AT&T Will Cut Off P2P Users?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Engadget has an interesting news item posted today that says an AT&T rep told the FCC they can terminate a customers service for use of P2P applications.

AT&T's Robert Quinn, who told FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell that, "use of a P2P file sharing application would constitute a material breach of contract for which the user's service could be terminated." Quinn was apparently quick to add, however, that AT&T hasn't yet kicked anyone off the network for using P2P.
 
So much for downloading software updates --legal file updates mind you-- via torrents.....

im an AT&T customer.....mostly because they are the only player in town out here in nowheresville kansas......


*walks away shaking his head*
 
What about legit services that use P2P? AT&T can't seriously be considering blocking those too.
 
read the article a little more carefully...It's talking about 3G wireless service for phones, not DSL home service.
 
I imagine they might reconsider when they lose all their WoW addicts since the blizzard downloader is torrent based. You can fall back to direct download but it's usually VERY slow in comparison.
 
They'll be making you register and post bond for the use of a VPN over their network.

And that's the problem .... they consider the things they built with partial public funds on public rights-of-way to be "theirs".

They don't want to be a common carrier .... then kick 'em off the poles and dig up their lines. Let them compete using "inductive coupling" (a term my boss used to use when he found that I had forgotten to electrically connect things together).
 
my buddy uses his phone as his ISP on his desktop. He just hooks up his phone to his desktop. (he is in a weird area where DSL doesn't come near him and cable is not an option) Apparently he uses newsgroups and is fine.
 
Bah, damm triple reference articles. Not allowing it on their wireless 3G is somewhat understandable, although limiting the bandwidth to something reasonable would seem to be the better solution. I'd think that would do that per user anyhow. P2P should traffic should have the same QOS issues as someone DLing a large (300MB+) file anyhow. The number of laptops using AT&T's 3G network must be fairly small still if they haven't booted anyone yet.
 
AT&T bans wireless phone subscribers from using file-sharing applications and threatens to terminate service of anyone caught doing so, the company told an FCC official on Friday.

Click-bait headline = fail.
 
Good to know. I was just getting ready to switch all my services to AT&T. Now, not so sure.
 
FFS hardforums are getting worse and worse with their inaccurate thread titles...
 
Click-bait headline = fail.

Just keeping people on their toes. Goes to show how many of us actually read the articles :p

To those of you who hasn't read the article yet: THIS APPLIES TO 3G INTERNET ONLY.

Sorry about the large font, but it's been said twice already and the bitching is still going on lol
 
Just keeping people on their toes. Goes to show how many of us actually read the articles :p

To those of you who hasn't read the article yet: THIS APPLIES TO 3G INTERNET ONLY.

Sorry about the large font, but it's been said twice already and the bitching is still going on lol

Satyrist said:
read the article a little more carefully...It's talking about 3G wireless service for phones, not DSL home service.

Sorry, beat you a few posts up :p
 
Kinda think that both the snippet on the main page and the summary on the linked page should mention that this is for AT&T Wireless service.

If you don't click through to the actual article, or read a ton of comments on the page [H] links to, you'd never know this was for 3G only.
 
At first I didn't have a problem with ATT doing this to protect bandwidth on their wireless network but I guess this could be the start of a slippery slope, as the bandwidth argument could be applied to regular service.
 
I wish they would terminate me. They locked me into a contract and I've been overpaying for about a year now :(.
 
I think it's perfectly fine for them to block P2P on the 3G network. That service is for business travelers who need to check their email and such on the go. It is not meant for use as a primary home Internet connection and cannot support heavy downloading.

Disclaimer: I have 3G service from Sprint as my primary home connection because it is the only broadband available here. I respect its intended purpose and avoid using P2P or doing any unnecessary downloading.
 
Makes me wonder if they'll start and/or continue blocking and cutting off P2P users when the next generation wireless comes out: especially since a lot of those solutions such as WiMax are touted as being alternatives to landline services (as opposed to today where 3G is not supposed to be used as such).
 
Lol at all the people bitching in the beginning due to misleading title. As far as the people using P2P on the 3g network, if you want to engage in such activities and are paying an excessive amounts why not just get a real ISP? Let's see $30 a month for 3g can fetch you DSL with way faster speeds.
 
While I don't think P2P over 3g or CDMA is a great idea (in fact the opposite) I do think this is a trend/habit I don't want to see continued. These are the same spectrum that they purchased off of the government and the same spectrum they agreed to have government oversight on. If comcast can get fined for doing this on cable internet, an actual wireless spectrum overseen by the government would probably qualify for a larger one.
 
Verizon Wireless terms say the same thing.

Data Plans and Features MAY NOT be used for any other purpose. Examples of prohibited uses include, without limitation, the following: (i) continuous uploading, downloading or streaming of audio or video programming or games; (ii) server devices or host computer applications, including, but not limited to, Web camera posts or broadcasts, automatic data feeds, automated machine-to-machine connections or peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing; or (iii) as a substitute or backup for private lines or dedicated data connections. This means, by way of example only, that checking email, surfing the Internet, downloading legally acquired songs, and/or visiting corporate intranets is permitted, but downloading movies using P2P file sharing services and/or redirecting television signals for viewing on laptops is prohibited. A person engaged in prohibited uses, continuously for one hour, could typically use 100 to 200 MBs, or, if engaged in prohibited uses for 10 hours a day, 7 days a week, could use more than 5 GBs in a month.

http://www.verizonwireless.com/b2c/...ion=priceSort&typeId=3&subTypeId=49&catId=448
 

Just because its in the TOS doesn't make it the law. They advertise it as unlimited* (not really unlimited). While I blame everybody for signing into an agreement they didn't read, the fact is these companies are trying to be deceptive. Just me now that At&T hass basically told the FCC to fuck off because its in their TOS. The FCC is now more likely rake them over the coals if they try to enforce this. The FCC is going to say they need to be completely neutral on their customers packets and that if they want they can put up bw limitations but can't at that point claim to be unlimited.
 
While I don't think P2P over 3g or CDMA is a great idea (in fact the opposite) I do think this is a trend/habit I don't want to see continued.

It will continue now that AT&T are presumably going down hard on P2P use. We're talking about wireless carriers here; what one does the others follow.
 
At first I didn't have a problem with ATT doing this to protect bandwidth on their wireless network but I guess this could be the start of a slippery slope, as the bandwidth argument could be applied to regular service.

It already is. There was a news article up a few months ago about how this fall they are going to be doing dl caps to "better service their customers".
 
Lol at all the people bitching in the beginning due to misleading title. As far as the people using P2P on the 3g network, if you want to engage in such activities and are paying an excessive amounts why not just get a real ISP? Let's see $30 a month for 3g can fetch you DSL with way faster speeds.

You along with 90% of the people posting in this thread need to learn how to fucking read. It's getting rather annoying :mad:
 
You along with 90% of the people posting in this thread need to learn how to fucking read. It's getting rather annoying :mad:

WTH are you talking about? How ironic that you don't take your own advice when the material is right in front of your face and doesn't require two mouseclicks to read. I was talking about using p2p on the 3G network and that you're an idiot if you do that because you can get DSL with much faster speeds for the same or less than what you're paying for 3G.
 
Lol at all the people bitching in the beginning due to misleading title. As far as the people using P2P on the 3g network, if you want to engage in such activities and are paying an excessive amounts why not just get a real ISP? Let's see $30 a month for 3g can fetch you DSL with way faster speeds.

demondiablo said:
You along with 90% of the people posting in this thread need to learn how to fucking read. It's getting rather annoying.

WTH are you talking about?

This is 'wth I'm talking about'.

my buddy uses his phone as his ISP on his desktop. He just hooks up his phone to his desktop. (he is in a weird area where DSL doesn't come near him and cable is not an option) Apparently he uses newsgroups and is fine.

Disclaimer: I have 3G service from Sprint as my primary home connection because it is the only broadband available here. I respect its intended purpose and avoid using P2P or doing any unnecessary downloading.


rapperwith1p said:
I was talking about using p2p on the 3G network and that you're an idiot if you do that because you can get DSL with much faster speeds for the same or less than what you're paying for 3G.

Unlike you I can comprehend what I read, thanks. Learn to think outside of the box.
 
^90% of the people in this thread would refer to the majority of people who were mislead by the title. And just because I posted right after you doesn't mean I was refering to your post specifically thus why I mentioned specifically the people who didn't read THE ARTICLE.
 
So much for downloading software updates --legal file updates mind you-- via torrents.....

im an AT&T customer.....mostly because they are the only player in town out here in nowheresville kansas......


*walks away shaking his head*

me in kansas too!!!
 
Back
Top