i7 vs Q9550: Why Go Q?

Joined
Oct 10, 2007
Messages
34
I'm pricing out different options for my new build. I was all set deciding between Q9550 and the higher end dual core line. But then Intel had to go and make it even more complicated for my wishy washiness and release the i7 and for a not so bad price either! I've seen the i7 920 selling for $288 - cheaper than the Q9950 and E8600. With this small gap in price, why go with the older socket? Aside from a price difference of ~$100 to go with the new LGA 1366 mobo, why get yourself stuck with LGA 775 when I presume that 1366 is the future? Would it be wise to go with the new to give myself a little better future proofing?
 
If you are building right now, unless you are trying to go as cheap as possible, there is no reason to buy a 775 board instead of x58.
 
I was very surprised at how affordable the i7 processors are, but the memory and motherboards are still twice as expensive as LGA775.

I think the difference between a Core and i7 system would probably be something like $300.

You can get a decent Core motherboard for $100, and 4GB of decent DDR2 for $50. X58 motherboards and DDR3 memory will be around 2-3x. maybe 4x, that cost.

edit: on the other hand, if you are just going to go with i7 to be future proof, that is pretty ridiculous. Go back in time a few years and tell me how many LGA775 motherboards that were available at launch are still a good platform. The LGA775 socket has been great and quite long-lived, but I don't think that first-gen motherboards of any socket are worth the early-adoption tax.
 
Personally , I'm just gonna do a P45 Mobo and a Q9550 maybe and wait on i7 for awhile. I friggin refuse at this point to pay over 200 bucks for a damn motherboard.
I don't really need the 9550 either as my Q6600 is still smoking at 3.6 for everyday use. However I like the idea of a cooler running Quad and Gigabytes new 2 oz copper mobo. GA-EP45-UD3R.
 
Still comes down to pricing. A 9550 is still going to be a decent cpu in 2 years. Right now the cpu's are about the same price [the i7 920 that is]. The difference still is the mobo is going to cost you between $100-150 more going with a x58 [depending on what S775 you picked] and the ddr2 versus ddr3 issue. 4gb of ddr2 is less than $50. Which is to say 8gb of ddr2 is cheaper than 3gb of ddr3.
 
i7 is not necessary yet, Q9450 and up are plenty for now :). even Q6600!
 
I'm not trying to debate my way into getting the answer I want from you guys, but like some of you are saying... it's not necessary, Q9550 and Q6600 are good for right now... but what I'm more focused on is the longevity of S775 from now onto the next couple years. I don't want to be stuck at the top end of a socket being (possibly) phased out for a new socket and get stuck when I want to upgrade. That's my concern. Know what I mean? I'm not that up to date when it comes to knowing the industry's news and projected technology, so some input from you guys in the know would be great.
 
If you look at Intel's roadmap it shows Core2quad being the mainstream processor of choice well into 2009. I don't think your S775 setup is going to be a bad buy at this time, but I wouldn't expect an upgrade path other than adding RAM. You most likely will replace CPU, mobo, and ram all at once whenever you move up. I don't think they will release any newer, faster versions of C2Q than what are already available now that i7 is out. Performance wise the Q9550 or Q6600 are more than enough for all but the most demanding users.
 
what will you be using the computer for

I'll be using it for trading, usually with a minimum of ten CPU intensive chart windows; simultaneously running a desktop sharing application like Dim Dim or Adobe Connect. When not trading, I'd like to run some flight simulators on it. I'll be hooking this up to six 20.1" monitors.
 
3 graphics cards would also work, if his mobo has 3 x16 length slots.
 
Well, you wouldn't necessarily need to go with x16 length video cards, and maybe save yourself some money, power consumption, or extra slots.
 
Not too sure about this, but it's 1 monitor per DVI? If so... lemme suggest the 4850X2 which has 4 DVI ports. So 2 4850X2s which requires only 2 PCIE16s will give you 8 DVI ports.
 
Unless you can save a considerable amount of cash or don't have enough cash for the i7, there isn't any reason to go Q.
 
I thought it was 1 card for 2 monitors since they're 6? :confused:
ecstatic.gif
 
I'm not trying to debate my way into getting the answer I want from you guys, but like some of you are saying... it's not necessary, Q9550 and Q6600 are good for right now... but what I'm more focused on is the longevity of S775 from now onto the next couple years. I don't want to be stuck at the top end of a socket being (possibly) phased out for a new socket and get stuck when I want to upgrade. That's my concern. Know what I mean? I'm not that up to date when it comes to knowing the industry's news and projected technology, so some input from you guys in the know would be great.

You are probably in the same boat as I am.

I know my system is still pretty decent and does most things just fine...probably will for a while as well. However, I am going with an i7 because it I haven't upgraded in a few years, and like many have said in the past, it just isn't worth it to upgrade to aother C2D chip (or Quad in this case).

The cost between a solid C2D build or a solid Quad build is about $300-$400 (I actually added them each up in a cart at Newegg last night). If you really want a Quad that will match the actual performance of an i7 chip, the lower end Quads probably won't do. Besides, why pay "almost" the same for older (I didn't say poor) techology when you can get into a complete new rig for a little more. Now, the term "little" is relative so take it for what it's worth, but you see my point. I consider myself pretty level-headed, ad I can't honestly see the purpose of upgradig to a Quad with the i7 here.

What I can see though, is the purpose of upgrading my f**king keyboard to one with a consistently working "N" key.
 
^ Upgrading to a C2Q makes sense if you have components that already support it (duh.. since you're not needing a new mobo and ram). It only does not make sense to C2Q if you are hanging below LGA775.
 
^ Upgrading to a C2Q makes sense if you have components that already support it (duh.. since you're not needing a new mobo and ram). It only does not make sense to C2Q if you are hanging below LGA775.

For just gaming I'm not sure this holds.... and this guy is sort of borderline
 
I'll be using it for trading, usually with a minimum of ten CPU intensive chart windows; simultaneously running a desktop sharing application like Dim Dim or Adobe Connect. When not trading, I'd like to run some flight simulators on it. I'll be hooking this up to six 20.1" monitors.

This means you'll be constantly multitasking. Furthermore, you seem to be putting a premium on getting real time information quickly and conveniently (i.e. 6 monitors) and likely want to be able to switch applications or views quite quickly. Also seems like you have reasonable flexibility with your budget (unless you just lost your shirt with the way equities are going...).

In this case, I'd simply go with the more capable processor unless the price difference was "significant". The i7 is more capable than the Q series. And the price difference for someone with some flexibility in their budget is minimal. Just go i7 with lots of physical memory.

(If you a pure gamer or on a budget, than might as well stick to the Q.)
 
^ Upgrading to a C2Q makes sense if you have components that already support it (duh.. since you're not needing a new mobo and ram). It only does not make sense to C2Q if you are hanging below LGA775.

Total agreement. Anyone still banging around on s939 or God forbid an older P4 or worse is really better off going i7. I mean if you lived with your current system that long [3-5 years] than the i7 platform is the better long term decision.
Now having said that anyone still using the same cpu and mobo from 3-5 years ago maybe does not need new high end parts. In 3-5 years a Q9550 is certainly going to be behind the times but it might be still good enough for some. While we are [H] how many people are still doing OK with P3's and AXP's? Shoot my second rig is still an AXP rig and its beyond good enough for Word, email, Internet and even the kids games like Spore and stuff. So maybe it only gets 5fps in Crysis that's not its primary purpose.
 
Nice last post. I'm one of those people you mentioned. I'm sitting with an AMD X2 3800+ for the past three years and was planning to build a Q9550 system. Now I jusr can't decide between the Q9550 and the i7 920. I may just wait a month to see where prices fall. I can't see x58 motherboards and memory staying so high. Come on, we have all been used to cheap memory for so long. And good motherboards by Gigabyte and Asus are only $100. The x58 stuff will have to free fall soon.
 
Nice last post. I'm one of those people you mentioned. I'm sitting with an AMD X2 3800+ for the past three years and was planning to build a Q9550 system. Now I jusr can't decide between the Q9550 and the i7 920. I may just wait a month to see where prices fall. I can't see x58 motherboards and memory staying so high. Come on, we have all been used to cheap memory for so long. And good motherboards by Gigabyte and Asus are only $100. The x58 stuff will have to free fall soon.

And in your case if you decided to go with the Q9550 and got a decent P45 mobo for like $125 and got 8gb of ddr2 for less than $100 you'd probably still be in decent shape in 2011. Games and apps are still not maximized for quads yet. You have to figure a Q9550 with a 2010 gpu is still going to be able to play 2010 games.
At the end of the day it boils down to price. You will save $$ going s775 now. If you got the bucks though might as well go i7. There are worse things though than a Q9550 and 8gb of ram
 
Wait till after the holiday known as "greedfest" then the price of ddr3 will go down and you wont have to buy ridiculous $300 motherboard.
 
Total agreement. Anyone still banging around on s939 or God forbid an older P4 or worse is really better off going i7. I mean if you lived with your current system that long [3-5 years] than the i7 platform is the better long term decision.
Now having said that anyone still using the same cpu and mobo from 3-5 years ago maybe does not need new high end parts. In 3-5 years a Q9550 is certainly going to be behind the times but it might be still good enough for some. While we are [H] how many people are still doing OK with P3's and AXP's? Shoot my second rig is still an AXP rig and its beyond good enough for Word, email, Internet and even the kids games like Spore and stuff. So maybe it only gets 5fps in Crysis that's not its primary purpose.

Haha... I'm actually one of those really cheap and indecisive bastards who still has a Prescott.
 
man this is a tough decision. im building a new rig aswell. i am coming from a 3 year old rig and while i hope it wont be that long before another upgrade i dont want to spend money on something thats going have a better model right down the road.

i think i am just going to go c2d for the savings to get the expensive case i want and a bigger psu for the future. then in about 6 months when things have settled and some bugs get worked out make the switch. i want to go quad but just dont think its worth it right now.
 
Haha... I'm actually one of those really cheap and indecisive bastards who still has a Prescott.

And that's fine, even if you settle for a Q9550 that's going to be world's better than your P4 now. In 2-3 years a Q9550 is still a cpu you should not sneeze at
 
I was very surprised at how affordable the i7 processors are, but the memory and motherboards are still twice as expensive as LGA775.

I think the difference between a Core and i7 system would probably be something like $300.

You can get a decent Core motherboard for $100, and 4GB of decent DDR2 for $50. X58 motherboards and DDR3 memory will be around 2-3x. maybe 4x, that cost.

edit: on the other hand, if you are just going to go with i7 to be future proof, that is pretty ridiculous. Go back in time a few years and tell me how many LGA775 motherboards that were available at launch are still a good platform. The LGA775 socket has been great and quite long-lived, but I don't think that first-gen motherboards of any socket are worth the early-adoption tax.


Surprisingly, it's not the motherboards which get you whacked with the so-called early-adopters' tax when it comes to LGA1366 (in fact, given similar configurations, it's basically a wash between LGA775 and LGA1366), but the memory configurations; however, this is *entirely* due to the triple-channel memory support of LGA1366, DDR3 vs. DDR3 (there are motherboards that support LGA775 and DDR3, including several that are DDR3-only at that socket's high-end; it is these motherboards that should be compared at all to their LGA1366 counterparts).

Bringing DDR2 in utterly queers any comparison (apples vs. oranges!); it would be just as unfair to compare DDR2 to DDR-supporting LGA775 motherboards (such as ASRock's 4CORE DualSATA R2 which supports standard DDR400).

What must be truly considered is if you are going to be using the targeted system for anything that truly takes advantage of the extra bandwidth that triple-channel DDR3 provides. If not, then stick with LGA775 and Yorkfield (or even Kentsfield, such as Q6600); if so, then Core i7, even at this early stage, would make more sense.

In short, it's still what you are going to use it for that should determine what you put into the system in the way of parts.
 
I'm using a C2D laptop right now. My last desktop was the Northwood P4 in my sig. Basically when available cash = cost for i7 that's when I pull the trigger. Whether that is when my cash gets more or i7 gets less is anybodies guess.

I am one of those that carries a system for 5+ years so I'm going for the new socket. My laptop does fine for now but there are other things I would like to do with a desktop but don't need to right now.
 
@ OP, it all depends on what your going to be doing ie. gaming, video encoding etc. If your gaming, stick with the cheaper 775 socket considering most games now still are not coded for 4 cores, let alone 8. Here is a good thread that compares the i7 to the c2duo/quad.

http://www.ocforums.com/showthread.php?t=583975

From the results of that thread, id take that extra money and get a awesome graphics card(s).
 
I paid $450 for my motherboard, 4GB ram, and CPU combo.

With it I'm able to get 4.3Ghz Stable, so I don't see why I need to go with i7. In 6 months I can sell everything for $250ish, and put that money into an i7 system that has better revisions and steppings and the mobos have all the kinks worked out of it.

:)
 
I paid $450 for my motherboard, 4GB ram, and CPU combo.

With it I'm able to get 4.3Ghz Stable, so I don't see why I need to go with i7. In 6 months I can sell everything for $250ish, and put that money into an i7 system that has better revisions and steppings and the mobos have all the kinks worked out of it.

:)

I paid 650 for my motherboard, 6gb of ddr3 and cpu, and in 6 months i wont have to bother upgrading because i already have i7 :)
 
Honestly, I'm going to sit with my Q6600 for a while. It's still got more than enough oomph left for everything that I need to do and probably will need to do for a long time. Plus I vowed to never be an early adopter again after buying the Opteron 175.

Despite the 175 being a great chip even though it cost $400 when I got it, and the mobo Asus A8N Sli Premium for $200, the processor lasted me a few years and probably would still do the job just fine for my media center. It just dropped in price like a lead weight. Same with the 7800GTX I bought when it first came out. Something like $400 at the time (I can look it up at newegg), and shortly after I bought it... a 512MB version was released.

So I'll wait things out until more boards are released with newer, better features, and everything movies into a reasonable price range.
 
Well one reason i upgraded is that SLI scales so much better on X58 boards. Also, this 750i board i have right now is pissing me off as it refuses to play nice with 4gb of memory. I built right after the q6600 dropped in price last year and skipped over the 45nm chips. I have been drooling waiting for the nehalems to come out. So now my q6600 will go into my media pc and replace the e2180.
 
yeah, eventually that's what will happen with my Q6600, my media center is an E6300, and the Q6600 will replace it. But that's a while down the road.
 
Back
Top