is this a good hard drive

i dont think i need all that memory
right now i have a 200 gig hard drive for 3 years and only used 100 gigs so far
 
I vote for the Segate, based on a personal bias against WD products :D
 
I've had good luck with the IBM/Hitachi Deskstars, but others haven't been so lucky. At one point they came to be known as "Deathstars" due to a high failure rate.

Hitachi bought IBM's disk drive division 6 or 7 years ago, that's the reason I mention IBM...
 
I've had good luck with the IBM/Hitachi Deskstars, but others haven't been so lucky. At one point they came to be known as "Deathstars" due to a high failure rate.

Hitachi bought IBM's disk drive division 6 or 7 years ago, that's the reason I mention IBM...

The "Deathstars" were only one model, IIRC the 75GB GX DeskStars that were inherently badly manufactured in a certain lot. This reputation goes far, but as far as I know today, Hitachi drives are pretty good performers. Of course, they're a bit behind in platter technology as their 1TBs recently switched from five platters to three platters of greater areal density, but as with any hard disk manufacturer, your mileage may vary determinant on if you get an inherently bad DOA drive or whatever problems with any hard disk brand. Others swear by WD, Seagate, Samsung, Hitachi, etc and others shun them. It's a matter of experience, of course.
 
Sandman, you may never use the full 640GB of that drive, but I guarantee it's 2x the performance as that 320GB seagate you linked.
 
Sandman, you may never use the full 640GB of that drive, but I guarantee it's 2x the performance as that 320GB seagate you linked.

I wouldn't say twice the performance. The Seagate 7200.10 320GB has an average transfer speed of 65MB/s give or take while the Western Digital 640GB has an average transfer speed of 95MB/s give or take.
 
How is the WD faster than the seagate? It has similar specs :confused:

Platter density, platter design, # of platters, efficiency, etc. All of that allows the WD 640GB drive to be faster than the Seagate 7200.10 320GB drive.
 
Back
Top