Intel's New Solid State Drive - Video Review @ [H]

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
Intel's New Solid State Drive - Video Review - A lot of smart people have said a lot of smart things about Intel's new 80GB Solid State Drive recently sampled to the media. But some of the basic questions I had on my mind were left unchecked, like, “Is it really faster, or is that just what HDTach tells you on a graph?” We get out the stop watch and a 5-disk RAID array and go to town.
 
I like the video review cause I can get the feel for something I can't quite afford yet. Shape size etc.

But the benchmarks I'd like to see in pictures, not pictures in the video, but in the article.
 
I wouldn't mind the expense if I could just find them in stores. No, it's not as fast as a Velociraptor at times, but I can't fit a Velociraptor in my laptop. I jumped on the bandwagon with my OCZ Core, and it's done a pretty good job for me, but I'll take any upgrade I can get.


Incidentally, since these 2.5" drives are compatible with notebooks, I wouldn't mind seeing a 2.5" platter based drive added into the review mix, just to compare for that segment of mobile users.
 
Very Nice Review. I love the Video along with the pics and graphs.

Very easy to Use. Only downside is if we can get some Fashion Model. Ie Pretty Woman.

Dm
 
I like the video review cause I can get the feel for something I can't quite afford yet. Shape size etc.

But the benchmarks I'd like to see in pictures, not pictures in the video, but in the article.

Roger that. We did include the graphs on the webpage lower down as a supplement as well as some higher resolution pictures. I know that is how I would have liked it.

Keep the suggestions coming!
 
Did anyone else half expect Kyle to open up with "Hi, Im Rodney Reynolds and this is another video review." LOL. Okay... maybe its just me then. *moves along*
 
I really like the video reviews much better than the normal ones. It is much easier to get a feel of what something will be like, and is easier to relate to. Thanks for the review Kyle!
 
Every time I come across a Maxtor drive I'll now think of Kyle and call them "ye old". :D


Nice review, it's good to see a number of different tests run on the different selection of drives. For what it's worth I saw that the 1TB WD was the green series, which is known for their slower speeds. I wonder how the Black series would have done?

As far as a hard drive suggestion? If you are going to do more HD reviews, I say throw a WD 640 in the mix. On this board, I think it is suggested more then anything else, and has great reviews.
 
I do like the video review, I can listen while doing other thing. But when I do watch, I do not care for the graphs being shown so much, impossible to read, but a quick scroll down I got them. Not sure how you would go about doing something else in its place. Just merely a comment. Great work none the less!

-Bill
 
Awesome vid. Especially since I own just about all of those drives. I think I will go out and buy the intel ssd, put the OS on it, and then load all my games on my old Maxtor.

Anyway, there is a particular drive missing here. First the 1Tb WD you tested is their Greenpower drive, which while nice, is low power usage and therefore lower performance (and btw, damn near silent). If you can get a hold of one of WD's 1Tb Black Edition drives, they are supposed to be silly fast:
http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,2845,2328723,00.asp

I can't believe the read speeds would be as fast, but with the storage a price difference, it would be important to include.
 
Very cool. Will check out the vid when I'm out of class:) I'm really interested in putting an SSD in my X61S laptop. I'd love to see a review sometime with a similar conversion - curious about the performance and batter life improvements over a standard 2.5" drive.
 
if we can get some Fashion Model. Ie Pretty Woman.

Hey there's an idea. Say Kyle, whatever happened to our beloved Asia Carrera? She'd be awesome for your hardware videos ;-)

Awesome review by the way. SSD seems to be getting there, but not quite yet. I love how it can work without it's shell for cooler operation. Does the shell protect it from interference as well as physical contact?
 
Ye old maxtor kicks some video game ass. *watches ebay prices rise* Damn you Kyle ;)

SSD's bore me still... You need to run a very quick battery of test on an SLC just to see how much different they actually are... Bug OCZ for one ;)
 
Just wanted to say I've really enjoyed each video review you've put out so far - they're very informative and interesting to watch. They really give an interesting perspective on the evaluations that the articles might not portray (ie: physical size, use, commentary, "observing tests"). Some positive feedback hoping that you keep them up!
 
Thanks for mentioning the temperature, that was a question I was preparing to ask.

And please stick with scribbling on print-outs rather than going for flashy powerpoint-style video effects, I loved the old-school feel :)

Great review.
 
I like the extra qualitative features of the video review, but it's not real often I have 20 minutes to watch the whole thing. It'd be nice to have a full written review along with the video, so we can get the hard details quickly from the text, then watch the video if we have questions or just want your opinion.
 
Am I odd for expecting power usage, one of the proclaimed advantages of SSDs, to be covered? Or is HD power usage so minimal as to make the comparison useless?
 
Am I odd for expecting power usage, one of the proclaimed advantages of SSDs, to be covered? Or is HD power usage so minimal as to make the comparison useless?

Considering a single hard drive doesn't really pull THAT much power I think that the power savings of SSD are one of its' least interesting features. Potential speed for the technology, lower heat production and of course reliability increases due to the lack of mechanical parts are far more appealing than a few watts of power saved.
 
Nice video review. Looks like we will have to wait for intels enterprise version to see if it can beat the raptors in both reads and writes.
 
Nice video review. Looks like we will have to wait for intels enterprise version to see if it can beat the raptors in both reads and writes.

Hopefully it can but I'd bet those would be even more expensive.
 
I like the video review, but Kyle needs to work on his performance/speech now that you're on camera. It sounds like a nitpick, but all of the "ugh.. and... ugh"s make it sounds like you are bored to be reviewing. If you make a conscious effort to eliminate unnecessary speech patterns, it will go away in a week.
 
I like video reviews in addition to the regular text & pics, it adds another dimension to our experience. Like pr0n, kinda.

As for ssd performance, I have found XP to offer much better performance with the same exact setup over vista. At the moment I am using (2) OCZ Core v2 60GB ssds, and a good 3ware 9690sa controller in raid zero. In vista I maxed out at about 200MB/s in hdtune, and with xp it basically saturates the controller at 303MB/s.

I think XP gives more consistant numbers for storage systems, so I think it would be nice to see the test done in XP too.

TiReZ
 
Considering a single hard drive doesn't really pull THAT much power I think that the power savings of SSD are one of its' least interesting features. Potential speed for the technology, lower heat production and of course reliability increases due to the lack of mechanical parts are far more appealing than a few watts of power saved.

I'm interested. Wasn't there a lot of noise awhile back that 1st gen SSD's actually reduced battery life in notebooks?
 
Makes me happy with my Velociraptor drive.

I'll buy one when they are 250+gb and under $300. But it is still nice to see the technology coming along.
 
I just put the cheaper OCZ 32GB unit in MY MCE rig as the boot drive to reduce system noise and power consumption. A side effect seems to be a quicker guide navigation in Media Center too, as seek times are instant so I assume database access is more responsive.

For some applications SSD is great.
 
I like the extra qualitative features of the video review, but it's not real often I have 20 minutes to watch the whole thing. It'd be nice to have a full written review along with the video, so we can get the hard details quickly from the text, then watch the video if we have questions or just want your opinion.

I'd also like a text version, but that's because my work blocks all streaming video.
 
Am I odd for expecting power usage, one of the proclaimed advantages of SSDs, to be covered? Or is HD power usage so minimal as to make the comparison useless?
I agree, even if it's not much it sure would be interesting. I know the 300GB Velicoraptor has awesome idle wattage.
 
Well, that sucks. I'm running an old 80 GB IDE drive for my OS (I'm upgrading soon, as I'm out of space, but other priorities have set in). It sucks seeing that my lowly little drive sucks worse than the Ye Olde Maxtor, and I could have SO MUCH FASTER!

I really enjoy the video reviews. Great to see the product hands on, and it brings a lot more personality to the site. It's friendlier and fun. Great work.

I really like the supplements with graphs and pics for what it hard to see in the video. Good work.

I wouldn't mind seeing a side by side load of the OS or something. 2 video's side by side (fancy video editing work!) would be awesome.
 
Awesome review, i truly believe that once massified, this products will become even cheaper than current hard drives, given the fact that no mechanic counterparts are required.
 
I'm interested. Wasn't there a lot of noise awhile back that 1st gen SSD's actually reduced battery life in notebooks?

Yes there is. I haven't validated the data. My point in saying what I said was to state that the power consumption is the least important of what SSD can potentially bring to the table. Faster speeds, and greater reliability with reduction in heat and foot print are all much more compelling than anything you might see in regard to reduced power consumption.

Individually hard drives don't use that much power when compared to everything else in the system. It just isn't that important.
 
Paper and a sharpie! Hey Kyle this si the 21st century, time to get with it. Here's a good idea use a tablet to write your notes on your graphs on the screen, rather than printing your notes out on paper and using a sharpie to write. it would make it a lot easier to see the graphs and you will be saving some trees in the process.
 
Really enjoyed the video review, quite nice to see the Intel SSD compared to the others in size.

A suggestion for the images in the video, you could throw a Powerpoint slide and draw on it with a tablet while you talk about it, like what they do for replays in NFL games.
 
I would like to say thanks for taking your time in testing SSD's and the key fact that you took your time in testing it more then four times to find the average. The level of detail you put it in shocked me..

Till next time
 
Can't wait until these get more affordable, definitely going to end up in my laptop at some point.
 
I love the video reviews you guys show lately. The videos help understand a review much better than juts text and pictures. Also seeing the hardware in a video gives a good contrast to the dimensions and overall look of the hardware you are reviewing.

What I would like in future reviews brought in over time is footage of you guys doing some of the testing in a separate video maybe of the hardware , your final thoughts on the tested hardware or whatever is being reviewed , your scores , some bloopers at the end of the video and maybe while testing show any problems you have during testing. Also maybe you could show an onscreen graph of your results instead of a printout that is hard to read.

The video reviews are some of the best I have ever seen yet. Rodney reynolds is good but he cant match up to Kyle's style of review.

KI hope you guys keep the videos coming.
 
Great review Kyle. Gave me a much better idea of what the size and feel of these drives are.
 
Nice video review! SSD is still too much for me haha. Also is that keyboard a Microsoft Comfort Curve 2000? It looks exactly like mine :) and its a great keyboard!(like it better then my zboard :eek:)
 
Gameload time..



I beated a WDC 1tb with a 160 GB :D


what the hell ? how does gameload work, gief explaination... this really get me wonderin hows it working and why it takes longer on a new drive :O....
 
Back
Top