Rate my media server/nas build.

Roliath

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 2, 2005
Messages
2,914
Well, I come to these forums for help as I've seen great budget rigs built here to be NAS boxes. This is similar to those types of threads but i'm throwing a possible HTPC solution to it. Main goals for this project would be a cheap NAS and HTPC setup with little heat output and noise. My total media isn't big compared to others but its around 600GB and grows very slowly.

Basically I'm looking for something cheap ($300 before shipping) and something with decent amount of power. The plan is to have the PC connected to my Mitsubishi WD52631 (DLP 1080p) at all times and have some sort of Media Browsing Interface (not sure on OS yet) to view and catalog my movies, music, and other files.

Below is the build that I have priced out in newegg (will take recommendations!!!)

Intel Pentium E2180 Allendale 2.0GHz - $69.99
Antec NSK4480B 380W Power Supply - $74.99
Western Digital Caviar SE WD1600AAJS 160GB 7200 RPM SATA2 - $41.99
CORSAIR ValueSelect 2GB (2 x 1GB) DDR2 667 - $34.99
ECS GF7100PVT-M Micro ATX Intel Motherboard - $49.99
BTC 9116URF RF Wireless Mini Wireless Keyboard - $24.99
Grand Total: $296.94 (before shipping)

So, the cpu from what I have read online overclocks fairly well (if I decide to oc this setup) and is strong enough for 1080p playback (8gb .mkv's). Motherboard has built in graphics Nvidia 7100 with HDMI (dvi -> hdmi cord included) so that should save on power and heat. I figure that the mobo paired with cpu should be plenty for 1080p playback and more than enough for the NAS side.

I did not include the drives or a raid card in the total as I have a few options available to me. But I will be using the following raid card and drives

2 x Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3750640AS in a Raid 1 Array On this raid card Adaptec 3405

I have the drives and the raid card already (not in use), one thing that scares me about going with that setup is I may be oversubscribing the PSU and I may not be able to power it all. If that fails, I have a Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 ST31000340AS 1TB that I could use in place of both 750's (but I would rather use those first). I could also in stuff 4x Seagate ST3300555SS SAS (300GB 15k rpm) hard drives in there since the raid card was used with them before but i'm almost damn sure that psu wouldn't be able to handle their load and those drives are loud and HOT.

So final thoughts, do any of you guru's/veteran's see anything wrong with my choice on hard drives. What would you recommend as far as drives go, which setup would be the most efficient? Any recommendation on OS? Do you think the onboard video and cpu would be enough? Should I drop that mobo and go with something else and use an Nvidia 6200 pci-express card I have lying around?

Thanks FAR in advance for any and all help!
 
That psu should have no problems powering that.
 
I personally have that EA380 PSU powering five hard drives and Pentium III CPU 24/7. Granted the PIII uses less power than the E2180 but still, the EA380 is more than enough for your setup.

Actually for 1080P content and other HD content (i.e Blu-Ray and HD-DVD), the E2180 + Nvidia 7100 is not suffcient enough for that. In fact, if you go into the HTPC subforum, you will find out that the only integrated chipsets capable of decent HD playback are AMD's 780G (which uses the ATI Radeon HD 3200 IGP) and Nvidia's 8200 chipsets, both of which are only available for AMD CPUs and motherboards. Intel's G33/G35/G45 do not handle HD content well.

So I recommend going with this setup:
AMD Athlon 64 X2 4600+ CPU - $58
Gigabyte GA-MA78GM-S2H AMD 780G mATX Motherboard - $75
----
Total: $133 Plus tax and shipping.

Just $13 more than your Intel setup but the 780G chipset will offload a majority of the HD decoding. As a result, a system better suited for HD content. Also, the X2 4600+ outperforms the E2180 when both are at stock speeds.

Oh and you can get that case with free shipping which will save you about $15 once shipping is factored in with Newegg:
Antec NSK4480 ATX Case with Antec Earthwatts 380W PSU - $80
 
I personally have that EA380 PSU powering five hard drives and Pentium III CPU 24/7. Granted the PIII uses less power than the E2180 but still, the EA380 is more than enough for your setup.

Actually for 1080P content and other HD content (i.e Blu-Ray and HD-DVD), the E2180 + Nvidia 7100 is not suffcient enough for that. In fact, if you go into the HTPC subforum, you will find out that the only integrated chipsets capable of decent HD playback are AMD's 780G (which uses the ATI Radeon HD 3200 IGP) and Nvidia's 8200 chipsets, both of which are only available for AMD CPUs and motherboards. Intel's G33/G35/G45 do not handle HD content well.

So I recommend going with this setup:
AMD Athlon 64 X2 4600+ CPU - $58
Gigabyte GA-MA78GM-S2H AMD 780G mATX Motherboard - $75
----
Total: $133 Plus tax and shipping.

Just $13 more than your Intel setup but the 780G chipset will offload a majority of the HD decoding. As a result, a system better suited for HD content. Also, the X2 4600+ outperforms the E2180 when both are at stock speeds.

Oh and you can get that case with free shipping which will save you about $15 once shipping is factored in with Newegg:
Antec NSK4480 ATX Case with Antec Earthwatts 380W PSU - $80

I actually had a 780G combo priced out paired with an Phenom 9600, I used to have an X2 4600 and with the combo I was running at the time I experienced fairly high cpu usage when doing simple file transfers (one reason I choose the phenom for the 780g combo). Would it be wise to go with pair the 780G with a Phenom for a shot at longetivity out of the build, or would an X2 4600 (or better) offer comparable performance?

I used Newegg to list all prices/specs but once I decided on a final build configuration I would shop around the usual sites (ZZF, Buy, Amazon, TD, etc.) to see about any deals/cheaper prices.

I will look into our HTPC forum and do a little more research but i'd like to hear your thoughts with the previous questions.
 
You don't need a quad-core CPU for HTPC and NAS duties. It is a bit overkill. The X2 4600+ is more than capable of handling HTPC and NAS duties.
 
You don't need a quad-core CPU for HTPC and NAS duties. It is a bit overkill. The X2 4600+ is more than capable of handling HTPC and NAS duties.

Thanks, I will have to revise my build a bit i'll update this thread a bit later.
Thanks again for your help Danny Bui
 
Back
Top