Apple Extends Exclusive Contract with AT&T

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you’re holding off on getting an iPhone until Apple makes it available on carriers other than AT&T, you’ll be waiting until sometime in 2010 since Apple extended their exclusive distribution deal with AT&T. Time to make alternate arrangements if you’re an AT&T hater but really want an iPhone of your very own.

Under the original iPhone contract, Apple had the right to offer the device to other carriers beginning in 2009. If Apple exercised that clause, AT&T would have lost one of its biggest points of leverage with customers — exclusive access to the iPhone. Nailing the extension "is a very big deal," Entner says.
 
It had to be done.

People hate AT&T, but they are the only nationwide standards-compliant GSM carrier in North America. Apple has three choices:
  • Ditch AT&T for a CDMA carrier, and only sell to the USA.
  • Ditch AT&T, and don't sell in the USA.
  • Keep AT&T and sell to everyone.

The choice is obvious.
 
It had to be done.

People hate AT&T, but they are the only nationwide standards-compliant GSM carrier in North America. Apple has three choices:
  • Ditch AT&T for a CDMA carrier, and only sell to the USA.
  • Ditch AT&T, and don't sell in the USA.
  • Keep AT&T and sell to everyone.

The choice is obvious.

Why couldnt they just make a CDMA version of the iphone and keep ATT?
 
Would YOU like to engineer and manufacture two completely separate devices that perform the exact same function?

Yup, exactly right.

I think it could be good as well, as it would place both carriers on equal footing. CDMA and GSM carriers- see who is better? Same exact phones, different technologies, who gets better reception and has less downtime?
It'd be hell for the carriers, but all in all good for the people in teh long run.
 
Yup, exactly right.

I think it could be good as well, as it would place both carriers on equal footing. CDMA and GSM carriers- see who is better? Same exact phones, different technologies, who gets better reception and has less downtime?
It'd be hell for the carriers, but all in all good for the people in teh long run.

No, that's insane. It would be a nightmare to maintain two completely separate engineering teams, and keep them in sync. It would be suicide for Apple from both a lost money perspective, and a device quality standpoint.
 
I thought in Japan they had WCDMA, a 3G complaint network, therefore the iPhone 3G works there..
 
Would YOU like to engineer and manufacture two completely separate devices that perform the exact same function?

Why not? HTC does it, and I'm sure that others do as well. Hell, RIM has phones that do both CDMA and GSM. What's more, at least portions of China are CDMA. South America is mostly CDMA, and I suspect the same is true in the U.S. and Mexico.

GSM rules the world market, but I'm unaware of any other handset manufacturer is exclusive to one technology. What's more, they could have opted out of exclusivity and brought T-Mobile into the fold.

My guess is that AT&T's subsidy is significantly higher than what other carriers would pay and that it will go down if the exclusive deal ended.
 
Darn! I initially read that headline as "Apple Ends Exclusive Contract", then was really disappointed when I read it again. :(
 
I thought in Japan they had WCDMA, a 3G complaint network, therefore the iPhone 3G works there..

"3G" is more of a concept than a matter of compliance.

As to AT&T being the only GSM network in the USA. No. T-Mobile is as well. But they have zip for 3G, at least until later this year, and then it's on a funky freq.

Japan: Japan is some funky Japanese proprietary stuff.

As to building devices for different networks: real phone makers do it all the time. If APPL want's to play with HTC, Samsung and Nokia they'll need to step up and get with the program and learn to play with the big boys.
 
Well, 3G still has a set of specific rules the phone must agree with in order to be 'hooked in' to the 3G network, so I'd say it has to have compliance. That's how all the phone manufacturers describe it at least.
 
Well, 3G still has a set of specific rules the phone must agree with in order to be 'hooked in' to the 3G network, so I'd say it has to have compliance. That's how all the phone manufacturers describe it at least.

3G is an ITU standard, but that doesn't mean that the iPhone can operate on that system. Sprint has a 3G network, as does Verizon, but the iphone won't work on those networks.

I believe that the 3G that the Iphone uses is HSDPA, which I think rides on top of WCDMA (but dn't hold me to that), but I don't now if the iPhone 3G will provide 3G speeds on a WCDMA network that doesn't have HSDPA support.

Perhaps someone who works for Lucent, Nortel or Ericson could pipe in with a more precise answer.
 
I believe you could be correct. I hate cell phones and cell phone networks. lol..
 
3G is an ITU standard, but that doesn't mean that the iPhone can operate on that system. Sprint has a 3G network, as does Verizon, but the iphone won't work on those networks.

I believe that the 3G that the Iphone uses is HSDPA, which I think rides on top of WCDMA (but dn't hold me to that), but I don't now if the iPhone 3G will provide 3G speeds on a WCDMA network that doesn't have HSDPA support.

Perhaps someone who works for Lucent, Nortel or Ericson could pipe in with a more precise answer.

ALL 3G capable phones use HSDPA. It's just a group of technologies or protocols I should say.My phone the Nokia N95(best phone out, might i add) is not capable of 3G(i have the 1st version of the phone), but the US versions can do ATT 3G, but not t-mobile 3G as the two operate on different frequencies 850mhz/1900mhz vs 1700mhz i believe...Pretty stupid of Nokia to do this...
 
It had to be done.

People hate AT&T, but they are the only nationwide standards-compliant GSM carrier in North America. Apple has three choices:
  • Ditch AT&T for a CDMA carrier, and only sell to the USA.
  • Ditch AT&T, and don't sell in the USA.
  • Keep AT&T and sell to everyone.

The choice is obvious.

What about T-mobile? I know a couple of people who are using their Jail-Broken iPhones with T-Mobile
 
hrm? I didn't think HSDPA was mutually exclusive, as in smart phones you can turn it off but still remain on the network in order to save battery.
 
It could be they are just on the GSM network using EDGE for data..

What I am getting at is that Apple could have opened up the phone to a lot more people without having to do any work to redesign it. It would have been nice to see T-Mobile versions of the iPhones in the US (T-Mobile iPhones are available in Germany)
 
Well, Apple is what Apple is. One of the many reasons I don't buy their products.
 
I finally got the chance to use an Iphone the other day (a 3G) and it was pretty bitchin', which makes me sad seeing as I will not be going to AT&T for one.
 
*unleashes long string of obsecinites built up with the anticipation that apple would end this foolishness EARLY, not extend it to last even longer*
 
Back
Top