Best LGA 775 Mobo

BAC4D00R SP1D0R

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 24, 2007
Messages
392
Well I'm on the market to get a new motherboard and this time I'm going to the Intel chipset route since I've used my eVGA 680i for nearly 3 years and I'm tired of all the random problems I'm getting. I'm looking for a excellent motherboard that will overclock my Q6600 with ease. My budget is around 100 to 150 bucks. I don't need the nicest mobo. Just something that will OC my quad and keep it stable and hopefully will last me another good 3 years;)

Some of the mobos' I'm looking at (P45 Chipsets):
Asus P5Q Pro
Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3L
Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R

If you guys have any other suggestions. Feel free to chime in. It will help. If you are curious about specs. It's in sig. Oh I also have the Xigmatek 80 mm CPU cooling tower since I know some mobos' heatsinks interfere with it. I also plan to purchase 2 x 2 GB G-Skill DDR2-1066 since my old OCZ goes to my girl's computer.
 
MSI P45 Neo3-F / FR is also something to consider, though the P5Q Pro and UD3R are probably the two most popular mid-to-high range P45 boards, with good reason. I'd take the Gigabyte over the ASUS due to personal preference.
 
Foxconn Blackops or the EVGA 790I SLi ultra motherboard....all good...or maybe a skulltrail?
 
Foxconn Blackops or the EVGA 790I SLi ultra motherboard....all good...or maybe a skulltrail?

stay away from the nvidia chipsets like the 790i.... and the skulltrail is socket 771, and costly for a setup.

the P45's mentioned above are good, take a look at those.
 
Foxconn Blackops or the EVGA 790I SLi ultra motherboard....all good...or maybe a skulltrail?
Skulltrail is dual socket LGA 771.

Since you don't need Crossfire or SLI, I would go for the Gigabyte UD3R. I think I'll be upgrading my P35 board to this after Christmas.
 
Yes I know that...but I love my Skulltrail...well not mine...anyone want pictures of it?
 
Yea that is what I was considering, a Gigabyte P45 mobo. I don't do crossfire and I won't go to DDR3 until a couple of years later. ASUS, DFI, Gigabyte. They are all excellent and the only criteria is needed a stable overclock which I want to get my quad up to 3.2 to 3.6 ghz.

The gigabyte will offer better options in the bios right? And do most of the motherboard manufacturers have solid state capticators now?
 
I've always been a bigger fan of Asus than Gigabyte. I've used both and they are very similar in terms of OCing. Right now, I have the P5Q Pro and I can't complain.
 
Yea that is what I was considering, a Gigabyte P45 mobo. I don't do crossfire and I won't go to DDR3 until a couple of years later. ASUS, DFI, Gigabyte. They are all excellent and the only criteria is needed a stable overclock which I want to get my quad up to 3.2 to 3.6 ghz.

The gigabyte will offer better options in the bios right? And do most of the motherboard manufacturers have solid state capticators now?

If you're going for best OC, rather than easiest OC... DFI is clearly the winner there.
 
Any thing with a Nvidia Chipset!

I know people will hate me for saying that, but Nvidia isn't really that bad these days.
 
Got facts? Or is it by experience :p

dfi as of late is rather renowned for leaving every switch, knob, and widget open to the user to manipulate in the bios. i'm talking way beyond gtl changes. this is what makes dfi boards more complicated to overclock.
 
ASUS Rampage Extreme. Hands down that's my pick.

lol well I wish I can afford it. As I said in the first post. 100 to 150. Overclockability that will last! Plus new Gskill DDR2 1066 memory.

I guess P5Q Pro or UD3R or DFI LP DK P45-T2RS PLUS

I'm leaning more towards the UD3R since most people had good experiences and seems like a good choice and can get up to 16 GB of memory which I won't and will just go for 8 gigs and call it a day.
 
P5Q Pro would be the best option IMO.

I hear there very good OCers, but i think the only support x8/x8 Crossfire.
 
Yea, as an owner of multiple RAM eating and data killing 680i's, they sucked hardcore. My 790i was much better but still ran crazy hot and wasn't as nice as an Intel board especially OC'ing.
If you don't believe me ask Dan_D about his wonderful 680i experience. He went through, I believe, 11 680i's in one year.

For you though I'd recommend the P5Q Pro or the Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R.
 
For the money, you can't beat the P5Q Pro. Good blend of price and features. Enough features to be useful, but not too excessive to drive the price through the roof.
 
Yea, as an owner of multiple RAM eating and data killing 680i's, they sucked hardcore. My 790i was much better but still ran crazy hot and wasn't as nice as an Intel board especially OC'ing.
If you don't believe me ask Dan_D about his wonderful 680i experience. He went through, I believe, 11 680i's in one year.

For you though I'd recommend the P5Q Pro or the Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R.

My 680i is doing just fine, i remember when they were really bad. As i said these days they are actually more reliable.

But remember, this is coming from someone that doesn't OC.;)

And yes the P5Q Pro is a good board and i recommend it, being so cheap and from what i hear a good OCer.:)
 
The Asus Striker Extreme which was based on the 680i chipset was one of the best overclocker back then. I don't remember seeing bad reviews and comments about the first 680i motherboard that was released the EVGA. It absolutely killed then current motherboards the top ranges 965 and 975bx2 series. It was the best in performance in terms of its nvidia chipset, quad core extreme support and nvidia SLi technology. Then the Asus make of the 680i, Striker Extreme topped it up and extended the tech with better overclocking capabilities.
 
The Asus Striker Extreme which was based on the 680i chipset was one of the best overclocker back then. I don't remember seeing bad reviews and comments about the first 680i motherboard that was released the EVGA. It absolutely killed then current motherboards the top ranges 965 and 975bx2 series. It was the best in performance in terms of its nvidia chipset, quad core extreme support and nvidia SLi technology. Then the Asus make of the 680i, Striker Extreme topped it up and extended the tech with better overclocking capabilities.

Except for the aforementioned data corruption issues and the RAID-killing problems the early 680i boards had. Also, the 680i boards didn't overclock any better than the 965P boards that were out at the time, and the P35 chipset that came out shortly after was much better for overclocking than the 680i was. Also, the 680i boards had some issues with quad-core CPUs as well.
 
I have a QX6700 on my 680i, no problems what so ever.

But yes those were the earlier problems the 680i's had, i dont OC so i dont know about that.
 
From what I've heard from others, GA-P35-DS3L
 
From what I've heard from others, GA-P35-DS3L

Certainly not. That board was a great budget board in its prime, but it was never among the best LGA775 boards, and right now it's already fairly outdated. There are much better budget options available like the GA-EP43-DS3L, GA-EP45-UD3P and UD3R, ASUS P5Q Pro, and others.
 
Except for the aforementioned data corruption issues and the RAID-killing problems the early 680i boards had. Also, the 680i boards didn't overclock any better than the 965P boards that were out at the time, and the P35 chipset that came out shortly after was much better for overclocking than the 680i was. Also, the 680i boards had some issues with quad-core CPUs as well.

Well the 2nd gen 680i killed most of the top end 965-975 mobos. The Asus Striker was the best oc'er in that period of time. Yeah the early 680i did have some problem with quad cores as they weren't released when the 680i came out. But everything was fixed after a BIOS update.
 
Well the 2nd gen 680i killed most of the top end 965-975 mobos. The Asus Striker was the best oc'er in that period of time. Yeah the early 680i did have some problem with quad cores as they weren't released when the 680i came out. But everything was fixed after a BIOS update.

No it wasn't. The early revision boards wouldn't OC more than about 500-600Mhz with a quad even after the BIOS updates, and even the later revision boards many people couldn't get past 3.2Ghz with the Q6600... while they were able to get their chips near 4Ghz on P35 based boards. (I know. I was one of them, and I was far from alone.) If you're using all 4 RAM banks on a 680i and are running a quad, life's hard enough just getting it stable at stock.

I've had 2 680i reference boards die on me, and I went through 4 variants of the 680i (EVGA 680i SLI SE, XFX 680i SLI LT, XFX 680i SLI, Abit IN9-32X MAX non-reference 680i) and two 780i variants (MSI P7N-Diamond and XFX 780i SLI) before I found one that would reliably run this quad at 3.6Ghz... which I know is good to 3.8 on a P45. My current board is the best of the bunch, and even it won't run the chip at 3.8, which frustrates me to no end.

As of right now, if you're buying a LGA775 SLI-capable board and it's not one of the following -- some variant of the 790i / 790i Ultra, the EVGA 750i SLI FTW, or Intel Skulltrail -- you're making a huge and potentially costly (almost certainly frustrating) mistake.
 
I find this interesting and sadly true. My 680i motherboard from eVGA won't overclock my quad. Which is why I'm going the Intel route. Sorry Nvidia but you have to come up with better designs.
 
Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3R

Said this because my personal preference are the Gigabyte boards. :p

Although, many seem to like and use Asus' P5Q Pro.
 
No it wasn't. The early revision boards wouldn't OC more than about 500-600Mhz with a quad even after the BIOS updates, and even the later revision boards many people couldn't get past 3.2Ghz with the Q6600... while they were able to get their chips near 4Ghz on P35 based boards. (I know. I was one of them, and I was far from alone.) If you're using all 4 RAM banks on a 680i and are running a quad, life's hard enough just getting it stable at stock.

I've had 2 680i reference boards die on me, and I went through 4 variants of the 680i (EVGA 680i SLI SE, XFX 680i SLI LT, XFX 680i SLI, Abit IN9-32X MAX non-reference 680i) and two 780i variants (MSI P7N-Diamond and XFX 780i SLI) before I found one that would reliably run this quad at 3.6Ghz... which I know is good to 3.8 on a P45. My current board is the best of the bunch, and even it won't run the chip at 3.8, which frustrates me to no end.

As of right now, if you're buying a LGA775 SLI-capable board and it's not one of the following -- some variant of the 790i / 790i Ultra, the EVGA 750i SLI FTW, or Intel Skulltrail -- you're making a huge and potentially costly (almost certainly frustrating) mistake.


I have to disagree on the last part.

If you dont OC then i say get a 680i or any Nvidia chipset, if you do i recommend the Intel chipsets. These days the 680i's aren't that problematic as they were ealier.
 
I would say go for the UD3R. I recently (two weeks ago) bought one and I have never been happier. It's great for the price and took my E8400 from 3.0 GHz to 4.0 GHz on air cooling.
 
As of right now, if you're buying a LGA775 SLI-capable board and it's not one of the following -- some variant of the 790i / 790i Ultra, the EVGA 750i SLI FTW, or Intel Skulltrail -- you're making a huge and potentially costly (almost certainly frustrating) mistake.
The Skulltrail board is not LGA775.
If you dont OC then i say get a 680i or any Nvidia chipset, if you do i recommend the Intel chipsets. These days the 680i's aren't that problematic as they were ealier.
If you don't overclock, why would you bother with a 680i board altogether? Although the 680i boards may not be as unstable as they used to be, Intel-based boards are still far more reliable, and if you need an SLI board, the 750i and 790i chipsets are also much better.

Edit: Whoops, sorry for the double-post. I meant to edit my previous one but clicked the post button accidentally.
 
If you don't overclock, why would you bother with a 680i board altogether? Although the 680i boards may not be as unstable as they used to be, Intel-based boards are still far more reliable, and if you need an SLI board, the 750i and 790i chipsets are also much better.

Edit: Whoops, sorry for the double-post. I meant to edit my previous one but clicked the post button accidentally.


Because it was cheap at the time.;)

And i am sure SLI works fine on it.
 
Because it was cheap at the time.;)

And i am sure SLI works fine on it.
I didn't mean you specifically, I meant anyone in general. And although the 680i boards do work fine with SLI, so do the 750i and 790i boards, which are also much more stable and reliable. So there's really no good reason to go with a 680i or 780i board considering the other available options.
With a BIOS update they do support 45nm Duals, so thats always a good thing.:)
Not good enough.
 
Back
Top