Q6700 @ $199 vs Q6600 @ $179

jds62f

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 9, 2006
Messages
73
Is there any reason for me to spend the extra $20 for the Q6700?

I'll mostly be playing games. The rest of the setup will be:

P5Q Pro
OCZ Platinum 1066 (2x2 GB)
Xigmatech HDT-s128 (or whatever the part number is)

I'd like to have a good chance of hitting 3.2/3.4 GHz.

Q6700 would be from tigerdirect, Q6600 would be from Microcenter (theres a store pretty close, so it would be a local pickup).
 
No reason to go with the Q6700. The Q6600 is already pretty easy to OC with its 9x multi. Just save the $20
 
I think he meant to say "No reason NOT to go with the Q6600..."

Actually I mean to say "No reason to go with the Q6700." Same thing though. Anyway, typo on my part...

Fixed.
 
I'm in the same boat, but I've got a question:

that 6700 is an "HH" G0 stepping. Newegg has the 6600 in "BX" ? stepping. I hear the BX is better for overclocking....is there truth to this? all I really need is a "yes" from a couple of people, but because I'm a nerd who likes to read, does anyone have a link to an article comparing steppings?

edited because I'm a dork*
 
I'm in the same boat, but I've got a question:

that 6700 is an "HH" G0 stepping. Newegg has the 6600 in "BX" ? stepping. I hear the BX is better for overclocking....is there truth to this? all I really need is a "yes" from a couple of people, but because I'm a nerd who likes to read, does anyone have a link to an article comparing steppings?

edited because I'm a dork*
i dont think there is such think as a BX stepping but there is a b3, and that still isnt better than G0 (the current and final stepping for q6600).

so no dont get a "BX" stepping, get a G0 from newegg or any other popular store.

g0>b3 in terms of overclocking.
 
Well the newest tigerdirect deal makes it a little more interesting. What if these guys are effectively the same price? 199 + free shipping or 193 (180 + tax)?
 
Well the newest tigerdirect deal makes it a little more interesting. What if these guys are effectively the same price? 199 + free shipping or 193 (180 + tax)?

That'd be fine then. The argument is its basically the same cpu so save $20 but if the real world difference is $6 then its less of a penalty.
 
I just ordered a Q6600 retail box from NewEgg last week, shipped from Edison NJ midweek. It's a G0 step.

Running like buddah at 3.0 right now. In a room with 65 degree ambient, it's idling (while just surfing) at 23,24,24,25. crazy.
 
I just ordered a Q6600 retail box from NewEgg last week, shipped from Edison NJ midweek. It's a G0 step.

Running like buddah at 3.0 right now. In a room with 65 degree ambient, it's idling (while just surfing) at 23,24,24,25. crazy.

Crank her up and we'll see you at 3.6
 
Get the Q6700 for the extra $20. People will tell you this and that about overclocking, but until you have a cpu in your hand, all you know is that one will do 2.4ghz and one will do 2.66ghz. Overclocking potential is NEVER a promise of performance.
 
Get the Q6700 for the extra $20. People will tell you this and that about overclocking, but until you have a cpu in your hand, all you know is that one will do 2.4ghz and one will do 2.66ghz. Overclocking potential is NEVER a promise of performance.

That's true in theory; but according to your theory the Q6700 will do 2.66Ghz whereas the one he has is already doing 3Ghz. Who is to say the Q6700 he gets won't hit 3Ghz according to that logic.
 
The difference is expected result vs known result.

The known result for clockspeed on a Q6600 v Q6700 is 2.4ghz v 2.66hz. There is a very good chance the Q6600 will his 3.0 or 3.2ghz. My point is, $20 to raise your known result by 266mhz is worth it. Always plan for worst case when buying a CPU, unless you are planning on buying multiple CPUs to find the best overclocker.

I always ask myself, assuming both CPUs CAN NOT overclock, would 266hz be worth the $20.
 
The difference is expected result vs known result.

The known result for clockspeed on a Q6600 v Q6700 is 2.4ghz v 2.66hz. There is a very good chance the Q6600 will his 3.0 or 3.2ghz. My point is, $20 to raise your known result by 266mhz is worth it. Always plan for worst case when buying a CPU, unless you are planning on buying multiple CPUs to find the best overclocker.

I always ask myself, assuming both CPUs CAN NOT overclock, would 266hz be worth the $20.

But he already has a Q6600. He just got it.

I just ordered a Q6600 retail box from NewEgg last week, shipped from Edison NJ midweek. It's a G0 step.

Running like buddah at 3.0 right now. In a room with 65 degree ambient, it's idling (while just surfing) at 23,24,24,25. crazy.

Do you want him to return it? Pay to ship it back and maybe get a 15% re-stocking fee.
 
I don't have either chip right now, thats what this thread is all about :)
 
I may be wrong, but from what I have seen on the web, it appears the q6600 is a better overclocker for some reason. However this may be because up until recently the q6700 was at least 80 dollars more than the q6600. But being that close in price, I would go with the q6700. It always helps to have a 10x multiplier than just a 9x.

Just my opinion.
 
I don't have either chip right now, thats what this thread is all about :)

I see that. Yeah typical thread the OP gets lost. In your case yes as aforementioned the Q67 is a fine choice no better or worse than the Q66 but I also won't say you're wasting the few extra bucks. Depending on your ram, the high multiplier might be a better thing for you
 
Another thing to consider is that the current batch of Q6600 seem to require more voltage to OC. I'm seeing Vcores of 1.325 to hit 3ghz posted around here. Not sure if new Q6700 are the same way, but the Q6700 I bought in march is doing 3.2ghz at 1.215v
 
Back
Top