Seagate 7200.10... my poor ears

cannondale06

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
16,180
I just bought a new Dell comp and I am about to go insane from the hard drive noise. its a Seagate 750gb 7200.10 and it is almost unbearable. I can hear it grinding from 30 feet away a quick google search confirms that this is one loud ass hd.

I got a super good deal on the pc and would hate to return it. changing to a different brand hard drive is not an option with the Dell oem os. is there anything I can do to lesson the noise or am I just out of luck?
 
You could try getting silicon cushion mounts for the screws that mount the hard drive to lessen acoustic vibration noise, but knowing Dell from past experience, case modding isn't on their "to-do" list for customer convenience...

If it really bothers you that much you could consider just upgrading the hard drive to the much quieter Samsung Spinpoint F1s or the WD Green Powers after imaging your disk from software such as Acronis or Norton Ghost if it bothers you that much.
 
+1 to Syntax Error's suggestion: Clone the drive over to a new drive using Acronis True Image. In fact, Seagate's Discwizard is pretty much a stripped down version of Acronis True Image and is offered for free for all Seagate and Maxtor drives.

Though I have a Seagate 7200.10 750GB drive in my current rig and I can hardly hear it. Then again I have the P180 case so yeah....
 
I have a couple of Seagte 7200.10 500gbs. I can't hear them when they are inside a case, but they make a hell of noise when I put them on my table.
 
If it really bothers you that much you could consider just upgrading the hard drive to the much quieter Samsung Spinpoint F1s or the WD Green Powers after imaging your disk from software such as Acronis or Norton Ghost if it bothers you that much.

+1 to Syntax Error's suggestion: Clone the drive over to a new drive using Acronis True Image. In fact, Seagate's Discwizard is pretty much a stripped down version of Acronis True Image and is offered for free for all Seagate and Maxtor drives.
.



okay that might be a little out of my league. so if I switched the image over to a different drive would there be any os issues.remember this is a Dell oem setup if that matters.
 
okay that might be a little out of my league. so if I switched the image over to a different drive would there be any os issues.remember this is a Dell oem setup if that matters.

Nope no OS issues at all. I've done many cloning of both retail (Dell, Toshiba, HP) and custom systems with Seagate Discwizard/ Acronis with no problems at all.

Seagate's Discwizard/stripped Acronis True Image is pretty easy to use. Once you get that second drive and have it formatted and installed in the Dell as a second hard drive, go here to download Seagate's Discward:
http://www.seagate.com/ww/v/index.j...toid=580a5e3ddbf60110VgnVCM100000f5ee0a0aRCRD

Install it and once installed, select "Disc Utilities" and select the "Clone Disc Option." Should be easy to follow from there
 
Those drives really aren't that loud. What sort of expectations do you have in terms of noise?

You could always set it to power down your drive after just a few minutes via the power control panel.
 
Those drives really aren't that loud. What sort of expectations do you have in terms of noise?

You could always set it to power down your drive after just a few minutes via the power control panel.
well if you dont think thats loud then fine but a quick google search will find tons of other people who agree with me. Im sure the type of case could make it sound worse but at any rate the sound was beyond acceptable. I tried playing games and watching a movie and the sound could not be ignored. I do have very sensitive hearing and I find it to be a curse more than a blessing.

I do have 320gb WD right now that even with the side of the case off is almost silent.
 
Nope no OS issues at all. I've done many cloning of both retail (Dell, Toshiba, HP) and custom systems with Seagate Discwizard/ Acronis with no problems at all.

Seagate's Discwizard/stripped Acronis True Image is pretty easy to use. Once you get that second drive and have it formatted and installed in the Dell as a second hard drive, go here to download Seagate's Discward:
http://www.seagate.com/ww/v/index.j...toid=580a5e3ddbf60110VgnVCM100000f5ee0a0aRCRD

Install it and once installed, select "Disc Utilities" and select the "Clone Disc Option." Should be easy to follow from there
thanks for the advice. I guess Im still a little nervous since I have never really done anything like that. so why does the oem os still let it be cloned onto another brand of hard drive? also after I do that would I even be able to use the Dell Vista oem install dvd to reinstall the os if I ever need to? sorry if these are stupid questions. :eek:
 
With cloning, it's an exact almost bit for bit copy of your OS install. So as far as the OS is concerned nothing changed. And yes you'll still be able to reinstall since the Dell OEM installation discs checks for a Dell BIOs, not the hard drive.
 
With cloning, it's an exact almost bit for bit copy of your OS install. So as far as the OS is concerned nothing changed. And yes you'll still be able to reinstall since the Dell OEM installation discs checks for a Dell BIOs, not the hard drive.
well could I just put in different hd in and use the Dell Vista install disc without doing all the other stuff?
 
so I could just get a brand new WD hd and put the Dell Vista dvd in and and reinstall? do I have to do anything to the new drive first? please walk me through step by step if you dont mind.

If you installed a Windows OS before, it's the exact same steps/way. No difference between installing OEM or retail disk on different hard drives.
 
If you installed a Windows OS before, it's the exact same steps/way. No difference between installing OEM or retail disk on different hard drives.
well I have never messed with a brand new hard drive before so i wasnt sure. my HP comps just have recovery discs that bring it back to the factory installation.


so all I need to do is take out that Seagate HD and put in the WD one and then just put in the Vista install disc in the dvd drive? so when I power on the pc it will just boot up from the dvd? and you are sure that a different hd wont be an issue for the dell oem vista disc?
 
so all I need to do is take out that Seagate HD and put in the WD one and then just put in the Vista install disc in the dvd drive? so when I power on the pc it will just boot up from the dvd? and you are sure that a different hd wont be an issue for the dell oem vista disc?

Yes, Yes, and Yes.

If anything happens, just pop back in the Seagate drive. Don't reformat the Seagate drive until the OS is up and fully running on the new drive.
 
All this concern about activation or "something going wrong" won't be an issue if you just disk clone; you just pop in the cloned disk and voila, your computer is as it was before you cloned it, just with a newer, quieter drive.

Reinstallation is easy, but to get everything up and running again for work/leisure/whatever is a PITA, and frankly, disk cloning would probably be easier and a lot less time consuming, unless for whatever reason you want to reinstall your OS because of spyware/slowdown/whatever.
 
All this concern about activation or "something going wrong" won't be an issue if you just disk clone; you just pop in the cloned disk and voila, your computer is as it was before you cloned it, just with a newer, quieter drive.

Reinstallation is easy, but to get everything up and running again for work/leisure/whatever is a PITA, and frankly, disk cloning would probably be easier and a lot less time consuming, unless for whatever reason you want to reinstall your OS because of spyware/slowdown/whatever.
I wanted a clean install anyway instead of all that stuff it came with.
 
If you use the factory-installed partition or the factory disk, it'll most likely install the crap bloatware that came with your computer as well. :(
 
If you use the factory-installed partition or the factory disk, it'll most likely install the crap bloatware that came with your computer as well. :(
it has a clean install disc and then a separate disc for the needed device drivers. this isnt the factory recovery junk like on HP/Compaq.
 
hi,

i have a seagate 7200.11 and initially i had the same complain.. it was very noisy even when i had it on silicon mounts inside my antec P180 case

it was running the drive in EIDE mode on my ASUS P5K-E at that time.. i changed it to run in AHCI mode i the bios and i noticed the noise was gone.. so i think AHCI's NCQ functionality has better seek patterns which reduced the movement/seeking of the drive.. and as a result a quieter drive

note that u can't just simply change the drive controller in the bios from EIDE to AHCI.. there are issues depending on windows vista/xp and drivers etc.. with vista u can change a registry value, restart, change in bios and be ok.. but with xp i believe u'll need to format and reinstall when going from EIDE->AHCI or else u'll get BSOD's
 
Something has to be wrong because i have a Dell Vostro 200 with the Seagate 250GB 7200.10 and its not loud at all. I would call Dell and have them replace it.
 
Something has to be wrong because i have a Dell Vostro 200 with the Seagate 250GB 7200.10 and its not loud at all. I would call Dell and have them replace it.
I looked at another one and and it made the same noise too. now I am just deciding on whether to get a different drive or just return the Dell and build my own.
 
The 7200.10s that were made in China tend to be noisier than the made in Taiwan ones. I have about 16 of them total, and it is true across the lot of them.
 
I had one in my Vostro 200 I got out of a server, it was too loud for my quiet room. I put it back in that server. Compared to the fans on my dell 600sc, the drive is quiet :)

Right now I'm sticking with two 160 gig samsung's. I'll upgrade to 2 1tb samsungs or wd's later on down the road.
 
Back
Top