stepping foot into other camp

tokey

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jan 8, 2008
Messages
6,651
okay so I am a long time loyal AMD purchaser, not a fanboy. I used them because they never disapointed me and they had earned my buisness. Well I purchased a phenom 9600 and a 9850 both are an amazing dispointment so I recently sold them. I am getting ready to purchase my first intel cpu, I am looking for a cheap $400 setup and wanted to make sure my choices are good.

I have chosen,

Q6600
Asus P5Q-E
OCZ DDR2-1066 2gb (2x1GB)


sound good?
 
The CPU is good value and the motherboard is fine from what I can see. You don't really need 1066MHz RAM with the Q6600 though, Core 2s don't really benefit from faster memory and 800MHz RAM would let you overclock the CPU to a maximum of 3.6GHz, which is about as high as they go anyway. Perhaps look at getting 4GB of DDR2-800?
 
The CPU is good value and the motherboard is fine from what I can see. You don't really need 1066MHz RAM with the Q6600 though, Core 2s don't really benefit from faster memory and 800MHz RAM would let you overclock the CPU to a maximum of 3.6GHz, which is about as high as they go anyway. Perhaps look at getting 4GB of DDR2-800?

i have $50 budgeted for ram for a month, and i have never oc'd so i dont know how high i would feel comfortable going. but i will go with the 800 if it will help oc numbers, if i dont oc would the Q8200 be a better choice or is the Q6600 faster?
 
I'll agree with Mithent, anything over 800 on ram is not really cost effective. If you are trying to keep the cost of your build down, your money can be better spent elsewhere than on ram faster than 800. I only have 1066 ram as I got a screaming deal on it.

Since it seems you are looking at your best bang for your $, I like the Q6600 over a Q8200, more cache, and tons of overclocking info out there on it.

The P5Q Pro is a better buy over the E, so unless there is a feature on the E you really want, go with the pro.
 
If you go with the P5Q Pro and DDR2-800 like the above posters recommended, you could fit 4GB of RAM into your budget. I suggest you go that route, since 4GB of RAM will be very beneficial if you decide to run Vista (which you definitely should).
 
Q6600 is a great chip for the money. It is my first Intel chip in many years and I am very happy with it. I would suggest getting an aftermarket cooler though. Some of the reported temps with the stock cooler even at stock speeds are high.

I recently picked up this Rosewill cooler from Newegg for 25 bux because it had a 4 pin fan my MOBO can control. It works as good as the Thermaltake Maxorb I had on there before. Temps at 3.2 GHZ are in the mid 50s.

I would also second the call for going with 4 gig of RAM. I am shortly going to pick up the other 2 gig I should have bought originally. I wish I had it in 2 X 2 gig modules instead of 4 X 1 giggers.

Don
 
If you go with the P5Q Pro and DDR2-800 like the above posters recommended, you could fit 4GB of RAM into your budget. I suggest you go that route, since 4GB of RAM will be very beneficial if you decide to run Vista (which you definitely should).

I am running vista ultimate 64 i plan on getting more ram next month thats why i only figured 2gb ATM

Q6600 is a great chip for the money. It is my first Intel chip in many years and I am very happy with it. I would suggest getting an aftermarket cooler though. Some of the reported temps with the stock cooler even at stock speeds are high.

I recently picked up this Rosewill cooler from Newegg for 25 bux because it had a 4 pin fan my MOBO can control. It works as good as the Thermaltake Maxorb I had on there before. Temps at 3.2 GHZ are in the mid 50s.

I would also second the call for going with 4 gig of RAM. I am shortly going to pick up the other 2 gig I should have bought originally. I wish I had it in 2 X 2 gig modules instead of 4 X 1 giggers.

Don

I have a tuniq tower that was hooked up to my phenoms that i am going to be using, i still have all the mounting hardware for it so thats not an issue. just havent played the intel game and wasnt sure about which chipset to use or really the cpu. the ram thing surprises me i figured faster ram=better, but if it doesnt make any difference we will go cheaper
 
the ram thing surprises me i figured faster ram=better, but if it doesnt make any difference we will go cheaper
Today 08:27 PM

That threw me for a while too. But you must realize how these things work.

I have 800 MHZ ram in my system. BUT, I am running at 355 MHZ with a X9 multiplier for a bus speed of 3.2 GHZ. I am good with 800 MHZ ram up to a bus speed of 400 MHZ or 3.6 GHZ on my Q6600. Just remember that you must be running in dual channel mode to take advantage of your memory's full speed. I can ALMOST guarantee that a Q6600 can not take advantage of memory faster than 800 MHZ.

Don
 
would i be better off with a faster dual core like the E8500 or the Q6600 and ocing it to 3 ghz? After my experience with phenom i kind of like the idea of a quad core cpu but if the dual core is going to be faster w/ gaming i may go this route, or does it really matter which way i go?
 
would i be better off with a faster dual core like the E8500 or the Q6600 and ocing it to 3 ghz? After my experience with phenom i kind of like the idea of a quad core cpu but if the dual core is going to be faster w/ gaming i may go this route, or does it really matter which way i go?

Doesn't really matter that much actually. Once you start playing at above 1280x1024, the differences between the E8400 and Q6600 is pretty minimal:
http://www.guru3d.com/article/cpu-scaling-in-games-with-quad-core-processors/
 
would i be better off with a faster dual core like the E8500 or the Q6600 and ocing it to 3 ghz? After my experience with phenom i kind of like the idea of a quad core cpu but if the dual core is going to be faster w/ gaming i may go this route, or does it really matter which way i go?

If you overclock the Q6600 to ~3.2GHz (which is easily accomplished), it will perform just as well in games as the E8400 will. Once you've passed a certain clock speed, games cease to be bottlenecked by the CPU and the GPU becomes the limiting factor.
 
I have chosen,
Q6600
Asus P5Q-E
OCZ DDR2-1066 2gb (2x1GB)
sound good?

Get good DDR2 800 RAM that runs at 1.8V and you'll likely get all of the headroom you need out of it. You'll find that most DDR2 1066 RAM runs at 2.1/2.2V which essentially means it's just overclocked DDR2 800 anyway.
 
If you go with the P5Q Pro and DDR2-800 like the above posters recommended, you could fit 4GB of RAM into your budget. I suggest you go that route, since 4GB of RAM will be very beneficial if you decide to run Vista (which you definitely should).

I was going to make a similar suggestion.
 
lol i guess i could fit 4gb in now, lol after shipping it leaves me a nickle out of my $400 :p
 
I like the P5Q Pro as well - it's good bang-for-your-buck right now on the egg - free shipping and $129. 2 x PCI Express 2.0, 8 sata ports, 3 - pci-3 x1 slots, Intel ICH10R.

However, if you do not find any/most of those features a good fit for your needs, than the Biostart P35 posted earlier is a great buy.
 
Oh, I thought you had another reason:D.

Well, I have another reason. It's one of the cheapest dual PCI-E 16/8x slot boards, overclocks like a champ, has almost all the features as the more expensive boards in the line have, has a great layout, good onboard cooling solution, and a very intuitive BIOS. I bought one for myself and I couldn't be happier.
 
Back
Top