What Bandwidth Addiction Will Cost

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
With our dependency on high-speed internet access, are we in danger of creating a bandwidth cartel much like the ones we have in the oil industry?

Americans today spend almost as much on bandwidth – the capacity to move information – as we do on energy. A family of four likely spends several hundred dollars a month on cell phones, cable television and Internet connections, which is about what we spend on gas and heating oil.
 
I think the cartels are already in force over there, but I also think the prices in many cases may be the way they are because the comms infrastructure that isn't up to modern standards, due to local decisions and cartel/monopoly-like behaviour. Why lay new cables to give your customers faster and cheaper access when you can continue to demand the same high prices as before?

I give 20 euro a month for 10 megabits (up and downstream, no limits, it's an rj45 plug in the wall), deals like that (100 mbit for twice the cost) are available in the 10-15 largest cities here and more are being added to the list, and this started only after the last monopoly on the communication lines was cut up by force.
 
Bandwidth in this context is far more abundant than oil/gas reserves. Cartels will just be monopolies really. Per mbps, some european countries pay drastically less than "Americans".

So what?

How much was an ISDN connection back in the 90's? $200/mo in some areas?

For about $50/mo I get 10mbit down and 1mbit up. I would like more upload, but hopefully that's coming soon. Either way, far better than ISDN back in the 90's.

Bandwidth has nowhere to go but up. Anyone who says otherwise is either trying to fool you, or rip you off (or take your liberties).
 
You would think that prices should go down as volume goes up and the entire US gets on the "grid". And yes, I am one of those who spends hundreds on cable, internet, iphones etc.

But then again I need that shit, I have to be plugged in. I swear I am not addicted, can stop any time. I swear. :D
 
Its a valuable service I dont think twice about paying for. Cartels? Unlikely.
 
Phones and TV? Pfff... both are obsolete if you're a true nerd with a good high-speed internet connection. I'd live in a box before I'd give up broadband :p
 
Bandwidth addiction? Well, we all know what addicts do when they can't afford what they want. They start stealing it. Oil it's kind of hard to force OPEC to give freely. Bandwidth however is a domestic object with entirely domestic companies like AT&T that in the end if things got really bad we'd simply take things away from them.

That's assuming bandwidth is actually an "addiction" though which is kind of silly - if they really priced things out of our willingness to pay we'd simply drop the service. There are a few people who are "I have to have my internet, I have to have my internet" but the masses - the ISP's have already stated before when talking bandwidth caps that 99% of people only use it for email and light web browsing. You price it too high for them and they WILL leave.
 
I spend something like $25 on 3Mbps down DSL, only reason I even felt the need to go that fast is because I was paying $40 for 1.5Mbps down. If anything the thing that pisses me off is that I continue to pay older rates, even though they drop down (for non-contract rates too!). The same speed would cost me $20 a month, so I figured an extra $5 for twice the speed capacity isn't too bad. However if I had to drop down to 1.5Mbps, or 768kbps, or what not I would without batting an eye.
 
I give 20 euro a month for 10 megabits (up and downstream, no limits, it's an rj45 plug in the wall), deals like that (100 mbit for twice the cost) are available in the 10-15 largest cities here and more are being added to the list, and this started only after the last monopoly on the communication lines was cut up by force.

That's a sweet deal. I'd like to start seeing that in the US. However, I do think that the US being more dispersed than Europe causes higher cost in infrastructure. Same reason we don't see as much mass transit, at least on the west coast.

we all know what addicts do when they can't afford what they want. They start stealing it. Oil it's kind of hard to force OPEC to give freely.

Funny you mention that... I remember a couple run ins we had with some oil smugglers in Iraq. Tried to bring some home myself, but it was on the list of things you can't bring home with you along with ear necklaces.
 
I don't care, give me a OC-3072 and I'll sell my kidneys.
 
I haven't read the article but it seems like its touches on something I've been thinking about for a long time. One of the cost vs. data sent problems with texting (of course this does not apply to unlimited plans)

I don't think the US has good healthy bandwidth competition anywhere and we know it doesn't have a broadband policy.
 
In my opinion i could Broadband could never be a cartel because truly it is not like Oil where we have a finite supply controlled primarily by overseas states NOT companies.

whereas with broadband internet it is provided to us through companies and is constantly upgraded and maintained and is not necessarily a finite resource, and can be theoretically upgraded many times over. Not to mention as already pointed out the internet isn't a need its a want we want internet but a lot of us could and have lived without it whereas without an effective means of transportation society would crumble.
 
I think they're exaggerating the cost comparision with gas and heating oil,with the prices these days I spend a hell of a lot more filling up than on cable and Internet.
 
In my opinion i could Broadband could never be a cartel because truly it is not like Oil where we have a finite supply controlled primarily by overseas states NOT companies.

whereas with broadband internet it is provided to us through companies and is constantly upgraded and maintained and is not necessarily a finite resource, and can be theoretically upgraded many times over. Not to mention as already pointed out the internet isn't a need its a want we want internet but a lot of us could and have lived without it whereas without an effective means of transportation society would crumble.

Ok, then lets call it what it is. A series of Natural Monopolies, or possibly, in some neighborhoods, Oligarchies. This thread is painful to read for economists and I'm not going to bother to try to correct all the horrible errors and terrible logic (or lack thereof) going on. Try looking up Natural Monopoly, that is what most cable/phone companies are.
 
I think they're exaggerating the cost comparision with gas and heating oil,with the prices these days I spend a hell of a lot more filling up than on cable and Internet.

I could purchase two months of broadband service for each fillup :(
 
Interesting way of looking at it, but got a little preachy towards the end. Competition for the airwaves is much different than competition for cables. With a cable it's pretty cut and dry who owns it and competition would be another company laying a line. I'm a firm believer in open markets and competition, but regulation or laws make sense with certian technologies.
 
You already are starting to see companies experimenting with capping your bandwidth each month and then charging you more for each GB you go over. This is only the start.
 
i know this is off topic, but has anyone here signed up for T-mobile's new phone service, thats suppose to compete with the landline? ive heard its only $10/month talk about competition.
 
In many places in Europe, you can get pretty much genuine 100mbit internet for about $80 per month, where in Missouri (US), MediaCom offers 8mbit internet for $60/mo+.

The difference? For 8mbit here in the US you are paying $7.50 per mbit (US), but for 100mbit in Europe you'd be paying only $0.80 per mbit (Europe). For crying out loud, I smell a monopoly! Here in America they try to juice the people out of money because they can.

Besides that, I really doubt there is or will be a bandwidth issue any time in the near future (or our lifetime). There is plenty of bandwidth available.
 
Cerulean, that is also not taking into account that in the US the upload is probably more severely limited in a proportional relation.
 
In many places in Europe, you can get pretty much genuine 100mbit internet for about $80 per month, where in Missouri (US), MediaCom offers 8mbit internet for $60/mo+.

The difference? For 8mbit here in the US you are paying $7.50 per mbit (US), but for 100mbit in Europe you'd be paying only $0.80 per mbit (Europe). For crying out loud, I smell a monopoly! Here in America they try to juice the people out of money because they can.

Besides that, I really doubt there is or will be a bandwidth issue any time in the near future (or our lifetime). There is plenty of bandwidth available.


Cost of living and income comes to be a big player that you are not mentioning.

While $80 USD a month may seem cheap, for those guys it isn't. Same concept when it comes to other goods/products... they pay pennies for music, software, and dvd's, while we pay a lot more... their rates are adjusted to the economy. Also, a lot of those services offer TV, phone, and internet over the same connectivity, effectivley killing sufing bandwidth. Also a lot of those carriers offer large sustained speeds but very little bandwidth allowment.

BTW, I get 16mb service from comcast with powerboost additional service for $19/month. Zoomtown used to offer decent ADSL services for as little as $14 a month in Cincinatti a few years ago. SBC is offering ADSL I think now for under 14 a month. So in reality, the numbers aren't too far off, it's just that you have to be under the right service areas.

A lot of european countries or areas pay a ton more than we do, it's just that some of them spoiled bastages gets really good connections for low costs with a lot of media coverage.
 
The markets are missing true competition. Until the FiOS vs. Cable products you really had a limited option for the fastest internet avaible, but we're still limited by geography and government restrictions to laying cable (which are probably better rather than having companies laying multiple lines).

I think it's interesting to see them all going out to setup bandwidth caps, its like a new form of price fixing that will ultimately lower their cost and still keep ours high.
 
It's funny to see the cable companies panic and scramble in areas where FiOS is providing real competition. Not that I think Verizon will behave any better once they start establishing themselves, but for now it's a nice alternative to cable, or a nice way to rattle the saber over your provider's head. Hell, we just got a free doubling of upspeed at my place, and I guarantee you it wasn't out of the goodness of Comcast's heart :rolleyes:
 
I'll quit cold turkey....ok just one more megabyte. Its my last one. I swear.
 
The only bandwidth problems we have come from the fact that right now there's a duopoly.

I pay 29.99 for a 256 kb/s connection - there is no cheaper connection in my area (AT&T is 19.99, but if I want that, I'll have to pay $39.99 for the same phone service I now get for 17$)

My relatives in Russia pay 300 rubles (~12.65) for a connection TWICE as fast as mine.

Sure, income over there isn't as high as it is here on average, but consider this: they don't pay rent. We do.

Adding bandwidth caps would be complete bullshit. The only place they're needed are 4.99 connections for those who can't afford anything else.
 
Back
Top