 months or a year of patches uninstalled.

Finally finally ;), I suspect that most attacks are accomplished via social engineering, where a user downloads something that opens up a vulnerability. And all that requires is the crime groups to write something that appears useful to the end user.

Regardless, Apple has now retracted the KB entry, so I guess they've changed their collective mind.
 
Apple doesn't get to market things one way for 5 years and then expect everyone who's been saying the entire time that it's all about Marketshare to shut up and pretend like 5 years of apple FUD never happened.

Seriously, I mean, this guy right here... How can you say it better?
 
I see this is an old thread but I thought it might be worthwhile to mention that PC Tools offers a free on access scanner for Mac OS 10.5 and 10.6. I recall reading that it only scans for viruses and malware that target Macs.

http://www.iantivirus.com/
http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/networking_security/iantivirus.html

Also may be worthwhile to mention that Clamxav has been rewritten from the ground up. It's still not an on access scanner but the price is right.

http://www.clamxav.com/
 
Back
Top