Why so many don't like Vista ?

Cov

Gawd
Joined
Dec 3, 2007
Messages
917
Sorry to bring back on old question but I still wonder ...

I remember when I used Windows 3.11 on my first PC, that seemed to be the state of the art at the time.
Well, if you look at it today, you wonder how we could put up with that.
Not to mention all the flaws the OS (dumped on the top of DOS) brought with it.
And not to forget all the hard ware restrictions we still had end of the 80s (286/386) in every form and shape ... as fundamental construction mistakes (64kb is more than eough for everyone ...
eek.gif
).

When the following versions of Windows came out, all the computer magazines went crazy and it always was subject number one on the front page.

And with every new version I thought: "Hmm, that's gonna be a keeper.", but I was convinced the same way with XP that it couldn't be improved that much.
I thought that was a keeper too ... but since I have changed to Vista ... I think again this is gonna be a keeper ... cause what could they still improve big except making further service packs available ?

We will see what the future brings, but so confident I was that I'd stick with XP - no matter what, so convinced I am now to stick with Vista.
Maybe because I'm an "eye-person" and since the new OS is all about eye candies, I certainly enjoy using it - every day.
Having managed a beautiful design, maybe some day they'll bring out the matching animations too ?

For example, I know that the defrag feature is not able to diplay the status (while defragging) 100% correct.
But I did enjoy watching the defrag process in previous Windows versions where you could see blocks being moved and changed colours ... didn't matter how precise that was.
Vista has none. You even don't know how long it may take approximately, it may take 15 min - or it may take 2 days.

There'd be many examples still where I would like animations to make complicated processes "transparent" ... if you know what I mean.
I can imagine a great potential of improvements in that respect as the user has not always 100% authority over what his PC does and neither does he understand what is going on in the background.

That needs to be addressed and I wish that we, as the owners of our machines get 100% control over what is going on.
Simple example: I give the order to interupt or stop something but Windows / the application does its own thing. That is not on. If I decided to stop the current process - it must stop immediately.
Otherwise I'm the slave of my own machine.

To wrap things together:

1. We need a GUI to keep the users more up to date about what the OS does. (Vista has already good attempts)
2. The OS must be able to diplay comlex process in simple to understand animations / graphics. (there's great potential)
3. At any time, the user MUST be able to decide what the OS does. (That's still a problem)


Is that too much asked for ?



The Mojave Project -----> http://www.mojaveexperiment.com/
 
It's really simple:

People don't like change.

An OS is supposed to be transparent, it's not supposed to "do" anything for the user. The purpose of an OS is to provide a way for applications to execute and for the applications to be able to communicate with the hardware for functionality, that's it. It's not supposed to get in the way, it's not even supposed to be visible, to be honest.

People expect too much from an OS these days, and they're becoming far more complicated than necessary, but that's just how life in general is becoming too. Sad, but that's just how it goes.
 
When Vista launched, there was not a lot of driver support, so some accessories didn't work etc. People don't realize that Vista has a built in scanner and camera wizard to pull pictures and to scan :rolleyes: Also, people are not very savvy when it comes to buying hardware, and they listen to companies like HP and Dell, who say it's OK to have 512 ram with Vista. Plus, there were a few bugs with the OS. At the end of the day, Vista looks like the bad guy where really it was the fault of Microsofts Partners for not giving the OS the proper hardware and mostly, because of user ignorance and self-made problems. There are people that spread rumors in the tech industry (about Vista), as well as users who cause their own problems by tweaking the OS by disabling a bunch of services. Those are preventable issues.

If you know hardware (or at least buy from an honest company) and they give Vista the right hardware (not necessary expensive to do if you know what to include and what not), Vista is possibly the best OS they have ever released.

Honestly, SuperFetch and Aero make the OS absolutely fly
 
another reason for Vista not dominating the market right now is on account of XP.

Windows XP has been around for so long now. It has been refined, optimized through numerous patches and software.

Also many people can not rationally justify the expense to upgrade to vista, when xp meets/exceeds their own needs and requirements.

and people are comfortable with xp. like an earlier post said; people don't like change.
 
My problems with Vista have been with hardware and software compatibility. At launch much of my hardware (i.e. color laser printer, scanner, etc) did not work. Still today my flat-bed scanner will not work and the vendor isn't planning to release a driver. Is that Vista's fault? Many say no, but I say yes. Microsoft has created this hardware and software community and they are what drive their OS's success. If they can't convince hardware companies to "do the right thing" then there will continue to be issues.

For all the software that didn't work I have bought new versions. For the hardware, at this point I have upgraded. Am I happy about Vista now? No. It still is less stable than my XP machine ever was, but I have moved on.
 
To wrap things together:

1. We need a GUI to keep the users more up to date about what the OS does. (Vista has already good attempts)
2. The OS must be able to diplay comlex process in simple to understand animations / graphics. (there's great potential)
3. At any time, the user MUST be able to decide what the OS does. (That's still a problem)


Is that too much asked for ?



The Mojave Project -----> http://www.mojaveexperiment.com/

Not exactly sure what you really mean with these points. Sounds like monitoring for the most part. Windows/Vista has some excellent monitoring tools built in and third party. The Sysinternal tools are quite good at monitoring all types of things for free: http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/0e18b180-9b7a-4c49-8120-c47c5a693683.aspx
 
As has been stated, Vista is different and people don't like change. Every issue pertaining to Vista also applied to XP when it launched. There were driver issues, older hardware was not supported, it was slow on older machines, it was a memory and HD space hog. Unfortunately, few people will write about their positive experiences with something, but they will be very vocal if they have trouble with something. Right now, it seems most of the Vista hate is coming from the "my cousins, mother's hairdresser's dog said Vista sucks, so it must suck".

Oh, and 3rd party drivers : In no way shape or form are Microsoft's business or problem.



 
I cannot get 4x 9800GX2's to run together under Vista.
The max is 2x 9800GX2's and a 9800GTX.
While I can get all 4 running under XP.

A lot of the little programs I use are not digital signed for Vista, so I need to hit F8 on every reboot.

UAC drives me mad but it complains when I turn it off.

So its a lot of little things that stop me upgrading my computers.

Luck ........... :D
 
I think what we're seeing isn't exactly the same as it was with XP. I believe we are seeing a maturing customer base for a maturing operating system market.

Windows 95 and 98 brought something extra to the table. Each was significantly better than what came before it. Then win2k hit, and after all the patching and SPs it was a GOOD OS ( still is, which is why you find it in use still ). Then XP came out to a lot of fan fair, but people started to realize that XP wasn't significantly better and they started questioning why. Oh, XP had some neat extra features, sure, but for the most part we could still be using 2k without much of an issue.

That attitude was left in place over how many years before Vista was released? By the time vista came out, even members of the general public didn't see the need. In fact, most of them didn't like the interface change, and I can't blame them. Vista brings a few neat features that Xp didn't have, but they aren't deal breakers in a world where 2k is still a valid OS for most of our applications.
 
Still today my flat-bed scanner will not work and the vendor isn't planning to release a driver. Is that Vista's fault? Many say no, but I say yes. Microsoft has created this hardware and software community and they are what drive their OS's success. If they can't convince hardware companies to "do the right thing" then there will continue to be issues.
It's not their responsibility to make sure vendors write drivers for it. They make an OS, the most dominate OS in the world, if your scanner manufacturer wants to stay in the stone ages, that's not Microsofts fault.
 
Xp is going to die. It will fade away and disappear over the next few years along with software/driver support for it. You can complain, whine, rant, and hold your breath all you want. Won't change nothing.
 
Boils down like this from experience with people I know:

Those who saw the pretty pre-release screenshots and wanted Vista, didn't do any research and bought it, found out all the pretty didn't run on their system. They hate Vista. Grumble, grumble.

Those who did their homework, new what they were getting into and maybe upgraded a little don't mind Vista.

Those who bought a new OEM PC or did a significant upgrade and then learned how to set "Classic View" in the Control Panel love Vista.
 
An OS is supposed to be transparent, it's not supposed to "do" anything for the user. The purpose of an OS is to provide a way for applications to execute and for the applications to be able to communicate with the hardware for functionality, that's it. It's not supposed to get in the way, it's not even supposed to be visible, to be honest.

I would say that's one view, and one which is followed by, say, the Blackbox window manager for Linux, which has almost no on-screen presence. It's not necessarily the only one though; probably the most common impression of an OS now is something which provides all the basic functions and utilities required on a computer in an easily-accessible way. Most users want a package of all the basics to start them off, not to have a blank slate which does nothing until they put in the effort to install even the most basic software.

Vista brings a few neat features that Xp didn't have, but they aren't deal breakers in a world where 2k is still a valid OS for most of our applications.

That's true, but I find it odd when people use that as a criticism of Vista. It's certainly a reason not to upgrade your XP machine, but I don't understand why people want XP on a new machine rather than Vista.
 
Windows 95 and 98 brought something extra to the table. Each was significantly better than what came before it. Then win2k hit, and after all the patching and SPs it was a GOOD OS ( still is, which is why you find it in use still ). Then XP came out to a lot of fan fair, but people started to realize that XP wasn't significantly better and they started questioning why. Oh, XP had some neat extra features, sure, but for the most part we could still be using 2k without much of an issue.


Just picked up an Ipod Touch for a friend of mine. For his B-day. His days of "2K is all I will ever need" came crashing down. The versions of ITunes that work with 2K do not support the Touch. He now runs my old version of XP Pro.

I strongly agree with all the "people dont like change" comments. I truely belive that is the core issue. That added to some erronious bad press early on lead to a lot of people making and setting thier minds.

Xp was the first x86 OS I was happy with. I have had and used 95, 98, me, XP, and now Vista.

Mac OS has always been good.

My .02
 
Agreed about the little boxes in Win9x defrag.. best part about Windows ever right there. When I was bored in elementary / middle school classes I would start and watch the defrag program.
 
It's not their responsibility to make sure vendors write drivers for it. They make an OS, the most dominate OS in the world, if your scanner manufacturer wants to stay in the stone ages, that's not Microsofts fault.
I would say it is most certainly their responsibility.

Most hardware manufacturers did not promise Vista drivers for XP-era and earlier hardware. If MS wants support for these devices as a selling point for the OS, then it is their job to make that happen. Remember that the hardware manufacturers had already sold their product; it's MS that is trying to push something new and (comparatively) unsupported into the market.
 
That's true, but I find it odd when people use that as a criticism of Vista. It's certainly a reason not to upgrade your XP machine, but I don't understand why people want XP on a new machine rather than Vista.
Look at it this way, over the past few years people have gone from, "Must have the latest MS offering" to "Why do I need those features"?

A simple extension of that is evident on the desktop. People have used XP and like it; why do they need to relearn the OS again? Why would I inflict the pain of learning a new OS on my mother who knows and understands XP well enough to keep the support calls to a minimum?

Further, why would should any business be forced to spend countless IT hours getting their backend infrastructure ready for Vista when they can still get XP on their machines?
 
I would say it is most certainly their responsibility.

Most hardware manufacturers did not promise Vista drivers for XP-era and earlier hardware. If MS wants support for these devices as a selling point for the OS, then it is their job to make that happen. Remember that the hardware manufacturers had already sold their product; it's MS that is trying to push something new and (comparatively) unsupported into the market.


MS never claimed to support the hardware device drivers, only that they have the best hardware support. Which is true. More hardware makers support their hardware via drivers on MS OS's than any other. Besides that, only if (hardware maker X) open sources their driver can MS even consider writing a driver for a piece of hardware they don't own the rights to. Drivers are software, they are the sole property of the owner. I could only imagine the outcry and lawsuits that would occur if MS started writing drivers for (hardware maker X's) hardware. Hardware maker X wants to sell you a new piece of hardware, plain and simple. They are choosing not to support various hardware for that reason. It has nothing to do with MS.
 
Look at it this way, over the past few years people have gone from, "Must have the latest MS offering" to "Why do I need those features"?

A simple extension of that is evident on the desktop. People have used XP and like it; why do they need to relearn the OS again? Why would I inflict the pain of learning a new OS on my mother who knows and understands XP well enough to keep the support calls to a minimum?

From a user viewpoint I find very little in how the gui works to have changed. Just how it looks. If I wanted to I could ignore all the new features and pretend it was XP with a special skin.
 
I would say it is most certainly their responsibility.

Most hardware manufacturers did not promise Vista drivers for XP-era and earlier hardware. If MS wants support for these devices as a selling point for the OS, then it is their job to make that happen. Remember that the hardware manufacturers had already sold their product; it's MS that is trying to push something new and (comparatively) unsupported into the market.

Does anyone remember when XP first came out? HW support was about where Vista was when it was first launched. I remember I had a stand-alone scanner. It was never supported in XP. When it comes to scanner manufacturerers, nothing has changed. If it is VERY recent model, i.e. still in production, it may get supported.

Once a model has stopped production, all support of it ends. At least that has been my experience, and the experience of the poster who had a scanner issue.

These days, I simply buy an all-in-one, which seems to get better support than a stand-alone scanner.
 
Look at it this way, over the past few years people have gone from, "Must have the latest MS offering" to "Why do I need those features"?

A simple extension of that is evident on the desktop. People have used XP and like it; why do they need to relearn the OS again? Why would I inflict the pain of learning a new OS on my mother who knows and understands XP well enough to keep the support calls to a minimum?

Further, why would should any business be forced to spend countless IT hours getting their backend infrastructure ready for Vista when they can still get XP on their machines?

One thing you didn't mention is that XP had been Microsoft's flagship desktop OS for a little over six years, which was very irregular considering MS's previous offerings were only a flagship product for about 2 to 3 1/2 years. That gave everyone enough time to settle with the 'then new' XP which in turn created a larger user base that accepted that they would need nothing better. The "Why do I need these features" argument isn't exclusive to Vista; it's just a whole lot more common. When XP was released in 2001, quite a few people complained that it lacked too many features to be considered an upgrade to Windows 2000 (and you weren't required to activate 2000). When 2000 was release, some people complained that it offered too little to be considered an upgrade to Windows NT; when Me was released, a hell of a lot of people criticized that it offered wayyyy too little and was a lot less stable than Windows 98.
 
I would say it is most certainly their responsibility.
So it's Linus Torvalds (all Linux distributors) fault and responsibility that Linux doesn't have good driver support?
Most hardware manufacturers did not promise Vista drivers for XP-era and earlier hardware. If MS wants support for these devices as a selling point for the OS, then it is their job to make that happen.
I don't remember ever reading Microsoft claim that they supported old hardware.
Remember that the hardware manufacturers had already sold their product
So it's OK that after they make a sale, manufacturers don't have to support their products with future driver stability upgrades and improvements? I think you just buy hardware from companies who don't offer good support. I want to buy from companies that care about their customers. When a company chooses to not support you, for THEIR products that YOU paid for, is it honestly Microsoft's fault? I think not, chief.
 
I never hated vista but I didn't really see how it was a necessity in my life. XP has been working reasonably well for a number of years. When things change you have to re-learn, re-do and dance to the computer gods praying that everything goes right. I am using vista now and for the most part it seems to be a refined XP.

So now I'm disappointed that it isn't radically different...ahhhh...grass is greener. :D
 
My main issue with Vista is that file transfers take a very long time compared to XP - even with good systems (modern C2D-type systems).
 
People don't like change

The driver model changed, it needed to, and hardware vendors were slow to get out drivers and alot of the drivers that were out there weren't quality. This resulted in performance and stability issues.

People bought into the FUD going around. Almost none of it true. It's just ammo for the linux and apple fanboys.

Microsoft did a bad job of explaining the changes under the hood. Most people just see a new GUI and think that's all there is. But so much has changed in Vista that is not always visable to the user so they think it's nothing new. Vista has alot of new technology, new advances, under the hood.
 
Its not just about change.. There are Tonne of compatibilty issues especialy with OpenGL and Cad DCC software wwhich I use.
 
I have yet to come across a single compatibility issue. OpenGL or otherwise. I'm sure some have issues but not most.

Still, that is for the software developers to fix.
 
They are choosing not to support various hardware for that reason. It has nothing to do with MS.

I'm not saying MS should be writing drivers for 3rd party devices.

If I go and write an OS in my spare time I would have no expectation that hardware vendors would start writing drivers for it. They certainly don't have any obligation to write drivers for my OS, since they never indicated support for it when they sold the hardware. It's the same situation with legacy hardware and Vista.

If I want people to start using my OS, then it is my responsibility to convince the appropriate parties to start writing drivers, and if I fail then I can't put all the blame on the hardware vendors, since they never indicated they would support the OS.
 
I dont dislike Vista but it cant be made secure enough for me sadly.

I use Protowall to ban naughty places on the web from speaking with my PC.
There is no 64 bit version for Vista 64 (no point in upgrading to Vista32 also with a 4GB memory limit), so I'm still getting high on XP until it is resolved :)
Protowall does function on Vista32 but the logging is broken so its a lot harder to unblock IP's and you cant see what is being blocked or if it is even working.
 
I dont dislike Vista but it cant be made secure enough for me sadly.

Incorrect statement. It can be made 'safe enough', just not via the use of a now discontinued freebie tool. Further development of Protowall has ceased, and there will be no Vista-compatible version of it.

The real reason Vista isn't suitable for you is because you want to use Protowall, not because Vista can't be made secure enough. There are alternative programs or options available.
 
Incorrect statement. It can be made 'safe enough', just not via the use of a now discontinued freebie tool. Further development of Protowall has ceased, and there will be no Vista-compatible version of it.

The real reason Vista isn't suitable for you is because you want to use Protowall, not because Vista can't be made secure enough. There are alternative programs or options available.

I can use IPcop externally but its a bind to update quickly.
Any other suggestions?
 
Vista doesn't do all that much over XP except use about 500-700 MB more RAM and have worse compatibility than XP.
 
I'm still no nearer to getting Vista, thanks anyway :)
 
I have yet to come across a single compatibility issue. OpenGL or otherwise. I'm sure some have issues but not most.

Still, that is for the software developers to fix.

These programs are expensive. I can justt use Xp and I know they will work or I can get vista and have problems.. Sorry But I can't justify forking 3k for a program anymore.
 
That's cool, Nenu. I wasn't trying to convince you to change.


Vista doesn't do all that much over XP except use about 500-700 MB more RAM ...

Read "5. Vista is a Memory Hog" here:

http://www.tweakguides.com/VA_5.html

Then please stop saying what you just said. Vista doesn't somehow make less memory available. Instead it does a better job than XP did at actually using the memory you have!
 
These programs are expensive. I can justt use Xp and I know they will work or I can get vista and have problems.. Sorry But I can't justify forking 3k for a program anymore.

I never said you should fork over 3k. All i'm saying is most people do not experience compatibility issues. Just pointing out that it's not an issue for most. That's all.
 
Back
Top