Worth Waiting for Nehalem?

davewolfs

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 7, 2006
Messages
338
Hey everyone,

I need to build a new PC. Currently only have laptops and need something faster. Is it worth waiting for Nehalem or am I better off just getting a quad for cheap and overclocking it?

Thanks,

Dave
 
depends if you ant to spend alot of money. new chip+mobo+ram will be 1k minimum.
 
Also depends what kind of work you'll be doing on it. Could just got with the dual core and get a better deal if you're not going to do too much multi-tasking.
 
I'd wait for DDR3 to drop in prices to upgrade to it. Getting a LGA775 board/DDR2 ram/whatever chip will probably be a lot cheaper than getting a new socket type board/chip/DDR3 RAM. I don't think the price is worth the performance right now.
 
I'm going to need to buy new everything i.e. mobo, ram, hd and cpu so my cost will be roughly 1k anyways. I'll check out that link that was posted to see what the new numbers are like.
 
depends if you ant to spend alot of money. new chip+mobo+ram will be 1k minimum.

1k min huh?

$74 for 2 gigs of ram http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145183

$300 for a 2.66ghz proc

and assume something between $200-300 for a motherboard.

You do the math out on that and tell me what you get.


As to the OP
It really depends what you plan on doing. If you're just surfing the web and watching porn then shrug. But if you're heavily into mutlitasking or use software that can utilize all that power than its probably something you might want to look into and wait on.

Even still Nehalem comes out in September, if we're lucky, but unless you want to be on the bleeding edge you're going to wait at least a month to see the final verdict on the thing. So you also need to ask yourself if you can wait until mid-october/early november to build this. If you cant wait that long than current c2d tech is still plenty viable.
 
And when I said he was wrong on the pricing I was talking about Nehalem as well. "The sky is falling" mentality around here when it comes to how much a new Nehalem setup is going to cost is getting old quick.
 
when he said $1k i am sure he meant nahlem
DDR3 + mobo + cpu
And demon responded with a proper nehalem price quote. RAM does NOT cost as much as people are saying it does, and he just proved that.

And for $1k, in october/november you'll be able to build a damn powerful PC, including GPU. A 4870, or a GTX260 will be usable if you salvage PSU/case/HDD from what you already have.
 
So.. Did you check out the poll a couple of threads below? This way you'll already see a large number of yes and no's to base the decision on.
 
My pricing was actually for a DDR2 machine. These prices are not exact but pretty close. I'm sure I might be able to find better prices but I don't think the total price will fluctuate more then $100. As for a Nehalem rig, it shouldn't cost more then an additional $300, $100 cpu, $100 mem, $100 mobo.

$100 4 Gig DDR2
$180 Q6600
$140 P182 Case
$50 CPU HS
$150 Motherboard
$300 ATI 4870
$150-$250 Corsair power supply 620W or 1000W supply
$50 Keyboard + Mouse

Total: $1120-1220
 
if you need a machine now, but one now. upgrade later if you feel you need the too.
prices now are very good.
 
bah.. nehalem won't be worth it at all...

how old is a q6600? 2 yrs ? and we still don't have a realt app or game to stress the sh1t out of it.
even the q9450 that some claim that is clock for clock faster, isn't being juiced..

so why would you get a nehalem, you won't even use it, the only thing is that its new tech,its cool to have new tech, you can brag all you want about it...

reminds me of the first amd 64's that came out..useless because there were no 64bit apps
 
bah.. nehalem won't be worth it at all...

how old is a q6600? 2 yrs ? and we still don't have a realt app or game to stress the sh1t out of it.
even the q9450 that some claim that is clock for clock faster, isn't being juiced..

so why would you get a nehalem, you won't even use it, the only thing is that its new tech,its cool to have new tech, you can brag all you want about it...

reminds me of the first amd 64's that came out..useless because there were no 64bit apps

Farcry 64!!!
 
bah.. nehalem won't be worth it at all...

how old is a q6600? 2 yrs ? and we still don't have a realt app or game to stress the sh1t out of it.

This is a crazy, narrowminded statement.

Any multithreaded application that runs CPUs to 100% will benefit from quad core.

Audio encoding, video encoding, transcoding, mastering DVDs, photoshop, virtualization and certain kinds of video editing come to mind right off the bat. The CPU, regardless of the number of cores, goes to 100% until the job is done. With quad core, the job takes less time or jobs that previously had to be batched can be done in realtime. Whether quad core or Nehalem is worth it is up to the individual and how they use their processing power.

If all the fine people in the CPU sub-forums cared about was games you may be right, but there's a heck of a lot more out there that uses computers other than games and web surfing.

Oh, and you might find that Flight Sim X actually stresses a Q6600.
 
I use Handbrake all the time for video encoding and its roughly twice as fast on my quad then on my duo.:cool:
 
I am planning to upgrade right now. It seems to me that only the people here who have no need to upgrade right now are telling you to wait for Nehalem.
I am running a P4/DDR400 system only for gaming, and I am getting a C2D/DDR2 system.

Isn't it so, that the first Nehalem CPU's are very basic, and it will take a long time until faster and more advanced models start to arrive. Just like it was with the C2Ds, only now are we beginning to see the fastest models emerge as a form of 45nm chips.And what about MoBos,DDR3,etc....it will be the same. You won't get the fastest models right away, and the new technology is always the most expensive.
So Nehalem-FanBoys if you are really waiting for Nehalem, why don't you wait long enough?
 
is it worth waiting for nehalem if I want to buy a q6600? Can I expect to see a price drop in current cpus when the new one comes out? How steep could it be?
 
Something to remember is that the first Nehalems out will be like the current extreme series processors. They are not going to be cheap in any way. Every time a new architecture is launched, the first ones are always expensive.

Another thing to keep in mind is the maturity of the processor, chipset and motherboards. If the Nehalem launch is anything like the C2D launch, then there will be some problems. The first chipsets were P4 chipsets. Even when the C2D chipsets came out, there weren't very many different motherboards for a number of months. Even if you could get one of the new motherboards (and it didn't cost a fortune), most of them weren't exactly the most stable motherboards around.

If you want to spend the extra money and risk the problems with being an early adopter, go for Nehalem. Otherwise, you're better off building a system based on the current Core2 architecture.

Personally, I would rather build a good, but cheap system right now based on Core2. Then, when the prices on Nehalem equipment are reasonable, build a system based on that. A number of the parts used for the first build should transfer to the new system just fine. More than likely all you would need is a new motherboard, CPU and RAM unless you went with a Core2 DDR3 motherboard and DDR3 RAM. Then you could reuse your RAM. Also, you could sell the Core2 stuff to lessen the monetary hit on buying the Nehalem stuff.

 
Something to remember is that the first Nehalems out will be like the current extreme series processors. They are not going to be cheap in any way. Every time a new architecture is launched, the first ones are always expensive.

The lowest Nehalem proc is a 2.66 quad that is NOT an extreme series proc. It will retail for $300 or less based on a leak that the batch pricing for 1000 of them is about $284.
 
Isn't it so, that the first Nehalem CPU's are very basic, and it will take a long time until faster and more advanced models start to arrive.

Well considering the review that Anandtech did that was linked at the begining of this thread, they show that a 2.66GHz Nehalem (the slowest one being launched this year) outperformed the current top of the line C2D, and this was with some issues as the whole system wasn't even running optimally. IIRC there were some memory issues.
 
The lowest Nehalem proc is a 2.66 quad that is NOT an extreme series proc. It will retail for $300 or less based on a leak that the batch pricing for 1000 of them is about $284.
Shhhhh! Some people are scared of reality. :eek:
;)
 
Back
Top