iTunes Borking Windows

It's iTunes for Windows, does anyone think it'll actually work without issues? Come on... get real. I have absolutely no reason to doubt Apple is doing things to intentionally cripple their products when used on the Windows platform so people will become so angry about it they'll figure "It must be Windows, so I'll go get a Mac..."

Please... Apple knows precisely what they're doing, second by second.

Doubt it, that would be a dumb business move on the part of Apple.
 
Doubt it, that would be a dumb business move on the part of Apple.

Exactly how? People already own the iPods, it's not like 20 million people with iPods running Windows will magically get rid of them and Apple loses money - the sale's already complete.

As for dumb business, well, every time a "Mac vs PC" ad comes on TV Apple is effectively giving Microsoft free advertising because, if you're really smart and you understand how these things work, you'd understand that in advertising, the cardinal rule is "Don't mention the competition in your own ads. Don't give them free advertising." Which is exactly what Apple does with each new commercial.

It doesn't help Apple, it hurts them. In January it'll be 25 years since the Mac was first unveiled. A lot has happened in that quarter century, but one thing has remained consistent: Macs are still niche products, and always will be. The ~6% market share backs that up... and that's ~1% more than it was pre-Intel Mac days with BootCamp and people being able to still use Windows on a Mac.

iTunes could be so much better on Windows, but Apple doesn't give a shit about Windows. They prove it every time they bash it with a new commercial yet they couldn't exist without it.

Funny how that works.
 
The first thing you see is a notice from Apple Software Update. It promises an update to iTunes+QuickTime and says nothing about any other software.

Opening the folder where Apple Software Update stores its temporary files reveals what’s really going on. The download consists of five installer packages and a master setup program.

One is a USB controller update, which is apparently used when connecting an iPod or iPhone to the system. On my system, this driver file was copied to the system but was not installed until I connected an iPod Mini via a USB port.

This sounds more like a trojan horse than a legitimate program. I sincerely doubt that it's malicious but this is still malware like behavior and frankly is pretty inexcusable whether or not it actually caused system lockups. Software should always disclose exactly what it is installing on your system, that Apple chose not to is very disappointing.

the whole, you need itunes to use an ipod sucks. i think i will buy my kids a ms zune next time. any other mp3 player suggestions. ijust want to copy and paste my mp3s into the device and play them i dont want some program forced on me to babysit me.

For MP3 players try Cowon, they aren't well known and fairly expensive but they are excellent. Right now I'm using their iAudio 7.
 
I have an older version on my system for my wife's iPod,it works well enough so I never bothered to update.Glad I didn't now.I did notice that the new version they tried to get me to download had conflicting info as to the size of the download.
 
My vista machine dropped the connection to my simpletech USB hub twice. The second occurrence caused my Drobo 2.0 to get hung and become unrecognized when I plugged it back in, even when using a USB port on the computer itself. I finally had to unplug the Drobo and that fixed it. That was a scary few minutes. I hope iTunes isnt the reason the hub acted up. That would be quite stupid.
I go back and forth between iTunes and Foobar, depending on what I'm doing. I wish Apple would have made separate software for all the iphone crap, rather than forcing endless iterations of their audio player upon us every time the pwnage tool released an update. Ever since the iphone came out, the program has gone from bloated to perverse.
I do sort of like the tile view though.
 
I know this is going to sound rude, but maybe some of you don't have your computer setup properly. I've been using a 1G nano and iTunes for about three years now and have not had any problems at all. I installed ver 8 tonight, plugged in the nano and wammo...my computer is just fine. Quit blaming the software and start looking are your install. No one is perfect. Also, I'm not an apple fanboy. The only Apple equipment I own is the nano and it will get replaced when it doesn't work anymore.

It's not rude, just ignorant. Two PCs running just fine, including iTunes 7.7 for months. Insatll iTunes 8 ad problems immediately occur. I'm glad you aren't having issues, but that doesn't mean the issues don't exist.
 
Still works fine for me. Bought a new CD last night, and loaded it to me 60 gig no problems. One thing i kinda don't like about V8 is how it lists my library as records now instead of the usual list.
 
the whole, you need itunes to use an ipod sucks. i think i will buy my kids a ms zune next time. any other mp3 player suggestions. ijust want to copy and paste my mp3s into the device and play them i dont want some program forced on me to babysit me.

Samsung P2. I have it and its awesome. ;)
 
I only have iBloat err iTunes because of my iPhone 3G. I have iTunes 8 now and luckily I don't have any issues. Once I get home from work and update to Firmware 2.1 we'll see what happens.

I have an original Zune 30 as well and while I'm no fan of the Zune software it's a helluva lot better then iTunes will ever be. No added services (have 4 for iTunes). No BS. Just connect the Zune, start the software, let it sync, unplug and walk away. Did it this morning in less then a minute when I bought Metallica's Death Magnetic from Amazon. (Great album btw! So much better then St. Anger!) Even without any changes my iPhone probably takes 5 minutes to sync and that doesn't include the backup or god forbid it actually having to sync new music or copy new applications across.

Unskinned WinAmp on a minimal install is still my choice for playing my music. :p I manually dealt with all my music years ago so I keep it clean just by quickly manually updating them when I get a new album. Album art the Zune Software generally takes care of and it's pretty accurate for me at least and I find that it's better then iTunes in that respect as well. I also don't have nearly the music collection some people here probably have. If I had to pick a program though I'd go with MediaMonkey.
 
My buddy has a first day xbox that's still running fine therefore everyone else who's had the RROD must be doing something wrong.

Apples and oranges. RROD is a known issue that MS admits to. Also, most people don't install all the software on their Xbox as it's a console.
 
about these BSOD's lately, I am wondering if it has anything to do with some damn piece of software it installed that i didnt ask for to be installed, called Bonjour and the mDNSResponder.exe it is associated with. I found a little utility that kills that service, and now i dont have random 100% cpu spiking either. I dont know if it was coincidental or not, but no problems here now.
 
Uh yeah, because every computer in the world is the same and installs should be flawless..

Say, that sounds awfully similar to Apple computers!

I've had iTunes on three different computers and two different notebooks. All different hardware and software. Never a problem for me. I still say PEBKAC.
 
I too am in the "never had a problem with itunes" boat.

I also have a 4th gen 30GB with a 2 color screen and i have been saying for years (4 1/2 now
) that i would replace it as soon as it died.....


so maybe i just have really good luck with apple...
 
This is the reason I don't buy Ipods or use iTunes. I have yet to use a version of iTunes that worked well, or have an iPod that worked like it should. I'll buy my cheap ass samsungs from here on out, use windows media player, and have my FM tuner, thanks.
 
I've had iTunes on three different computers and two different notebooks. All different hardware and software. Never a problem for me. I still say PEBKAC.

Well enjoy your Utopia my friend, while the rest of us stay in reality and try to figure out what Apple and/or Microsoft did wrong. Don't pull your arm out of it's socket patting yourself on the back by the way.
 
Apples and oranges. RROD is a known issue that MS admits to. Also, most people don't install all the software on their Xbox as it's a console.
At what stage of the automated process do you suggest people are screwing up the install then? It's impossible to screw up an install where the software does it from start to finish for you :rolleyes:
 
At what stage of the automated process do you suggest people are screwing up the install then? It's impossible to screw up an install where the software does it from start to finish for you :rolleyes:

clearly he unpacks his installer, then opens each file, then repacks it with a correct checksum of course, and then does his install. :rolleyes:
 
the whole, you need itunes to use an ipod sucks. i think i will buy my kids a ms zune next time. any other mp3 player suggestions. ijust want to copy and paste my mp3s into the device and play them i dont want some program forced on me to babysit me.

Hate to tell you, but zune requires special software also. A lot of people wish it would just use windows media player or be drag and drop, but it isn't. you have to install the zune software to use it. Although it doesn't install anything extra with it like itunes does.
 
One program I've been tinkering with has been Songbird.

It's based off of Mozilla, and a lot of the add-ons work with it as a result. Doesn't appear as clunky as Itunes is, and can even import ITunes libraries.

The closest thing I have to Quicktime on my Windows machines is Quicktime Alternative...Only installs the bare minimum crap on the machine.
 
I've been avoiding installing Quicktime and iTunes for years now, cause I don't want their additional crap installed on my computer.

Exactly, and this is why I bought a creative zen.
 
Well, I use MediaMonkey. Very powerful player / ripper / organizer, and with 3.0, it can handle 100,000 songs...:)

I'll be trying this out. Thanks for mentioning it. Although I have a pro license for Winamp, I'm getting tired of its lack of performance on my system & random freeze/lock-ups. MediaMonkey looks great & the user skins are well made. Gives me something to look forward to when I'm off from work. :D
 
Genius only took all night to analyse my music, but no BSOD or crashes, running Vista Ultimate 32. Maybe it's a problem with certain USB controllers. I'm running a i965 chipset.

KC
 
While I agree that iTunes is a bloated piece of shit that I would never install on my machine, a BSOD is indicative of a Windows problem. Granted, the iTunes software must be pretty broken to cause such a catastrophic reaction from the OS, but if the OS is properly isolating application level executables, the worst thing that should happen is that the application crashes, or slows th machine to a crawl.

This is a case of an iTunes bug exposing a Windows bug.
 
While I agree that iTunes is a bloated piece of shit that I would never install on my machine, a BSOD is indicative of a Windows problem. Granted, the iTunes software must be pretty broken to cause such a catastrophic reaction from the OS, but if the OS is properly isolating application level executables, the worst thing that should happen is that the application crashes, or slows th machine to a crawl.

This is a case of an iTunes bug exposing a Windows bug.
I have to disagree. I mean, back with XP, I cannot tell you how many BSOD crashes I had that were due to a bad driver, and a simple reinstall of the driver fixed it.
 
While I agree that iTunes is a bloated piece of shit that I would never install on my machine, a BSOD is indicative of a Windows problem. Granted, the iTunes software must be pretty broken to cause such a catastrophic reaction from the OS, but if the OS is properly isolating application level executables, the worst thing that should happen is that the application crashes, or slows th machine to a crawl.

This is a case of an iTunes bug exposing a Windows bug.

Wrong. BSOD can be caused by software interfacing the operating system and/or it's kernel improperly.
 
Wrong. BSOD can be caused by software interfacing the operating system and/or it's kernel improperly.
The OS should isolate the application in such a way that if the application tries to do something it's not allowed to do, the OS will intercept it, and handle it gracefully.

The point that was made by Modred189, however, stands. There is always the possibility of a bad third-party driver.
 
The OS should isolate the application in such a way that if the application tries to do something it's not allowed to do, the OS will intercept it, and handle it gracefully.

The point that was made by Modred189, however, stands. There is always the possibility of a bad third-party driver.

So by your definition, virus doesn't or shouldn't exist. Virus is essentially a deliberately written bad software.
 
From the topic title, it sounded like Steve Jobs was bending Bill Gates over and giving him the business. :eek:
 
I dropped iTunes about a year ago after I had enough of it and couldn't take it anymore. It got to the point where for some reason I would go to sync my iPod, and it would take literally overnight, if not longer, to sync one or two albums, and cause everything else running to behave abnormally. I did some research, and ended up switching to MediaMonkey, and haven't looked back since, and now refuse to put iTunes on my computer. I love MediaMonkey, and it syncs my iPod better than iTunes did. All I have to do is plug it in, hit the sync button on MM, and I'm good to go. No apple apps on my computer since then, except for QT Lite.

QFT. I switched to Media Monkey back when iTunes 7 was released. For some reason, iTunes 7 would BSOD my computer after about an hour of playing music. I switched to Media Monkey, and not only did the problems go away, but it was way easier to use.
 
So by your definition, virus doesn't or shouldn't exist. Virus is essentially a deliberately written bad software.
I never stated that viruses don't or shouldn't exist. Nor did I claim that bad software couldn't be written. In fact, I stated the opposite. However, the scope of damage that the virus does is limited by its level of access to the system. A virus executed at the user level can do as much damage as the user can. If a virus executed at a low-privilege level manages to do something that is supposed to be reserved for a high-privilege level, then it's taking advantage of a bug.
 
Basically, had Apple listened to MS guidelines and written the driver and software to run at a low level of access, it would not have been as big of a problem. The software would have still crashed, but would not have taken the OS with it.
 
fat chance of that. apple cant even follow windows program design standards.
 
the whole, you need itunes to use an ipod sucks. i think i will buy my kids a ms zune next time. any other mp3 player suggestions? I just want to copy and paste my mp3s into the device and play them. I dont want some program forced on me to babysit me, like itunes or aol.
[/QUOTE]

The Zune forces you to use the Zune desktop software exactly as the iPod requires iTunes. And it is no better--it's actually far worse, in my opinion. At least there are some "drag and drop" hacks for the iPod, like EphPod.

I have a Zune, got it as a gift. The device itself seems at least as good as the iPod in features and usability, but the Windows software is pretty awful IMHO.

If you want "drag and drop" get a Sansa.
 
iTunes sucks. Damn 250MB install everytime you need to update it is retarded. No, I don't want safari or quicktime everytime I install iTunes! Bloated POS.
 
sorry, but although safari and quicktime are installed when you install itunres, what is to stop you from just uninstalling them seperately, i am the main source of solutions to computer problems at my school, and i've never had any problems with itunes in the last 3 years. the only slight muck-up i've had is on my own XP laptop, where you can't use bonjour to share libraries with other people, which i've NEVER used while i've had an ipod (had shuffle 1st gen, 2nd gen nano, now on 80GB classic).

i know multiple people in this huge environment that have just found safari on their computers, not knowing how it got there (some of them thought it was me lol) and started using it, with a relatively gradual movement from IE to Safari over the last 12 weeks. if people don;t want it, i either uninstall it, or they just leave it there, and delete the desktop shortcuts...

i'm running 7.7, but a LOT of people at school have updated to 8.0 and no problems at all, and we are talking over 1000 laptops all running XP pro on the same network. almost everyone who has itunes, has an ipod, and people who don't have ipods still use it, because it is easy to use, and ther eare many different ways to use it.

so what if media monkey has support for 100,000 songs, big deal, i know at least 20 people who have over 35 days worth of music, or 40GB of music, and these computers handle them fine. I also use macs on a regular basis, and update them with the latest itunes versions when they come out, and there is basically no difference between the two.

total, this is a huge amount of people who have no problems at all syncing ipods of all different generations to different computers with no rpoblems at all... maybe its windows, maybe its not, but i have had almost no problems whatsoever, and even then, they were very minor.
 
Back
Top