Thinking about an external HDD; USB or SATA?

videobruce

Gawd
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
515
This is one of those 'I always wanted to do, but never got around to it projects'. I'm not sure which route would be best.

Situation;
Three PC's; two towers (both w/ two HDD's) and one Laptop (not used often),
Not alot of data, but instead of using DVD's to back up, this seems easier,
One device for all three would be nice, though the Laptop I could live without,
It would be used mainly for my main box (tower).

Questions;
1. If I went with a USB interface, can I assume the PS is external?
2. Can I then assume most are those damn 'bricks' as opposed to internal PS's within the HDD enclosure?
3. Are there any models w/ internal PS's, or at least a PS that is on a cable so it isn't hanging from the power strip?
4. Between the all in one (HDD, enclosure & PS) vs buying the encloseure, PS and the HDD separately, what's the better route?
5. If I went with a SATA drive, are there any enclosures that are taylored to this setup?
6. The cableing from the PC to the unit. Make shift or use a premade PCI slot plate w/ connectors (assuming they are available)?

Sorry for all the questions, as I was just thinking of my known options and configurations.
 
If you went with a 2.5" USB drive, then there is no need for an external PSU, it just uses 2 USB ports, one for data and one for power.
 
videobruce
I bought one of these one week ago and it works great. What I like best - it is very simple
This for bare drive and must be / have SATA for connection in this drop in case.
I bought this one which has USB and SATA connection. Very handy if person has or will be having several Sata drives.
With name videobruce U may be like me finding out how fast drives fill up with Video files.
I don't have as of yet connection on computer for Sata but I am looking into Sata controller so for now I am using USB connections.
Link below has good information on this new product and Video showing use for it.
They have 3-4 models of this. These handle 3.5 and 2.5 Sata drives
Another Option instead of External HD enclosers

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=3829117
 
Those are nifty hot-swap connectors, but its design and the nature of it being totally exposed makes me leery about keeping those things connected for long periods of time. Good for IT professionals who always need to connect and test hard disks all the time, though.
 
You beat me to the punch line. I agree totally. Everything is exposed with the HDD. No protection. If you are in a 'clean room' or at least a area that has a 'clean' status (surely not any house I have been in), that might work.

Interesting idea, but it needs refinement. At least some enclosure around the HDD.
 
I totally agree
Everything is exposed with very little protection BUT my only fear is problems from handling drive.
Person could always come up with some type cover for this like box open in front and tall enough be able put drive in and take out.

Cheap as HDs are now I will be using this for Video and backup data to drive.

I have no less than 5 external hd and have in pass when hd is full or for other reasons.
Always had take hd enclosure apart take out drive and hook up another.
YEP I like ideal of being able to turn this thing on and drop in hd & swap if needed.

;) Nothing seems be perfect for everyone and this drop for hd sure is long ways from being perfect setup.
I am sure if this type catches on others will greatly improve on it. I HOPE

Be worth keeping ;) eye on and updated

Harold
 
I picked up a WD external drive that supports USB and eSATA. It has a power brick that comes with it. It's not very heavy. I got a good buy on it - works fine for moving my files around.
 
Person could always come up with some type cover for this like box open in front and tall enough be able put drive in and take out.

Kinda like this one?

I have another brand that also has an enclosure and it gets pretty toasty.

My other enclosures have active cooling.
 
Just wondering: is there any benefit to getting a 2.5" laptop-sized external drive versus one that uses 3.5" desktop hard drives? Or is it that simple: price vs weight?
 
Just wondering: is there any benefit to getting a 2.5" laptop-sized external drive versus one that uses 3.5" desktop hard drives? Or is it that simple: price vs weight?

To me, 2.5" enclosures generally don't require external power connectors, which is a big plus in my book for convenience and portability. In the case of my particular 2.5" enclosure, which is a WD Passport (old version) that I removed the original 250GB hard disk and put that in my laptop and put my 160GB Hitachi 2.5" disk inside the enclosure, it only has one connector - Mini-B USB, which both powers the drive AND transfers data. Not having to lug around a big external AND have to reach to connect the power (forgive me, I'm a lazy bastard ;)) is a big plus for getting a 2.5" portable hard drive.
 
Do eSATA/USB 2.5" enclosures have that same benefit?
I like the speed of eSATA.

I'm convinced. I will pay the small premium to get portability and the convenience of a USB-powered device.
 
Portable 2.5" HDs can generally be used with one USB connection if the host machine is using a 110V supply.

When using them with a lappy on battery power, most need a USB Y cable for the correct power.

eSATA and SATA plugs have no power.
 
Portable 2.5" HDs can generally be used with one USB connection if the host machine is using a 110V supply.

When using them with a lappy on battery power, most need a USB Y cable for the correct power.

eSATA and SATA plugs have no power.


Thanks, that's a bit of good information I'll remember!
 
Thanks.

What eSATA+USB 2.5" enclosure do you recommend? I'm really liking the no-AC adapter idea. I'm fine with using AC power when operating on eSATA...but the USB-only connection idea is very appealing!
 
COOLMAX HD-250L (i like leather...but they have an aluminum one too)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817159069

I've had mine for about 5 month's now, no issues. The only hiccup i ran into was that my laptop wouldn't provide it enough power with the enclosed y usb cable...Simple fix, got a shorter mini usb - reg usb cable. Didn't need the y adapter or anything, just a 9" cable.

Let me reiterate, YOU DO NOT NEED A Y CABLE...just a shorter cable

plus the leather case makes it so you never have to remove it from the case. i've dropped my drive on many occasions and no damage, pretty well insulated.

Love it
 
COOLMAX HD-250L (i like leather...but they have an aluminum one too)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817159069

I've had mine for about 5 month's now, no issues. The only hiccup i ran into was that my laptop wouldn't provide it enough power with the enclosed y usb cable...Simple fix, got a shorter mini usb - reg usb cable. Didn't need the y adapter or anything, just a 9" cable.

plus the leather case makes it so you never have to remove it from the case. i've dropped my drive on many occasions and no damage, pretty well insulated.

Love it

That's a really nice 2.5" enclosure, I love the pleather on it. :D
 
Back
Top