Apple Recommends Antivirus Software For Macs

I'll be keeping my mac anti-virus AND virus free ;)

the only viruses ive seen out there require a PEBKAC exploit...
 
No, he's right. There is a way to have a 100% secure system. The only problem is, it has no functionality.

so little functionality that it would have zero input and zero output....in other words you might as well pull the plug. i'd hardly call that a system of any sort. even then take into account hardware hacks, etc. there's always a way in, its just a matter of if it could be done in your lifetime is all. or hell if its even worthwhile.

one of the first things you learn in a programming class or advanced computer class is that there are three levels of security (with as many sub levels as you can dream up)

1. unprotected/open - think of DOS, nothing protecting it really

2. passwords/closed systems - like what we use now

3. totally secure - this one is what we try to achieve, but we can never quite get there. its considered purely hypothetical.
 
wtf...i thought that shit just worked. what in the blue hell does it need AV for? :p :rolleyes:
 
kdw1975:
http://www.wired.com/techbiz/people/magazine/16-12/ff_kaminsky

read the first 2 pages, how do you remove the user without defeating the purpose of the product?

as far as time and money being no object, the infinite monkey theorem applies. If you could afford to hire a programmer working 24/7/365 to be constantly improving your OS it could be virus proof, until he stopped.

Bullshit. Billions, millions, or trillions of line's of a code in a complex OS can't be monitored and changed by said programmer constantly. When something is exploited they have to figure out where it occurs, change the code but not only that, verify it doesn't fuck anything else up. It's not a simple "Oh, I see he has found this simple typo in my line of code, <Fixes typo>, okay, time to release to millions of people in the public!!" :rolleyes:
 
Apple just shot themselfs in the foot with those "Apple PCs don't have viruses" commercials. What it took like 3 months for the first ones to cause trouble and now Apple is recommending you get AV software :p
 
I know very little about programming but this is surprising. So your saying that If I have an operating system with the bare minimum of code. One that simply starts up the hardware and wouldn't run any software that it would be susceptible to viruses as well?

Let me put it in the simplest possible way. Unless the problem a program solves is trivial, it has flaws.

Operating systems are not trivial programs and neither are the vast majority of applications that are bundled with the OS.

To write a bullet proof OS, you'd have to be an all knowing individual capable of anticipating every possible vector of attack.
 
Apple just shot themselfs in the foot with those "Apple PCs don't have viruses" commercials. What it took like 3 months for the first ones to cause trouble and now Apple is recommending you get AV software :p

They're going to backpedal. They're going to say "we meant Apple don't GET viruses, not that Apple can't have viruses". You just watch.
 
Rofl @ apple.

*Prepares for incoming "hip" commercial starring almost forgettable young, cool actor.*
 
I'm deaf, so I don't hear all the words.. but..
Obviously you don't.

PC: "...last year there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs."
Mac: "PCs. Not Macs".

You interpret this to mean "there are no viruses for Mac OS", do you? That's...well, that's a pretty impressive leap.
 
Obviously you don't.

PC: "...last year there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs."
Mac: "PCs. Not Macs".

You interpret this to mean "there are no viruses for Mac OS", do you? That's...well, that's a pretty impressive leap.

Hey fuck you.

I gave you a disclaimer.
 
If you're actually deaf, then I apologize. I assumed you were just being a smartass.
 
Obviously you don't.

PC: "...last year there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs."
Mac: "PCs. Not Macs".

You interpret this to mean "there are no viruses for Mac OS", do you? That's...well, that's a pretty impressive leap.

I would argue that this commercial is saying exactly that.
 
If you're actually deaf, then I apologize. I assumed you were just being a smartass.

In phide's defense it is hard to tell if you were being serious of sarcastic in the context and the fact we're not face to face.

phide, with that commercial it was like Apple was throwing down the gloves to issue a challenge which in fact judging by Defcon a lot of people took very serious. I mean look how script monkeys (fly my pretties, fly) react when you call them out, its a fucking nightmare (as Gibson Research can surely serve as a reminder/warning).
 
I would argue that this commercial is saying exactly that.
I'm not sure I understand that. I mean, if you overheard a conversation where one person says "I have eight PCs on my table", and the other person says "I don't", you would assume that the second person has no PCs at all? All you could garner from that conversation is that the second person doesn't have eight PCs on his table.

Now, I think the commercial was worded very carefully to make viewers think that, maybe, Macs don't get viruses (a little shady, which isn't at all atypical for Mac ads), but the commercial doesn't make that claim.
 
I'm not sure I understand that. I mean, if you overheard a conversation where one person says "I have eight PCs on my table", and the other person says "I don't", you would assume that the second person has no PCs at all? All you could garner from that conversation is that the second person doesn't have eight PCs on his table.

Now, I think the commercial was worded very carefully to make viewers think that, maybe, Macs don't get viruses (a little shady, which isn't at all atypical for Mac ads), but the commercial doesn't make that claim.

I would argue that the commercial is implying that Macs get few, if any, viruses. While the claim is never made explicitly, I feel it is pretty much implied from the wording. Had the response been "Macs only had X" or "Macs didn't have nearly that number," then maybe it would have been clearer that they were implying less instead of none. However, the way it's worded now, to me, seems to be an issue of have vs. have not, rather than quantity. Of course, this could be my thinly veiled disdain for all things Apple influencing my interpretation of the connotation here, but....yeah.:rolleyes:
 
Whats funny is that the Mac elitists at macrumors.com only post good news about Macs, and thus this article was not posted. Many of the guys there need a reality check.
 
I would argue that the commercial is implying that Macs get few, if any, viruses. While the claim is never made explicitly, I feel it is pretty much implied from the wording. Had the response been "Macs only had X" or "Macs didn't have nearly that number," then maybe it would have been clearer that they were implying less instead of none. However, the way it's worded now, to me, seems to be an issue of have vs. have not, rather than quantity. Of course, this could be my thinly veiled disdain for all things Apple influencing my interpretation of the connotation here, but....yeah.:rolleyes:
Can you tell me how Apple suggesting anti-virus protocols is proof that implying Macs get "few, if any viruses" is a lie? Historically the crux of this argument for the PC side was that Macs just didn't have the market share that PCs did and that's why there were very few (and at one point in time, absolutely zero) Mac viruses. But Apple's market share has been steadily (albeit slowly) increasing for years now, and I don't see a ton of reports on terrible viruses. Which is also surprising, because a large amount of viruses are spread from your computer-illiterate grandmother opening a .vbs file she got as an attachment in her e-mail; PC elitists have long maintained as an integral part of their arguments the idea that people who buy Macs are just too stupid to learn how to use a "real" PC.

Granted, I have not been following the reports of Mac vs. PC viruses extremely closely, being as it is that I don't particularly care. I just feel compelled to post in these threads wherein 15-20 PC "fans" (nice word deliberately used) catch on to a tiny, potentially negative thing about Apples, or Macs, and use it to gloat about the PC's superiority and talk about how much they hate the snobby "elitists" who buy Apple's products. Hypocrisy hurts my bones, and you guys aren't even doing a remotely decent job of it.
 
But I clearly remember being informed on MULTIPLE occasions that the reason for viruses is that Windows is badly programmed and that's why there are no viruses for Mac OSes. If that's not true, we'd have to believe something crazy such as that Macs are so unimportant that they can't even get negative attention. I mean, I realize they're useless, but still, THAT useless?!!?

Don't you dare talk poorly of Steve Mobs! He may be the CEO we fired 10 years ago and hired again, but he is god!
 
To KDW1975

I write software, and I can tell you that it is not realistic to write an OS that is virus-proof.

An application that is written in ASM, and interfaces with a single piece of hardware can be virtually virus proof, no problem. Companies like HP have code that runs exclusively on a specific circuit card, very secure.

But when you write an OS, you want much more functionality than that. You want the user to be able to download and run applications. You want a web browser that supports many types of plug-ins that allow web pages to display and run all sorts of graphics and custom displays. You want the user to be able to remotely log on to his/her PC/Mac, while they are at work, maybe to copy a file, or even remotely run an application.

This opens the door for potential security flaws. If you allow a user to download and open a program, how are you going to prevent the program from doing something malicious? You could attempt to de-compile/reverse engineer the program (which is not legal to do), and evaluate every function, and prevent it from running certain functions. This would occasionally hang the OS indefinitely, or crash it, because there are many platforms that compile PC-compatible software. And also this opens the door for many lawsuits, because a lot software is copyrighted, and you are not permitted to legally de-compile it. You will say "fine, then force software makers to comply with my OS agreement, so I can decompile everything before it runs." If you implemented this, it would cripple your OS in terms of performance, and there are many scenarios, that I will not go into, that could still defeat even this security measure.

Or you could have the OS watch the application, and whenever it tries to do something deemed malicious, you could "pause" its operating thread, and alert the user. Many antivirus programs do something similar to this. In fact, Vista does this exact thing with UAC. One of the problems is determining what is a security flaw, and what is not? If Microsoft Office wants to overwrite a registered dll with a newer one, is this OK? What about a freeware application? Who decides what is safe and what is not? Should all system files be made non-replaceable? No? Really? What if someone wants to write a new "skin" for you OS? What about web page plug ins? Can browsers execute code on the users PC? No? Then how will some web applications run properly, or update properly? Provide a popup blocker, and let the user decide? We already have that now, and black hat hackers pride themselves on making the best pop up window that looks just like a windows security prompt "Security breach! Click here to Fix. Its OK, I am a Mac/Windows component".

If you allow the user to make any security decision, then there is no way to prevent every piece of malicious code from running. Vista does a pretty good job of at least alerting the user before a potential security breach is about to occur.

Anyway, OS makers do not make built-in antivirus applications. Companies that exclusively write antivirus applications can devote their entire software budget to making the most effective anti-virus possible.

There is no way to make a bullet-proof OS, that can’t be exploited. Even if you only had the most basic functions enabled, you are at the mercy of every software vender on the planet, because a lot of upgradeable software has security flaws that hackers take advantage of.
 
you re all missing the point, this is glossy white anti virus software... with an illuminated fruit that serves as a beacon to boldly declare your superiority over the unwashed masses and their malignant generic computers.
 
you re all missing the point, this is glossy white anti virus software... with an illuminated fruit that serves as a beacon to boldly declare your superiority over the unwashed masses and their malignant generic computers.
You beat that dead horse, dude! You beat it long, and you beat it hard.
 
the great part is they say use MORE then one!

lets see how fast OSX is now with McCrappy and Norton installed at the same time!!!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7760344.stm

The support note recommends that Mac owners install one or more of three anti-virus products.

Advice on the site said: "Apple encourages the widespread use of multiple antivirus utilities so that virus programmers have more than one application to circumvent, thus making the whole virus writing process more difficult."

Apple recommended users try McAfee VirusScan, Symantec Norton Anti-Virus 11, or Intego VirusBarrier X5.
 
I do hope that Apple will be more proactive about malware no matter what. For too long they have used it as a marketing gimmick in relation to Windows claiming better security. One of the first "I'm a Mac" adds used this misperception.

Microsoft has had to deal with malware much more seriously and is just beginning to get past the joke stage of security.
 
I don't think a single, INFORMED, apple user thinks their Mac's can't get a virus. I think we *all* know we're protected through obscurity.

Mac's don't get viruses. They can, but they don't. Who fucking cares *why* they don't. Why do people argue over this crap?
 
okay found it!


http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/os-x-applications-games/132225-apple-says-get-antivirus.html

from one poster..

OS X, and any computer operating system, is susceptible the viruses - that is a fact, and a long-standing one at that. The difference between OS X and Windows is that it is not prone to viruses because there are built-in safeguards that make it very difficult to write a successful virus unless there is an unpatched hole. This is precisely why there has never been an "in-the-wild" virus for OS X.

Although Apple may now officially recommend an anti-virus product, they're simply useless as they have nothing to scan for (aside from Windows viruses). I'll also go a step forward and say that provided you are cognizant of any requests for your administrator password, you'll likely never have an issue with any kind of malware.


Thoughts?
 
I don't think a single, INFORMED, apple user thinks their Mac's can't get a virus. I think we *all* know we're protected through obscurity.

Mac's don't get viruses. They can, but they don't. Who fucking cares *why* they don't. Why do people argue over this crap?

Huh?:confused:
 
What a load of BS.. Apple has recommended Anti-virus software for years. People see what they want to see

From 2002: http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=50569
From early 2008: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1147
Virex with .Mac accounts: http://www.thestandard.com/news/200...tes-same-antivirus-advice-it-gave-6-years-ago

Really? I think the point is that apple recommends antivirus at all, not that it just did this a minute ago or years ago or whatever. It proves the idiots that spam forums with "macs don't need AV" wrong, once and for all. ALL computers need AV, unless you really have the machine locked down tight and know what you are doing. For instance with Vista, you get DEP, ASLR, Protected Mode IE7, Two-way firewall, auto-updates and UAC, unless you download malware and run it on purpose, you aren't going to get infected.
I can run my PC (and have for over a year) without AV and every so often I do a malware scan and it finds nothing. But Mac OS X doesn't even have most of Vista's protection, it only has a small market share and that only does so much protection.
 
Arcygenical , go take a look over on www.mac-forums.com,. all i ever read is "you dont need anything, your safe! for the last few years i have been on that site..

here..

Those kinds of drive-by downloads are nothing new. I would be concerned about them if I was running something like IE that is prone to holes that can be opened with ActiveX scripts.

Sorry, but wasnt Safari to first one to go in the competition a few months back, exploited by a malicious web site?
 
Apple just shot themselfs in the foot with those "Apple PCs don't have viruses" commercials.
wasnt Safari to first one to go in the competition a few months back, exploited by a malicious web site?
Maybe they should have spent some of thier money on fixing their OS, instead of advertising :eek!:

IMO those three sum it up pretty good.

Elitist snobs... Can't wait until I ask the next Mac jackass I see about this. "Hey I was thinking, if Macs are so great and always virus free, why did Apple start promoting the use of Anti-Virus software on Macs last week?"

Nice. Bigotry doesn't even get a person a slap on the wrist, but swearing, which everyone else does (including you) earns them a ban.
It wasn't the word itself, the context ;)
 
Back
Top