Going pre-built -- any recommendations under $999?

JYeager11

Gawd
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Messages
563
I'm looking to upgrade from a 2.41 GHz Dual Core AMD Opteron I built myself, to a pre-built system.

My reasons for going pre-built are simple : I've been going this route when helping friends/family pick a new computer, and they've never had any issues with any of the ones I've pointed out to them from Best Buy or Future Shop. Moreover, their computers are always a lot more silent than mine. And when I looked at prices here in Canada for individual parts to assemble myself, I was surprised by how expensive they were. Unless someone can prove otherwise, I just don't think it's worth building your own computer in Canada right now.

My budget is $999, or less. No monitor required.

My needs :

- Extreme music recording & mixing, via Sonar 8. We're talking 50+ wav files of 24b each streaming simultaneously, with as many real-time FX plugins (chorus, reverb, delay, EQ, etc) as my system can handle. Only when it starts buckling (and it will) will I commit to destructive changes on the original wavs to improve performance.

- Extreme Photoshopping, via well.. Photoshop. Some of these files are OVER 2GB LARGE, and risk becoming larger in the months/years ahead. Right now, my current system just locks up when I try opening two at the same time. Hence the need to upgrade.

- Everyday web surfing.​

No video games. I've got an XBOX 360 for that. But the color representation and 2D rendering at extreme-high resolutions needs to be adequate. I don't want to see Photoshop redrawing everything I move around.

From what I've read, the Q6600 is the best value for our money right now. Is that right? But what about the Intel vs AMD wars? Last time I upgraded, Intel had become the better choice again. That rule still in effect?

And I'm looking at *at least* 6GB of ram, if not 8. Right?

MUST BE SILENT - because a microphone will be recording 3' away from the machine. However, I've noticed that pretty much ALL pre-builts I've recommended to friends/family are pretty quiet. My current system (which I built myself) sounds like a jet engine, and not in a good way.

I'm looking to purchase from either http://BestBuy.ca, http://FutureShop.ca, or http://Dell.ca. I tend to trust those sources, but am not adverse to considering other Canadian entities (note all those .ca's in the urls... I'm in Canada!)

Any recommendations you guys might have for me would be helpful.
 
Hey J, If you're asking about where to buy a computer, and not building it yourself, I would ask a mod to move this thread to the Computers and Gadgets sub forum. Thats where these kinds of questions are answered.

Also, $999? :D
 
Newegg.ca is now live. But are you 100% sure you want a prebuilt? If you build yourself, you can replace any stock case fans with silent ones, like Yate Loons, Scythe, etc., and you can get a good but quiet custom heatsink/fan combo.

Is that $999 CAD or USD?
 
Newegg.ca is now live. But are you 100% sure you want a prebuilt? If you build yourself, you can replace any stock case fans with silent ones, like Yate Loons, Scythe, etc., and you can get a good but quiet custom heatsink/fan combo.

A friend of mine told me the same thing you just did, so I challenged him to build me something (virtually), and here's what he came up with :

CPU (214.95$)
Q6600
http://www.pcvonline.com/productDetails.aspx?prodID=4832

CASE (92.00$)
NZXT Hush Case
http://www.hltechnology.com/one_prod.php?pid=11409

MOTHERBOARD (65.13$)
MB GA-945GCM-S2C
http://forums.ncix.com/forums/index..._id=26477&msgcount=0&overclockid=0#msg1727592
(has videocard for 1 monitor, only 100mb lan, only 4gb ram)

RAM (31.02$)
ValueRAM PC2-4200 2GB 2X1GB DDR2-533
http://www.directcanada.com/products/?sku=12410BD1479&vpn=KVR533D2N4K2/2G&manufacture=KINGSTON

RAM (31.02$)
ValueRAM PC2-4200 2GB 2X1GB DDR2-533
http://www.directcanada.com/products/?sku=12410BD1479&vpn=KVR533D2N4K2/2G&manufacture=KINGSTON

HD (69.85$)
Western Digital SE16 500GB SATA2
http://www.bestdirect.ca/products/115540/Western_Digital/WD5000AAKS/

HD (69.85$)
Western Digital SE16 500GB SATA2
http://www.bestdirect.ca/products/115540/Western_Digital/WD5000AAKS/

FAN (57.35$)
Zalman CNPS9500
http://www.directcanada.com/products/?sku=15210AC7548&vpn=CNPS9500 AT&manufacture=ZALMAN TECH

POWER SUPPLY (108.88$)
Corsair TX650W 650W ATX
http://www.directcanada.com/products/?sku=11180AC2550&vpn=CMPSU-650TX&manufacture=CORSAIR

So you've got a Q6600 with "only" 4GB of ram and 1 TB on the HD. But of course, he forgot the DVD, and the video card happens to be integrated with a cheap $60 motherboard (I've got my own specialized audio card so that's fine). And naturally, this doesn't come with Vista 64 like most pre-built systems now do.

That's why I decided to look at the pre-builts again.

Is that $999 CAD or USD?

CND, and I'm buying in Canada. Custom fees make buying in the U.S. impossible (I've tried a few times and got snagged with those fees every time).
 
I was told to avoid AMD like the plague, and really focus on Intel's Q6600 or higher. How good or bad was that advice?

Keep in mind, while my 3D graphic needs are minimal, I will be a major power user as far as CPU/ram resources go.

AMD is not the plague but for your extreme photoshop needs you're better off with the Q6600. As far as ram goes by 2gb sticks. If you cannot afford 8gigs now just get 2x2gb that way you can add more when you get more funds.
 
AMD isn't bad, but Intel will be your best bet. A Q6600 would treat you very well, but if money doesn't permit one, a high-speed Core 2 Duo would also be a fine choice.
 
AMD isn't bad, but Intel will be your best bet. A Q6600 would treat you very well, but if money doesn't permit one, a high-speed Core 2 Duo would also be a fine choice.

But money DOES permit a Q6600 on many pre-built systems I've seen for under $999.

This one comes to mind :
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16883229048

What I find odd is that this is a gaming machine. So the video card may even be overkill for my needs. In other words, I might be able to find something *like* this, but with less invested in the video card and more elsewhere (like ram).

Am I on the right track as far as my thinking goes? Feel free to set me straight, I've been out of the loop for awhile.

I could also just recycle the Asus EN6600 GT video card I'm currently using, but that would suck a tiny bit, because it would cripple what would otherwise be a fully functional 2nd computer. Unless I can think of something else to recycle that'll make it worthwhile to end up with just the new computer.

For instance, I'm currently using 4 sticks of 1024MB each. Two Corsair CMX1024-3200C2's, and two Kingston PC3200's (I was supposed to run XP x64 on this machine, but found compatibility issues too daunting to surmount, hence the unnecessary extra ram).

From what I understand, my new computer will likely still be limited by only 4 slots, so I have to get 2GB sticks. Hence, recycling my old ram wouldn't be recommended.

Now the other problem I'm seeing is that pre-built systems will likely load up all the slots (4 x 1GB instead of 2 x 2GB) making it impossible for me to upgrade to 8GB without replacing what's already there (instead of adding to it). Is this a fair assumption on my part, or am I way off?

Will the pre-builts that vaunt 4GB ram expandable to 8GB provide 2 free slots?
 
Well, what display(s) are you using? If you have a large monitor for Photoshop, you need some video power. You wouldn't need a high-end gaming video card, but you probably wouldn't want onboard video either.

Prebuilts often use proprietary designs, making upgrading difficult. That's a big plus to building yourself.
 
This one comes to mind :
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16883229048

What I find odd is that this is a gaming machine. So the video card may even be overkill for my needs. In other words, I might be able to find something *like* this, but with less invested in the video card and more elsewhere (like ram).

No. Cyberpower is one of the worst PC OEMs out there. They are not well-recommended here on the forums. You're better off looking elsewhere.

Now the other problem I'm seeing is that pre-built systems will likely load up all the slots (4 x 1GB instead of 2 x 2GB) making it impossible for me to upgrade to 8GB without replacing what's already there (instead of adding to it). Is this a fair assumption on my part, or am I way off?

Will the pre-builts that vaunt 4GB ram expandable to 8GB provide 2 free slots?
Depends on the pre-builts. Some Dells and HPs have a 2x2 setup with two slots remaining. Then again some Dells and HPs do have a 4 x 1GB setup.

How come you didn't go with that HP prebuilt you link to in your last thread? That was a pretty good deal for a prebuilt.
 
Love them or hate them, look at AVADirect.

They generally build a good system, almost to order, and are very reasonable.

(ducks for cover):eek:
 
Okay, I just read up on Nehalem, slated for release Q4 2008. Seems this will make all Core computers obsolete, as they are at the end of their cycle. Naturally, this would be a red flag for me.

So how about this alternate scenario... I upgrade to a temporary setup that'll take me into early 2009, and then spend what needs to be spent for a motherboard/CPU that is at the beginning of its cycle?

Here's what I have right now (been so long that I'm relying on "System Information for Windows" by Gabriel Topala to tell me) :

MB: A8N-SLI Deluxe (Socket 939)
CPU: AMD Dual Core Opteron 180
RAM: 4 x 1024 (2 Corsair CMX1024-3200C2 [200MHz] + 2 Kingston PC3200 [200MHz])
VIDEO: Asus EN6600 GT (GeForce 6600 GT)
AUDIO: Echo Gina3G (24b Specialized Audio Card)
HD1: Seagate Barracuda 250GB (ST3250823AS)
HD2: WD Caviar 500GB (WD5000AAKS)
HD3: WD Raptor 75GB (WD740GD)
DVD: Plextor PX-716A
OS: WinXP SP3 (32b)

Before you ask, I had 4GB ram because I was going to use XP x64. Having reverted back to 32b, I realize I'm wasting half of it.

That being said, I'm thinking... if I can purchase :
- MB + CPU to run Q6600
- 1 x 2GB Good RAM

...then I could just port over most of my current system onto the new one, at a fraction of the cost I was envisioning. The HD's, DVDR, Video Card, Audio Card... these can all be ported over. Including the boot drive running XP SP3.

I didn't mention the RAM because I simply assumed that :

1) Today's RAM would be accessed better and faster on the new machine than my current one would, and

2) Having a single 2GB stick could potentially be recycled next year should I go new-gen with Nehalem. Right?

But then again, maybe I should just use my 2 x 1GB Crucial sticks in the new "temp" setup, if the general census is that a new single 2GB stick won't make much of an immediate difference on XP SP3.

Thoughts?
 
Whoa, killer. Nehalem is going to be great, but unless money is no object, you won't be building a slick Nehalem system when it comes out. I would forgo a temporary system and build a killer rig right now.

I wouldn't say it'll make Core processors obsolete. I think they'll be around for quite awhile, especially since they'll be very affordable.
 
The new Nahelem chips run with DDR3, so your "new" RAM would be worthless in the set-up you would buy for a quick fix. Although the DDR2 RAM currently is so cheap it would be the least expensive component in that build.

And a new Nahalem set up is going to be expensive as a "fisrt-adopter" configuration.
We really don't even have any MBs yet to look at from a retail perspective.
The ASUS P6T that Kyle reviewed is probably going to fetch 350 bones initially.:eek:
 
Whoa, killer. Nehalem is going to be great, but unless money is no object, you won't be building a slick Nehalem system when it comes out. I would forgo a temporary system and build a killer rig right now.

But I'll be overpaying for that killer rig right now, even if I decided NOT to go with Nehalem until the "new shine" wears off. (I'd be agreeing with you if Nehalem was out and you recommended I buy a killer Quad Core rig anyway.. because of the price drop that's sure to affect everything that day).

So essentially what I'm hearing is that as long as I'm running a 32-bit OS, there's no point having more than 2GB ram. So if I build a temp Q6600 setup, I'd best port over 2 of those 1GB Crucial sticks rather than buy a single 2GB new stick (since I won't be able to use it on a DDR3 rig).

That settles that question. But why do my system stats report 3GB of ram installed, if the OS can allegedly not see more than 2GB? Right now, I've got 4 sticks of 1GB mounted, but the OS is reporting 3GB. Why not 2GB? I thought the extra 2 sticks were superfluous on a 32-bit OS?
 
But I'll be overpaying for that killer rig right now, even if I decided NOT to go with Nehalem until the "new shine" wears off. (I'd be agreeing with you if Nehalem was out and you recommended I buy a killer Quad Core rig anyway.. because of the price drop that's sure to affect everything that day).

So essentially what I'm hearing is that as long as I'm running a 32-bit OS, there's no point having more than 2GB ram. So if I build a temp Q6600 setup, I'd best port over 2 of those 1GB Crucial sticks rather than buy a single 2GB new stick (since I won't be able to use it on a DDR3 rig).

That settles that question. But why do my system stats report 3GB of ram installed, if the OS can allegedly not see more than 2GB? Right now, I've got 4 sticks of 1GB mounted, but the OS is reporting 3GB. Why not 2GB? I thought the extra 2 sticks were superfluous on a 32-bit OS?


Your understanding of 32 bit OS' and the 4GB ram limitation is a little off. Basically, a 32 bit system can address 4 GB of memory total. That includes ram you normally use, ram on your video card, ram possibly on your sound card, etc. So in this case you are able to use about 3 of your 4GB of ram you have installed as part of the actual ram usable by your system (and not just ram usable by your video card etc). It is "wasteful" to get more than 2 GB in most cases because you wont' be able to use it all, but unless you have an SLI or Crossfire rig with your video cards taking up 2+ gigs of addressable memory, you will see "some" benefit of having more than 2 gigs of ram. Make sense?
 
The HD's, DVDR, Video Card, Audio Card... these can all be ported over. Including the boot drive running XP SP3.

You would have to reinstall the OS since it's a new mobo. Rarely does moving an existing XP install to another system with a different motherboard work well, stably or reliably. So it's best to do a complete reformat and reinstall when you get that new mobo.
 
You would have to reinstall the OS since it's a new mobo. Rarely does moving an existing XP install to another system with a different motherboard work well, stably or reliably. So it's best to do a complete reformat and reinstall when you get that new mobo.

Crapety crap crap crap... :( can this be confirmed by anyone else?

How often will a HD with the OS already installed port over well onto a new MB? Is the answer really "rarely"?
 
Crapety crap crap crap... :( can this be confirmed by anyone else?

How often will a HD with the OS already installed port over well onto a new MB? Is the answer really "rarely"?

These threads confirms it:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1348707
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1262751
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1342547

Note the author of the last post in the first linked thread. Yes, the answer really is "rarely". At least in my experience anyway. You could try a repair install as mentioned and shown in the above threads but for best practice, I recommend a total reformat
 
Back
Top