Windows 7 Shooting For a 15 Second Boot Time?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A senior member of the Windows 7 development team says that there is a team of engineers dedicated to start up performance that has set a goal of having a15 second or less boot time. The post goes into detail about what it takes to achieve that goal and how the team is progressing. Interesting stuff.

Startup can be one of three experiences; boot, resume from sleep, or resume from hibernate. Although resume from sleep is the default, and often 2 to 5 seconds based on common hardware and standard software loads, this post is primarily about boot as that experience has been commented on frequently. For Windows 7, a top goal is to significantly increase the number of systems that experience very good boot times. In the lab, a very good system is one that boots in under 15 seconds.
 
Just so long as the short "boot time" doesn't mean every other app will load after you're "booted up" making the system unresponsive until they're all loaded into memory.
 
The biggest problem on the average PC is all the extra software installed insisting on leaving apps running all the time, and most checking every boot for updates. Some of these programmers need reminding that their product is not supposed to take over a PC.

When I say "average" PC, I don't mean an [H] reader's machine. You should see the unbelievable level of rubbish on a normal user's PC!!
 
Who cares... I see most people using sleep/suspend.

I hope this isn't at the expense of other, more important factors. Last time they made a big deal out of boot time, claiming that for most people it was a big deal, whilst ignoring obvious design flaws.
 
I've got an old P3 800 laptop with 256MB of PC100 RAM in it, a 4200 20GB hard drive, and it boots XP Pro in 13.8 seconds.

15 is progress? :)
 
I think this 15 second boot up is hype and a pipe dream. As mentioned, a lot of other stuff has to initialize besides the OS before the hard drive activity stops (which is when I consider a computer fully booted up). Too many factors, too many manufacturers, too many different programmers to come together to make something like a 15 second boot up ever happen.
 
Hell boot time smoot time. People that I know, my mother especially NEVER turn their machine off. :)
 
Since I can't edit my previous post, I'll add that I think they are considering a boot up to be when it hits desktop. I don't consider that a boot up at all cause many things are still going on as the hard drive light will indicate the activity still going on. They may get it to hit desktop in 15 seconds but then the rest of the boot up will still be happening with no total time change. When I boot up, I don't touch the computer until I see the hard drive light stop. That's a boot up as far as I'm concerned.
 
I concur, my mom's machine takes 2 minutes because "weatherbug" has to laod and then wait for the wireless to connect...too many mfr, too many poorly written programs.
 
15 second boot time? One of the ways that will have to happen is to create a bootvis type of application to run at least near real-time or real-time to monitor the initial bootup drivers and rearrange them on the fly or to make suggestions to the user on how that should be done.
 
I've got an old P3 800 laptop with 256MB of PC100 RAM in it, a 4200 20GB hard drive, and it boots XP Pro in 13.8 seconds.

15 is progress? :)

Why dont i believe that ?

I had a Pentium M Laptop with better specs than that, and it didn't boot a fresh installation of xp in that time .

I guess you may be talking about the time it takes to show the loading bar from the press of the start button .
 
No, it's time as measured by Bootvis on a "Trace - Next Boot + Driver Delays" pass. I made a post about it a few years back, trying to locate it now with the picture snapped of the trace and Bootvis clearly showing "Boot Done (in 13.8 sec)".

It's not all that hard to do, yanno, and I've actually had slightly faster boot times on some hardware, but my record with XP Pro is 11.3.
 
I can't believe people actually give a crap about boot time.

I care about how the machine runs After it is in windows. 99% of the time I am not at my machine waiting on it to boot.
 
My Amiga booted in about 10 seconds at the most back in 1997, and that's to a usable desktop.

AmigaOS4.x still boots in under 10 seconds.

Sure Windows is "bigger" and we have more programs autostarting these days. On the other thand, my current CPU runs at 58 times the clock frequency of my Amiga (plus it's dual core and much faster per clock), I've got 114 times the RAM (with massively higher memory bandwidth and much lower latency) and 1140 times as much storage space with much lower access time and probably 50 - 100 times the transfer speed.

When a Windows PC can go from Off to a usable desktop in under 10 seconds, I'll call it progress :)
 
I can't believe people actually give a crap about boot time.

I care about how the machine runs After it is in windows. 99% of the time I am not at my machine waiting on it to boot.

Maybe you might not care about boot time, but wait until the marketing literature comes out and you will see it as a selling point.
 
There should be a law passed that we are not allowed to discuss features of an operating system until the OS is in beta. Remember all of our conversations on WinFS? Yeah, that was worth it.
 
From Article said:
For this same system, it is worth noting the resume from sleep time is approximately 2 seconds, achieving a nearly instant on experience. We do encourage users to choose sleep as an alternative to boot.QUOTE]

Sounds nice and all, but I STILL have trouble getting Vista to sleep/shutdown properly. MS and the motherboard makers keep playing "point the finger" ...
I hope they get the shutdown/sleep feature right... It's a freaking pain to have to yank out the power plug just to get the system to power down. The high pitched scream from my 8800GTX doesn't make it any more pleasant.
 
The last time I saw a Microsoft OS boot in under 15 seconds was Windows 3.1. I've seen many other MS OSes boot in about 20 seconds but almost never under 15.
 
I built my mom a shuttle based system with xp home on it (athlon xp 2400+ @ 2ghz with 500mb of ram) and it's always booted fast, say 15-17 seconds from power button to fully usable. My home machines with xp home have never loaded that fast, and i have barely anything launching at startup. Never understood it.
 
Who cares... hey maybe the next os will have an Ultimate version that includes vaseline. After Vista I swear to Jeebus I will not purchase or use another Windows operating system on my computers at Home.
 
As someone who turns their computer off every night to reduce energy use I am all for faster boot times. However as others have said once you add in anti-virus and other aps boot times are greatly increased.
 
They'll only do it by trimming down features. It's really all those features we've come to call "normal" that take up loading time. 10 years ago you didn't watch UT vids in a browser. Now you'd think it abnormal if you couldn't.
 
Yeah I really couldn't care less about boot time. My machines are typically up for about 90 days between reboots.
 
No, it's time as measured by Bootvis on a "Trace - Next Boot + Driver Delays" pass. I made a post about it a few years back, trying to locate it now with the picture snapped of the trace and Bootvis clearly showing "Boot Done (in 13.8 sec)".

It's not all that hard to do, yanno, and I've actually had slightly faster boot times on some hardware, but my record with XP Pro is 11.3.

See I don't even have a problem with XP boot time as it is. I think anything under 30s is perfectly fine. I remember when my Promise ATA-100 chip on the KT133 chipset wasn't working and boot-up in 98SE took 2 mins. Seriously, booting time should NOT be a critical concern these days.
 
Vista takes 52sec to get to a useable desktop on my comp, do I want 15sec?:confused:? Not really, they should be spending resources on more important things that take up the other 23hours 59min of my day...
 
We should do a boot test video showing our rig next to a timer

I am happy with my current boot time which I will repost when I can time it. I wake up, turn on the computer, make food and come back to everything ready lol.


... to those admins reading this .. has there ever been talk about an active chat room for us ?
 
Yeah I really couldn't care less about boot time. My machines are typically up for about 90 days between reboots.

Ditto. Reboots usually occur during blackouts or when forced to by an installation.
 
This will go a long way towards impressing the non-PC savy. My co-worker watched in amazement as my vostro rebooted in about 30 secs. There were hardley any programs installed, but not a whole lot of folks would make that connection.
 
Not as bad as one kid I saw trying to convince everyone his laptop could boot in a matter of like 3-4 seconds, and all he was doing was pulling it out of sleep mode...

-_-
 
The post I made was in early 2007 and in a period where a forum rollback occurred, and a LOT of good posts including mine were lost. A lot of Vista "tutorials," and many others were lost when that happened. Bleh...

I regularly have clients that get referred to me by word of mouth drop off XP laptops that take 12-25 minutes to boot to a usable state on the Desktop (seriously). I hit 'em with everything I know, all the tweaks, get rid of all the crap, clean 'em up, strip out the junk, etc.

The usual customer pickup goes something like this:

Customer: "So you're all done?"

Me: "Yep, here ya go. Go ahead and turn it on." (Customer takes laptop, opens it, turns it on, turns to me)

Customer: "That's great, and I appreciate your fast turnaround. So what do I owe... HOLY SHIT... what did you do to my laptop?" they ask because when they got to the word "owe" in their statement they were staring at the Desktop, ready to roll, with AV installed, fully updated, with their stuff still in place, wireless working too, all of it.

I should charge a lot more than I do, but... a flat rate has done wonders for my bank account over the years, and created a client list of hundreds that keep cash in my pocket. ;)

As for whether a fast boot time is important or not? The hundreds of people that call me regularly to get their machines booting fast tells me that yes, yes it does matter. Quite a bit.
 
Well I imagine most of us here are already accustomed to fast boots...maybe that's why I'm not as impressed by a sudden "increased focus" on this for Windows 7.
 
I'll believe it when I see it, they've claimed shorter boot times with every single Windows release... Some actually achieved it with varying degrees of success, but boot times usually erode to hell once you actually start using the system (even if you're careful about startup/background aps). 'Sides, who really cares anymore? Between hibernate modes that work just fine and stuff like ExpressGate getting more popular, what's the need?

A lot of people never turn their systems off anyway, either because of stuff like Folding or merely because of convenience... If they just enable Hibernate it's as good as turning it off (as far as power usage), and coming back from hibernation is fast enough usually, probably 15 on average. How are they gonna deal with BIOS issues and AHCI recognition and the kinda stuff that can often add 5-10s to the boot time regardless of what the OS does anyway...

It's all even more irrelevant in the typical office where systems are booted on in the morning and turned off when everyone's leaving...
 
My Amiga booted in about 10 seconds at the most back in 1997, and that's to a usable desktop.

AmigaOS4.x still boots in under 10 seconds.

Sure Windows is "bigger" and we have more programs autostarting these days. On the other thand, my current CPU runs at 58 times the clock frequency of my Amiga (plus it's dual core and much faster per clock), I've got 114 times the RAM (with massively higher memory bandwidth and much lower latency) and 1140 times as much storage space with much lower access time and probably 50 - 100 times the transfer speed.

When a Windows PC can go from Off to a usable desktop in under 10 seconds, I'll call it progress :)
Yeah, the Amiga was the king of fast boots (and many other things) :)


The last time I saw a Microsoft OS boot in under 15 seconds was Windows 3.1. I've seen many other MS OSes boot in about 20 seconds but almost never under 15.
Heh, I've been using old slow computers that took plenty of minutes to boot 3.1. I'm not joking when I say it could take 15-20 minutes. Unfortunately, I have no clue what specs those computers had. Didn't really know anything about PC hardware then.
 
Btw Joe, that's all great... But a good hunk of what you're alluding to has nothing to do with Windows or the plausible optimizations MS could do, heh, and we all know it.

Your customers are relieved that their system don't take 10m to boot because A) I'm sure they're often either obsolete systems or new ones with an inadequate amount of RAM (why they still do this w/Vista and RAM as cheap as it is I dunno) OR B) apps, spyware, and endless amount of crap that will bring any Windows install to it's knees regardless of how fast it boots when it's clean. Half of that stuff is often installed by the OEM itself.

If you obviate those two facts, whether a clean Windows system takes 15s to boot or takes 30s is probably irrelevant...
 
Ditto. Reboots usually occur during blackouts or when forced to by an installation.

Or repeated windows crashes.

By the way, I've got linux servers around the house that may take half a minute to boot, but I can't be sure - I can't remember the last time I had to reboot one of them.
 
Back
Top